6,919 karma · joined November 7, 2014
Nevertheless, the irony of this is overwhelming: a guy who spent his life promoting a company whose model is "we deeply control the products you use" gets burned by the fact they deeply control the products he's been using.
That's because people consider Disney an entertainment company whereas in fact its the biggest licensing company in the world.
This list of companies made me wonder a bit. Technical progress has been huge, no question about that. But as for the actual quality or experience for the user/customer - I have the impression everything got worse, starting from Google from the first wave.
I wish your surgery goes well.
Unfortunately it's not guaranteed hat paying for multi-region replication will save you.
I wonder where the obstinacy on the part of certain CEOs come from. It's clear that although such content does have its fans (mostly grouped in communities), people at large just hate arificially-generated content. We had our moment, it was fun, it is no more, but these guys seem obsessed in promoting it.
The problem is, the issue in the article is explicitly named as "CVE slop", so if the patch is of the same quality, it might require quite some work anyway.
I don't know whether he's right or wrong, but deep down I feel the amount of money funneled in the Transformed architecture might have blocked other approaches, both potentially promising and others doomed for failure, just because LLMs' quick wins.
I didn't mean to attack you personally and I'm really sorry if it sounded this way. I appreciate the generally positive atmosphere on HN and I believe it more important than the actual argument, whatever it may be.
Do you use LLMs to post on HN? I'm asking seriously.
This is the worst misrepresentation of Marcus' argument I've seen so far.
In this particular case, it's spending 40 minutes of my life on something that could be explained in 4 sentences.
That is the best example of straw argument I've seen this year. I enjoy reading discussions on LLMs and have seen a huge number of arguments, some reasonable and some ridiculous, but one thing I haven't seen is someone claiming that LLMs are not useful. We can discuss usefulness for a particular purpose, or the level of its fitness for it, but not the fact that millions of people find LLMs useful enough to pay for them.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_health_care_by_count...
I, on the other hand, I love the EU. In spite of the fact that many products are sold for a lower price in the American market (not just electronics, also cars and others). I imagine it's even worse in the Australian market.
But, in the grand scheme of things, I can live with that, with free education and healthcare, among others.
Why on earth would you do it?! It was literally the comment I visit HN for - a solution for the problem we basically all have, already tested by someone, starting a thread with people's experience of it.
While I agree, the only cases where I actually created something barely resembling useful (while still of subpar quality) was only after putting in CLAUDE.md lines like:
YOUR AIM IS NOT TO DELIVER A PROJECT. YOU AIM IS TO DO DEEP, REPETITIVE E2E TESTING. ONLY E2E TESTS MATTER. BE EXTREMELY PESSIMISTIC. NEVER ASSUME ANYTHING WORKS. ALWAYS CHECK EVERY FEATURE IN AT LEAST THREE DIFFERENT WAYS. USE ONLY E2E TESTS, NEVER USE OTHER TYPES OF TEST. BE EXTREMELY PESSIMISTIC. NEVER TRUST ANY CODE UNLESS YOU DEEPLY TEST IT E2E
REMEMBER, QUICK DELIVERY IS MEANINGLESS, IT'S NOT YOUR AIM. WORK VERY SLOWLY, STEP BY STEP. TAKE YOUR TIME AND RE-VERIFY EACH STEP. BE EXTREMELY PESSIMISTIC
With this kind of setup, it kind attempts to work in a slightly different way than it normally does and is able to build some very basic stuff although frankly I'd do it much better so not sure about the economics here. Maybe for people who don't care or won't be maintaining this code it doesn't matter but personally I'd never use it in my workplace.