1,085 karma · joined May 30, 2012
By calling this creation an "Artistic Operating System",
we assert that it should be unique and personal, even
peculiar in its way of representing and interfacing with
the rest of the media world. In this sense, it is freed
from the implicit social requirement that new
technological projects conform to standard principles of
progress, universality and efficiency. There's no need
to claim to be the "Next Big Thing" or to even suggest
that anyone, other than the creators of this device,
should use it. However, its existence serves as a
polemic for a more diverse, inclusive and participatory
interface culture where new technological systems might
be judged for their poetic qualities instead of
marketability.Put less flippantly: The Luddites hated technology because they feared it would take their jobs. While this project calls a lot of strong technological conventions into question, it doesn’t reject technology nearly as fundamentally as the Luddites did. It also has nothing to do with the feared obsolescence of labor.
First, I think I misinterpreted paragraph C w.r.t. how it applies to the ads themselves. I think you're right here, that the ads aren't illegal, since they don't do any discriminating in and of themselves.
However, the text of the law seems to say that placing the order for the ads may be illegal. Placing the order would seem to constitute the making of a statement (with respect to the sale or rental of a dwelling) that indicates a preference (or intention to make that preference) based on race. I realize that might feel like way too low a bar, but it seems to fit.
IANAL, but that's how it seems to me.
... objectively (in no bad way whatsoever) acknowledge
trait differences ...
This is like the "frictionless surface" of sociology. It sure sounds like a great thing to shoot for, but our laws carry centuries (if not millennia) of cultural baggage along with them. It's nigh impossible to craft policies that aim only at the ideal, and ignore people's heavy emotional priors (e.g., if you're a person of race A who grew up amidst feelings of animosity towards people of race B that were brought on by centuries of physical and emotional trauma). As made applicable by section 3603 of this title and except as exempted by
sections 3603(b) and 3607 of this title, it shall be unlawful—
...
(c) To make, print, or publish, or cause to be made, printed, or published
any notice, statement, or advertisement, with respect to the sale or rental
of a dwelling that indicates any preference, limitation, or discrimination
based on race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, or national
origin, or an intention to make any such preference, limitation, or
discrimination.
[0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/3604#c it is cheaper to just get rid of you even
if you are innocent
Is it? One clearly has some value to their employer. Replacing an employee isn’t free either. It’s also not “free” to add social friction to interactions with one's coworkers.As best I know, this has never happened to anyone in / near my social network. That leads me to believe that this isn’t something that happens very often in the general population (unless I’m an outlier). And if it’s so rare, then it doesn’t seem to be worth going out of my way for.
Public disclosures of these kinds of actions
are meticulously calculated
Are they? All we have is a FB post from one of their entrepreneurs. She probably (sensibly) thinks there’s a better authority for dealing with the situation than the general public. many others will make a fear-driven overreaction.
This. The actual risk involved here (job loss due to fraudulent accusations) must be so tiny as to be negligible.And besides, I have a hard time imagining that a large VC firm would fire one of its founders on a flimsy claim. He’s obviously extremely valuable to RFJ, so you’d expect they’d have done some basic cost-benefit analysis before getting rid of him. To me, firing him sounds more like “preemptive damage control” in the face of very credible claims than it seems like “overcautious PC policing”.
EDIT: and also previously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15642856