HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

edb

225 karma · joined May 14, 2008

submissionscomments
edb··on Ask HN: How do I find out if I'm infringing copyrights?
Is it wise to contact the RIAA and ask them if what I'm doing is legitimate?
edb··on Ask HN: Is this plagiarism or competition?
But I literally have EVERY feature he has. It's kind of freaky, but it's a very basic site he's put up. His upcoming features also have a huge overlap with mine. He has, however, gotten lifehacker coverage, as well as on a couple of other sites that drive in traffic.

It's a pretty untapped space where even the simplest ideas are a big deal at this point, so I don't want to be charged with ripping him off.

Should I delay my release until there's a substantial improvement on his?

edb··on Ask HN: Any DIY/installable alternatives to Dropbox?
I always thought that dropbox would be much better if I could tie it together with my S3 account and just have all the data saved there, to an unlimited amount paid by me.
edb··on Who Owns Your Great Idea?
the difference being that you pay them. Give me free education and labs (paid by the university, not the state) and the university can have a huge cut of all my ideas.
edb··on CakePHP 1.2 Released
I don't know why this framework doesn't get more attention. Good on them for finally releasing the 1.2 version.
edb··on Ask YC: Let's start a Hacker News book club
http://www.ravelry.com/
edb··on Ask YC: Let's start a Hacker News book club
This should be a feature of hacker news, have a books link at the top menu where you can submit a book and a deadline, then people can commit to reading it, and then everybody can discuss. Upmod if you're committing, then the top few books will generally get a following and a good discussion going.

I guess you could do something like kill all books without more than 20 committed readers or something like that to eliminate the noise.

edb··on Ask HN: How do I go about PHP?
CakePHP has changed ALOT, and for the better to boot! As a 6 year php coder and a 2 year cakephp developper, I HIGHLY recommend it.

Yes, everyone thinks the docs aren't good. They're currently pretty decent actually. Also, the community is amazing and all of it (core code, docs and community) is just getting better.

It's a really good, VERY flexible framework and most important; incredibly portable, which I think is the reason why I love it.. I haven't had a hiccup with it since the latest versions have come out (1.2 RC3?). I've also done ALOT of client work using it, rarely on my on web host. It is the Madlib to rails' Timbaland.

That being said, cakephp 1.1 was REALLY bad. I can't stress that enough. This is probably why it gets so much bad press. There's still ALOT of information written on 1.1, alot of technical articles, howtos, etc.. and an upsetting amount of reviews and performance tests based on 1.1 or early beta 1.2 releases.

I capitalize ALOT. I'm REALLY sorry. I just really like cake...

edb··on URL Routing in Recess my upcoming PHP Framework
This is actually pretty cool, but I'm genuinely curious why it's advantageous to write the routes in the controller files instead of one central place that's easily maintained?

CakePHP, (http://book.cakephp.org/view/46/Routes-Configuration) for example, can do all of what this does out of the box without the need for an application to monitor your routes.

REST also seems very well implemented : http://book.cakephp.org/view/476/REST

Am I missing something? Can someone explain the benefits?

edb··on PHP Design - Biggest Database Oversights
These problems have been solved by the various popular php-based MVC frameworks. My favourite is http://www.cakephp.org/, but I hear a lot of good things about http://codeigniter.com/ as well.
edb··on Is it going to rain?
I hear ya. My name is Bill Gates and I sign up to an unheard of amount of services from my apt in the 90210 area. Thank god for the great spam filter I have on my personal email: support@microsoft.com, I get alot of spam there for some reason
edb··on Ask HN: Is there a HN for music?
Good point. In the case of both last.fm and HN, maybe they would benefit from a "Lemming" feature that could be turned on and off. :)
edb··on Ask HN: Is there a HN for music?
It may be a little shortsighted, but it's hard to sum up all my thoughts in one textarea.

The long story short of it is that in my experiences, a real life discussion about music among 5 knowledgeable people always turns into a festival of egos. I think if you put it on the internet, it's going to magnify that worse than what you could see in the hacker community because everybody who loves music thinks they like the music they do because their perception is unique and more insightful than yours (I'm guilty of this too). We could talk music for hours but as soon as you namedrop that band that I think is trash, I no longer believe your opinion counts.

If you can solve that problem, then by all means, I'll be a believer. I think that's why last.fm is so good. Yes, there's alot of echo, put in a band like Mono into the 'radio station' feed without logging in and you'll see there's not a whole lot of variety. However where it excels is if you listen, for example, to a lot of classical music, when you put in a post-rock band, it will find the post-rock music that appeals to you as a classical music fan and will inspire you to dig deeper into the genre.

This is what I think news sites need. The problem with them is that as more people sign up, you see the lowest common denominator trickle to the front page. What would be better is if, for example, I'm a big rails fan and I upmod an article that shouts the greatness of PHP, I'd like to then start seeing more php related articles on MY (not THE) front page. Initially they would start off being very rails influenced, but as I upmod more php articles, the system would wean me away from the ror crowd and more towards the php crowd, unless I'm the type who only upmods articles titled "php is great when it's like ruby", in which case I don't really care for other opinions anyways, so who's losing?

... in a nutshell

edb··on Ask HN: Is there a HN for music?
Thanks. That got me all wet to dance.
edb··on Ask HN: Does the SaaS model really work? Really?
Anybody know if schools are a good target?
edb··on Ask HN: Is there a HN for music?
I did a radio show for two years, and all the recommendations on this page are a great way of finding music, but by no means are they better than just reading interviews and articles on your favourite artists, find out what makes them tick. Heck, go to a concert at your local (smaller) venue and chat with the band if you liked what they did.

That was always the best way I found music, lots and lots and lots of research and discussion with like minded people, mostly at shows.

... at least until www.last.fm came about. :) This, in my opinion, is the best way to find music that's in line with what you listen to. It takes what you listen to and finds people who listen to the same thing. It then finds out what they're listening to that you're not. Yes, you have to feed it your listening record, but once you've done that, your life won't be the same. I don't know why it's so neglected.

In fact, I always thought this would be the best way to run HN. Take all the articles I've upvoted, find people who've upvoted the same articles, look at what they've upvoted that I haven't and show me THAT on the main page.

The main problem with a HN for music is that music is too subjective and immeasurable. In hacking, you can argue stats, performance, visitors, etc. Music is different. More people listen to Brittany Spears than North of America, she also made more money, but there's no fully logical way to argue why she sucks. It's all a matter of perception and emotions. You can't wrap a webapp around that, nor can you get a group of people to agree on what's good and what's not because tastes vary so greatly.

edb··on Ask HN: Is relying on scribd's API a big mistake?
Thanks for the good reply. I guess it makes sense that I use scribd to get my community going, and if it takes off, use those resources to wean my dependency.
edb··on Pivotal Tracker: The iPod of project management software
This looks like a great tool, but here's my beef: I had used assembla.com for a long time. 100% free, integrated svn and optional trac, bug-tracking, per-project access control with unlimited projects, free massages on thursdays; the works.

This was fantastic, so I put 10 of my non-critical but still important projects on there. All of a sudden last month they've realized that their business was unsustainable and will be charging a fixed monthly rate per project. No monthly rate * 10 can be affordable, so now I need to find another. If it's hosted (and especially free), I run the risk of having to convert all my projects again..

I generally find that hosted == bad when it comes to my code.

edb··on Someone wants to buy my site, how can I value it?
I hear what you're saying. There's just a key point that I would like your opinion on:

So, for the first 4 years, you have no income as you pay off $50,000 of that $200,000 each year.

The assumption though is that it's a healthy company and will continue to grow, if not hold its revenue, otherwise the annual multiplier shouldn't be 4 and you shouldn't be buying it. However, for the sake of argument, let's assume that the above is true. Yes, you're not making an obvious income, but you are earning 50,000$ worth of a company at the end of each year with 0 investment from your pocket. Isn't that a good reward for your efforts? PLUS if the company grows, you keep the surplus in profits.

What I'm saying is it's subjective/relative. If you're a person who's making 30,000$ per year and you want to make 50,000$ per year, then it's worth it to buy this company at 200,000$ since you will increase your yearly earnings, even if the first 4 years you're paying off the worth of the company. It's an investment, like a house. At the end of 4 years, you own a company that's worth 200,000$ or more, if you run it well, PLUS you have a salary of 50,000. That's not bad, and I think you could find someone who'd be interested in that, no?

That's why I say pick your buyers. If you try to sell to someone who wants to buy the company and then sit on their couch while the company rakes in 50,000$ per year, then no, you won't be able to sell it for 200,000$. If you have someone who's looking for a new job and sees future growth potential in your company, then yes, 200,000$ is a good price.

Does that make sense?

edb··on Someone wants to buy my site, how can I value it?
So, if your site needs a full-time programmer, it's worthless. I mean, it's worth something to you because it can be your income. However, it's not worth anything to an owner since they'd be paying all of the income to a programmer (yes, even if that's themselves since they aren't getting the site for free).

I think this is false. If the buyer is able to run the site without hiring a programmer then the site provides a valuable income for the buyer. That income is a reward that could make the buy price worth it for the buyer, since the buyer will save the salary of the employee, no?

I think when selling a web site or web application, it's important to choose a buyer that will know how to draw value from it, instead of squander its profits on employees that will do the work that the owner should be doing.

edb··on Ask HN: How to get out of a startup cleanly to start a startup?
I'm still young and cost of living here can be 15k/year. I can afford to take the risk right now.
edb··on Ask HN: How to get out of a startup cleanly to start a startup?
I just need this off my plate. Even when the workload is light my partner doesn't like the idea that my concentration isn't fully directed at our business. We've had many open conversations on the matter and we both agreed it would be a good idea if he bought me out.

If he was interested in doing something else, then we could set this up as a passive income generator, but he's not interested in that

edb··on Don't buy that textbook, download it for free
The biggest problem with this field is that most undergraduate-level teachers really don't have the passion required to research free replacements for the textbooks recommended to them by the publishers associated with the university.

I think students in each faculty should rally together and really push this point and work with the professors to find alternatives to 200$ textbooks..

The financial strain that textbook publishers place on students for profit inhibits the learning that their textbooks are supposed to stimulate... That's the big irony.

edb··on Rails, Textile, and javascript WYSIWYG roundup
I definitely second that, and the source of the problem is the same as that with WYSIWYG editors: tables.

I've solved the problem by making things like tables editable in another content management module and including it in the WYSIWYG editor as %%%DATA_TABLE1%%%.

WYSIWYG seems to only work for me when I only allow the client to choose h1,h2,h3,etc.. and bold and italic. If you're just doing that, the WYSIWYG editor is fine and there's no need to try to teach your clients Textile.

Of course, this all depends on who your client is...

edb··on Ask YC: MacBook alternative?
I've been running a Dell Inspiron 6400. If you buy it with a warranty, second LCD, etc.. and know how to talk to the salespeople, you can get it loaded up with all kinds of hardware upgrades for cheap, ESPECIALLY if you buy the 3 year warranty, and it will still be cheaper than a Macbook Pro.

I'm dual booting XP (for my music stuff) and Hardy on it (for my programming stuff) without a hitch, it has 1680x1050 resolution (screen real estate that the macbooks just can't compete with), swanky compiz effects to rival osx's and if anything on my machine goes wrong within the 3 years after purchasing, dell will fix it within 5 days. ANYTHING. (Used it once. Got my laptop back 3 days after I mailed it in!) The warranty alone is the main selling point for these machines.

I can't think of a better price/quality ratio than the Dells

edb··on Pandora for iPhone will be a huge hit
Hrmm, I have always found that last.fm finds better music based on my seeds than pandora does, especially for a discriminating (read:snobby) music junkie such as myself. I remember they had a last.fm app that was usable with jailbroken iphone/touch, that was much better in my opinion.
edb··on Why you should never be a startup girlfriend
you need to watch a movie called "Les Poupees Russes" (Sorry, don't know how to do accents on my iPhone)
edb··on Why I Still Use Windows 95
This article reminds me of my father. He still uses what we call "lefebvre books" to do his business's payroll by pen. When I was younger, I thought he was an idiot. Eventually he rationalized it to me for long enough that I thought it was charming and really interesting that his business is like a snapshot of how things were run in the past.

Right now, his company grew to more than 20 employees and he's selling it because his tools and methods don't work in his changing environment and he refuses to adapt to new tools.

Don't get me wrong, he's by no means unhappy, but his business is no longer running at it's full potential. I think a comparison can be drawn here. I believe that your output is a function of your methods AND tools.. I don't care who you are, you can't build facebook in DOS.

If your environment is changing and you still want to excel in that environment, I believe that you have to adapt.

edb··on Why Functional Programming?
"proclaiming the death of patterns due to closures and dynamic typing."

Can somebody explain that?

edb··on Ask HN: How safe are unique URLs as an authentication method?
Yea, I'm wondering if it's actually safe to use URLs instead of authentication.. I guess not
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →