HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

el_cujo

1,010 karma · joined December 31, 2018

submissionscomments
el_cujo··on SingleSpot: meet singles in bars and cafés around you
I think part of the appeal of Tindr/Plenty of Fish/etc. for a lot of people is how you can do the initial interacting online. I'm not saying that it isn't better for the actual people/relationship to have the first encounter be in person, I just feel like a lot of people like online dating for that exact purpose, whether its simply due to convenience (can talk to/filter through matches from home) or being too socially awkward to be comfortable with meeting someone in person that you haven't gotten to know a little bit ahead of time. Moreover, the people who are most at ease with asserting themselves with strangers probably don't need the app, as the only utility it really provides is targets.

However, if like another poster said, only women can see the "targets" and the onus is on them to make the first move, then I can see this app having utility as it can be a way for men to make themselves available to an in person interaction without feeling like they'll come off as predatory by making the first move (and likewise allowing women to encounter men in person without having to worry that every man in the room will think she's inviting interaction). But it isn't readily apparent that the app works that way.

el_cujo··on What Was the Happiest Day on the Internet This Decade?
This article is kind of trash. It basically starts off by saying you can write off anything that happened after 2016 because Trump winning made twitter go into a downspiral of sadness, when in reality that downtrend seemed to have started in mid 2015 (right around when election coverage started really ramping up, interestingly enough).

Then after going through the effort of showing graphs and numbers to make the rankings seem legit, the author describes how the scoring is done, and it seems incredibly skewed by the addition of arbitrary events that each add a point to the score. So basically, if the author wants a day to get a higher score, they can just look into it more to find more events so that its score goes up. If an event happened that day that contributed to happiness, the hedonometer score already reflects that, it makes no sense to double dip by giving the score extra points since that days happiness may have had multiple small contributions rather than just one big one.

I don't even really agree with how the hedonometer score was integrated. I think to really see how "happy" an individual day is, it would be better to subtract that day's happiness from the baseline/average happiness of that month rather than the raw score. This gives small happy days in a happy period an advantage over big happy days in a less happy period. I guess if you're just trying to say that day is happy without trying to tie any event to it, the raw data is fine, but I think that's much less interesting. There is probably some fancier math that could be done to weight the scores on a curve that would be more fair than just subtracting from their baseline if you really wanted to get into it.

In the end they come to the conclusion that same-sex marriage being legalized is the happiest day on the internet, but if you look at the first graph, it really barely looks like an out of the ordinary day, you wouldn't notice it if it wasn't being pointed out. This really makes it feel like the author came into this article wanting that to be number one and made everything else fit around that.

el_cujo··on Weekend ‘catch-up sleep’ is a lie
Yeah I was a little confused by reading this. I know several people who underwent dramatic weight loss but still had cheat days a few times a month, I don't really think that's uncommon. I mean I'm sure it slows your progress compared to not "cheating", but I've seen enough success stories to know it doesn't completely undo everything (depending on how bad you cheat I guess?)
el_cujo··on Weekend ‘catch-up sleep’ is a lie
I also take issue with how the article mentions that sleep is not a balance sheet, but doesn't really lay out that this was explicitly tested.

They said the participants slept only five hours a night for weekdays. 8 hours is the generally recommended amount for a good nights sleep, so to truly bring balance to that schedule, they'd have a 15 hour sleep-debt to make up on the weekends, in addition to the full 8 hours they'd need to sleep those two weekend days on their own. I seriously doubt the participants were able to sleep 16 hours on both friday and saturday night to fully pay the sleep debt even at their level of sleep deprivation, so I don't think you can really say the "balance sheet" approach is wrong.

I'm not necessarily saying I support a balance sheet view of sleep, I just think these kinds of articles are not very careful with the kind of wording they use. Also maybe I'm just living under a rock, but I don't feel like its that common to only get 5 hours of sleep every single weekday unless you're like a single parent with a baby (in which case you probably wouldn't magically get 8 hours on the weekend), I'd be more interested to see what happens if this was done in smaller spurts, like two consecutive days with three or four hours of sleep to emulate some work or school deadline approaching, but then 8 or 9 the rest of the week after its complete. As it stands now, the title of the article comes off as click bait because its a pretty fear-mongering conclusion drawn from what I consider to be pretty extreme circumstances.

el_cujo··on What is it like working at a company after releasing a negatively-received game?
I think a lot of it has to do with the games being popular rather than violent, though I guess you could say in the current culture of gaming, violent games are more popular. For example, parts of the Pokemon community are extremely vitriolic and relentlessly criticize every new entry in the series. As a fan base gets bigger, its easier for people to dehumanize each other over the internet and thus be meaner to one another, where as smaller fan communities don't have that problem because you see a lot of the same names around and maybe even have an easier time talking to the actual devs. It's less of an anonymous mob, so people are less terrible to each other.
el_cujo··on What is it like working at a company after releasing a negatively-received game?
You can still be responsible and give people disclosure while using a throw away. The benefit is you don't have to worry about people mining your entire post history to look for stuff they can use to draw negative conclusions about you/blizzard. You can also never look at that account again after that post so you don't have to worry about any crazies sending abusive messages about Diablo Immortal or whatever.
el_cujo··on We Need Chrome No More
>the switch would almost certainly make things worse because add-ons people relied on won't work and now you've burdened them with having to find new and unfamiliar alternatives to what they were comfortable with.

I have no data to back this up so you could say I'm just talking out of my ass, but I would guess that the non-technical users who makes up most of Chrome's userbase either don't use any add-ons at all or mainly use extremely popular ones that have equivalents in other web browsers like adblock.

I 100% agree with everything else though, the average user who uses a web browser exclusively for instagram and gmail does not see things like small performance increases or privacy as being worth changing habits for. Hell, some of the technical people I work with have no problem with companies/the NSA spying on them because they have "nothing to hide". I really think the only reason Chrome got so popular was because the meme that Internet Explorer sucks premeated our culture so strongly that basically everyone started to know that the first thing you do with a new computer is use IE to download a different browser, and what better to use than the one made by the search engine you use every day?

el_cujo··on A Raspberry Pi Grimoire For The Command Line Wizard
I love seeing these kinds of projects, but as someone who currents owns 2 pi 3s and one elgato that are all gathering dust, I hit the wall before actually starting a project because of that pesky "what would I even do with this" thought.
el_cujo··on Four new DNA letters double life’s alphabet
"In March 2015, NASA scientists reported that, for the first time, complex organic compounds found in DNA and RNA, including uracil, cytosine and thymine, have been formed in the laboratory under outer space conditions, using starting chemicals, such as pyrimidine, found in meteorites. Pyrimidine and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) may have been formed in red giants or in interstellar dust and gas clouds, according to the scientists."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meteorite#Meteorite_chemistry, which cites https://www.nasa.gov/content/nasa-ames-reproduces-the-buildi...

el_cujo··on Four new DNA letters double life’s alphabet
>Are there new proteins this lets them make?

I think for now we are still a ways off from this being interesting at the protein level. I would think you would need new tRNAs to recognize the new bases in-order to really utilize them at a protein level, and those tRNAs would need to bind to different amino acids than we currently have for there to be any new protein function that we can't already accomplish with ATCG.

That being said, you can still do a lot of interesting stuff with nucleic acids like DNA and RNA, more and more research these days show they can do more than just encode information for proteins.

el_cujo··on We're Entering a Golden Age of Podcasts
>I'm actually worried that podcasts are going the way of the web. What, for a while, was a weird world of enthusiasts talking about things that interests them seems to be morphing into a world of a few big corporate entities calling the shots.

I think podcasting is somewhat shielded from this by the fact that you really don't need an insane amount of capital to put out a good product. There definitely are podcasts that have expensive, professional studio set ups, but there are others I've listened to that are just straight up recorded on an iPhone and they can actually sound very decent. This low barrier of entry makes it easy for people to make their own weird podcast without having to water down their product and pitch it to investors. I guess with time that could change if your podcast is considered dead if its not on one of these big corporate channels. As someone who really enjoys the "homemade" feels, I hope this never happens, a podcast feeling overproduced is a big turn off IMO.

el_cujo··on Bookworm: A Simple, Focused eBook Reader
I agree with your point about the library. Maybe I'm just weird, but typically I'll read one, MAYBE two books at a time before moving on to another. Because of this, I really don't need the app to show me my library like this every time because its not like I'll be hopping around between books several times within an hour. I can see how this library setup makes sense for a music player or some sort of gaming platform, but it feels like for books they're just bringing the feature along without considering whether or not it makes sense. I guess it is nice to be able to gaze upon your library and think "wow I've read a lot" or "wow I have a lot of options to read", but I"m not sure I'd say that's worth the start up time.
el_cujo··on Activision-Blizzard layoffs after reporting record results
Maybe I'm just heartless, but "I have to either move cities or switch to another field that I'm also qualified for" does not really sound like too bad of a deal to me. I mean yeah, it's a pain not to be able to keep on doing what you've been doing, but neither of those options sounds life-shattering to me.
el_cujo··on Activision-Blizzard layoffs after reporting record results
Also despite having a "record year", Activision/Blizzard's stock has dropped almost 50% from where it was in September 2018, which I think was at least started by the PR blunder that was the Diablo Immortal announcement. The article doesn't really give any context into what the CEO meant by "record year" or even when he said it. If he'd said it back in August maybe that would make sense, or maybe it was a business move where you "look on the bright side" when things are looking shitty, but based on their stock price I'm not at all surprised they're having lay offs and restructuring.
el_cujo··on Netflix Posted Biggest-Ever Profit in 2018 and Paid $0 in Income Taxes
This is how it works in America as well.
el_cujo··on Why isn't the internet more fun and weird?
I see that kind of attitude even on twitter and large subreddits. I don't think its specific to imageboards, in my experience it's just a very popular attitude/outlook among those currently in their late 20s/early 30s.
el_cujo··on Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize
The poster responded to someone saying “why would anyone not want to unionize” by saying “some unions are shitty”, is that not reasonable? They aren’t even saying it’s a good reason, but a lot of people seem to have this idealistic view of unions and I do think it is healthy to keep in mind that this isn’t the case, just wanting to unionize and handing the reigns over to people who are lazy or greedy can leave you with labor problems AND a bite from your paycheck.
el_cujo··on An investigative reporter has changed his tech habits after what he has learned
I'm not saying having lots of technology in your house is a bad thing by any means, but in my mind at least what I kind of considered as the "baseline" for most people would be smartphone and some sort of personal computer (laptop or desktop). It's just interesting to hear someone say that they think phone+laptop+tablet+nest isn't that much technology, we've gone so quickly from these items being uncommon to people thinking they aren't a big deal. Sure you could say the same thing about lightbulbs and indoor plumbing but I wasn't around for that transition.
el_cujo··on Hard Part of Computer Science? Getting into Class
I went to a relatively large public school with a big endowment. The "just teachers" were called Adjunct Professors and they really had a shit deal. They basically didn't make any more money teaching at my school than they would teaching at a community college and I don't even think they were considered full-time with benefits. Meanwhile, my research PI was a tenured professor who made a very decent living (salaries of teachers at the school were publicly available) but almost all of his salary was paid out by research grants, not the school.

Really among most of the department, I was surprised how much of an afterthought teaching seemed to be. They were by no means bad teachers, and I guess when you've been teaching the same class for many years it becomes pretty effortless, but there really is no good incentive for them to sign up and teach a bunch of extra classes when research is what they are interested in and pays for their salary (along with the salaries of all of their lab members).

el_cujo··on Hard Part of Computer Science? Getting into Class
>Aafia Ahmad, a sophomore computer science major at U.T. Austin, had hoped to take an elective course in computer security this semester. But when she tried to sign up during early registration in November, the course was already full.

I know this doesn't refute the point the article is trying to make, but it doesn't seem that unreasonable to me that an underclassman might not get into a highly sought after elective. A lot of the "fun" electives when I was in school were little passion projects taught by one professor for one or two small sections a semester (or maybe only one semester per year), and while I agree it sucks that not everyone can take the classes, I wouldn't want them to die out because of complaints along the lines of "if you can't accommodate everyone, don't offer the course". Not that the article is saying that should be the case, I just worry that too many complaints about this kind of thing just puts pressure on the good professors who put enough effort into a class that a bunch of people want to take it.

el_cujo··on An investigative reporter has changed his tech habits after what he has learned
Terrible clickbait title, at least the actual article mentions Facebook so you have some idea of what it's about.

I found it kind of funny towards the bottom when he said:

>We’re a pretty analog family. Aside from the requisite phones, laptops and iPad, I don’t have a lot of gear.

We've gotten to point where if all you have is smartphones, laptops, and tablets, you're considered pretty "analog".

el_cujo··on Ride That Nearly Killed Me Changed How I Think About Ride-Hailing Apps
Yeah I'm not sure why the author chose that title, it makes you think its going to be a "pro-ride sharing/anti-traditional taxi" piece. I wonder if this is a click-bait strategy.
el_cujo··on Ethical bot-making
I was expecting a little more out of an article with a title like that, this piece is a lot of fluff that can be summarized as "be nice".
el_cujo··on A three-page paper that shook philosophy, with lessons for software engineers
I don't think any of his code examples are really JTBs because, like you said, its not "true". In the cow example, you make an assumption based on the papier mache cow that actually turns out to be true through information you didnt have access to. All of his code examples are more about him making assumptions that turn out to be false instead based on information he didn't have access to (or rather didn't think to access at least).

I don't think this really affects the take home message from the piece, I'm just being pedantic that it doesn't parallel perfectly (which he even acknowledges people may say in the last paragraph).

el_cujo··on People older than 65 share the most fake news, a new study finds
People are increasingly aware of fake news now and I really hope this spreads further into scrutiny on science, especially news articles about science. You really need to dig deep into the methods of a study so you can understand all of the caveats that go with its conclusions, but obviously a "news" article on a finding is going to gloss over most of that and crystallize the entire paper into one click bait sentence.
el_cujo··on CES Revoked an Award for a Female Pleasure Device for Being 'Immoral'
Correct me if I'm wrong, but they were to be given an award that was then revoked, correct? They weren't banned from the show floor, were they?

If so, then this isn't really the obvious double-standard the article makes it out to be unless the male sex products are winning awards without the "no sex products" rule being applied to them as well. If anything it seems in line with their push to have sexual things present but not featured.

el_cujo··on How Estimates of the Gig Economy Went Wrong
Thanks for this, if anything it's these paywall'd links that shouldn't be welcome.
el_cujo··on How to give a great scientific talk
>most talks, like most research in general, are incremental improvements or variations of X

Again, I don't know if this is something that is only true in Biological science and less so in Computer Science, but while I agree most research is a minor incremental improvement, its often on a topic so specialized that most outside of your research group aren't very familiar with the intricacies.

This begs the question, like you said, then why would you care about hearing that talk? Maybe you don't even care about their thesis and are just interested in adapting a technique they used in your own work. Or maybe their thesis bridges a gap between two fields of study that were previously not very closely linked. Besides, when you're trying to communicate your work to other people, isn't it to your advantage to try and cast as wide of a net as possible? Isn't part of the point of talks and conferences to widen people's spheres a bit? There's no need to leave your home lab if you want to converse with people who understand most of what you're researching already.

el_cujo··on How to give a great scientific talk
>I feel this is how to give a great talk, not necessarily a great scientific talk.

I come from a Biology background so maybe its different, but I have been to so many talks where 90% of the audience is grad students and looking around the room you can tell none of them are getting anything out of the talk because they got lost in the first five minutes. Sure it would be silly for every Neuroscience talk to waste five minutes explaining what a brain is, but even seasoned scientists seem to take for granted that not everyone studies their same corner of the field. Giving sufficient background info is severely underrated in talks, as is very explicitly stating ideas that will be necessary to appreciate the core thesis of the talk is. I'm sympathetic to the fact that timing is tight and scientists want to save a significant amount of time for their actual research, but if most of the room comes away from the talk with absolutely nothing then it was a wasted effort. You're right that the presenter should know their audience and that would fix things, its just that in my experience, the presenter is almost always overestimating their audience.

el_cujo··on People with Depression Use Language Differently
So was their analysis of depressed people purely based on post/comments on mental health forums? To me, it makes sense that if you were going to one of these forums for the express purpose of getting help, of course you'd be using first person pronouns and negative-words, I imagine a lot of the posts would have something to the tune of "I've been feeling sad lately". Likewise, they compare this to formerly-depressed people on a forum explicitly for positive encouragement and found they used more positive-sounding words. The study seems to me to be analyzing whether people stay on topic in these forums more than saying anything about depressed people in general. While this would be much more difficult to accomplish and probably isn't realistic, I think it would be way more helpful to analyze how depressed people post on social media or via text or other "normal" conversation rather than how they interact when they go somewhere to talk about depression/being depressed.
← PreviousPage 7 of 7