HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eadmund

4,538 karma · joined February 3, 2012

submissionscomments
eadmund··on Firefox is fine. The people running it are not
I don’t believe that ‘capitalism’ is a good explanation for the behaviour of a charitable organisation with no shareholders.

An issue with private funding for charitable projects is, as you note, appeals to the emotions of private donors.

An issue with the public funding for charitable projects you propose is appeals to the emotions of both legislators and executive agents. Another issue is corruption: a project which can figure out how to both receive money from taxes and influence elections can ultimately write its own meal ticket.

eadmund··on Why are there still 7 continents?
> people who seriously called people who live on the same tectonic plate as us, who used to be directly connected to us with a land bridge only a few 10kA ago, and who have no continental slope or suchlike between us, "the continent".

It’s more surprising to me that there are Brits who consider themselves European. From my point of view, there’ve been deep distinctions between Great Britain and the Continent for centuries. Britain seems distinct from the European nations that, for example, Burgundy or the Hanseatic League, or modern Germany, are not. Part of that, of course, is just that I’m an Anglophone. And certainly the Scandinavian countries are in some regards equally different from ‘Europe.’

eadmund··on CU Randomness Beacon
NIST v2: https://csrc.nist.gov/projects/interoperable-randomness-beac...

NIST v2: https://csrc.nist.gov/projects/interoperable-randomness-beac...

eadmund··on Backlog.md – Markdown‑native Task Manager and Kanban visualizer for any Git repo
This seems tailor-made for Org mode! Seeing all those ‘To do’ and ‘Done’ reminds me of it. Did you consider building atop Org mode?
eadmund··on The Real GenAI Issue
> The business leaders pumping all this money of course don’t understand the technology.

True enough!

> They’re doing this for exactly one reason: They think they can discard armies of employees and replace them with LLM services, at the cost of shipping shittier products.

I imagine that they believe they can discard armies of employees and replace them with LLM services, shipping products at either the same level of quality for the same price or for a lower level of quality at a lower price.

> The first real cost is hypothetical: What if those business leaders are correct and they can gleefully dispose of millions of employees?

I am absolutely certain that when Tim Bray needs a ditch dug on his property, he does not insist that the contractors use spoons. I am pretty sure that he does not insist that the timber for his house be hand-sawn only. I am pretty sure that he does not drive a horse and buggy. I am pretty sure that he does not grow all his own food by hand, nor does he require that all his food be grown by subsistence farmers. I am absolutely certain that the computers he uses for work and play are not hand-built from raw inputs like sand and rubber trees, but are instead the end product of a massive industrial supply chain no single man can hold in his head. I think well enough of him that I expect he is not gleeful at the thought of how many more jobs he could create if only he abstained from all technology developed after, say, 753 B.C.; why will he not extend that same grace to business executives?

I’m being a bit ridiculous, but that’s kind of the point. Technological innovations free up labour for more productive uses. If you go back far enough, most of our ancestors lived miserable, short lives of back-breaking effort. It wasn’t until the 1920 census that the majority of Americans lived in cities.

There’s no ‘mental stench’ (to use his infelicitous phrase) involved in using technology to reduce the amount of precious human labour required to achieve an end. Desktop publishing made high-quality output accessible to a much larger number of people than before; so too has generative AI.

eadmund··on Why English doesn't use accents
I’ve always seen it written with an acute accent: ‘curséd.’ Wikipedia notes both usages, but to my knowledge I have never once read a poem which used a grave accent that way.
eadmund··on The Broken Microsoft Pact: Layoffs and Performance Management
> Unions can't (always) make an unprofitable company profitable

Indeed, I think their major trick (in America, anyway) is to make a profitable company unprofitable. Much like the bad forms of private equity from above, they bleed a business dry from below.

eadmund··on How to Network as an Introvert
> I like the idea of baiting with a “whatzit” item

Me too! I can’t believe that I never thought of it before, but it makes perfect sense.

eadmund··on As a Labrador swam by me out to sea his owner said I hope he doesn't meet a seal
Evolutionary success is survival for genes.
eadmund··on What to build instead of AI agents
> If you can't be an expert after 5 years then there is no such thing as experts.

I think you’ll find that after 10 years one’ll look back on oneself at 5 years’ experience and realise that one wasn’t an expert back then. The same is probably true of 20 years looking back on 10.

Given a median career of about 40 years, I think it’s fair to estimate that true expertise takes at least 10–15 years.

eadmund··on RFC 9804: Simple Public Key Infrastructure (SPKI) S-Expressions
The DER-encoded ASN.1 byte sequence Base64-encoded to MBMCAQUWDkFueWJvZHkgdGhlcmU/ could be represented as:

    ((tracking-number 5)
     (question "Anybody there?"))
While we are all familiar with opaque X.509 certificates such as (from https://www.fm4dd.com/openssl/source/PEM/certs/512b-rsa-exam...):

    -----BEGIN CERTIFICATE-----
    MIICEjCCAXsCAg36MA0GCSqGSIb3DQEBBQUAMIGbMQswCQYDVQQGEwJKUDEOMAwG
    A1UECBMFVG9reW8xEDAOBgNVBAcTB0NodW8ta3UxETAPBgNVBAoTCEZyYW5rNERE
    MRgwFgYDVQQLEw9XZWJDZXJ0IFN1cHBvcnQxGDAWBgNVBAMTD0ZyYW5rNEREIFdl
    YiBDQTEjMCEGCSqGSIb3DQEJARYUc3VwcG9ydEBmcmFuazRkZC5jb20wHhcNMTIw
    ODIyMDUyNjU0WhcNMTcwODIxMDUyNjU0WjBKMQswCQYDVQQGEwJKUDEOMAwGA1UE
    CAwFVG9reW8xETAPBgNVBAoMCEZyYW5rNEREMRgwFgYDVQQDDA93d3cuZXhhbXBs
    ZS5jb20wXDANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAANLADBIAkEAm/xmkHmEQrurE/0re/jeFRLl
    8ZPjBop7uLHhnia7lQG/5zDtZIUC3RVpqDSwBuw/NTweGyuP+o8AG98HxqxTBwID
    AQABMA0GCSqGSIb3DQEBBQUAA4GBABS2TLuBeTPmcaTaUW/LCB2NYOy8GMdzR1mx
    8iBIu2H6/E2tiY3RIevV2OW61qY2/XRQg7YPxx3ffeUugX9F4J/iPnnu1zAxxyBy
    2VguKv4SWjRFoRkIfIlHX0qVviMhSlNy2ioFLy7JcPZb+v3ftDGywUqcBiVDoea0
    Hn+GmxZA
    -----END CERTIFICATE-----
an SPKI certificate might be:

    (sequence
        (public-key
         (rsa-pkcs1-md5
          (e #11#)
          (n
           |ALNdAXftavTBG2zHV7BEV59gntNlxtJYqfWIi2kTcFIgIPSjKlHleyi9s
           5dDcQbVNMzjRjF+z8TrICEn9Msy0vXB00WYRtw/7aH2WAZx+x8erOWR+yn
           1CTRLS/68IWB6Wc1x8hiPycMbiICAbSYjHC/ghq2mwCZO7VQXJENzYr45|)))
        (do hash md5)
        (cert
         (issuer (hash md5 |+gbUgUltGysNgewRwu/3hQ==|))
         (subject
          (keyholder (hash md5 |+gbUgUltGysNgewRwu/3hQ==|)))
         (tag
          (* set
           (name "Carl M. Ellison")
           (street "207 Grindall St.")
           (city "Baltimore MD")
           (zip "21230-4103")))
         (not-after "1998-04-15_00:00:00"))
        (signature
         (hash md5 |54LeOBILOUpskE5xRTSmmA==|)
         (hash md5 |+gbUgUltGysNgewRwu/3hQ==|)
         |HU6ptoaEd7v4rTKBiRrpJBqDKWX9fBfLY/MeHyJRryS8iA34+nixf+8Yh/
         buBin9xgcu1lIZ3Gu9UPLnu5bSbiJGDXwKlOuhTRG+lolZWHaAd5YnqmV9h
         Khws7UM4KoenAhfouKshc8Wgb3RmMepi6t80Arcc6vIuAF4PCP+zxc=|)))
Note that this is not a translation of the X.509 certificate above, though — I pulled it from <https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-ietf-spki-cert-e...>. Note that this is a very 90s example: MD5 and a bespoke data format instead of SHA-2 and ISO 8601.

I think it’s clear that an SPKI certificate is much, much more readable.

eadmund··on RFC 9804: Simple Public Key Infrastructure (SPKI) S-Expressions
This XML (from https://www.w3schools.com/xml/note.xml):

    <note>
      <to>Tove</to>
      <from>Jani</from>
      <heading>Reminder</heading>
      <body>Don't forget me this weekend!</body>
    </note>
could be this S-expression:

    (note
     (to Tove)
     (from Jani)
     (heading Reminder)
     (body "Don't forget me this weekend"))
But if every note must have a body, this might make even more sense:

    (note
     (to Tove)
     (from Jani)
     (heading Reminder)
     "Don't forget me this weekend")
eadmund··on RFC 9804: Simple Public Key Infrastructure (SPKI) S-Expressions
This JSON (taken from https://www.w3schools.com/js/js_json_intro.asp):

    {"name":"John", "age":30, "car":null}
could be this S-expression:

    ((name John)
     (age 30)
     (car ()))
The canonical representation (suitable for cryptographic hashing) would be ((4:name4:John)(3:age2:30)(3:car())).
eadmund··on RFC 9804: Simple Public Key Infrastructure (SPKI) S-Expressions
After 29 years, Rivest’s S-expression draft is an RFC.

They are a straightforward, easy-to-parse S-expression format whose canonical representation is useful for cryptography. They are suitable as a general replacement for JSON, XML, HTML, ASN.1 and more.

eadmund··on Don’t use “click here” as link text (2001)
It’s not really about clarity, or even about accessibility (although both of those are great!): it’s about what a Web page is. A Web page is a document which can link to other documents.

> Links should absolutely be verbs

No, links imply a verb: ‘get.’ Buttons imply another verb: ‘post.’ It’d be awesome if there were ways in HTML to indicate other verbs, such as put and delete.

> > Get _Amaya_!

> That... doesn't tell me how to get Amaya.

No, it doesn’t: it is a document calling its reader to action. That’s something a document does: it tells a reader how to do something, or calls the reader to do something. Clicking is just an artifact of a particular technology at a particular point in time (heck, I imagine most people nowadays don’t click, because they are using smartphones — they tap instead).

eadmund··on The Medley Interlisp Project: Reviving a Historical Software System [pdf]
> What does a Lisp Machine of the future look like?

Depends on what one means by that.

Dedicated hardware? I doubt that we’ll ever see that again, although of course I could be wrong.

A full OS? That’s more likely, but only just. If it had some way to run Windows, macOS or Linux programs (maybe just emulation?) then it might have a chance.

As a program? Arguably Emacs is a Lisp Machine for 2025.

Provocative question: would a modern Lisp Machine necessarily use Lisp? I think that it probably has to be a language like Lisp, Smalltalk, Forth or Tcl. It’s hard to put into words what these very different languages share that languages such as C, Java and Python lack, but I think that maybe it reduces down to elegant dynamism?

eadmund··on FICO to incorporate buy-now-pay-later loans into credit scores
> There is usually no magic spread to be captured unless you’re willing to take more risk (say, money in equities instead of CDs).

Which is what one should do, provided one believes that the long-term result will be positive.

> Financing a depreciating asset against one that is volatile in the short term (and has seen drawdowns of 20% several times in the last 10 years) is a duration to risk mismatch.

Financing an asset and the value of an asset are independent. If one believes that one will get a better yield by investing than one could by avoiding financing, then one should finance. I believe that over time my investment returns will be higher than the current car loan rate.

> people don’t in practice use credit as liquidity backed by an investment, they use it as a cash advance to buy more car than they would absent financing … So now instead of buying a $20k car cash, people will buy a $40k car, increasing their debt load against a depreciating asset.

Yes, fools are foolish. A wise man makes educated predictions of the future. If his current total portfolio debt load can support financing a purchase, and if the rate to finance it is less than what he predicts his yield will be, then he’ll finance it.

> if that small spread from borrowing to buy a depreciating asset makes a significant difference to you

Hey, an extra 1% a year for the duration of one’s working life adds up quite significantly! The key is to carefully manage one’s expenses and balance sheet, maintaining a healthy debt ratio, only incurring debt when it makes sense, and refinancing or paying it down when that makes sense.

eadmund··on FICO to incorporate buy-now-pay-later loans into credit scores
The trick is to borrow $40,000 to buy the car at 6% and keep your $40,000 invested making more than 6%. Even at 7% annually, you’d make $16,102 over five years (1.07⁵ × $40,000). For that matter, at 6.1% annually, you’d make $13,782 (1.061⁵ × $40,000). Heck, even at 5.9%, you’d make $13,277! The reason why you make more even with a lower rate is that you pay less interest each month with the amortising loan!

The trouble is if one borrows that $40,000 to buy a brand-new car (which will lose $16,000 over five years), or if one borrows that $40,000 and doesn’t have or doesn’t invest $40,000, or both. Life’s a lot easier if you already have the money.

eadmund··on FICO to incorporate buy-now-pay-later loans into credit scores
A mortgage doesn’t make money, but it (can) enable spending less money. If you buy a place such that interest, maintenance, insurance, taxes and the opportunity cost of not being able to easily relocate are less than rent, then you have saved the difference.

It’s also a way to force saving, which is psychologically useful (and thus valuable).

eadmund··on How to negotiate your salary package
> At startups you negotiate for equity instead of salary

Never take equity over salary. Equity at a startup is a lottery ticket. Would you agree to be paid $10,000 less for $10,000 in lottery tickets? For $20,000 in lottery tickets?

eadmund··on YouTube's new anti-adblock measures
> Why should I reward that by paying them?

Do you want to have a great YouTube experience? Paying for it gets you that.

I watch YouTube videos frequently. Never see an ad. It’s great.

eadmund··on Harper – an open-source alternative to Grammarly
If a language changes, there are only three possible options: either it becomes more expressive; or it becomes less expressive; or it remains as expressive as before.

Certainly we would never want our language to be less expressive. There’s no point to that.

And what would be the point of changing for the sake of change? Sure, we blop use the word ‘blop’ instead of the word ‘could’ without losing or gaining anything, but we’d incur the cost of changing books and schooling for … no gain.

Ah, but it’d be great to increase expressiveness, right? The thing is, as far as I am aware all human languages are about equal in terms of expressiveness. Changes don’t really move the needle.

So, what would the point of evolution be? If technology impedes it … fine.

eadmund··on Unexpected security footguns in Go's parsers
> In my dayjob I see this tendency constantly to have a lot of different very narrow structs that somehow integrate into some library, and then a TON of supporting code to copy between those structs. Only to then do very little actually useful work with any of the data at the end.

Don’t think of it as doing a little useful work at the end; think of it as doing all the useful work in the centre. Your core logic should be as close to a pure implementation without external libraries as possible (ideally zero, but that is often not easily achievable), but call out to external libraries and services to get its work done as appropriate. That does mean a fair amount of data copying, but IMHO it’s worth it. Testing copies is easy and localised, whereas understand the implications of a JSON (or Protobuf, or Django, or whatever) object carried deep into one’s core logic and passed into other services and libraries is very very difficult.

There’s a common theme with the ORM trap here. The cost of a little bit of magic is often higher than the cost of a little bit of copying.

eadmund··on JavaScript broke the web (and called it progress)
> the amount of em dashes

… means absolutely nothing. I’ve been heavily using them for decades at this point.

The article itself may or may not be AI-generated, but we cannot penalise folks for simply using a stylish bit of punctuation.

eadmund··on MCP Specification – version 2025-06-18 changes
It is mostly pointless complexity, but I’m going to miss batching. It was kind of neat to be able to say ‘do all these things, then respond,’ even if the client can batch the responses itself if it wants to.
eadmund··on Long live Xorg, I mean Xlibre
> this transition

That begs the question of whether there should be or is a transition. From where I sit right now, there should not be and there isn’t. Wayland doesn’t meet my needs (not ‘needs’ in the sense of food and air, of course!) today, despite how interesting it is and despite the genuine improvements it offers in some ways. It may in the future, but until then any transition would be a net loss for me.

eadmund··on Long live Xorg, I mean Xlibre
I wrote in a sibling comment ‘I do get it — no-one owes me anything.’ No-one should be forced to do anything. Folks are and should be free to work on whatever suits their fancy.

But folks should also have a sense of duty or responsibility not to needlessly interfere with others. I am free to release a reïmplementation of ls(1). I’m free to extend it. But I shouldn’t change the meaning of ‘ls -d’ to delete all matching files, because it conflicts with POSIX. I shouldn’t change the meaning of ‘ls -b’ to overwrite matching files with nulls (blanks), even though POSIX doesn’t define it at all and in theory I am free to do so, because GNU ls(1) already uses it for printing C-style escapes.

eadmund··on Long live Xorg, I mean Xlibre
> intercepting/sending keystrokes in particular had to be redesigned to make to make it more secure. without that there would not have been a point to wayland at all.

Sure, and I really would like to enjoy that security improvement. But would an evolutionary approach have been possible?

For example, would it have been possible to start by running Wayland with all programs in a privileged status, then migrate to using something like OpenBSD’s pledge(2) to spawn programs preferentially in an unprivileged status, then migrate to spawning some programs (e.g. legacy X11 display managers) in a privileged status?

It sure seems like Wayland requires a lot more work from software using it than X11 did. Wayland has been out for 16 years and still isn’t almost universal; 16 years after X11’s 1984 release it was well-nigh universal.

Again, I get that no-one owes me anything. But it seems to me that the Wayland developers committed the fundamental error of trying to replace a working system with vapourware. It’s still vapourware, in that in 2025 Wayland is still not a drop-in replacement for X11.

> your actual apps that just display stuff on the screen and take your input all still work though.

My display manager is an actual app that is a fundamental part of my workflow.

eadmund··on Long live Xorg, I mean Xlibre
Is it possible to run an X11 window manager in XWayland and have it manage Wayland windows and intercept keystrokes for all windows?

If not then it’s not really an upgrade path.

I do get it — no-one owes me anything. They don’t even, really, owe me the kindness of not breaking the software I use. In principle I could fork and maintain everything I want myself, or working with others. But …

eadmund··on Long live Xorg, I mean Xlibre
That doesn’t really work. If there’s no longer a browser which supports X11, then I have to choose between browsing the web and having a usable desktop.

The problem is that the Wayland folks are trying to replace X11 rather than provide an easy upgrade path. They simply don’t care about anyone who uses a computer in any way outside of the ways they can be bothered to support. ‘It’s better!’ they cry, despite users telling them for well over a decade now that it’s not actually, because we cannot do the things we want.

And Wayland is being used as a form of lock-in. ‘GNOME uses Wayland now. Just drop support for that crufty old X11,’ they whisper. Never mind that plenty of folks don’t use GNOME and don’t want to use GNOME. Never mind that Wayland is still not fit for purpose.

It may be someday, and that would be great. I’d genuinely look forward to being able to move on from X11. But Wayland does not work for me, and as projects start to remove support for X11 they are removing support for me.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →