HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dumbneurologist

831 karma · joined July 13, 2017

submissionscomments
dumbneurologist··on Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who support backdoors
all human beings should be allowed to record their thoughts and communicate without those thoughts being surveilled. What is so different in 2018 that the ability to think and communicate in secret is somehow a threat to law enforcement? Law enforcement has always had to work hard to crack a case. Now that computers exist, they want to have a comprehensive record of everything that's ever been uttered, retroactively play back anything that the authority deems inappropriate, and make arrests on that basis. It is fascism in a can. There could be no clearer indication that political protections are inadequate to safeguard this than the current president, who has run amok without legal consequence (to date).

I cannot understand how any thoughtful person can support anything more invasive than hard police work and a warrant... any legal case can be cracked with human tools, because no criminal operation has 100% operational security. The need to spy on the thoughts of innocence is an insane price for any extra crime fighting ability we get on top of this.

dumbneurologist··on Curry spice turmeric boosts memory by nearly 30%, eases depression, study finds
This is addressed by pre-trial registration. You can't have publication bias (his argument) when you register the study and see that this is the only one.
dumbneurologist··on Curry spice turmeric boosts memory by nearly 30%, eases depression, study finds

  Sorry to state this so strongly but I feel it's 
  important to point out that this is misinformation of the 
  most egregious kind.
  
  There is no examination of statistical power in this article whatsoever so there is no basis for your 
  claim that this study is properly powered.

The power is only relevant when you fail to detect an effect. This is a positive study, so the power is simply not relevant to criticizing that particular study.

The nature article you reference talks about literature in aggregate, and the problem created by small studies in general, but it does not allow you to say anything about a single positive study. In fact, the place where those very authors draw their primary conclusion, they state:

  Inflated effect estimates make it difficult to determine an adequate sample size for replication 
  studies, increasing the probability of type II errors
Which means: when you try to replicate it, you might fail because you thought the real effect size was bigger than it is, based on your estimated effect size with small n.

That's well and good, but is a problem for the replicating authors, not for these.

An even more direct point related to the current article: it was preregistered, so you know the authors have not been farming well-designed but small curcurmin studies until they did one than that was positive by chance, and then published it. The act of pre-registration goes a very long way toward addressing the issues raised by Button et al.

dumbneurologist··on Curry spice turmeric boosts memory by nearly 30%, eases depression, study finds
Except that it was preregistered, as described in the article.

https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT01383161?cond=NCT0138...

It's great to be skeptical, but it's really lame to be skeptical and lazy. It's a terrible combination that causes patients not to trust their doctors.

dumbneurologist··on Curry spice turmeric boosts memory by nearly 30%, eases depression, study finds
None of your criticisms from wikipedia pertain to this publication. The paragraph is essentially making the argument that a randomized, double blind (DB), placebo controlled (PC) clinical trial (RCT) is unlikely to show that curcurmin is effective. yet, the published article is exactly that, and shows a statistically measurable impact on a clinically meaningful endpoint: a direct refutation of the paragraph.

the fact the "interference properties" and being an "unstable, reactive, non-bioavailable compound" is subsumed by the study design.

  claims to have studied a bioavailable form of curcumin
This is not really relevant to the claim or conclusions. could it be that the bioavailability matters? maybe. could it be that curcurmin is a trick molecule to study? yes. but come what may, this is direct evidence (not proof) of a cause-effect relationship between this treatment and the outcome.

the only thing this effects is the chance that other forms of curcurmin will be comparable (and it might have consequences for regulatory status by the FDA).

  The study also notes its sample was small
This is a very weak criticism when the study is positive (i.e. shows an effect). when the sample size (and statistical power) of the study is small, you need a BIG EFFECT SIZE to be positive. The fact that the trial was positive actually means that it's more likely to be clinically important, because a big effect size means it protects memory in a dramatic way. This is like penicillin: in the pre-antibiotic era, how many cases of pneumonia do you need to treat in order to be satisfied that penicillin is effective? Not bloody many, because the effect size is so dramatic. Likewise for parachutes. few are the therapies that fall into this category, but when you have an inkling that one does following a DB, PC, RCT, you better pay attention.

So does it need to be replicated? definitely. does the sponsorship matter? definitely; they could have cheated in some way. until then does it make sense to prescribe this to seniors, or encourage them to increase curcurmin in their diet? quite possibly, given the presumably low rate of adverse effects.

Bottom line: this study is not the end-all be-all of curcurmin and memory, but there is legitimate early evidence that the emperor has clothes.

edits: mainly spelling, formatting

dumbneurologist··on Curry spice turmeric boosts memory by nearly 30%, eases depression, study finds
completely true.

the problem is that efficacy studies (like I want) are not that exciting to report. as a result, the lay press reports only mechanism studies (because their readers like to be "wowed" and think about things, like the poster I originally replied to).

that wouldn't matter at all, but we all get sick. and when a person gets sick with this mentality that they need to understand the mechanism, then they start overthinking the treatments that are available today, drawing all kinds of spurious conclusions, and making medical decisions that are unjustified at best and harmful at worst. and in my experience, the smarter the patient is, the more willing (and insistent) they are to take this approach (witness Steve Jobs). This is absolutely not the patient being "dumb" or stubborn: it's completely understandable given how they understand science. But it hurts them, which no physician likes to see.

let's note how incredible it is that we are having this conversation in the setting of some incredibly expert scientists (albeit in other fields). it really shows how hard science can be to understand sometimes.

dumbneurologist··on Curry spice turmeric boosts memory by nearly 30%, eases depression, study finds

  there are tons of potential pitfalls and a combination of 
  experimental limitations
you provided some, which are at least partially addressed by the study design. (I don't think it's your point, but let me agree that "the scientist can cheat" is always true).

  poor academic incentives,
this is addressed because it is double-blind

  insufficient statistical and scientific training
this is (partially) addressed by peer review, and the availability of the data. you can't make this general criticism of the paper at hand: find the place where the design or statistics used were in error.

  I think it’s bad science, that will one day 
  retrospectively be viewed as invalid scientific method.
that's a claim without any evidence to back it p.

  I think the way to combat this is to avoid studies 
  that solely attempt to demonstrate an effect, but to 
  complement that part of an investigation with additional 
  studies that demonstrate a plausible explanation. This 
  reduces the risk of false positives and increases our 
  confidence in the result.
If you have a double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized clinical trial then what can the mechanism possibly add? Is an effective medication less effective because we don't understand how it works? If you want an amazing example, read about the mechanism of action of general anesthesia: we have many ideas about how it works, but nobody really knows. Nobody gets caught up by this when their appendix ruptures. I hope, for your sake, that you will lower your standards in the event that you need surgery.

  The additional studies could take the form (for example) 
  of deliberately intervening such that the effect should 
  be manipulated by the intervention in a predictable and 
  measurable way. Essentially, come at the hypothesis “from 
  another angle”.
If you have a properly designed and executed randomized, double blind, placebo controlled trial, then you have measured the effect of the intervention, and only the intervention. You can repeat it in order to gain confidence, but you have to decide when the diminishing returns of "more confidence" are not worth your study dollar. And for curcurmin, which is cheap and has low side effects... it's probably not that far away.

edit: fixed formatting

dumbneurologist··on Curry spice turmeric boosts memory by nearly 30%, eases depression, study finds
none of this applies to a double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized clinical trial (which is what this article is).

the reason it's the gold standard for medicine is because the only thing that is different in aggregate between the groups is the intervention. Therefore, it is the strongest possible evidence of causality we have, and does say something about causality (rather than correlation).

It's important to replicate, but the points made by Pearl are not relevant here and the mechanism is moot when you have a causal link shown by RCT.

dumbneurologist··on Curry spice turmeric boosts memory by nearly 30%, eases depression, study finds
agree that replication is important and that it's too early to believe fully, but when a study size is small and you still find a difference, then it implies the effect size is large.

If you meet statistical significance, then diminishing n means increasing clinical significance.

dumbneurologist··on Curry spice turmeric boosts memory by nearly 30%, eases depression, study finds
I am a neurologist. this is actually the exact opposite of what you should care about, which is "does it work to treat ___"

In this trial, and 99% of other trials, there is no mechanism provided by the study, only a measurement of causality (which is the same thing as effectiveness).

The authors may think they know based on other, prior, basic science research (as they are postulating here), but it does not affect the conclusions of the trial ( whether they do or don't (or even if they are wrong).

Obviously it's intellectually satisfying to understand WHY, but it's not as important as "is it true?"

dumbneurologist··on The day I accidentally killed a little boy
the other reply is correct, but i had a hard time understanding the point without a concrete example: making the roads narrower with visual cues regarding your speed causes people to slow down.
dumbneurologist··on Firefox is on a slippery slope
> I'm hopeful that we'll learn from this.

Consider for a moment what you think the lesson is.

Now that you have it...

(have it? great)

... is it different from the lesson when Pocket was made part of the browser?

dumbneurologist··on Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions Cheating
thank you for bringing this up; I wasn't aware exactly how high the costs of cheating really were.

but it's tremendously important: what would we say about a person who killed or contributed directly to the killing of 38,000 people?

your fact seems less "real" because it's a statistical individual, but they are morally equivalent.

dumbneurologist··on Brain abnormalities found in victims of US embassy attack in Cuba
ultrasound is completely capable of not only affecting brain tissue, but destroying it.

as with anything else: it's about the amount of energy you put into it.

Focused ultrasound would be completely capable, and share the quality of being perceptable in the targeted region, and absent elsewhere.

https://www.fusfoundation.org/diseases-and-conditions/neurol...

dumbneurologist··on Harvard and the Making of the Unabomber (2000)
this section:

  its research committee approved my request to view the 
  records of this experiment, the so-called data set, which 
  referred to subjects by code names only. But because 
  kaczynski’s alias was by then known to some journalists, I 
  was not permitted to view his records.
is straight-up B.S.. the only (putative) purpose of withholding records is to protect confidentiality. but in this case, the journalist was researching with Kaczynski's consent. they might have been playing games with the author (alston chase) and omitted this detail so that he didn't come back with the signed slip of paper, but any of the subject's data should absolutely be available to the subject.

I say "putative" because the _real_ purpose seems apparent... to hide from an investigation.

dumbneurologist··on GPL Violations Related to Combining ZFS and Linux (2016)
there is a lot of self-confidence in your reply, but it doesn't address his/her point: that there is essentially a "loophole" that Oracle could exploit if they wanted to by writing a new version of the CDDL.

his/her contention is that most of the code has been released without the explicit opt-out for a more recent version of CDDL.

there's no need to get nasty; just bring the facts.

dumbneurologist··on BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over hack of Mt. Gox
what ever happened to him? the news with his name stops the day he was arrested.
dumbneurologist··on The New Firefox and Ridiculous Numbers of Tabs
> Meanwhile there are great plugins for searching within all open tabs

which is your favorite?

dumbneurologist··on Scientists Reverse Brain Damage in Drowned Toddler?
yet she/he is still a human being, and (i hope!) cares about your son. being "old school" means that she/he was trained in a certain way, but it doesn't mean that they have been brain-washed or is incapable of seeing success with unconventional treatments (look at CBD / cannabidiol, which is unconventional but is in the process of being adopted by these same "old school" doctors).

we wish it were otherwise, but: if your son had a brain injury where cells died, no amount of oxygen is going to bring them back (or even help his recovery).

i'm sorry for your son's circumstances (and yours...). But you are a victim twice when you invest time, energy, money, and hope in these quack therapies (I'm sorry to call them that, because it seems so pejorative, but that's what they are).

i don't know what it is about quack treatments that make us so susceptible to them... I think it's a missing piece of the Kubler Ross model of grief. Just like our parents who fall victims to ridiculous "nigerian prince" or "check cashing" scams when you can't understand how... it's not because they are dumb, or stupid, but because there is some aspect of human psychology (hope? denial? grief? whatever...) that puts us all at risk of fooling ourselves... we become unable to see the truth, because of how powerfully we want to see something else.

i hope this possibility makes sense to you, because your son will benefit a thousand times more from your attention than if you take the same attention and spend it fighting against "the system" (in whatever form it takes). and take comfort in the fact that even though "the system" really sucks in terms of its limitations, that it does, in general, stumble toward progress, and the future will be better than the present.

Until then... cherish your son and enjoy your time with him to the best of your mutual abilities.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K%C3%BCbler-Ross_model

dumbneurologist··on Scientists Reverse Brain Damage in Drowned Toddler?
I obviously don't know anything regarding your mom's condition, but SAH (a form of hemorrhagic stroke) by itself can have very complete recovery. The real question is how much ischemic stroke there was with it. If the answer is "none", then, if she survives (scary caveat, obviously), then her recovery could be very very good. Having said that, ischemic injury is common (as is herniation, which is similarly permanent and very very dangerous). I hope she comes through it ok.
dumbneurologist··on Scientists Reverse Brain Damage in Drowned Toddler?
Does his neurologist recommend it?
dumbneurologist··on Scientists Reverse Brain Damage in Drowned Toddler?
I am really sorry to hear that you've had such a terrible thing happen to you. I think the scientific community is moving in the right direction in recognizing the insidious nature but ultimate impact that these injuries can have. But by skepticism helps us protect the already-scarce resources we have to study what treatments actually work. Let's not repeat the mistakes of the autism community that spent millions and decades on trying to blame vaccines. The science will eventually come out, but we can literally spend as much money as we want to to reach the same conclusions.

You deserve to have hope, but for me personally, hope comes from the fact that science works. This article is not real progress (even though the child had a good outcome, and that's awesome), but there are a dozen places where real progress is occurring, even if it's less visible.

dumbneurologist··on Scientists Reverse Brain Damage in Drowned Toddler?
the diving reflex is real, and is used clinically to treat supraventricular tachycardia (where a re-entrant electrical feedback loop in the heart can be broken by slowing down the choke-point through which it passes). It slows down the heart and lessens its contractile power consumption. That could conceivably work (in my mind) after a cardiac arrest, but it isn't really related to brain death (which is an issue in the days and weeks following, in the ICU where oxygenation and glucose usually plentiful).

Remember: the "theory" behind any medical idea is almost irrelevant if you have data regarding the outcome. If you have outcome data, it supercedes the theory, and is all-important. The theory simply helps us prioritize which treatments to assess first - the better the fundamentals, the more worthy it is of scarce research resources.

That's one of my biggest criticisms of the lay press: they emphasize the scientific narrative and don't focus enough on the outcomes. The most meaningful outcomes in scientific terms always mean the same thing: a meaningful improvement by blinded observer in something we care about.

"meaningful improvement" - this means that improving survival by a tenth of one percent might not be worth the trouble of implementation

"blinded observer" - because it cancels out the placebo effect and expectations

"something we care about" - such as returning to school. But if you do a SPECT scan and the SPECT scan "looks better" to the doctor? That's not important. We sometimes use things that are well-documented to reflect important things even though they are not important in their own right... we call these biomarkers.

dumbneurologist··on Scientists Reverse Brain Damage in Drowned Toddler?
I can't speak intelligently to your questions, because I have no relevant first-hand experience or knowledge of CPR literature.

My only point regarding

> The average rule is that if heart has not restarted after 6 minutes, brain damage is irreversible

is that it doesn't mean it's worthless to continue CPR. Different people have different preferences about how grievous an injury they would want to survive. Whether to continue comes down to that preference. Have an advanced directive, and make sure your loved ones know what you want to have happen if you are every in an emergency!

dumbneurologist··on Scientists Reverse Brain Damage in Drowned Toddler?
Haha. This is an incredibly polite reply, sharpened to a very fine point.

I'm grateful I have something to contribute to a site that I've gotten an incredible amount out of. And it's a powerful reminder that very very smart people can have a hard time critically appraising medical claims. As powerful as the internet is, medicine is really complicated, and it's easy for doctors to forget that.

I'll let the surgeon speak for him/herself, but for my part: I am raising the issue of industry size and quackery to give other readers context. It doesn't make the article wrong necessarily, but I would want to have that context as a non-expert reader trying to understand how it fits into the larger body of scientific understanding. And I would say yes, that does happen (and is appropriate to have happen) in scientific discourse.

On a related note: one amazing site that isn't well known is the OpenPayments[1], maintained by the US government. If you live in the US and have doctor, you can see how much compensation they received from industrial sources. Some of the numbers are shocking. Put your own doctor in, and see where they are. There is no need to resort to conspiracy claims when you can audit them, to some degree, yourself.

The physician mentioned in the article, Dr. Paul Harch, has received $74.48. So way to go Dr. Harch! we can worry much less about getting a skewed opinion based on a industry payments.

But weighing against that is his CV, which lists publications with "D Amen", who I suspect is Daniel Amen - an overly-credulous hyperbaric oxygen physician who has his own page on quackwatch[2], and subscribes to medical theories that are even less credible than the ones in newsweek. When Mehmet Oz[3] is an endorsement on your web site (Amen; not Harch), the public is justified in putting you in the same category. Farther down the CV is "Department of Defense trials for hyperbaric oxygen and TBI: issues of study design and questionable conclusions", wherein I'm predicting he single-handedly dismantles a large federal study of whether HBO is useful for traumatic brain injury. Feel free to find the original article and independently appraise it, if you think it's worth your time... I can barely find 10 minutes to pay back a favor to a good-natured community that has taught me a lot about computers and programming.

Finally: let's not lose sight of the incredibly good thing that happened for this child. Regardless of how or what or why, this is an exceptional outcome, and it's fantastic for this child. I only wish it wouldn't create false-hope for families who are less fortunate, but have thousands (or tens of thousands) of dollars to blow on questionable treatments and false reason for hope.

1. https://openpaymentsdata.cms.gov/

2. https://www.quackwatch.org/06ResearchProjects/amen.html

3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WA0wKeokWUU

dumbneurologist··on Scientists Reverse Brain Damage in Drowned Toddler?
> Could this be just a case of the medical community not accepting a new technique

That the medical community wants evidence to substantiate an extreme claim is not a valid criticism of the medical community: it's literally the scientific process.

There are just too many extreme claims based on "unconventional" medical ideas to possibly draw conclusions that any one of them deserves closer attention.

It's great that some doctors at LSU think these ones are deserving - I really want them to succeed, because it means my patients benefit. But the mechanistic reasoning behind /why/ we think it /should/ help is so dubious that there are a thousand better places for me to spend my own time.

Bottom line: 99% of doctors want to see new, revolutionary ideas succeed. If they don't think things are work, it's because they haven't personally seen it being revolutionary. And the harder it is to see a revolutionary effect... the less revolutionary it is, by definition

dumbneurologist··on Scientists Reverse Brain Damage in Drowned Toddler?
Disclaimer: I am a neurologist

The enthusiastic replies on this thread are understandable, but disappointing to see: we all need to be less credulous regarding the lay science press, and especially the lay medical press.

I would love nothing more than to have this kind of therapy be a reality for my patients. However, I am deeply skeptical of this report.

Why? Because

- hyperbaric oxygen therapy has a big industry of quackery behind it[1][2]

- oxygen is a standard part of medical care and can just as easily be harmful as helpful

- because there is just no way in hell that oxygen is going to reverse cell death.

- this is in newsweek, and not a peer-reviewed journal.

And if there was no cell death, then the recovery is almost inevitable.

Some posters are skeptical because 15 minutes is impossible.

On the contrary: the key point is the temperature. The article says the water was 4 degrees C. That is cold enough that you can recover fully. In fact, the most amazing recovery is also one of the best-documented: with a 66-minute submersion in Utah that was followed by complete recovery[3] (this is a far more interesting article than the original post - it was in 1988, and utilized extracorporeal rewarming). This observation was used to pursue hypothermia in other causes of anoxic injury, which is clinically used today. I'm sure the 66-minute case also got oxygen during the recovery, but to say that it was due to oxygen (which is standard of care) rather than the temperature is silly.

Sorry to be a wet blanket, but this article is just clickbait junk.

1. https://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm364687.h...

2. https://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/HBOT/hm01...

3. http://www.nytimes.com/1988/07/26/science/the-doctor-s-world...

dumbneurologist··on Things to know about the A68 iceberg
it seems to me that the way scientists address the question of "is this global warming?" is wrong-headed, even though it's not literally wrong.

We deal with this frequently in medicine. There are lots of questions that the non-expert doesn't know how to ask, or asks clumsily. When patients ask "doctor: does this medication have any risks?" The literal answer is "yes; dozens of side effects are possible, ranging from mild to life-threatening".

But that answer is so accurate that it's useless. What almost all patients really want is "help me understand the most common side effects, and tell me what to watch out for regrading rare-but-serious side effects".

With respect to global warming, we don't really care whether this event can be tied back to antropegenic climate change in a linear way. What we really are asking is "should we be taking climate change seriously?". And the answer is an emphatic "hell yes".

This is an opportunity for people to focus on climate issues. I worry that HN will think I'm a paternalist jerk, but scientists shouldn't get bogged down in the literal answer to the literal question in this case.

My best answer would be "climate change is real, accelerating (meaning getting worse every day we continue to consume more fossil fuels), and the biggest threat we have to face as a species".

← PreviousPage 2 of 2