398 karma · joined October 16, 2019
https://gutenberg.org/ebooks/7849
It's a really entertaining read.
And yes, it perfectly matches this situation - right in the very first sentence already.
In the first row of the "Why telegram?" section, right in the middle, it says:
> Private
> Telegram messages are heavily encrypted and can self-destruct
I'm sorry but you misread what I said, perhaps I was not clear enough:
I nowhere said or at least did not intend to say that DeFi per-se is bad.
I merely don't understand what's good about the DeFi projects which the person I replied to listed. So my intention was to ask what is good about those in particular.
> Loans issued via Ethereum lending protocols like Maker or Compound are fully collaterized, and default leads to automatic liquidation of the collateral to compensate the lender. It's impossible for the borrower to cheat, because an immutable smart contract enforces the terms of the loan.
So what is the point of borrowing money then if you have the money already, which "fully collaterized" implies?
> No, any asset can be represented as an Ethereum token and traded on a DEX. Having assets worldwide use a common exchange that can never be shut down, hacked or made inaccessible, holds enormous potential for improving financial inclusivity and capital efficiency.
That is a valid point!
I don't understand why a token is needed though, it's impossible to enforce its physical correlation to the asset anyway, so it would be enough to send naked ETH/BTC and use a regular decentralized forum system for setting up trades. I.e. if someone says on a forum "You send me N ETH and you get a car" that has the same validity as moving 1 car token, because nothing can enforce that the digital movement of a car token causes the physical handover of the keys. So "I owe you 1 car" only needs to be documented somewhere, e.g. as a bare textual message in an OP_RETURN or as a hash referencing a forum post, it doesn't have to be a token.
So to be completely honest, I feel like the only reason the developers cramp a token into this usecase is because that allows them to issue the token, which implies they can issue a lot of it to themselves "to fund development", and once it grows in value they're rich.
- The official entrypoint for staking is a very large, complex manual on a website. It asks you to set up various different software systems, in a server-admin-esque fashion with a shell frontend etc. I would have rather expected a large "DOWNLOAD STAKING SOFTWARE" button which yields a GUI app with a "Stake" button. With the large kind of money involved of at least 32 ETH (to do it without relying on a middleman which could steal from me) I do not want to go through the hassle of potentially making mistakes in complex shell scripting operations.
- The guide says that you need external software to stake, it is not apparent which one is official. They offer 4 different implementations to chose from. As someone who does not have the time to dig deep into the ecosystem I would rather have wanted them to offer ONE official solution which works.
- If you do click through the large manual, at the end it asks you to upload a file to the website. I thought Ethereum intended to be decentralized, and I do not wish to support centralizing core network features.
- Semi issue: It is hinted at but not clear enough at which conditions staking is a risk of theft because the ETH is constantly online. I would only stake if theft was 100% impossible even if all involved online machines are compromised. Their docs sound like that is possible, but it should be explained more explicitly right away, you shouldn't have to search for it.
Source: https://launchpad.ethereum.org/
It is intended for memorizing things, but the fact that it forces you to divide knowledge into pieces small enough to fit on a flash card also helps to organize it.
And you can have different card stacks in Anki, so there also is categorization of knowledge.
Cf. the "Zettelkasten", a physical flashcard system which is actually intended at organization, not memorization: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zettelkasten
Anki can be used to emulate that digitally.
> A list of tokens by locked in value is full of systems that are revolutionizing finance: https://defipulse.com/ Defi protocols are providing useful services and are making money. I doubt I could overstate their enormity.
The top ones are all lending and exchanges.
Lending money to someone isn't revolutionary, it's been possible for centuries - and given how easy crypto is to steal and never return, I wouldn't WANT to lend it to anyone anyway!
And decentralized exchanges are cool for sure, but they are self-serving in terms of only needing to exist because cryptocurrencies exist. So they can't really be used as a pro-crypto argument like you're doing because then the solution you're arguing for would only need to exist to solve a problem which it has created itself.
So what is so revolutionary about these?
I will reconsider.
Thank you! I will have a look at the site!
(And yes, I agree echo chambers are bad, I merely grant myself an exception in trying to filter corporate viewpoints out because they're basically everywhere in daily life so I really don't think I need to see any more of them to know their point of view.)
Well, when procuring physical product, the source of its raw materials is relevant as well, you wouldn't want rain forests to be chopped down for your wood - so why aren't the raw materials of software relevant when considering if you want to use it?
Guess a point has been made by that?
Well, see, that's interesting, because even if I had known you would consider what I would say as "inflammatory" before I wrote it, I would have brushed that off because:
Google is not only inflammatory as well but actual full blown cancer on our society, isn't it?
They are absorbing insane amounts of control over what humans consider as the truth. They willingly coax users into actually building a database on how they browse the web - complete surveillance.
They also basically own root access on a large percentage of surveillance devices which almost everyone has in their pocket.
So perhaps "inflammatory" isn't the 100% perfect word, but Google certainly is something worse than "inflammatory".
Hence my threshold for stopping myself from bashing them is very high.
I hope you can understand what I mean?
Yes.
> Probably wasn't downvoted because of some roaming downvote squad of FAANG-employed users. Lots of more straightforward reasons you can see here
Yeah, well, um, is reading HN with the rulebook open in a tab a thing that people actually do?
And why did they then upvote the person who called my argument "stupid" right below? Isn't that a more blatant rule-violation?
HN users do seem to upvote a lot of calls for government crackdown on freedom-embracing technology, so I wouldn't be totally opposed to "yes, there's people who strictly abide the rulebook, they like rules here", it's just not my style of interacting with humans. I just try to be honest and avoid being completely rude.
That's also a large incentive to consider something else, if people here can censor my content to the point where I even myself cannot read it anymore that's rather...google-esque?
*EDIT*: It somehow is visible again now. Will read it again.
OTOH, one is confronted by corporate interests all day long merely by existing, they're everywhere.
I'm really not sure if I need to see any more of that to get their point.
I am not. I genuinely think Google is evil and should be dismantled.
> - slices and maps are already generic in Go
So people are supposed to not rewrite 2 of the possibly infinite types of data structures and classes, and constantly rewrite all the rest of them?
> - Go has great performance, great readability and write ability, and that's valuable for everyone, not just beginners
Enough other languages do as well.
> Go is a language, not a library
If Google abandons the funding it does not matter what it technically is. No money, no developers.
Yes.
> And if so, are you actually holding yourself to the same standard? Never using a recaptcha? Never visiting a site that uses Google Analytics? Never watching a YouTube video? Never using a device which runs the Android operating system? etc., etc.?
I intentionally enter a large percentage of invalid data into recaptchas to spoil their dataset.
Google Analytics is blocked by my ad blocker.
Same goes for ads on youtube.
With regards to using their stuff, I don't demand anyone should stop privately using it if they need it. You just shouldn't encourage any further people to use Google stuff by filling their ecosystem with more new software.
Have you ever used a library where the company who paid the development went "whoops, not our product anymore! poof goes the paid team, website, the community forums, the knowledgebase" ?
Usually nobody continues to maintain these after 90% of the workforce behind them gets fired and the surrounding infrastructure disappears.
Software is almost worthless without the brains behind it.
> As for generics, they're just nothing more than a developer convenience,
So you propose people write the 100,000th implementation of linked lists, maps, etc. because what they want to stick into it is not class A but class B?
> Also they're planned in Go for next year.
The fact it took years to plan them instead of including them right away is a nice proof of how ill-conceived Go is as a language.
It might have been nice as a toy to teach aspiring programmers. It shouldn't have ended up in production software.
> Damn, these are some stupid arguments.
Thanks. I consider yours as stupid too. How much progress exactly have we achieved with this wording now?
If it is a feature to some people they are perfectly fine to consider it as such.
What gives you the right to proclaim what a user wants their software to do?
If it is a feature to some people they are perfectly fine to consider it as such.
My point is that Google is an evil company, and we shouldn't support evil entities by using their stuff.
And to make that point apparent, I mentioned other instances where people would think it is pretty obvious that "producer is evil = don't use their stuff", hoping that you would see there is no reason to act any different on Google just because they produce products which are of a type different from those that evil entities normal produce.
Because it really doesn't matter whether it is software or clothes or diamonds, if you use something publicly of someone you support them, and Google should not be supported.
- is controlled by Google.
- doesn't support generics. Do we really want people to constantly rewrite basic data structure classes in 2021 and thereby reinvent bugs constantly (and waste time which could be spent on more meaningful purposes)?
It should not be "in place X there are women, so I am going to get one."
It should be "person X is a nice person I like. I will see if she also likes me, and if yes, we might work something out."
In other words: You're talking like it is a pond with fish and any you pull out will be good for eating. That is not a healthy attitude to have towards people.
And it will rightfully annoy them once they find out, which they likely will.
If people argue very much about if X applies or not, then X probably applies to a certain part close to 50%.
So Bitcoin kinda is like money, and kinda is not.
So can we just stop the arguing and move on to figuring out ways to make use of it, or write code to improve it if you don't like the as-is state, given that it exists and won't go away? :)
Hell yes!
Also: It was dead for me the moment a *giant search engine company* decided naming something with 2 letters is a good idea.
That is either proof of being completely negligent with regards to wasting people's time in terms of making their work more difficult; or it is proof of bragging how good your search engine is.
Neither is a favorable thing to do. And actually probably both apply, people do probably miss a lot of good search results on Go no matter how smart their search engine is.
And you can't force everyone in every nook and cranny of the Internet to spell it "golang".
They could just leave their website online as is, no need to block it if the laws don't apply to them anyway.
There's a really plausible explanation for huge dislike ratios on videos for children:
Very young children don't understand the UI, they just randomly mash buttons.
So a 50/50 like/dislike ratio would represent that randomness.