HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eigenschwarz

231 karma · joined April 14, 2017

submissionscomments
eigenschwarz··on Valve Rolls Out Wine-Based “Proton” for Running Windows Games on Linux
I have my dual boot on 2 separate SSDs and personally find it nice to keep gaming and research separate; there is no temptation to game during the week this way. As an aside, curious why some of these reboot times take so long.
eigenschwarz··on The Higgs boson: the hunt, the discovery, the study and some future perspectives
That's not how science works. Cf. Michelson-Morley.
eigenschwarz··on A Hawaiian island got about 50 inches of rain in 24 hours
Passive aggressively glib. Would 'we' feel sympathy for the people of California if/when the Big One hits and flattens cities, kill thousands, and levies hundreds of billions in damage? Or if/when massive flooding from a Perfect Storm inundates a major coastal city like NOLA or Houston again? I'm sure I can come up with an appropriate analogy of ignorance for where you live.
eigenschwarz··on Calling for a new approach to depression
If you don't mind sharing, I am curious about some of the dietary interventions you tried.
eigenschwarz··on Physicists Uncover Geometric ‘Theory Space’
I'm not well-versed in his work but it seems like Laughlin is an advocate for the approaches to looking at the system instead of the components. One could say that is what the conformal bootstrap does when it's used to solve a theory by calculating its critical exponents. I'd definitely be interested in seeing if we could calculate the critical exponent of the IR fixed point of turbulence.
eigenschwarz··on Physicists Uncover Geometric ‘Theory Space’
Jared Kaplan, one of the researchers mentioned in the article, has a good set of notes here: http://sites.krieger.jhu.edu/jared-kaplan/files/2016/05/AdSC...

David Tong does a good job explaining background physics and his notes can be found here: http://www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/user/tong/teaching.html

The fourth chapter of his string theory notes are about as approachable an introduction to conformal field theory that there is. His QFT notes are good too.

eigenschwarz··on Physicists Uncover Geometric ‘Theory Space’
I'll give it a shot!

Why are we interested in conformal field theories (CFTs)? One reason is it appears that all quantum field theories (QFTs) can be viewed as points along a “path” between a high-energy CFT to a low-energy CFT (c.f. the roadmap analogy in the article). Therefore, studying CFTs lets us study the space of well-defined QFTs, which are the mathematical framework in which to construct models in particle physics.

At the same time, we can describe seemingly unrelated theories like the 3d Ising model as CFTs. The conformal bootstrap approach has enabled researchers to recently calculate the critical exponents for the 3d Ising model, which effectively “solves” the theory as the critical exponents are universal and characterize all the physical properties of a theory.

The whole business about the “unknown polyhedron” and mapping “the geometry of theory space” means figuring out where these theories (e.g. Ising and other thing) live on this (higher-dimensional) map in relation to each other and potentially how to get from one to the other.

The article briefly talks about the AdS/CFT or holographic principle and how we can use CFTs to study gravity (this is more what I'm interested in) but this is a whole other can of worms. Needless to say, it's also super exciting! Two examples of the types of 'big' questions being looked at are gravity as 'emerging' from a CFT and probing the black hole information paradox / beyond the horizon.

Hope this helps!

eigenschwarz··on Physicists Uncover Geometric ‘Theory Space’
Yes, not that they do exist but perhaps the notion of how a quantum field theory of quarks is really nearly the same thing in some ways as an Ising model, etc. The ultimate goal is to understand how these disparate physical systems are similarly mathematically structured and how to get from one to the next, and to find out the limits of the space of theories. (The signposts and roads analogy in the article is a good one.)
eigenschwarz··on Physicists Uncover Geometric ‘Theory Space’
I work directly in this field. This article covers a lot of a material that is at the forefront of theoretical high energy physics where we are neck-deep in the 'fog of war.' Truthfully, I can think of few subjects more difficult to describe to people not in the field than the conformal bootstrap; there are a lot of technical details that are easy to get hung up on but are crucial for understanding the big picture.
eigenschwarz··on France to ban mobile phones in primary, junior and middle schools
Again, same as above: do you watch TV or listen to radio in school unless the teacher introduces it as part of the learning process? It's not that everything about a smartphone is bad - just like not everything about TV is bad - it's the unfettered and ubiquitous distractions inherent in smartphones being used during school hours for uses aside from learning.
eigenschwarz··on France to ban mobile phones in primary, junior and middle schools
Do you watch TV or listen to radio in school unless the teacher introduces it as part of the learning process?
eigenschwarz··on France to ban mobile phones in primary, junior and middle schools
Definitely true. As pointed out in your link, the redeeming thing about complex video games (e.g. an immersive RTS or a complex level designed and puzzle filled FPS) is it causes advantageous adaptions in the brain, although at the expense of potentially becoming addicting with too much nonstop playing.

We can decouple these effects in video games partly by limiting continuous playtime; it would be interesting to see if the same could be done with smartphones in an educational setting. I can think of one suggestion: make smartphones only able to utilize educational technology (e.g. a VR tour of the solar system) during school hours and disable text/email/social media apps (but leave emergency call numbers). How to implement this beyond the honor system, I am not sure. But maybe that is all that is needed.

eigenschwarz··on France to ban mobile phones in primary, junior and middle schools
The scary thing about smartphones is how they might be permanently changing adolescent and teenage brains, and not in a good way.

Checking texts and emails, surfing the internet for information, and yes - even sites like HN and reddit - cause a dopamine surge in the brain that can lead to so-called 'dopamine loops' [1]. In such a crucial part of brain development, my fear is we are turning kids into the equivalent of 'lever-pushing monkeys' [2]. Certainly there is already evidence that smartphones might be contributing to negative development [3].

[1] https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/brain-wise/201209/why-w...

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=axrywDP9Ii0

[3] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/11/magazine/why-are-more-ame...

eigenschwarz··on The Scotsmen Who Invented Modernity
David Hume, Adam Smith, James Clerk Maxwell, Andrew Carnegie, Alexander Graham Bell, James Watt, Alexander Fleming, Lord Kelvin - the list goes on... For such a tiny nation Scotland has truly had a remarkable influence on “modernity”.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2