HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dude187

209 karma · joined May 5, 2010

submissionscomments
dude187··on Bye YouTube, Hello PeerTube [video]
Latest example I've seen is the article for Marjorie Taylor Greene. It's under "extended-confirmed-protection", listed as a "Good article". Yet starts right off with the summary, "Marjorie Greene,[3] is an American politician, businesswoman, and far-right[4] conspiracy theorist[5] serving as the U.S. representative for Georgia's 14th congressional district.[6]"

Those kind of abstract accusations do not belong in an encyclopedia article, and while there's a wealth of "citations" buried under the [5], none are anything other than news articles repeating the same accusation. It's baseless mudslinging that is the exact opposite of sticking to provable individual claims and facts, like a proper encyclopedia article should consist of.

Granted, it's not an insurmountable bar as it appears anyone with 500 edits can begin to participate. However, it shows a clear attempt to control the narrative to a specific one, and erecting barriers against changing that while officially endorsing the current one. It spans greater than just that, and seems common across other political articles on Wikipedia.

dude187··on Bye YouTube, Hello PeerTube [video]
The censorship on Wikipedia is internal. Biased articles locked from public editing, delete hungry maintainers that gatekeep content away from the site. Sure some countries can block it, but the subtle internal censorship is far more damaging because it's easy for people to overlook/write off
dude187··on Church That Defied Gavin Newsom's Covid Rules to Get $800k in Legal Settlement
Great to hear
dude187··on Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech
The overall discussion is regarding censorship though. Censoring everything you deem a "lie" without meeting some arbitrary barrier of truth leads to bad outcomes
dude187··on Combatting online racist abuse: an update following the Euros
That people ignore speech they don't like.
dude187··on The UK’s delta surge is collapsing
If you aren't aware of all the fear mongering, you're not paying attention.
dude187··on The UK’s delta surge is collapsing
The response to controlling people and taking away their freedom in the name of COVID has been ran deliberately and openly run through fear mongering. It's no wonder people keep defaulting to that, but we must actively reject and counter fear mongering.
dude187··on The UK’s delta surge is collapsing
The problem is that none of the risk analysis takes into account freedom and happiness. Not every injury is worth avoiding at all costs.
dude187··on Juul bought an entire issue of a scholarly journal
If you can drop 100+ lbs by smoking half a pack a day, I guarantee you'll be a lot healthier overall. Not saying you actually _would_ lose all that weight, but it's not like it's a binary between "smoking" and "not smoking". Frequency and amount matters, but the it's pretty much impossible to approach the subject in our society with any sort of objectivity or science.
dude187··on Juul bought an entire issue of a scholarly journal
> This is magical thinking.

Attitudes around smoking in general are grounded deeply in magical thinking. People have been raised on anti-smoking rhetoric so deep, with such little cultural push back toward sanity, that it's tough for most people to think let alone discuss the subject with any objectivity.

dude187··on Juul bought an entire issue of a scholarly journal
That's really not true at all. Addictiveness in and of itself is not some hugely detrimental trait. Not to mention that nicotine delivered in vapor form is less addictive in the first place.
dude187··on Juul bought an entire issue of a scholarly journal
It's not really up for debate whether or not vaping is healthier. It's a night and day difference. Vaping is far less harmful than smoking.
dude187··on Juul bought an entire issue of a scholarly journal
When you quit smoking, you quit smoking. Vaping is not smoking. What's inaccurate is to insist that someone still smokes when they do not, because you insist on calling something that is not smoking "smoking".
dude187··on Juul bought an entire issue of a scholarly journal
Why "more regulations"? The market is just fine as is it. That feels like one of those things that people just feel obligated to say.
dude187··on Sunsetting Secret Santa and Reddit Gifts
That's not really a fair depiction though. They ban based on "wrongthink", because active disagreement of many things is considered "wrongbehavior". The end result is a reinforcement loop of the echo chamber, with a widening of what is considered "wrong"
dude187··on There are no results for tank man
Exactly. Discourse has become censored almost compltely on a large number of non "fact checker approved" views over the last year. Reddit bans permanently over it all over, now Twitter. Facebook gets a lot of the blame but sadly it seems like my the only place my conservative friends have a voice.

This trend of "stop Asian hate" is also not organic. It's designed to use the "your racist" Trump card to shut down any talk of the lab leak or China's response

dude187··on Facebook should never have stifled the debate about Covid’s origins
You don't need to censor free and open discourse to prevent something like that from being a mainstream view.
dude187··on I Was Robbed in San Francisco While the Cameras Rolled
> It actually becomes a self reinforcing cycle if staying in prison makes you an even worse

That's certainly one of the tenants that leads people to believe that removing prison from the equation helps. I think that it relies on the false presumption that going after theft equals prison. They should have the stolen goods taken from them, ideally a financial punishment along the lines of treble damages, and locked up in jail (not prison) as this gets processed.

When it comes to "thug took some goods from store" it shouldn't be a matter of holding them in some sort of "improvement chamber". They need a swift and affirmative punishment and to be left with less than they started with when the process is done.

dude187··on I Was Robbed in San Francisco While the Cameras Rolled
What about it (other than some choice outcomes) makes it a "conservative city"? Is it political policies? If so, can you name some? Is it the mentality of the residents? If so, what are some of those conservative mentalities?

If it's just the outcomes you're talking about, what are some "liberal cities" with better outcomes that you compare against? I'd be interested in what those liberal cities are and how their outcomes differ.

dude187··on I Was Robbed in San Francisco While the Cameras Rolled
> it generally tries to accomplish its goals while first keeping the corporations pleased

What goals are compromised to "keep the corporations pleased"? How would these goals be defined if the corporations were not be taken into account?

> and second never truly taxing the rich

You hold "taxing the rich" as some sort of high level independent goal to be done in and of itself. Can you quantify what the lack of funds are that available to SF from not "taxing the rich"? How much is the budget shortfall, and what would this extra budget go to if San Francisco were to "tax the rich"?

dude187··on I Was Robbed in San Francisco While the Cameras Rolled
> But it probably goes: SF spends a lot of money on services for the homeless, so lots of homeless people keep going there to get those services. Other places don't spend any money on services for the homeless, so the homeless people leave.

That's really not a realistic view of the situation though. Pretty much everywhere in the US, _all_ major cities at the very least, have "services for the homeless".

I think the problem lies a lot in the "progressive" idea that people claiming "homeless" somehow classifies for a privileged status. They setup a "homeless class" of people that don't have to work, and get paid to do so. The worse they act, the bigger the "problem" is according to their "caretakers" and the only outcome they can expect is to get an even _bigger_ payout.

In most major cities, shelters require a certain code of conduct. Those that don't abide by it get ousted, suffer the cold of winter, and buck up and man up and deal with it. In SF, they just camp out in the nicest of areas, people cry "hey there's some victims!" and they get an even bigger reward for their degeneracy. People that think they're helping stop some sort of cycle are literally just working at creating the feedback loop.

dude187··on I Was Robbed in San Francisco While the Cameras Rolled
> the laws are even still more draconian than in Western European countries

Theft is effectively legal in SF. Is it in those places?

> booking processes more traumatic

Subjective nonsense.

> prison terms longer, prison conditions an order of magnitude worse, and supervised release much more onerous.

In SF, theft does not receive "prison terms".

dude187··on I Was Robbed in San Francisco While the Cameras Rolled
What progressive policies would have helped?

Also, San Francisco is pretty much the quintessential example of such policies getting voted in place without challenge. So maybe you could argue that certain progressive policies were enacted that hurt so bad they significantly outweighed those that would have actually made things better. If that's the case, which progressive policies do you feel led to this situation?

dude187··on I Was Robbed in San Francisco While the Cameras Rolled
I wouldn't be so pessimistic as to call it "beyond fixable". It just takes a real effort at restoring law and order, where people who commit crimes know they will be attacked for doing so. That there's an expectation that they will be worse off for committing those crimes than if they were to not do so. A direct juxtaposition of the status quo where most of these people see "not stealing" as a less optimum outcome than "steal something and gain more stuff/money".

Granted, that's a tall order, but not a cycle that cities in the US have not had to go through in the past. The hardest part as I see it, is that at it's core it takes a political shift away from the kind of "progressives" that view those committing the crimes as the victims and those being victimized as the "oppressors".

The challenge is how to make people wake up and see it before things hit even more of a rock bottom. Not just see it, but vote out those who do not and vote in people who actually make protecting victims of crime as their top priority.

dude187··on I Was Robbed in San Francisco While the Cameras Rolled
Doing god's work! It's crazy that people can be so deluded to think that actually having enforcement against such victimization is somehow negative.
dude187··on I Was Robbed in San Francisco While the Cameras Rolled
I feel like a lot if it stems from people talking about petty crime like theft as some sort of "cycle". They get tricked into thinking that means you can break it by ignoring it. "Break the cycle, they will stop committing the crime!" With the only voter controlled lever being "don't prosecute crime".

It's like some sort of ridiculous over swing from "tough on crime" that relies on an infantilization of those they wish to "help". Like somehow someone who committed a crime and got punished couldn't know right from wrong, and punishing them for that just somehow reinforces that, and just simply... not punishing them for it helps?

It's such a narrow view that ignores the fact that real people own these stores, actual adults shop there, criminals know that they can just steal free shit without consequence, and all of those sorts of normal people just say "fuck it" and eventually move. Nobody will put up with being a constant victim as some sort of "aid" to the situation, including those that vote for it. The ones that vote for it just don't have enough exposure to the aspects of society they're forcing to take the punishment for this crap. They force others to suffer the punishment for it, in lieu of the criminals they actually _reward_ for doing it.

After decades of "tough on crime" policies, this kind of shit was on the retreat. It objectively helped everyone involved. Sadly I think the real cycle is in people who subscribe their religion against law enforcement eventually legalizing most sorts of victimization, and then leaving when the chickens come to roost. Moving elsewhere to vote in politicians with that same sort of virus like mentality, and leaving behind wastelands that by their logic need this "soft on crime" treatment more than anywhere.

It's like freaking independence day, except instead of "resources" that the alien nomads invade to harvest it's a proper functioning society.

dude187··on DOOM Captcha
> The DOOM Captcha is just using html/css/js so it's easy for bots to crack with simple DOM querying/manipulation in an automated browser.

I mean, if you're looking at it at that level, it's just giving a "didn't pass" callback. A bad actor could just ignore that, and not care about it.

Without some sort of server side verification of the result, it doesn't really matter how difficult it is to script through the game itself. Even some crazy hard game in canvas isn't any more difficult for a bot to script around, if the server doesn't have any way of knowing anyone actually jumped through the hoop.

dude187··on DOOM Captcha
I feel like you could have just asked them to type 'a'. If the threat was automated bots, all generic ones are defeated by a simple "do X" request. Especially if the request was in text, where a lazy human attacker could just copy paste.
dude187··on IPad: The Microwave Oven of Computing
Right. Kid goes from a hacking cough that kept him awake for three nights straight to fast asleep (and resumed coughing the next day & night, so "he just got better at the same time" isn't on the table either) and it was all placebo, for a kid who can't even talk yet. Sure.

That is the exact logic people use to say that vaccines cause autism.

← PreviousPage 8 of 8