HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eadmund

4,531 karma · joined February 3, 2012

submissionscomments
eadmund··on The great medieval water myth (2013)
> I always thought it quite weird that somehow by virtue of being in beer, that the water somehow becomes sterilised.

The reason that water in beer is sterilised is that beer is brewed — i.e. boiled.

> If you've ever tried home brewing, you'll know that non-sterile conditions lead to foul rancid filth due to all the bacteria etc.

I believe that pre–germ-theory brewing practices tended to discourage unwanted microbial activity, in part through inoculation with large amounts of fresh barm. Did they put two and two together and connect those practices in the context of brewing to the broader context of water or food safety? Maybe.

> I'd find it odd if the people then knew to sterilise the water and equipment to make beer, but then not do the same to drink it.

Indeed, the article quotes Paulus: ‘But waters which contain impurities, have a fetid smell, or any bad quality, may be so improved by boiling as to be fit to be drunk.’

eadmund··on Gutenprint Discontinues macOS Support
> Does anybody know how many active projects are still left there?

https://sourceforge.net/directory/ shows hundreds of thousands, but I can’t see a good way to filter out inactive projects.

> And who wound up owning them after Slashdot?

https://sourceforge.net/about/leadership appears to indicate that it’s still associated with Slashdot Media. I remember when they were bought that the new owner spent quite a bit of time regaining the trust of the software community. No idea how healthy the company’s business or operations are now, but it’s impressive that they’ve survived this long.

I don’t really know what their USP is anymore. It might be fun to start a new project there just to see what it’s like now.

eadmund··on Mirror Ball Emoji Proposal (2018) [pdf]
Apple displays the pistol emoji as a squirt gun. That’s wrong. It has always been wrong. It will always be wrong, because a squirt gun is not a pistol. Time doesn’t erase an error. ‘Get over it’ is the wrong response: ‘Apple, stop being wrong’ is the correct one.
eadmund··on Emacs as your video-trimming tool
https://github.com/emacs-jupyter/jupyter exists. No idea if it’s awesome or terrible.

FWIW, Org Mode is what a native Emacs user might reach for as alternative to Jupyter notebooks: https://michaelneuper.com/posts/replace-jupyter-notebook-wit... That doesn’t imply that you should both try Emacs and replace Jupyter! Just be aware that if either you are using Jupyter for your own reasons or working with like-minded team there is an alternative which may be preferable for your use-case.

eadmund··on AGENTS.md – Open format for guiding coding agents
I believe with direnv or a similar tool (e.g. Emacs’s directory-local feature) one can append $REPO/.config to XDG_CONFIG_HOME, $REPO/.local/bin to PATH and so on so that when in the context of a particular directory everything Just Works.

I think all this agentic stuff could live quite happily in $REPO/.config/agents/.

eadmund··on AGENTS.md – Open format for guiding coding agents
Anything with a capital letter requires hitting two keys: Shift and then the desired letter. Thus /Programs requires 10 keystrokes rather than 9. Even worse, since the capital letter is at the beginning of the directory name, I have to type it and am unable to rely on tab-completion.

/Programs with its ten keystrokes is over twice the keystrokes of /bin and its four. Short names are quicker to type and require less effort. Given that to a first approximation I spend my entire life typing on a keyboard, I very much wish to optimise that experience.

eadmund··on AnduinOS
> Yet, other than the Netbooks glory days, I am yet to buy a Laptop, even from Linux shops, where everything is 100% supported, or eventually doesn't get broken in some kernel update.

Purism’s laptops appear to be well-supported and to hold up well over time.

System76’s too.

eadmund··on AnduinOS
> Because instead of trying to improve GNU/Linux to be a solid alternative to Apple, Google and Microsoft offerings, we have politics with everyone doing their own little village.

The politics are required by the fact that we don’t all agree on what improves GNU and Linux versus what makes them worse.

But at least with GNU/Linux we have the freedom to disagree and ‘[do] our own village.’ On Windows, Microsoft decides and users comply. Don’t like Windows 11? Tough! Don’t like some (mis)features of Windows 11? Tough!

eadmund··on Snapshots of Kids Bike Jumping in the 1970s
I’m more worried about drivers, who drive more closely to helmeted cyclists.

But even for cyclists, are they as likely to ride at all if they only ride helmeted? Do you treat cycling as a form of transportation, or as exercise?

My belief is that the more cyclists are on the road, the better drivers drive, and that helmets increase the friction of cycling as transportation, and thus that they may decrease actual cycling safety.

eadmund··on Snapshots of Kids Bike Jumping in the 1970s
> Helmets increase survivability and decrease the degree of injuries in every respect.

Of course a helmet increases survivability of a head injury in a crash, that’s indisputable. But of course there is a window: some crashes are so minor that they are already survivable without a helmet; and some crashes are so bad that a helmet cannot help. And of course many injuries are not to the head at all.

The first-order effect of cycling helmets is definitely positive! But what are the second-order effects?

> To respond to the 'nuance' of your remark, that helmets change rider behavior for the worse, resulting in higher aggregate injuries - that is also incorrect.

There is evidence that they decrease the number of cyclists; and there is evidence that they change the behaviour of drivers.

When Western Australia imposed cycling helmet laws safety got worse: http://www.cycle-helmets.com/

eadmund··on iPhone DevOps (2023)
> Offline folders

> This is like rsync for your phone. In fact I would not be surprised if this is implemented using rsync. Once you configure an offline folder, it will two-way sync that folder while you use the app. The kicker is: on your phone you can now open that folder in another app (like an editor) and make changes. When you switch back to the shellfish app, the changes are uploaded almost instantly.

One can get this killer feature for free with Android and Syncthing. It’s definitely pretty nice!

And of course one can also run Emacs and other free (as in speech or beer) text editors on Android.

IIRC there are a couple of ways to get a full Linux command line environment as well.

I ended up moving away from it just because ‘typing’ with my thumb is painful.

eadmund··on Open Banking and Payments Competition
> Why does every employee in the US need to pay an accountant to file their corporate payroll taxes, when the corporation knows how much they paid and can just use THEIR accountant to report this same information?

How would my employer know how much money my savings, chequing and investment accounts make? I owe taxes on all of those as well as on my income.

How would my employer know what interest I pay on my mortgage, how much I contribute to charity and my other deductible expenses?

> some states have NO WAY for you to file taxes without an accountant

Which ones?

eadmund··on I tried every todo app and ended up with a .txt file
Who’s forcing? I’m recommending.
eadmund··on F-Droid build servers can't build modern Android apps due to outdated CPUs
> I'd assume that a modern CPU would do the same amount of work with a fraction of energy so that it does not even make economical sense to run such outdated hardware.

There are 8,760 hours in a non-leap year. Electricity in the U.S. averages 12.53 cents per kilowatt hour[1]. A really power-hungry CPU running full-bore at 500 W for a year would thus use about $550 of electricity. Even if power consumption dropped by half, that’s only about 10% of the cost of a new computer, so the payoff date of an upgrade is ten years in the future (ignoring the cost of performing the upgrade, which is non-negligible — as is the risk).

And of course buying a new computer is a capital expense, while paying for electricity is an operating expense.

1: https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.ph...

eadmund··on Debian GNU/Hurd 2025 released
> I played with RedoxOS a bit in a virtual machine a few years ago, and it seemed cool, so maybe that can be the logical successor to something like Hurd.

A problem with RedoxOS is that it is not GPLed: contributors have no assurance that they and others will be able to use software built with their contributions.

Microsoft, Apple, Google and Facebook all have plenty of money to pay engineers; they don’t need my contributions for free.

eadmund··on How Kentucky bourbon went from boom to bust
No-one who has ever had a hangover is unaware that alcohol is a poison.

But it can also be an amazing social lubricant, it pairs so well with food and it can make a night sparkle. There’s a reason that mankind’s history is deeply entwined with alcohol’s.

eadmund··on Snapshots of Kids Bike Jumping in the 1970s
I still believe that bicycle helmets are a net negative for cycling safety, due to a combination of them not improving crash survivability as much as folks believe while at the same time increasing the number of crashes due to rider and driver behaviour. But who can argue against the perception of the masses?

I think it wasn’t lawsuits, but good ol’ American advertising: helmet manufacturers created a need in the minds of consumers where there had not been one before (cf. deodorant, cigarettes and plenty more).

eadmund··on We keep reinventing CSS, but styling was never the problem
> 99.9% of applications I interact with are just a series of simple CRUD operations.

The vast majority of web apps out there could be implemented as REST systems (in the real, Fielding, HATEOAS sense, not the JSON-over-HTTP sense).

There are a few out there which need to be web apps, but those are relatively rare.

eadmund··on StarDict sends X11 clipboard to remote servers
The Wayland framing at the end strikes me as misleading. This gets it exactly right:

> Or maybe StarDict would have started asking for special permissions to let it work on Wayland, and users would have accepted those defaults the same way they currently do.

Yes, that’s what it would do. Its installer might even configure that special permission automatically, without user intervention.

Malware’s gonna mal. Wayland might help defend against some things, but it’s not going to defend against packages installed as part of the distro.

eadmund··on I tried every todo app and ended up with a .txt file
> If I switched to Emacs locally, I'd still have to maintain a working knowledge of vi and context switch when in a remote shell.

Even ignoring the possibility of installing Emacs on remote systems, there are still alternatives:

1. You can run remote shells within Emacs, and edit files remotely using TRAMP. When you are editing a remote file, shell commands run from Emacs run on the remote system.

2. You could use Evil, the Emacs implementation of vim. Then you would use the same bindings everywhere.

3. I have been running Emacs locally for literal decades now, but I still remember and use vi frequently, both locally and remotely. It’s really not a problem.

I feel like there must be an editor version of the Blub Paradox.

eadmund··on I tried every todo app and ended up with a .txt file
> I am now in search of a simple way to sync notes between my phone and computer (without using Big Tech solutions).

Syncthing?

eadmund··on I tried every todo app and ended up with a .txt file

    man 5 user-dirs.dirs
I hate the default directory names, and like you I hate the capitalisation — fortunately they can be overridden.
eadmund··on I tried every todo app and ended up with a .txt file
> I am not going to completely change my editor and rebuild two decades of optimization just to use two Emacs tools.

Change your editor and rebuild two decades of optimisation in order to use Emacs, two Emacs tools, and also every other Emacs tool out there. Org Mode, TRAMP, Magit, gptel, eglot, flycheck, elfeed, ERC, Emms, EWW … there are a ton of reasons to use Emacs.

Or you can keep using less-capable systems and being annoyed when folks recommend that you upgrade.

eadmund··on GitHub is no longer independent at Microsoft after CEO resignation
You forgot things like shipping decades-old free software with their OS because Apple are so implacably opposed to their users having freedom to use, examine, modify and share that software.
eadmund··on Cursed Knowledge
Hey, if I don’t name this class AbstractBeanFactoryVisitorCommandPatternImplementorFactoryFactoryFactorySlapObserver how would you know what it does?
eadmund··on Emailing a one-time code is worse than passwords
Don’t put in place systems which encourage lock-in, even at the B2B level.
eadmund··on Emailing a one-time code is worse than passwords
> Passkeys is the way to go.

No, please, not as long as attestation is in the spec. I firmly believe that passkeys are intended to facilitate vendor lock-in and reduce the autonomy of end users.

Frankly, I do not trust any passkey implementation as much as I trust a GPG-encrypted text file.

eadmund··on Mac history echoes in current Mac operating systems
> a server

I used Macs from the 1980s up to 2000 or so, and I was very familiar with that icon of a hand with a tray and some files, but it wasn’t until today that I realised that it was a pun on ‘server’ used to mean what my dialect of English terms a ‘waiter.’

There’s probably a lesson about i18n in there somewhere!

What’s funny to me is how characterless I thought the half-volleyball iMac was at the time, compared to the classic Bondi blue iMac (and its awesome color variations too), but now when I compare it to Apple’s current offerings it has so very much more character. I miss the days of shape and colour and texture.

eadmund··on Ask HN: Have you ever regretted open-sourcing something?
> The only way to escape wage slavery without being born wealthy is to be a business owner and have that business scale.

‘Business owner’ in the sense of owning stock, sure.

Save 10–20% of your income. Invest it in index funds (we can argue about which particular indices). Work for a few decades. Retire wealthy.

Then bequeath that wealth to your heirs when you die, giving them a leg up on this whole process.

> Many of us spend our lives writing software that has lasting benefit for our employers but our reward is a flat hourly fee.

The employer takes the risk that the software will have no benefit at all. We get paid no matter what. I like that trade. I’ll invest in a diversified market index rather than my single program, thank you very much.

eadmund··on Plain Text. With Lines
It looks pretty neat. I like that it has a textual representation!
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →