HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dylangs1030

2,946 karma · joined October 29, 2011

dylan.sacco@yahoo.com

Security researcher residing in New York.

submissionscomments
dylangs1030··on U.S. directs agents to cover up program used to investigate Americans
From what I gather in this explanation, if the DEA has unusable evidence, they can still springboard it to finding evidence that would be admissible in court? Is that true?

So, effectively, despite the fruit of the poisonous tree doctrine, there isn't real, persistent transparency going back more than a step or two in the evidence gathering process. It's more like judging immediate evidence on its own, without questioning the steps that lead up to its (otherwise valid) finding?

dylangs1030··on Latvia blocking extradition of Gozi writer due to disproportionate US sentencing
I would be okay with a maximum sentence of five years.

I believe it's important to consider prison as rehabilitation, not as vengeance. The tone of your consideration makes it clear that you'd want him in jail only for vengeance - it's not up to you to "be okay" with the offender's sentence. All that matters is that it is appropriate.

Depending on the prison, I would be okay with a criminal spending only five years for every degree of murder save for first degree.

I can assure you, you'll get over your bank account being empty. Yes, I know, you could lose a substantial amount of money. But there is insurance for these sorts of things (despite it not being foolproof), and I don't think you fully consider how five years of prison can change you.

dylangs1030··on HN is Becoming 2005 Slashdot
I strongly suspect he means stories.
dylangs1030··on HN is Becoming 2005 Slashdot
I disagree with 'tptacek on the number of actual users plaguing Hacker News like this, but I think it's fairly undeniable the phenomenon is there and it's strong.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_know_it_when_i_see_it

You don't need data. I know, that's an unpopular phrase to say on a forum like Hacker News - but seriously, if you were alive at the keyboard on HN during the NSA debacle, you shouldn't need to ask for data. Whether there were 100 or 10 people poisoning the discussion with political strife, they were certainly the most vocal and noticeable. Their comments were easily upvoted because they were full of pathos and emphatic calls to action. As I wrote in my reply to pg here, I don't think it's enough to do what's being done now with stories - there should be a user filtering system. Restricting posts somehow could be good, but I also understand that we don't want to turn the forum into some sort of elaborate rule system.

I also believe the problem is intimately related to karma farming, and also intimately related to overpopulation. Hacker News is a fond ideal, but I don't believe it scales. Not without changes at least. I know that might be an unpopular opinion, but I think it's true.

dylangs1030··on HN is Becoming 2005 Slashdot
With respect, pg, three things:

1. Why is it not a cause to worry if Hacker News declines at all? It doesn't matter if it happens by default when it does happen. It might not be reversible.

2. Corollary to that, I believe it has happened. During the NSA scandal, I tried to do what I could to dispel what could best be described as hysteria. I don't believe the majority of people on Hacker News can be described by hysteria, but a hugely vocal minority can be, and they direct the movements of the front page.

3. I am not pessimistic about Hacker News, I don't like to believe the forum is succumbing to the inexorable march of time, or some such. And I'm not going to soapbox comparisons to reddit. However, I don't think optimism is enough. You don't seem to be particularly concerned about this, but I see sentiments of concern at least daily in some form or another.

I understand I'm not a powerhouse of karma and influence here on Hacker News, but I've tried twice to raise proposals for some sort of change to the political atmosphere of the forum. It hasn't worked. What else do you have but optimism, to put it bluntly?

EDIT: When I joined Hacker News in 2011, I wasn't as savvy to the mechanics of the forum as I am now. I thought that the front page being dominated by political fads every few months or so was just regular. But in being here to the present, I've seen that it has only gotten worse from 2011 to 2013, and in reading archives/the comments of senior members, I can see how this pattern developed. That's why I've tried before to submit a proposal to the changes thread.

I submit that it doesn't matter if politics can be intellectually gratifying or even relevant, as per the guidelines. It's categorically unrelated to startups or technology, save for being indirectly so in occasional cases when those two topics scale. Whatever benefit comes with political discourse is eliminated by the sheer level of scathing derision that comes from combatting sides debating the topic.

dylangs1030··on HN is Becoming 2005 Slashdot
Fair enough. I did mean unintentionally.
dylangs1030··on HN is Becoming 2005 Slashdot
Haha, I'm assuming you're speaking to my comment length...sorry, that's pretty par for the course with my comment history :) I like to write with a level of verbosity.

But...I do agree with you. It becomes harder to sift through facts when a post is very long. I do it because I enjoy writing long prose on topics I'm interested in - I don't think it's particularly correlated with getting high karma. I've seen very high comments that consist of a little paragraph (albeit packed with technical information).

But I think a lot of people do just click and write for karma. As long as there is a karma system, this is somewhat unavoidable. I really wish we could do away with the entire karma system entirely, but your suggestion about posts "costing" karma sounds really neat, I'd definitely test that on a small forum...not sure how you'd deal with throwaways though, and how would new users accrue karma?

dylangs1030··on HN is Becoming 2005 Slashdot
While I agree with you that all of those things are ridiculous (and I was vocal in arguing against them), is it fair to characterize the entire forum as being so easily swayed by ant-state sentiments?

During the two week "freak out", I saw a lot of linkbait about the NSA having massive conspiracies, but I saw relatively fewer actual comments where people were clearly being swayed by anti-government sentiment. For every comment I read that was outlandish, fallacious and clearly media spoon-fed, I have to say I can recall a thread of people saying, "No, that doesn't make sense, you're trying to disprove a negative", etc.

tl;dr - My point here is that I think the baseline intelligence of Hacker News is higher than we might think it is just by observing the front page, and that there are actually a lot more savvy people gaming the front page who are just driven by a relative few who act as the passionate, vocal majority.

That's just my opinion. I could be wrong. But I like to think there's a lot of under the radar intellectual activity, and people are just being really opportunistic for karma or some such.

As for legal acumen, I agree completely - I don't have nearly as much as, for example, 'rayiner. But that's exactly why we have people with niche expertise or domain knowledge. It's a real problem when people get frenzied and decide they know Constitution without having read it.

I haven't been here as long, but I believe that we have sampling bias from the hugely outspoken minority who know it's trendy to be anti-state.

EDIT: I want to submit my experience about the site being gameable - it's true it's easy to get the top comment for news stories that are heavily politically loaded, but I have to say it's easy to karma farm even if you're not anarchist/cynical/conspiracy mongering. I do not try to game the forum to get high comments, but I can still personally attest to having some top comments in the high 40s during the NSA scandal while being incredibly vocal against the "popular opinion" that Google was directly aiding the government. I probably had the top comment on at least half of those stories, arguing against the tone of the story profusely. I don't have a sockpuppet ring, so those numbers of people who upvoted me are to the best of my knowledge genuine. They may not have been as vocal in their agreement with me as the detractors who replied to my comments, but they certainly exist.

I guess I just want to try to dispel pessimism. I don't think all is lost regarding the political climate of Hacker News :)

dylangs1030··on Ask HN: What is your significant other like?
Completely unlike me; a liberal arts major and works on Broadway. Much more creative than I am - she prefers to talk about more down to earth, entertaining things (T.V. we're watching, her day working with actors/actresses, etc.) than computer architecture, and she loves being artistic (painting, drawing, singing).

That said, she's very intelligent, but not technically so. I'm the kind of person who sucks up knowledge like a sponge - she doesn't get the same kind of joy out of reading Wikipedia :).

To be clear, I love this setup. It's really wonderful being with someone completely non-technical for a host of reasons. The worst thing that comes up is that she asks me to debug her computer once in a while.

EDIT: Read the other comments. I do find she has the same sense of humor as me (I think that's really important), and I think that's really important. In situations like this I think it's really important that we're both open to different lifestyles for it to be compatible. She's very open to listening to the intricate details of a programming language, and I get pleasure out of learning how professional theatre operates (to give one example).

dylangs1030··on Founder of Tor Freedom Hosting arrested in Ireland, awaiting extradition to USA
You missed the more important part of my comment - that this shouldn't be up for discussion. That has nothing to do with whether or not I'm right.

I think I'm right in my view, and if you think I'm wrong that's okay. But let's not argue that kind of point here on Hacker News. That's not to say you can't question my view; I was answering a question. But I'm not going to engage in debate about it because I find it abhorrent to do so.

dylangs1030··on Founder of Tor Freedom Hosting arrested in Ireland, awaiting extradition to USA
You see, this is why I had said it shouldn't be discussed on a forum like this. I believe an honest human response would be more empathic and simply take something like CP being important without requiring extensive rationalization.

Your response, nit-picking my words as a form of debate, is counter to an empathic response, and entirely what I had hoped to avoid. I'm not going to engage in that line of thought because, honestly, there are a multitude of reasons why child pornography should be a priority. I won't argue them, and I understand that might be unpopular, but will you really debate someone on this?

dylangs1030··on The White Hat's Dilemma
Classically, I respond to this line of thinking - the doubt of being an exceptionally "good" person - with the following self-assessed metric:

"If you were raised in the deep South during the 18th and 19th centuries, would you be aggressively racist, ambivalent or abolitionist in your views towards Black enslavement?"

The immediate gut feeling that people feel is important, because it doesn't end there. You then ask if that gut feeling can be reasoned to be consistent with their behavior, or if it's just a feel-good response. If someone really feels they'd be abolitionist, this should be at least somewhat reflected in small examples of day to day behavior. People don't reserve "goodness" for large deeds, they are usually the kind of people who help out in small, less noticeable/outspoken ways as well.

NB: This is not a test designed to prove how good someone is to another person, it's a self-assessment. It's asked to help the person learn more about themselves.

dylangs1030··on The $4 Million Teacher
Ah I understand what you're saying now. Thanks for the clarification :)
dylangs1030··on The $4 Million Teacher
rayiner, how is it consistent with the rest of what you're saying that math/science degrees are worthless?

Understand, I acknowledge you might have more knowledge/experience on this, I'm just skeptical. I would think - and the tone of your argument seems to posit - that it matters more what you decide to do with that degree than what degree you have.

Is it really worthless to have a good math degree if you become a quant? I understand market oversaturation, but that could be said of almost every degree, moreso liberal arts.

dylangs1030··on The White Hat's Dilemma
I agree, and I'd also like to mention the other usually cited experiment along those lines - the Milgram obedience experiment.

http://wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_Experiment

dylangs1030··on The White Hat's Dilemma
Eh...well intentioned, but no. There would be severe consequences for just offering employment to such sensitive individuals.

People like Snowden are not branded untouchable because people are ideologically opposed to his actions - that's a misrepresentation of what's actually going on. Whistleblowers become shunned because whoever they come into contact with will be elevated to accomplice status.

Google doesn't want that kind of fire under their ass. Altruism is all well and good, but there's a reason wh you're instructed to put your own oxygen mask on in a airplane emergency.

If a company like Google did that, they would immediately: 1. Place Snowden in United States lawful jurisdiction, 2. Endanger their own fiscal well-being, 3. Draw political attention and divisive sentiments to themselves.

I believe tech companies have a responsibility to take a stand, but being the hero and standing up to the man like that is essentially taking out Snowden and your company in a massive kamekaze attack that benefits only his detractors.

dylangs1030··on The White Hat's Dilemma
It's categorical rejection. Instead of opening up that venue and having to navigate the murky waters of cognitive dissonance and moral obligations against lucrative opportunity, you simply don't open the door. You stick to a client base that is meaningful (relatively so) but not highly impactful and potentially dangerous down the road.
dylangs1030··on The $4 Million Teacher
Anecdotally, I know many. Both my parents would work for that amount all their lives if they had to because they're good and love the profession.

More importantly, $60,000 is enough for a middle class income. It's also not the reasonable maximum for being a public or private school teacher in metropolitan areas. You can realistically earn $90,000-$120,000 as a teacher if you're good, network for connections, and stay in the loop for jobs. Seniority and having a degree go a long way to raises.

dylangs1030··on The $4 Million Teacher
I agree. My mother worked in the NYCDOE. She's had to deal with incompetent teachers reaching tenure all her life. The problem is that tenure is more a function of time and seniority than qualifications or track record.
dylangs1030··on The $4 Million Teacher
I have to agree with you here. Both my parents were career teachers (then professors). One was in the NYCDOE - she could talk your ear off about the mispraftices of the teacher's union and the unfairness of lackeys promoted to a position of tenure in a school administration.

There's another issue here too - I know very qualified teachers who can't leave the city public schools because people with tenure reduce the amount of open positions on the market. This is partly market saturation of teachers, but still, it's hard to find a lucrative school system with more than one position open, and even then it's flooded with spammed resumes.

EDIT: I'd like to note that the "unfireability" isn't by itself a bad thing. It's just that the system rewards consistent mediocrity rather than relatively untested brilliance. The first people out the door are young and unexperienced teachers, even if they have a higher track record for success than their seniors. It's deplorable.

dylangs1030··on Founder of Tor Freedom Hosting arrested in Ireland, awaiting extradition to USA
Honestly, I have to say I don't think this is an appropriate comment for a forum like this. It opens up a possibly disgusting debate.

That said...it's an incredibly common problem. I'm not going to point you where to look for proof, but you could easily find it if you wanted to. And that's horrific.

The reason why it's so bad is because it's exploitation of children, who could not have led themselves into a vulnerable situation of their own accord.

There's no reason to get into it any further, it's vile. And I want to reiterate...this really isn't the place for questioning why it shows up so much.

dylangs1030··on Why I hate read receipts
I don't agree. If someone got angry at me for ignoring them, I'd be very transparent about the fact, and then continue to ignore them. Not my responsibility. Human beings are free to continue or end social communication at any time for any reason, without being required to disclose the reason. Full stop.

It's also not just an aloof principle - how often does someone who really matters message you on Facebook? You can afford to have friends and family get angry because you ignored them. It's not as if your boss will routinely ping you through informal means.

dylangs1030··on Why I hate read receipts
Theoretically, they shouldn't have to. If he's too busy, he probably didn't open it in the first place, leaving only one option.

In practice, however, I find people can usually tell via context that they're being ignored. There are some subjects you'd expect this or see it coming before other, more benign ones.

dylangs1030··on Why I hate read receipts
This is incredibly hyperbolic...there's no such thing as a compulsory reply. It's not your responsibility if someone reacts badly and gets upset because you don't want to respond; they need to deal with it. Period.

Read receipts really aren't this serious. They don't even warrant an entire article about the sociological implications of their implementation. It just says the other person got it, and read it. That's it. No mandates follow. Just have the personal fortitude to not respond when you don't want to respond, that should be second nature before you engage in social communication.

It's really not a big deal to ignore people. You shouldn't be afraid to just because of what they'll think. It's not your problem - it wasn't before this technology, and it won't be after the next innovation.

dylangs1030··on License-Plate Readers Let Police Collect Millions of Records on Drivers
I disagree. I think that is probable cause.

I don't think there should be a penalty for it, but it's definitely worth checking out.

For example, if there's a man with a suspended license and no wife or kids, it would be suspicious for his car to just be on the road.

dylangs1030··on Stop selling your Software for Peanuts
This is right. As much as we as developers would love to raise our prices, we exist in an insular world where we all understand the development process.

Users and customers don't care how long it took to build an app - it's replaceable and they can afford to pass it up. Developers can't afford to have users pass their software up.

The market is dictated by customers, not the other way around. Like it or not, the app economy (in its current state) rewards those who deal with this reality and break out of it somehow. It's ugly and not ideal, but accepting this is the first step to finding success.

On the other hand, encouraging people to charge more for a beautifully designed, but otherwise replicable game is useless. The highest grossing apps consistently are the first in their niche, do something none of the competitors can, or have incredible financial and engineering endeavors to get noticed.

dylangs1030··on Stop selling your Software for Peanuts
The race to the bottom is everywhere, but you're right in that it's most apparent in games.

As always, developers are not necessarily savvy in business. Common sense suggests that undercutting competition with lowered prices will drive market share upwards, eventually beating them out. This is a desperation move, and one that only ever works in the short term, if it does at all.

The truth is the race to the bottom exists because this kind of tactic is deployed by everyone in response to everyone else. But it will only work as a calculated move that crunches the numbers to find a sweet spot. Reducing your game from $5 to $1 might get a lot more customers, but you'll need to increase your user base fivefold just to match your previous revenue. That's not realistic in most cases.

It's the same logic that people without a real edge mistakenly employ when they say they'll disrupt an industry by taking something really valuable and making it both better and free. It's not sustainable, but everyone does it.

dylangs1030··on Stop selling your Software for Peanuts
It's never going to be simple because the market isn't an ideally functioning organism.

'patio11 makes great points, but his advice is mostly actionable for desktop software and web applications, which are a completely different beast than mobile apps.

Mobile applications won't sell at high prices unless they have a real core competency that solves a real need that doesn't exist yet - indie games and to-do list apps have little hope of achieving that kind of benefit.

Aside from that, there is such a low barrier to entry that they need that kind of incredible edge over the competition to survive at high prices.

Take a look at the high-priced apps and you'll notice a trend - they're typically not games/entertainment/weather/"fun" apps. They're real tools that can be used in production or they're productivity suites.

dylangs1030··on Stop selling your Software for Peanuts
The author has a really good point here, but it's not realistic advice for a lot of mobile developers. As much as I'd love to agree on principle, I don't think it'll happen with the app stores' current incarnations.

There are several problems that prevent this from being actionable for most devs:

1. The barrier to entry is consistently getting lower, not higher. It's no longer particularly difficult to deploy an app - either learn to design and build it, or pay people to do that for you. It's never been easier to put yourself out there as a mobile developer.

2. This isn't marketing enterprise software to employees with spending access to sizable company budgets. This is marketing small applications of limited practical value (i.e. almost every mobile game) to people with limited wealth without much in the way of customer support. People are shrewd about their software nowadays - yes, they are more willing to spend their money on a Starbucks coffee than an app, and you can argue the existential implications and idiocy of this all you want, it's still what they're willing to do with their money.

3. The markets are too large. They're saturated with crap and quality alike and it's insanely difficult to get noticed. If you are making a game, weather, networking, camera, utility or entertainment app, you've got the deck stacked against you. These are released en masse every single day by teams of developers. Because of this, it's a race to the bottom and quality becomes undervalued. This is, as always, supply and demand.

4. A lot of the app store is an old boys' club, and the way to get in front of a wide range of users is broken. If you have a reputable team behind you, a large company's backing and you do a lot of marketing, this will not be an issue for you. But that's not most developers. Most developers will struggle to swim upstream in vain just to get noticed in one of the "Top ___" lists. They might get a faint spotlight at #25 before being thrown back into the depths of the app store like a rejected fish on a line. It gives the term "starving artist" a new meaning.

I mean, I don't want to be cynical. I'm all in favor of developers not underselling themselves. But I think you have to do a lot more than just tell people to adjust their prices when you have all the aforementioned forces working against them.

I can see that in some cases selling your mobile software for more leads to nice benefits, like less of a customer support headache, requiring fewer purchases, etc. But that's not possible for most devs because most apps couldn't reasonably be priced at 30 euros. A really high quality audio or business app could be, sure. But that indie game house? No, that advice doesn't help them.

dylangs1030··on Senate approves massive immigration bill
I read through this article and I don't believe it has a real bearing on most of HN's audience. I can understand politico-technical news and politics with underlying technology, but this is just pure government policy.
← PreviousPage 12 of 28Next →