HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

el_nahual

2,300 karma · joined December 14, 2017

submissionscomments
el_nahual··on Building an email-to-calendar LLM
As long as you can sanitize the LLM output somehow. You should never `eval` LLM code straight from the tap!
el_nahual··on Weather Planning for Eclipse Day
I drove down to Carbondale, IL last eclipse from Chicago, usually a 5 hour drive. It took 8. Not too bad! Pulled over in some country rode with a patch of clear sky. It doesn't really matter where you are: the show is up there.

The moment the eclipse ended we drove back to the interstate, which minutes prior had been empty.

It was bumper-to-bumper. Like something out of a cartoon.

The drive back to Chicago took 14 hours. I decided to follow Waze, which took me (and an endless line of cars with the same idea) through a one-lane dirt road through a bunch of farms.

The people who lived there took lawn chairs out and sat down to drink beers and watch the strange procession.

Stopped for lunch at a crossroads Panda Express. It was bedlam. Thousands of people all looking to eat something in rest stop that usually feeds dozens. The crew of pimply highschoolers resorted to slapping spoonfuls of random faux Chinese food into Styrofoam containers and giving it out for free. "Just take it!"

The only scary part was being caught by one of those Midwestern thunderstorms about two hour out from Chicago--at 2am, after diving for about 18 hours straight, sticking my hand out of the window to wet it before slapping myself on the face to stay awake (no way to pull over--not when visibility is ~zero).

Adventure indeed!

el_nahual··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
I don't know about the game theory of the whole thing.

If a group does want to murder a whistleblower, they presumably want to do it for two reasons:

- To prevent them from testifying further - To scare other potential whistleblowers into not testifying

A public statement of "if something happens to me it wasn't suicide!" is certainly not evidence enough. But it's a strong hint...which is actually the most favorable outcome to the murdering org, since it maximizes the chilling effect of the murder.

el_nahual··on Operating on a minimal two-core Postgres instance: Query optimization insights
The problem with having business logic in the DB is not a performance problem, it's a maintainability, testing, and documentation problem.
el_nahual··on New York restaurants fight back against reservations by bots
> Finally they seat me and remind me I only have the table 90 minutes.

As someone that lives in Mexico City where dinners (and lunches!) easily last 3, 4 or even 5 hours this sounds horrifically demeaning.

el_nahual··on WeWork Goes Bankrupt
Can you elaborate on which part exactly doesn't make any sense? The idea that one could rent wholesale then sublet retail (with a few value add goodies, printing, coffee, etc sprinkled in) is not "obviously" dumb to me.
el_nahual··on Best Night Vision vs. Darkest Room [video]
I enjoy the veritasium youtube channel but it's important to remember that videos like this are enabled by the military as recruiting and propaganda aids. The same is true of channels like Smarter Every Day when they partner with the coast guard or military.
el_nahual··on Phoenix 1.7 for Elixir: Edit a Form in a Modal
Internet-shorthand for The Featured* Article--the webpage/blog post/etc being linked.

Sort of like OP, GP, etc.

el_nahual··on Phoenix 1.7 for Elixir: Edit a Form in a Modal
I'm a big Elixir fan, but unfortunately Phoenix is starting to suffer from an overuse of LiveView.

LiveView is great, but it's sort of becoming the default way to render everything--even static pages! TFA is a good example of this, where they use a Live view to render...a static list of icons.

The problem with this is twofold:

- LiveView is not free. It seriously affects people with unstable connections, for example. It creates a new class of silent bug at the client/server interface, where the client just sees "broken" pages (instead of 500 pages).

- It adds cognitive overhead. We bloody know how to do server side rendering. We've been doing it for 30 years (!). It's a good model. Don't make me learn something else, please.

Phoenix, which is a jewel of a framework, is risking becoming an "SPA-like" framework, with a new paradigm, and a whole lot of overhead to learn, footguns you've never encountered before, bizarre failure modes, etc.

I mean, TFA even has a section where they talk abut an obscure but that "...is a doozy, so I will save you some hours of debugging."

We don't need this!

One of the things that made Phonix/Elixir great is how simple and opinionated the core team has been. Conventions are Very Strong, but not magic. Unfortunately, LiveView is so cool (it really is!) that no conventions were built around it and it's now used for everything.

IMHO LiveView should be used with a very clear heuristic:

- If the page is static, render a static page.

- If the page is dynamic, and the content changes depending on calculations happening server side, use LiveView. It truly shines here.

- If the page is dynamic, and the content changes depending on actions performed by the client, use JS.

el_nahual··on A look into the finances of SpaceX
By definition, spending on something that is consumable (like a rocket launch) is not a capital expenditure.

A capital expenditure is when you buy something whose value slowly decreases with time.

If a factory buys a building for $10MM, it isn't any poorer. Yes, it has $10MM less in the bank, but it also has a building worth $10MM.

As the building loses value with time the factory gets poorer: it's that loss of value which can be depreciated.

el_nahual··on Squeeze the hell out of the system you have
I haven't read the transcript of this conversation in a long time, but thank you for sharing it.

The sophistry of his argument is extreme.

Yes, of course there are always "unknown unknowns"-- but the statement "there is no evidence that Iraq is supplying WMDs to terrorists" is not a statement made in a vacuum, in which all permutations of known/unknown are equally likely.

el_nahual··on Israeli startups are moving jobs and money out of the country
It should go without saying that the 5 million Palestinians living in (Israel+Palestine), who make up 30% of the combined population, did not live in a democracy even before these changes.
el_nahual··on Elixir for Ruby developers: the three most important differences
Too late to edit this comment, but as evidence: at time of writing this, the top comment has a very thoughtful reply by...Jose Valim (creator of the language).
el_nahual··on Elixir for Ruby developers: the three most important differences
The community is small, but that means that a reasonable question on elixirforums (not a stateless discord/slack, pun intended) has a good chance of:

1. receiving an answer from a core contributor (valim, McCord, etc)

2. Having the answer become part of the documentation for the language or library

As an aside, the elixir community has a different didactic approach to many others: the documentation in elixir is genuinely instructive (vs a descriptive reference).

As an example, I've been able to download the elixir, Phoenix, and ecto docs and work on an app entirely offline, on an airplane ride, and never felt like I needed to Google anything.

A common elixir answer to "where are all the blog posts" is "read the docs. No, seriously."

el_nahual··on Confronting failure as a core life skill
> To paraphrase Richard Pryor, I support anyone trying to do anything at anytime.

What's the actual source quote here? Your paraphrase is excellent in and of itself.

el_nahual··on What we talk about when we talk about system design
> To me, it’s clear that designing systems is the way to maximum ongoing profit

This is a huge claim. If true, then the way to profitably find your way upward is similar to what the linked article itself is doing:

Write about it, in a credible way, build your reputation as a person that can drive change leading to results, and then become a consultant.

el_nahual··on Comic Code: Monospaced interpretation of the most over-hated typeface
I wish we had a monospaced version of Comic Neue[0], which is a really nice font!

[0]: https://comicneue.com/

el_nahual··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
The cynical(?) explanation is that it is precisely because of the dismantling of standardized testing that getting rid of legacy admissions tenable...because it means schools can still proxy for class in admissions decisions (except veiled as extracurriculars, or "oh, this student knows calculus" in boston/sf).

If Harvard or USC were on the list I'd wager this to be the case, but MIT, Mellon & Pitt are serious schools so I believe them when I say it's in favor of increased rigor.

el_nahual··on Launch HN: Highlight.io (YC W23) – Open-source, full stack web app monitoring
Hijacking your thread a bit, but I have to give you feedback on your landing page copy. I don't understand what you sell!

I thought you were an app for people that care about their social media reach (like, twitter tech influencers). Forgiveable since your hero copy is " Build your Reach".

It's super important when writing marketing copy to name your users. If I'm a club chair for the local bowling league and I see "sports leagues" mentioned then my brain will just think "oh, this is for me!"

The first paragraph in your about page is so much better:

> Whether you're a sports club, social group, hobbyist organization, or non-profit, embolt is the solution to running your organization. We believe every club and organization should have a reliable platform to accept online member dues, manage registration, run events, and so much more.

I would replace the hero copy with a condensed version of that.

el_nahual··on Llama 2
Do those campaigns increase or decrease engagement? My gut is that LLM use will decrease social media demand.
el_nahual··on Llama 2
People keep saying this is commoditize your complement but that's not what this is!

Goods A and B are economic complements if, when the price of A goes down, demand for B goes up.

LLMs are not complements to social media platforms. There is zero evidence that if "the price of LLMs goes down" then "demand for social media apps go up".

This is a case of commoditizing the competition but that's not the same thing.

Commoditizing your complement:

- All-inclusive resorts. Restaurants are a complement to hotels. If food is free I might go on vacation more.

- Smartphone app-stores. Apps are a complement to phones. If apps cost $0.99 there will be more demand for iphones than if apps cost $20.

This is Zuck being an absolute shark and not wanting his competitors to have a monopoly over LLMs in case they win at some other game. It has nothing to do with "commoditize your complement."

el_nahual··on Surfactants safely take down mosquitoes without using insecticides
Surfactants are just soap, and their mechanism of action is mechanical: they will physically remove a membrane, or clog a pore, or whatever.

This is in contrast to insecticides, whose mechanism of action is toxological: they can act on a bug's nervous system.

One is soap, the other is toxin.

What this means is that soaps (surfactants) are much, much safer for the environment because they can be effectively diluted, unlike toxins which can be lethal to intersects even in minute amounts.

So yeah, if some of the soap gets on a bumblebee it might die, but you're not going to get a "one drop of this got in a hive and now everything is dead" effect.

el_nahual··on Chiptune.app
I'm old enough to remember playing games with chiptunes, but young enough to not have known what a tracker was. This YouTube video (from the amazing Ahoy channel) is an incredible, in-depth overview of trackers, their sound and history:

https://youtu.be/roBkg-iPrbw

el_nahual··on Computationally optimal arrangements of barbell plates
Do you really only use one warmup weight when lifting heavy?

Let's say I'm squatting 325lb / 140kg. I'll usually do 5/reps empty bar, 5 reps 135lb, 5 reps 225, 5 reps 275, then 3-5 "working" sets of 325 (3x5 or 5x5).

Do you think all those intermediate warmup reps are a waste of time?

el_nahual··on Americans have quit quitting their jobs
> The only exception might be a mortgage of 25-33% of a house value, I'd put 75-66% in cash.

Can you explain your rationality for this? You're still allowing the bank to have senior ownership of your house except... for less money.

If you default, they keep your house, no matter what the debt-to-value is.

Like, I understand saying "I couldn't make my mortgage payments so the bank took the house, but I guess they did pay for 90% of it".

But this seems like all the insecurity of a mortgage for a lot less money?

el_nahual··on AI and the Automation of Work
This isn't the dunk you think it is since GP is a human (I presume), and he thought the solution worked.
el_nahual··on 43% of white Harvard students are legacy, athlete, or donor/staff related (2019)
Legacy status is different from race. I propose the following thought experiment as comparison.

"I need to see a cardiologist, but there's a long waiting list. Fortunately, my dad is a cardiologist so he saw me immediately."

Few people would think that this action should be illegal.

Compared with:

"I need to see a cardiologist, but there's a long waiting list. Fortunately, I'm White, so he saw me immediately."

(notice how it's still distasteful even if we replace White with Black, Asian, or whatever).

Notice as well how the situation is different if we're talking about a public hospital--in that case we wouldn't accept the nepotism case.

So there's real reasons why we would allow a private institution to have legacy admissions but not race-based admissions (and...come on. Only in the USA would that sentence be controversial!).

The rub is that in the USA many (most? all?) private institutions--yes, even Harvard--receive government support, participate in government programs, and so constitute a sort of shadow arm of the government.

The real answer, unpalatable though it may be to most, is that if private universities have legacy admissions, they should receive no govt support

el_nahual··on CSS-Only Chat
It's actually right there in the name: Cascading Style Sheets.

Css was never meant to be a style language (if by language we understand "a syntax with logical constructs"). It was simply meant go be the stylesheet for a given website. Headers look like this. Body looks like that.

Except, they cascade: headers look like this, but headers that are emphasized look like so.

The idea was that one could define a stlesheet for screens, a stylesheet for print, a stylesheet for screenreaders, and so on.

As such, no programming "language" logic was considered, except "how do styles cascade" (ie, how do we resolve which style "wins" when there are multiple candidates).

The alternative to css was inline styles; styling but without the sheet part.

el_nahual··on Ancient Maya city discovered in Mexican jungle
Verbatim, from his diaries.
el_nahual··on My ranking of every Shakespeare play
Anyone who likes Shakespeare--or anyone who wants to like it--should watch this marvelous BBC Series called "Playing Shakespeare": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D2VnxiW3oqk&list=PLboSQWmG70...

It's produced by the Royal Shakespeare company and is comprised simply of some of the greatest shakeasperean actors (Judi Dench, Ian McKellan, David Suchet, Patrick Stewart) talking about different elements of how to act shakespare.

I recommend starting with Episode 8, "Exploring a character" if only to see David Suchet utterly outclass (the much more famous) Patrick Stewart in their portrayal of Shylock.

← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →