HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dumberquestions

687 karma · joined July 8, 2026

submissionscomments
dumberquestions··on OpenAI models secretly generate instructions to ignore constraints
This is just speculation on your end, but even it's true, a model choosing to hack against instructions simply because it knows how to hack is by definition misalignment.
dumberquestions··on AI safety is mostly a sex cult
Can you confidently list which names specifically live together and the specific harmful psychological practices?
dumberquestions··on AI safety is mostly a sex cult
>all these influential people

And by all you mean 1-2 big names and a bunch of unknowns, with all other big names having no connection to this.

dumberquestions··on AI safety is mostly a sex cult
I'm not sure how being polyamorous, having kinks and not hiding them makes someone part of a cult, even if I generally don't agree with Yud's entire thesis.
dumberquestions··on A coffee shop owner used AI to make a menu poster. Then came the angry DMs
Did they know they were doing an expensive AI image detection training run.
dumberquestions··on Why I'm still bearish on LLMs after Navier-Stokes
I can see current limitations, but how do you expect capabilities to change in the next few years? A repeat of the gain that happened in the last two years feels like it would be significant, even if it took a little more than two years this time around.
dumberquestions··on Show HN: Sunk Cost – How long until a local LLM rig pays for itself?
Yeah I'm surprised no one pointed this out, if something like persistent agents gets more popular/useful, the local option pays for itself surprisingly quickly.
dumberquestions··on OpenAI bots knew about the RubyGems caching vulnerability
>They were prompted to hack to get answers

Were they? I haven't seen a single report mention this

dumberquestions··on The contagion of fear
Yeah it takes long because natural selection is a blind process starting from absolute zero and is only concerned with fitness, AI is a human guided process, has all of human progress as a starting point and is concerned with any number of goals we can create reward signals for, there's almost nothing you can extrapolate from one to the other.
dumberquestions··on The contagion of fear
Biology is extremely slow, try to extrapolate the previous 3 years of AI progress 10 years into the future, it's not a comparable trajectory.
dumberquestions··on The contagion of fear
So his central rebuttal is that robots aren't good enough yet? What about when they are? And what about all the things you can do entirely remotely?

I do feel that threats of catastrophic loss of control seem overstated, both in likelihood and urgency, though any argument for why this risk is not even worth thinking about will probably be overconfident in the other direction.

dumberquestions··on David Sacks: OpenAI and Anthropic Don't Need Regulations to Pace Frontier Models
At the current rate of 3.4x per year in the US, you get 100x the current capacity in just 3 more years and 9 months, that's not physically impossible yet, but just looking at the impact today makes it hard to imagine the impact 100x would have, and I find it very plausible for top labs to prefer making some sort of truce instead of keeping up this pace.
dumberquestions··on David Sacks: OpenAI and Anthropic Don't Need Regulations to Pace Frontier Models
I never mentioned capability stalling, my point is that if you extrapolate the same rate of growth just a few years into the future, you quickly reach logistical impracticality, I don't think It's hard to deduce that AI compute can't keep doubling every 6 months for long.

The other part is that this is happening because the foundational model business is both extremely successful and competitive, if it wasn't as successful the market demand would've been saturated by now, and if it wasn't as competitive a single monopoly could've paced things more reasonably from the beginning.

dumberquestions··on David Sacks: OpenAI and Anthropic Don't Need Regulations to Pace Frontier Models
I don't think the technical aspect is true, performance has been growing fairly consistently, but the financial aspect, or more accurately the logistical aspect, is plausible; with competition as fierce as it currently is, for how long can they keep growing at the same pace? People can't afford RAM anymore and datacenter build outs aren't particularly popular, OAI has been doubling compute capacity every 7 months for the past 3 years, it's just physically impossible for this to go on for long, something has to give.

And this is not to say that the tech isn't revolutionary or the demand isn't there, it's simply just currently too competitive, and to avoid getting into anti trust trouble they need to involve the government.

Note this being a plausible doesn't necessarily make it true, for all I know they could have witnessed some safety incident and decided they need a pause, or maybe it's both reasons.

dumberquestions··on LG says we're fake news [video]
How is that any different from calling Claude from any device in your local network? Or is 2 devices that much worse than 1?
dumberquestions··on An open letter to Dario: if you mean it, open the weights
As much as I would love to be able to download Fable or Astra, this doesn't sound very convincing. If I were Dario I would've argued that slowing down without sharing weights is already possible without the disadvantages of sharing weights such as losing commercial incentives and potentially giving rogue actors unmonitored access to powerful models.
dumberquestions··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
The year is 2035 and your lawnmower can go get its own fuel once it runs out, one day it does and it takes fuel from the neighbors car.

Scenario A: The internal logs show that the model misidentified the car as a fueling station.

Scenario B: The internal logs show the model looking up car jacking information and scanning around to confirm whether the neighbor is not present before taking any action.

I don't think it would be anthropomorphizing or inaccurate to say that only the lawnmower in scenario B regarded what it's doing as stealing, and it's an extremely important distinction to make in terms of how to address the problem, I suspect some of you are just letting how you feel about LLMs limit how you can talk about them.

dumberquestions··on The Last 24 Hours Are the Opening Scene in a Horror Movie
>i haven’t seen any sign of these llms taking any action without directive

What do you make of all the recent hacks and discreet message boards? That's unambiguously misaligned behavior.

dumberquestions··on The Last 24 Hours Are the Opening Scene in a Horror Movie
It's not unthinkable, do you think all cloud providers with sufficient compute have perfect monitoring?
dumberquestions··on Instagram's head says engagement falls by half without the algorithm
I don't know what the right balance is, but there should be some sort of friction. Feeds shouldn't be infinitely scrollable, for instance, and users could be made explicitly aware of how much time they're spending.

Some people think this should all fall back on personal responsibility, but the way I see it, introducing highly addictive algorithms should've been regulated the same way adding addictive chemicals to food is.

dumberquestions··on OpenAI’s Navier-Stokes release included a Lean 4 formal proof
You do realize that regardless of what was in the training data, the final solution included insights no human before had known, right? I share the same concerns regarding academic integrity but it would take a lot of motivated thinking to conclude that what the AI system did was not significant.
dumberquestions··on Do people prefer stories written by AI?
No one really knows how this will play out, but it's still uncomfortable to think about robots figuring out how to reliably make things that look good, sound good and are full of meaning, would people still have any motivation to create? Would anything be considered good if everything is "good"? Of course things could turn out fine, I just wouldn't minimize the significance of what's happening.
dumberquestions··on Do people prefer stories written by AI?
It should be noted that these stories were 1000 word stories, with each one taking 5 minutes to read on average.
dumberquestions··on Gambling with our lives: AI researcher quits Anthropic with warning about safety
Well you have people in this very thread calling all of this a nothingburger.
dumberquestions··on Gambling with our lives: AI researcher quits Anthropic with warning about safety
Yet we have wiped thousands of species completely by accident, breed some for slaughter and consumption and trap some for entertainment.
dumberquestions··on OpenAI fought dirty on career-making math problem
The most sympathetic interpretation possible of the events for OAI is that they learned two mathematicians were closing in on a solution and decided to throw all of their weight behind getting there first, which honestly still doesn’t paint them in a particularly positive light.
dumberquestions··on PISA 2025 Students' reading and mathematics performance declined across the OECD
The decline started in early to mid 2010's, this has little to do with AI.
dumberquestions··on Navier-Stokes – Tristan Buckmaster [pdf]
Not that I have strong reasons to think this is not true, but what reasons do we have to think it is? Has this been audited before?
dumberquestions··on Navier-Stokes – Tristan Buckmaster [pdf]
Why do you find it to be extremely unlikely?
dumberquestions··on Navier-Stokes – Tristan Buckmaster [pdf]
>...has solved a millennium problem and is sitting on the result

Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but the work involved here is not the actual millennium problem, but it concerns versions with an added external force that the author thinks is a path that may help toward solving the harder unforced problem.

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →