109 karma · joined August 25, 2011
1mdc was a similar service to this that I used as did many others about 10 years ago for the purpose of obfuscating and anonymizing e-gold transactions between various accounts. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1mdc
One interesting comment from the wiki page: "1mdc's e-gold was held in unallocated (pooled) storage (in several e-gold user accounts) which allowed for extra privacy from e-gold's administrators. However, this increased storage risk, as the client had no precedence on the e-gold they entrusted 1mdc to hold, and there was virtually no way for a user to ensure that 1mdc is maintaining full reserves of their e-gold."
https://blog.hypothes.is/a-letter-to-marc-andreessen-and-rap...
And yes, as others have said-- this isn't anything close to the feature set we want, that has now been taken from us: the customer.
And what of Eric's quote? Sounds like someone who's busy building a self-driving car-- not someone who loves the beauty of being a pilot!
Are we to cede all functions that we used to master to computers? Really?
Give me a break.
Unfortunately I probably won't make it to a day or two. What you really strive for as a designer is more like "I can guarantee that after 30 seconds you won't be going back". I can tell you that I'm already uninstalling it. Don't change the styling-- or at least leave the information density that we've got w/ HN now.
It's worth saying (and has been said elsewhere already) that fully distributed search has existed for years. Kadmelia is just one notable example in wide use. I do think it's great that it's coming to the torrent world though!
The characterization of it by many seems to suggest that this is novel and groundbreaking.
The statements made about how you'd have to shut down the internet to take it down are also a bit hyperbolic. After all, algorithms to sniff, detect and either block or throttle this kind of traffic are widely deployed. Of course it's an arms race and encryption and obfuscation are used to counter. I'm not sure what the current state of that battle is, but clearly the main tool in protecting these kinds of capabilities is our voices, not fundamental technical properties.
Morality is a social construct, a contract that we all essentially buy into. Immorality is the violation of that.
If anything is immoral it's stealing 100s of 1000s of people's precious time (multiple times per day) with robotic systems--simply so you can make a few bucks, by providing no social value whatsoever. It undermine the fabric of what holds us together.
Personally, the response seems elegant and appropriate. A highly targeted activity that is likely to affect only the intended target. Maybe someone that lives in Latvia will go buy a cream pie and throw it in his face as he leaves his house!