HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dvfjsdhgfv

6,919 karma · joined November 7, 2014

When commenting on HN, the most important thing for me is to make sure I speak my mind rather than conform to common opinions/gather the karma etc. In this way I contribute to reducing the filter bubble that is present in all online communities, including HN. Speak your mind, that's what matters.
submissionscomments
dvfjsdhgfv··on Show HN: Stop AI scrapers from hammering your self-hosted blog (using porn)
Your approach to GenAI scrapers is similar to our fight with email spam. The reason email spam got solved was because the industry was interested in solving it. But this issue got the industry split: without scraping, GenAI tools are less functional. And there is some serious money involved, so they will use whatever means necessary, technical and legal, to fight such initiatives.
dvfjsdhgfv··on Apple has locked my Apple ID, and I have no recourse. A plea for help
I deeply sympathise with the author.

Nevertheless, the irony of this is overwhelming: a guy who spent his life promoting a company whose model is "we deeply control the products you use" gets burned by the fact they deeply control the products he's been using.

dvfjsdhgfv··on Rats Play DOOM
This is a very popular theme, unfortunately without any practical conclusion.
dvfjsdhgfv··on The Walt Disney Company and OpenAI Partner on Sora
> To the point where you assume it's an unauthorized rip off until you discover they license to anyone.

That's because people consider Disney an entertainment company whereas in fact its the biggest licensing company in the world.

dvfjsdhgfv··on The AI wildfire is coming. it's going to be painful and healthy
> The next cycle, driven by social and mobile, burned again in 2008–2009, clearing the underbrush for Facebook, Airbnb, Uber, and the offspring of Y Combinator.

This list of companies made me wonder a bit. Technical progress has been huge, no question about that. But as for the actual quality or experience for the user/customer - I have the impression everything got worse, starting from Google from the first wave.

dvfjsdhgfv··on [dead]
Regarding point 3, instead of writing such posts on HN, you'd do better by contacting that person, apologizing, and making sure you make up for all wrong you did.

I wish your surgery goes well.

dvfjsdhgfv··on Linear algebra explains why some words are effectively untranslatable
True true.
dvfjsdhgfv··on We cut our Mongo DB costs by 90% by moving to Hetzner
> unless you are paying extra for multi-region redundancy things like the recent us-east-1 outage will kill you

Unfortunately it's not guaranteed hat paying for multi-region replication will save you.

dvfjsdhgfv··on We cut our Mongo DB costs by 90% by moving to Hetzner
While I agree, I remember we once had cross-region replication for some product but when AWS was down the service was down anyway because of some dependency. Things were working fine during our DR exercises, but when the actual failure arrived, cross-region turned out useless.
dvfjsdhgfv··on We cut our Mongo DB costs by 90% by moving to Hetzner
As much as I love Hetzner, the article is misleading. Using a single server today makes no sense whatsoever unless it's for hobby projects. It will fail. My servers at Hetzner routinely fail every few years (4-5 maybe), usually it's a hard drive, but sometimes motherboard or PSU. If it's a drive, you need to take it offline to rebuild the array, it can take a few hours. Like honestly, this article blew up my mind. I'd never use such setup in production. Just add the damn second server (or two), it's dirt cheap!
dvfjsdhgfv··on SlopStop: Community-driven AI slop detection in Kagi Search
So we have two universes. One is pushing generated content up our throats - from social media to operating systems - and another universe where people actively decide not to have anything to do with it.

I wonder where the obstinacy on the part of certain CEOs come from. It's clear that although such content does have its fans (mostly grouped in communities), people at large just hate arificially-generated content. We had our moment, it was fun, it is no more, but these guys seem obsessed in promoting it.

dvfjsdhgfv··on FFmpeg to Google: Fund us or stop sending bugs
> "Don't come to me with problems, come with solutions"

The problem is, the issue in the article is explicitly named as "CVE slop", so if the patch is of the same quality, it might require quite some work anyway.

dvfjsdhgfv··on Vibe Code Warning – A personal casestudy
The correct analogy would be that half of the lights wouldn't light up randomly and then you'd have to go out anyway but in a hurry and only to certain ones just do discover you need to get back 20 minutes later because there is another problem with the same light, and your boss would expect that you do everything much faster and you end up frustrated even more.
dvfjsdhgfv··on Sam Altman's pants are on fire
But you need to agree that we can single out one specific argument he is most famous for, right? And when Josh Wolfe is saying that "Apple Gary Marcus'd LLM's reasoning ability", it does refer to a very specific issue of whether LLMs can lead to AGI or not.

I don't know whether he's right or wrong, but deep down I feel the amount of money funneled in the Transformed architecture might have blocked other approaches, both potentially promising and others doomed for failure, just because LLMs' quick wins.

dvfjsdhgfv··on Sam Altman's pants are on fire
I'm sorry, I didn't mean to insult you. To explain the reason: you seem to use some particular wordings that just seem strange to me, such as first saying that Marcus position is that "LLMs are impossible" which is either false or incredibly imprecise shortcut for "AGI using LLMs is impossible", and then claiming it was beautiful.

I didn't mean to attack you personally and I'm really sorry if it sounded this way. I appreciate the generally positive atmosphere on HN and I believe it more important than the actual argument, whatever it may be.

dvfjsdhgfv··on Sam Altman's pants are on fire
> And my phrasing was wonderful and perfect.

Do you use LLMs to post on HN? I'm asking seriously.

dvfjsdhgfv··on Sam Altman's pants are on fire
> LLMs are essentially impossible

This is the worst misrepresentation of Marcus' argument I've seen so far.

dvfjsdhgfv··on Sam Altman's pants are on fire
Well, sama managed to convince a lot of people to give his company billions, is making apocalyptic predictions that some CEOs take seriously etc. Making sure people at large realize the guy has a very loose relationship with truth, for many years, seems like public service. It's only libel if you spread false statements which Marcus is careful not to make.
dvfjsdhgfv··on I was right about dishwasher pods and now I can prove it [video]
"It won't be the same if I just tell you, you have to watch it" - my mom on the video of some fake MD selling his miraculous variant of vitamin C that cures everything from cancer to dementia.
dvfjsdhgfv··on I was right about dishwasher pods and now I can prove it [video]
Mind sharing the script? It's becoming a big problem to me: people send me links to "must watch videos" but neither the title nor description nor subchapter titles tell me what it actually is about.

In this particular case, it's spending 40 minutes of my life on something that could be explained in 4 sentences.

dvfjsdhgfv··on EVs are depreciating faster than gas-powered cars
Most individual buyers are unable or not willing to take global perspectives into account, otherwise Japanese cars would never make impact on the American market for example. You need people in power to make informed decisions, and even then you risk the only result will be people getting very angry that politician mess up with the market.
dvfjsdhgfv··on AI has a cargo cult problem
> If I'm tired of one thing related to AI/llm/chatbots it's the claims that it's not useful.

That is the best example of straw argument I've seen this year. I enjoy reading discussions on LLMs and have seen a huge number of arguments, some reasonable and some ridiculous, but one thing I haven't seen is someone claiming that LLMs are not useful. We can discuss usefulness for a particular purpose, or the level of its fitness for it, but not the fact that millions of people find LLMs useful enough to pay for them.

dvfjsdhgfv··on Migrating from AWS to Hetzner
3x seems quite low, I routinely get 7-11x higher performance on Hetzner when compared to AWS. Also the conclusion of this old benchmark is still partially true: https://jan.rychter.com/enblog/cloud-server-cpu-performance-...
dvfjsdhgfv··on M5 MacBook Pro
Well, they could continue the 8gb joke so let's appreciate the fact that they finally switched to 16gb base models (and similarly stopped the 128GB SSD madness, these models were outdated when bought).
dvfjsdhgfv··on Disk Prices
Well, at least for the medical care, it pretty much is:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_health_care_by_count...

dvfjsdhgfv··on Disk Prices
> The EU sucks.

I, on the other hand, I love the EU. In spite of the fact that many products are sold for a lower price in the American market (not just electronics, also cars and others). I imagine it's even worse in the Australian market.

But, in the grand scheme of things, I can live with that, with free education and healthcare, among others.

dvfjsdhgfv··on The day my smart vacuum turned against me
> I initially skipped this comment as sarcasm

Why on earth would you do it?! It was literally the comment I visit HN for - a solution for the problem we basically all have, already tested by someone, starting a thread with people's experience of it.

dvfjsdhgfv··on I am a programmer, not a rubber-stamp that approves Copilot generated code
Agree completely, while "what" is completely redundant most of the time, a couple of "why"s can be of immense help later, to oneself and others.
dvfjsdhgfv··on Palisades Fire suspect's ChatGPT history to be used as evidence
I don't get these people. I get nervous to type even something like "why in movies people throw up after killing someone" in Google, even in incognito mode. Why would anyone put something even remotely incriminating into the hands of another company?
dvfjsdhgfv··on Why the push for Agentic when models can barely follow a simple instruction?
> we know that creating CLAUDE.md or cursorrules basically does nothing

While I agree, the only cases where I actually created something barely resembling useful (while still of subpar quality) was only after putting in CLAUDE.md lines like:

YOUR AIM IS NOT TO DELIVER A PROJECT. YOU AIM IS TO DO DEEP, REPETITIVE E2E TESTING. ONLY E2E TESTS MATTER. BE EXTREMELY PESSIMISTIC. NEVER ASSUME ANYTHING WORKS. ALWAYS CHECK EVERY FEATURE IN AT LEAST THREE DIFFERENT WAYS. USE ONLY E2E TESTS, NEVER USE OTHER TYPES OF TEST. BE EXTREMELY PESSIMISTIC. NEVER TRUST ANY CODE UNLESS YOU DEEPLY TEST IT E2E

REMEMBER, QUICK DELIVERY IS MEANINGLESS, IT'S NOT YOUR AIM. WORK VERY SLOWLY, STEP BY STEP. TAKE YOUR TIME AND RE-VERIFY EACH STEP. BE EXTREMELY PESSIMISTIC

With this kind of setup, it kind attempts to work in a slightly different way than it normally does and is able to build some very basic stuff although frankly I'd do it much better so not sure about the economics here. Maybe for people who don't care or won't be maintaining this code it doesn't matter but personally I'd never use it in my workplace.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →