HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dylangs1030

2,946 karma · joined October 29, 2011

dylan.sacco@yahoo.com

Security researcher residing in New York.

submissionscomments
dylangs1030··on Largest Homeless Camp In US is in Silicon Valley
>In absolute terms there is undoubtedly more extreme poverty in India than the US. Why that is so is not as simple as the country's broken social institutions, we're still talking about the world's largest democracy here. I would imagine the caste system plays a part. Colonialism too.

Wealth disparity is not what Rayiner was talking about. He was talking about social infrastructure. You're actually adding to his point here.

What he meant was that the wealthy class in India have about the same spending power as the middle class in the United States. They are sheltered away from the extreme destitution that is on display everywhere in their country and don't interact with the poor at all. It's perhaps 10x what you'd see from a rich person walking in NYC avoiding a beggar asking for change on the street.

Rapid urbanization and the slow collapse of the caste system has left a vacuum in India's culture that leads to stories like that of the poor woman we saw on Hacker News just last week or so. That is the lack of social infrastructure. Not enough is being done, and not quickly enough, to positively impact the society in a meaningful way. As it is now, India is in a state of culture shock that does nothing to help its economic system.

dylangs1030··on We Let Our Employee Set Their Own Salaries
Regarding your example about 100k and 20k 401k vs taxable 120k, it's probably not fiscally responsible to choose the latter except for certain fringe cases.

Without going into the deep financials, it's much easier to live below your means now in your 20s then when you are raising a family later on in life. It would therefore be wiser to live below your means (even if this means living like a college student in San Fran or NYC) and choose 100k, be relatively frugal, and put away that extra 20k without tax. Starting a solid 401k in your early 20s is one of the most fiscally sound decisions you can make.

I don't mean to criticize your reasoning, I'm just offering another perspective.

dylangs1030··on Retraction from Tumblr
I know it seems that way, but that's actually reddit and r/programming. Based on sheer numbers, I think most engineers don't frequent Hacker News.

I was just at dinner with an ex-Zynga game dev last night who had never even heard of it.

dylangs1030··on Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests
No, they aren't, not after the Guardian backtracked on "direct access." It was independently reported elsewhere as well.

http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-57588337-38/no-evidence-of...

dylangs1030··on Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests
How do you know it's just PR theater, and that these companies aren't just trying to legitimately defend their reputation? You dismiss the entire story and claim that it's so obvious, but how can any of us know that right now?

And, in the face of not knowing, why default to an explanation other than what has been given to us?

dylangs1030··on Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests
Yep...we have no proof of Google or Microsoft being complicit in NSA surveillance.

Despite that, news like this is going to be analyzed in whatever light suits the reader's bias. People are going to argue and say that this is just a fake attempt at saving face, and that it's a conspiracy sanctioned by the government to allow these companies to regain their reputation. Then there are going to be counter arguments citing what the CEOs announced publicly. And so on and so forth.

People will believe what they want, one way or another. Occam's razor be damned.

dylangs1030··on Dark Patterns - User Interfaces Designed to Trick People
Yep. Single click purchases shouldn't be utilized as much on mobile devices. The state of mobile apps is such that it's already not intensive to get to a checkout page where you buy something; it's not like Amazon where you might jump through 4-5 pages of confirmations and it's useful to seasoned buyers. Apps are so much smaller (comparatively) than entire websites that really you just need to tap a button from the options/main menu and then get to the selection area before payment. There's no address to put it, or shipping details that a "one-tap" could bypass and expediate.

I think whoever first thought, "Let's port one-click purchases to mobile!" either was being disingenuous or was only successful because it was used in an unintended, quasi-fraudulent way.

dylangs1030··on Dark Patterns - User Interfaces Designed to Trick People
Can you elaborate on this? Why did the practice of preferring bank withdrawals prevent you from just choosing a card...or paying some other way?
dylangs1030··on Dark Patterns - User Interfaces Designed to Trick People
Politely, I know you think you're helping people by maintaining awareness of the NSA, but a passing mention of Lavabit on a PayPal thread doesn't warrant a a tangent about the NSA and privacy. It seems kind of obsessive.

Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

dylangs1030··on Founder with an accent? Free offer from SayAfter.me
My girlfriend works in Broadway. I wish she knew enough about the recent foreign accents thing to find this as funny as I do. Well done.
dylangs1030··on Go Ahead, Mess With Texas Instruments
Regarding your 3), I think Python would be really good for this. Then they could graduate to C and lisp.

Also, I strongly agree with your 6). A small, monochrome screen was very painful to look at on my TI-83 when I was in school. I hated it (I also programmed it, but didn't have nearly as much fun as the author..I didn't think it was that cool).

dylangs1030··on Go Ahead, Mess With Texas Instruments
Hacker News patriotism is out of place here.

There's nothing in the guidelines about what constitutes legitimate top comments. Hacker News uses a democratic system, where those who choose to vote dictate what the most visible comment is.

Your expectation is narrow and doesn't reflect what the vocal majority want to see, evidently. It would appear most people appreciated his comment, in which case, who are you to dictate that should and should not be the top comment?

If you want to read salient points about the article, make an excellent comment so it will be upvoted, or scroll down and read them. They're there.

EDIT: I'd ask that if you downvote me, you at least comment on why you disagree. It's not like my opinion is just going to go away, guys.

dylangs1030··on Dean Karnazes: the man who can run for ever
>Next, they performed a lactate threshold test. They said the test would take 15 minutes, tops. Finally, after an hour, they stopped the test. They said they'd never seen anything like this before."

I'm not a biologist, but that seems like a bad reason to stop. He cleared an hour on the test. Why not maintain the test for several hours? Four times the theoretical maximum is not "forever"...

This article seems highly sensational. I'd like to see more science behind this.

dylangs1030··on Founders' Accents
There's really an island where people speak 18th century English? I find that really hard to believe. Do you know what it's called?

How well do they integrate with modern English speakers when they leave the island?

dylangs1030··on Graying Linux developers look for new blood
I actually love grep. I'm not sure why, but it's taken such a hold in my brain that I intuitively associate searching for something specific with the word "grep."

I agree with man. It makes sense technically because of "manual"...except that "man" is its own word. Every time I type man, I feel like I'm typing the gender, and it's weird.

cp bothers me because they shortened a four-letter word, the same with ls and list. Despite the original terminal constraints, they couldn't spare two characters?

dylangs1030··on No federal challenge to marijuana legalization in Colorado and Washington
People would dislike cops (even) more, slow down while driving, and municipalities would suddenly have an increase in revenue.
dylangs1030··on NSA finds Snowden hijacked officials’ logins
Short of a one-time pad, there's no such thing as truly secure, only theoretically secure according to time and processing constraints.

I'm not trying to be pedantic, I'm just saying, it's not mathematically impossible to crack a salted encryption without the cipher key.

dylangs1030··on I'm Building a GitHub for Writers
You could combine the advantages of git versioning with wiki style collaboration and make a git-wiki like the parent said, but for writers.

Wikipedia is largely prose, but of a nonfiction variety. This would be a good intersection for git, which was born out of code.

You could call it..."geeky"...too bad it wouldn't be for geeks.

dylangs1030··on What the fuck, Yahoo?
I'm late to this, but if I understand your problem correctly, you could tweak your firewall to auto-reject outbound packets being sent to Yahoo or Yahoo subdomains. You could also do this with a proxy intercepting all the requests your browser makes. Look at the headers and bodies of the packets and see if you can get a sense of what's going on in them to find out origin or referral codes for a possible abuser.

The next step is to remove the malware from your system. I'm assuming that you're using Windows (I don't think that's a dangerous assumption, as I've only ever seen toolbar malware and related on Windows). You'll want to google-fu the details you found in the packet headers. If that turns up nothing, dig around in your registry.

dylangs1030··on Bring Me Your Accents. Immigration Fuels Innovation
The ridiculous logic that statement employs aside, he has no obligation to treat it fairly. But if that's the case then whatever he says will just be disregarded. I won't treat his unfair dismissal as fair either. Okay, so we're where we started, with my point still standing.

Again, being snarky like this leads nowhere. If you're going to give a solid rebuttal, good! If you're not, then you're not achieving anything.

dylangs1030··on Bring Me Your Accents. Immigration Fuels Innovation
I suppose I could have said "coherent and articulate" instead of "heavily accented" so you're right. But I think my point stands.
dylangs1030··on Bring Me Your Accents. Immigration Fuels Innovation
I don't think you're being antagonistic towards PG, but I respect your not wanting to get into a heated debate. Nor do I.

I can see a reasonable case for you to say PG should add more clarification to his words when he's in an interview, but I also think PG has already done this. In at least two other places, Graham has publicly clarified what he meant by his comment about foreign accents. Perhaps if he had yet to do that and people were making a big fuss over his words, then I'd agree. But I think he's already done the due diligence.

dylangs1030··on Bring Me Your Accents. Immigration Fuels Innovation
I think you just disregarded my entire argument using a cultural taboo. Nice work.

See? I can play at that game too. The problem is, doing that doesn't get anywhere, because I'm still convinced of my point, and you're still convinced of yours, and there's no dialectic to compromise our ideas.

dylangs1030··on Bring Me Your Accents. Immigration Fuels Innovation
Bad example. There is nothing intrinsically different between a black QB and a white one, all other things being equal.

All other things being equal, there is a lot of difference between what an eloquent speaker can achieve and what a heavily accented speaker can achieve in the role of CEO.

This has nothing to do with preconceived bias. This has to do with Paul Graham's examination, over the course of funding over 500 different startups and his experience in that entire domain as a whole, that foreign accents are not desirable. The data is there; your bias prevents you from seeing it because you're misinterpreting it as discriminatory.

dylangs1030··on Bring Me Your Accents. Immigration Fuels Innovation
If being male, being white, and attending Harvard are all positively correlated with being successful in a startup, then there's actually nothing wrong with selectively looking for those qualifiers.

Does it make it more difficult to get a foot in the door if you're female, Ecuadorian and went to a community college, despite being a phenomenal programmer with a great idea? Yes, it does make it more difficult, but that's not their problem. They are choosing where to invest their money, and using math to do so should be encouraged.

If they don't have a spreadsheet in front of them, then at the very least they should understand that prestige is prestige for a reason.

Does that make it impossible to succeed without those qualifiers? No, but it's not unfair that it's more difficult to do so without them. You can't play a fair game all the way through. Sooner or later something's going to happen that's not in your favor.

dylangs1030··on Bring Me Your Accents. Immigration Fuels Innovation
I think people are blowing this out of proportion.

>I do not doubt that there may be correlation between people who have performed poorly in YC and "very strong accents", it does not mean causation.

It doesn't matter what the cause is, he's an investor, not a doctor. The cause is irrelevant. If there's correlation, that's enough to say no. Being an investor is a game where you find what's wrong before you try to find what's right. You don't approach deal-flow with "How can I make this work?" but "What does this person have to offer me?"

>The defense of "accents so strong you cannot understand" holds no water.

Nor should it be a defense; it's a solid fact. How many CEOs do you see in the United States who can't be understood very well when they're speaking?

>Nothing could have stopped him from saying "people who do not communicate well make bad CEOs.

You're right, nothing stopped him. Then again, he doesn't have any responsibility to people on a message board who will critique him without any experience of internal operations of Y Combinator. "Nothing stopped him" is a good enough reason for anything. It's invalid because it's not a logical rebuttal, it's just a tautology.

>Heaping the blame/responsibility of understanding on the readier/listener. How ironic considering the topic.

I'm a bit confused by this part. I think Paul Graham's entire point is that the responsibility of understanding is on the speaker...hence why strong accents aren't desirable in a CEO.

>I hope his position does not lead to default bias in YC companies. "He has a strong accent, I cannot ask him to be my co founder". Or "His strong accent means he will be a bad CEO so why employ him at all"

I don't care if it becomes a default bias. Do you know why? Because it isn't a bias in the sense of discrimination. If the statistics bears out that it's not a quality correlated with success, then you don't want it. This isn't unicorns and candy rainbows. This is capitalist investment. There isn't room for everyone to succeed. That doesn't mean we're being ethnocentric.

In fact, if the math bears it out, I honestly hope YC companies do take this on as a qualifier. If it's valid, it doesn't matter if it hurts your feelings. They're not being racist.

>This tread will soon disappear. But I will end with a Martin Luther King quote from the I have a dream speech 5o years ago yesterday. "Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about the things that matter"

You're taking this entirely the wrong way. This has nothing to do with unfair discrimination. It's entirely about the logistics of public speaking and communication in a company that has everything going against it. A quote from MLK has nothing to do with any of this.

dylangs1030··on Bring Me Your Accents. Immigration Fuels Innovation
So, he's not criticizing Paul Graham for making the statement (and admits he understands Graham isn't anti-immigrant or anti-foreigner), but is instead criticizing him for not taking responsibility for how his words might be taken out of context by everyone else? Is that it?
dylangs1030··on Why aren’t there any technologists on the NSA review panel?
It looks like you're a throwaway, but I'll bite. If you follow the conversation, you see that 'tptacek isn't using appeal to authority to defend an argument. Rather, he was responding to an abrupt dismissal of two people. He also clarified that he doesn't necessarily like or agree with either of them.

There's no appeal to authority here. If the parent had actually made a strong argument, Thomas might have responded with an actual argument as well.

dylangs1030··on He got 1%, we can't hire him
Those are the obvious ones. I've taken the MMPI. There's a lot more than just those. None of these are the seemingly innocuous ones I was talking about.

Again, I'll reiterate: can they be gamed? Yes. Is it likely? Emphatically, no.

dylangs1030··on He got 1%, we can't hire him
No, it can certainly be gamed. It's just so hard without prior knowledge and preparation as to be statistically negligent. This is also why I said you should avoid giving the same test twice. But a single, cold test administration should be very difficult to game.

You should also read upthread, what the actual psychologist said. It clarified my comment really well.

← PreviousPage 3 of 28Next →