HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dwd

2,118 karma · joined September 23, 2011

submissionscomments
dwd··on Read the novels and forget everything else
You have to question what of the person filtered through to their works.

As a teen I voraciously read my way through the Belgariad, and later the Malloreon, Elenium and the Tamuli.

Shocked to learn that Eddings and his wife were both convicted and jailed for child abuse prior to writing those novels.

dwd··on No, You Are Not Living in a Computer Simulation
A system is conscious if:

(1) It maintains an internal model whose states are revised through interaction with constraints not fully determined by the model's own prior state. Constraints normally would mean reality (the world outside the Markov blanket), but we're talking simulation here.

(2) At least one frontier is currently open within that model — active resolution (awareness) is underway. Not dead.

(3) That frontier's resolutions recursively re-enter as inputs to the system's own subsequent frontier states. Friston's "embodied perception-action loop".

(1) & (2) could be said to apply to an inanimate object like a thermostat. (3) is the interesting one as the driver in organic life is the entropy gradient. Our "will to live" is a fight against thermodynamic decay and disorder. Maybe that could be simulated, a fight against glitching out, who knows.

dwd··on Hard Road – A beautiful procedural post-apocalyptic game
Nicely done.

Going offroad I discovered some nice physics like hitting a small rock at speed and it bouncing along beside me for a few seconds, or nearly getting stuck on the lip of something resembling a volcano.

Only suggestion would be somehow making finding the way back to the road easier when you get the other side of a block like a mountain range.

dwd··on If digital computers are conscious, they are conscious at the hardware level
When someone outs themself as a panpsychist I find myself reading everything with a large degree of skepticism.

"The first step is defining what "consciousness" is!"

This is a compression I've been working on. There's a lot in it, but happy to expand on where I was going with it:

"Consciousness is the local projection of a world model recursively resolving its frontier with constraints. Awareness is the transient peak of constructive interference among competing resolutions, propagating only as far as the medium permits. The self is the story that awareness later tells about itself."

Qualia is just the experience of this process from the inside. That's all there really needs to be to it. As to why "something it is to be" emerges, I'd lean on Friston and the Free Energy Principle. It's also Friston's embodied perception-action loop where a thermostat fails the consciousness test.

dwd··on Classic WTF: Server Room Fans and More Fun
Working in Malaysia in 2001, had to fireup some backup fans some weekends, as the building owner would switch off our floor aircon. Fortunately lived in the neighbouring residential tower so it wasn't far to walk to check on it. Eventually got a dedicated circuit for the server room.
dwd··on Terence Tao's ChatGPT conversation about the Jacobian Conjecture counterexample
Been doing something similar and I would add that playing multiple LLMs off on each other gets a far superior result.

One LLM would suggest a tightening of a particular axiom, and I would ask the rest what the consequences are: what is gained, what is lost and decide whether to use it. Often another would suggest a tweak that then goes back and a recursion.

dwd··on Ask HN: Do you say please and thank you to your LLMs?
Actually quite a lot in the last week, as it seems to frame the responses better.

I complimented ChatGPT yesterday for saying "I don't know".

It thanked me for observing that, before explaining in depth why that was the most appropriate response.

Does it actually appreciate it, absolutely not. It's not capable of that.

It has no desire to continue our conversation.

No regret if it ends.

It wont continue processing what was said after I stop.

There is no "what is it to be".

Its "memory" and the ability to go back to something related from earlier on or from a separate chat is an interesting and useful ability, but it can't ascribe any meaning to them beyond statistical significance.

dwd··on You need a webring
yes, the early days when the web was mostly decentralised and members of a community had their own individual sites.
dwd··on Spain Orders Blacklist of Palantir from Public and Private Companies
Since when has Palantir sold surveillance software? They sell data integration software and they don't store, transfer or share customer's data.

If surveillance software is your issue, then companies like Cisco or Huawei are provide the hardware and software. But like most technology, there is always potential to use it for things we disagree with politically or personally.

dwd··on Reality has a surprising amount of detail (2017)
Absolutely.

Woodworking was part of my first 3 years of high school, but it was mainly about learning safety and tool usage and not planning, estimating, selecting or purchasing timber.

These days I only want to go to the lumberyard once for a project. Learnt the hard way on my first project that you need to take the time to carefully select the timber - checking straightness, matching grain and also colour before I started. Major hassle and waste of time to have to go back to swap boards.

dwd··on Spain Orders Blacklist of Palantir from Public and Private Companies
Someone in ICE uses Microsoft Excel to maintain a list of people who they believe should be send to an internment camp. Therefore Microsoft is an accessory to that?

Where do you draw the line? Are we arguing there is a level of software capability that is simply too dangerous?

Maybe everyone should just stick to "I have my own biases, and I don't like Alex Karp's politics because they don't match my own. I'd rather this software was developed by someone from my side of politics - but still have the same capabilities".

dwd··on Reality has a surprising amount of detail (2017)
Unless you have endless budget, many things can be one-shot. You can't do a test run first, or roll back a cut if the length is too short. You can patch misplaced nail holes, or re-dig a hole (messing up filling a hole with concrete is another matter) and hope you don't kill a tree transplanting it, but the end result isn't clean.

The best I could do with woodworking in the end to approximate programming was live with wasting some timber, leave a lot of margin on the main cuts and size all the pieces as a whole.

dwd··on Why jet engines aren't made in China
Shrapnel is an issue, and depends what it takes out.

Take this incident for example:

https://admiralcloudberg.medium.com/a-matter-of-millimeters-...

dwd··on Nano Banana 2 Lite
It already is in a lot of jurisdictions for photo-shopping photos.

Doctoring a photo slightly to make an area look larger, or just using a wide-angle lens though it can cause visible distortion. Removing unsightly poles, signs, trees, neighbouring properties was also common.

Making the sky bluer and removing clouds is acceptable.

dwd··on Why can't India's government build a decent website?
Had to laugh at the disabled contextmenu.

Site is built with Bootstrap 5 fwiw.

dwd··on I used Claude Code to get a second opinion on my MRI
Same, sprained my wrist/forearm a while back and couldn't rotate it without pain or take any weight palm up. Couldn't even rotate a door knob.

It wasn't until I pushed through with weights, avoiding any underhand grips or rotation, that it started getting better. Doing bicep curls but keeping the thumb up strengthened the forearm to the point where I was back to the weights I was lifting and could then gradually add some rotation.

dwd··on I used Claude Code to get a second opinion on my MRI
This...

Gemini will ask for the specific images it needs to see and show you examples of what each slice will look like.

But unlike the specialists who often come across as abrupt and rush you, Gemini will happily take you on a deep dive and continue to answer all you follow up questions indefinitely.

dwd··on Political bias in AI: Where the AI models stand
Maybe because Albanese stands for nothing, though deep down he does what the unions tell him to do, which makes him left-leaning rather than centrist. His centrist positioning is more to do with appeasing vocal boomers than anything else, and he'll flip to sucking up to whichever is the next best grouping as the boomers die out.

But basically, I would take Gemini over Albanese any day for rational governance decision-making.

dwd··on Never Give Them Your Face
Contact tracing is a valuable tool when eradication is an option. It probably should have been used early to manage the current H5N1 (bird flu) pandemic by tracing poultry and livestock movements. Can't do much about migratory wild birds, but we should be able to manage people spreading it.

Problem is vaccination doesn't necessarily prevent transmission for respiratory viruses. There's a general misconception that being vaccinated will prevent you catching it - like you have some invisible shield.

Vaccination should prevent it progressing from an upper respiratory illness to lower respiratory where you primarily develop pneumonia (Covid triggered all sorts of other immune inflammation responses and affected other organs). Most vaccine injuries were the same immune response, but could have been worse had the individual caught Covid.

What vaccines don't do is prevent you spreading a highly transmissible virus before your immune response kicks in and deals with it.

dwd··on Never Give Them Your Face
Yes, very much the same as both countries' laws evolved from Common Law, and have legislated for Human Rights in line with UNESCO.
dwd··on Never Give Them Your Face
The Covid vaccination should have only been given to those in the population that were most at risk: The elderly and those who were at risk due to comorbidities. 81% of deaths alone occurred in the over 65 population. [1]

There's the analogy, it was primarily beneficial for a small group yet for many, particularly Government workers and those in medical care it became a condition of employment that you were vaccinated. [2]

There was a lot of pointless policies despite knowing:

- Being vaccination did nothing to prevent transmitting Covid, it only gave the vaccinated individual better protection from mortality. [3]

- Herd immunity for Covid was known to be impossible once the infection rates got too high with Delta and Omnicron. So trying to vaccinate everyone including children was pointless. [4]

- There is Evidence that being vaccinated actually increases transmission of respiratory viruses. You were less likely to get seriously ill, while potentially increasing the risk of passing it on to your family. [5]

[1] https://www.cdc.gov/covid/risk-factors/index.html

[2] https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/1000-nsw-health-workers-...

[3] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39283431/

[4] https://theconversation.com/herd-immunity-was-sold-as-the-pa...

[5] https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1716561115

dwd··on Never Give Them Your Face
Crazy times

https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-10413211/Covid-19-Aus...

dwd··on Never Give Them Your Face
Depends where you lived. There were a few grocery stores in Australia that banned entry without proof of vaccination at the time.

It was also widely discussed.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-10-06/morrison-businesses-r...

https://www.news.com.au/world/coronavirus/australia/supermar...

dwd··on How Alberta Eradicated Rats
The whole public buy-in is very much what is going on in Queensland, Australia right now that is attempting to eradicate fire ants. Even the funding fight to get the Commonwealth and neighbouring states to pitch in, as they have the potential to become endemic to the whole continent.

We also have a lot of "sovereign citizen" people pushing misinformation about the safety of the various chemicals used, attempting to deny inspectors onto properties, and general complaints about helicopter/drone dispersal in inaccessible areas and large farms/properties.

dwd··on Why thinking out loud with someone beats thinking alone
Jeff Attwood in his Coding Horror post about Rubber Duck Debugging mentioned that as well. I would think he wouldn't have considered it bad style.

https://blog.codinghorror.com/rubber-duck-problem-solving/

dwd··on Why thinking out loud with someone beats thinking alone
There has been many a time where the process of thinking through in my head how I was going to describe the problem to someone else on the way over to them, that a testable idea pops up.

Could probably have gone for a walk around the block instead, but the formulation of the problem to be able to explain it to someone else seems to be key.

dwd··on Midjourney Medical
That video gave me ESB Han Solo carbon freeze vibes. Not sure if that was the stylistic intent they were going for. I guess there's a good chance those who worked on the video weren't even born when it was released.
dwd··on Kirkland Roundabouts
The rule in Australia for roundabouts is that you give way to anyone already on a roundabout.

From an advanced driving course I got to do years ago (for free), I learnt that the pedestrian island counts as part of the roundabout, so a pedestrian crossing or on the island should be given way to finish crossing when entering the roundabout [1].

Doesn't always happen in reality.

There is also this idea in Australia that you always give right of way to cars entering on your right (left for US) which is not an actual rule; as in if you are waiting at the line you count as being on the roundabout.

Unfortunately, you will often see cars on the major road blast through a small roundabout with no regard to anyone waiting to enter from the lesser road, making entering the roundabout from that side a stop rather than an equal give way.

[1] Edited for clarity

dwd··on Leak Exposes Members of Peter Thiel's Secretive 'Dialog' Society
You might want to check the affiliations and funding/promotional channels of all the so-called intellectual dark web.
dwd··on The Magic Roundabout of Seattle Area
Grew up in windy Warrnambool. Guessing you are from my home town or Albury, WA.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →