HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

elagost

936 karma · joined December 4, 2018

submissionscomments
elagost··on Librefox: Firefox with privacy enhancements
What's the difference between those branches? Any explanatory links, or care to elaborate?
elagost··on Librefox: Firefox with privacy enhancements
Not just the weird habits of the users, either. I have way more confidence that Mozilla will fix issues in a timely manner than the one developer behind Waterfox, or the several behind Palemoon. Especially when the forks are depending on upstream to fix things for them. A few years ago there was a build of Waterfox that was substantially late because the one developer had exams.
elagost··on Librefox: Firefox with privacy enhancements
Chrome makes addon installation via Group Policy in Windows very easy. I've not attempted with Firefox but it seems similarly easy. The docs are here: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/deploying-firefox-with-...

If you use Windows, you can use local group policy (if you're not part of a domain) and it's not too difficult to export/import for new machines.

elagost··on Librefox: Firefox with privacy enhancements
This seems like an a slightly more complete version of Firefox Profilemaker (https://ffprofile.com/).

I personally use a fairly vanilla Firefox with a few addons and try to keep customization as default as possible. How will further differentiating yourself from the masses (especially since Firefox is already a minority browser) help with privacy, tracking, and fingerprinting? Why not at that point just change your user agent to Chrome/Win7 and run everything in a virtual machine?

edit: To that end, does anyone use browser forks (like Waterfox and Palemoon, or things like unGoogled Chromium) and seriously think they're better than the mainline browser? I see a lot of fair criticism for what Mozilla has done with Firefox (deprecating old extensions, Mr. Robot addons, Cliqz, etc) but it's pretty much the most trustworthy Internet company as far as I'm aware. They seem to genuinely have good will and Open Source at their core, and these forks claiming that Mozilla is this monstrous organization looking to invade your privacy (along the lines of what Google does) seem a little silly to me.

elagost··on BBC podcasts on third-party apps
Anything that isn't an RSS feed that serves MP3s, and therefore can't be synced to an offline media player, isn't a "podcast", and shouldn't be called such. If they can just remove their show feed from Google's program, then it's probably not an open/standardized RSS feed, and Google's program probably isn't a podcast program as we know it.

Podcasts are great because they're essentially open and standardized, and I can sync them with bloated desktop programs like iTunes, FOSS programs like Antennapod, or even command-line interfaces like Newsboat. DRM and arbitrary gating of media behind proprietary technologies just makes it worse and blocks it off from so many people.

elagost··on Keybase is not softer than TOFU
Thanks for the correction. I've not heavily investigated Keybase but I believe this point applies to the other products mentioned.
elagost··on Keybase is not softer than TOFU
It's a step toward people running their own servers, either federated with Keybase proper, or just as a personal instance. That would be valuable for quite a number of enthusiasts. Federation (like email/XMPP) is a very reasonable feature for any forward-looking communication platform.
elagost··on Keybase is not softer than TOFU
This can be applied to pretty much any security-focused product, or product claiming to be secure/encrypted. If it relies on an unknown number of proprietary/closed-source components, it can't be trusted. Keybase, WhatsApp, Telegram, and iMessage are all good examples of this. If your code can't stand up to public scrutiny it might not be able to withstand attack. I'm not willing to blindly chuck messages into a black box and hope what comes out the other end is exactly what I put into it. (This complaint is not specifically about Keybase; in fact the linked article and a few comments say their client doesn't trust the server at all, which is really cool. Point still stands.)

Keybase looks really really cool, and I would love to use it, but I can't in good conscience recommend something that is cagey about the half-open nature of their product, especially when the server. It is by definition "man-in-the-middle"-ing all your data, and if you can't inspect it you can't reasonably trust it.

elagost··on The New iPad Mini
I have an 8" from last year that performs fairly well. I only use it for reading comics and watching videos, and I have f-droid and some programs from there installed (Termux, firefox klar) and it never feels like it's lagging or too slow. The dual speakers are nice, and I like that it has a microSD card slot.
elagost··on Tails 3.13.1 Is Out
More verbose release notes from the website: https://tails.boum.org/news/version_3.13.1/index.en.html

Side note - anyone use this on a regular basis? I keep a flash drive around and update periodically but never really use it. I'm curious to know about your use case.

elagost··on Ad Fraud Scheme Drained Users’ Batteries By Running Hidden Video Ads In Android
The new technologies behind ads are really terrible, but I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with a full-page Rolex ad in the WSJ. Dude in a fancy suit wearing a watch that looks great, and a quick description - that's a very simple, easy to understand model. If I like that watch, I can save up for it. Rolex doesn't know I saw it and doesn't care.

New technologies behind ads, tracking users wherever they go and hounding them relentlessly and using their personal communications to harvest more data - that's the scourge. I'm fine with ads, but I block them on every website because I'm not fine with tracking.

elagost··on Show HN: A Color Picker I Made
This is fantastic, and gets a lot of little things right. Just piling on at this point, but you can never have too many compliments. I really like the little added touches like keyboard navigation and the quick, bouncy animations. Makes it feel really friendly. Super cool! I'm bookmarking this.

In the future would there be a way to enter a hex code and have the system work off that? That's the only thing it's missing (for me).

elagost··on How I'm able to take notes in mathematics lectures using LaTeX and Vim
This method is beautiful and incredibly complicated. Anyone who has enough determination to build up their tools like this and make them 100% ideal and customized for their situation deserves all the praise they get.

If your use case is similar to the author's, perhaps consider taking your environment and leaning hard into customization. As he's proven, it's very much worth it. Seems like it would be much less useful to copy his configs rather than building your own organic system after years of use, though - which is what he did.

I really like vim, personally, but I encourage my coworkers more familiar with Windows to use nano over vi (nobody wants to type that extra m, for some reason) because they're less likely to mess things up. Better off for them to learn their own way rather than being dumped in the middle of the vi desert with no way to exit.

elagost··on A look at an original iPhone prototype
If anything a big board like this is one way to ensure it's not easy to steal.

The on-board (pun intended) documentation - "Do not connect battery without removing J49", etc - is pretty neat too. Is this something that's fairly standard in the industry?

elagost··on 4chan, 8chan blocked by Australian and NZ ISPs for hosting shooting video
On the Internet, even if you're "ironically" being something, it doesn't matter - in text, where it's difficult to interpret intent, if you're being something ironically, you're still being that thing. And for those that find it hard to interpret the irony, all they see is you being that thing.
elagost··on AirPods
First off, I just want to be clear - not trying to sound confrontational, but I want to respond because I'm having fun reading and thinking about your comments.

>Compared to what, your "over-ear" set?

Yeah, that's the comparison I was making. The airpods didn't provide any functional upgrade over earpods (or any set of cheap wired headphones with a remote/mic in them) for me. The airpods made things harder. The double-tap to skip tracks was far from ideal given that it just resulted in slamming this little headphone into my ear, and that kind of hurt. The inline remote/mic was better for that, and it also allowed me to change volume - the airpods not having volume adjustment on them meant I had to keep my device in my pocket, so now the advantage of bluetooth (device set further away, not in the pocket) is gone. The over-ear set has volume controls and a play/pause button.

>Put them in the case, they're charging. The case stays charged for days of casual use. What exactly is "finicky"?

Charging my over ear set is uncomplicated - everything I have charges off of microUSB so I always have that connector around, and to charge the headphones I just plug in the charger. I can use them while they're charging. Airpods require me to stop using them to charge. Nothing else I have is like this - phones, iPods, laptops, or other bluetooth headphones.

I don't worry about the over-ear set coming off. They're comfortable and sit nicely while walking. I always wear a hat when using airpods because I worry about them falling out. When an earpod falls out, it dangles off the other one, and I put it back in. Especially useful while biking (helmet makes wearing ear-covering hats harder).

I get that airpods are probably the best in the category of tiny little 'true wireless' earbuds. I get that 'put them in the charging case' is really the only way to do charging for this type of headphones. I understand they did the best they could, and that with this style of headphones there's severe limitations. But after having owned a pair, I don't understand why anyone would want to use them over something 1/3 the cost that offers much more convenience.

elagost··on AirPods
These are not good headphones. The battery life is kind of bad, the charging system is finicky, the sound is poor, and there's not even passive noise isolation. I have a $50 pair of over-ear bluetooth headphones that have week-long battery life, sound pretty good, can be charged while being listened to, and have a 3.5mm plug for passive wired listening when the battery runs out.

Like everyone else, I bought and used a set of AirPods for a while, but I ended up going back to the wired headphones when I wanted tiny little earbuds while walking or biking. My wired headphones work everywhere (including my iPod, which I use every day) and the AirPods are finicky, frequently lost connection between themselves, and required charging all the time. Much easier just to tuck a wired set down my sweatshirt and use the in-line remote to control volume (which the airpods can't do).

elagost··on Thinkpad X210
There's more or less a cult around using Linux on older Thinkpads. They're so widely available for so cheap, and since so many people use and test software with them, pretty much every Linux distro works out of the box. The older models are coreboot and libreboot-friendly, the keyboards are amazing, and almost every single part is replacable (the older 14" models have socketed processors even).

Many still enjoy the old IBM models. I'm typing this on an X220 model, and I do understand the risks associated, which is why it's running coreboot, a stripped-down Intel ME, and GNU/Linux (as opposed to original firmware and Windows).

The X220 that I'm using has run every Linux distro I can think of with zero modifications, and I even had macOS on it as a hackintosh for a time. I've replaced the wifi card, I have two hard drives in it and two batteries for it, and it still does everything I need a computer to do with zero fuss.

Even without Coreboot and Linux, many still find the risks don't outweigh the rewards. Same reason people buy newer Macbooks that lack magsafe, sd card slots, USB-A, Ethernet, a decent keyboard, an escape key, replaceable disks/RAM, etc. For Macs, it's form over function. For Thinkpads, specifically the older ones, it's the exact reverse.

elagost··on iPad Pro as Development Machine
Another incredibly good point. Tablets are great at things like watching videos, reading comics, and if you're not doing any typing, are really good 'couch computers'. Rotating the display provides a whole new set of functionality that you just can't get on a laptop, where it's incredibly awkward to do so.
elagost··on iPad Pro as Development Machine
There's no bigger software ecosystem than a laptop running Windows that can be converted into a laptop running a Linux distro.

But, you've got me on the 'best displays' portion. I think the iPads have 120hz displays? They're amazing and threre's nothing like them. They most certainly are "all that", but despite having the opportunity and the spare cash, I still prefer the trashy, ghosting, dim, low-rez display that I have attached to a real laptop.

elagost··on iPad Pro as Development Machine
These articles are always hilarious.

The way most people use iPads as 'dev machines' could be just as easily configured using a $199 netbook from Best Buy and a copy of PuTTY. (Or, buying any not-broken laptop from Craigslist for $50 and saving yourself $1100.)

Granted, as a sysadmin, most of my job could be done on an iPad too (SSH, RDP, web browser, and messaging applications), but every few days I need USB, Serial, VGA, or Ethernet (along with manual config of the adapter), among other things.

So, with these iPad there are always caveats: you end up needing to keep a "real computer" around for all the cases the iPad can't cover, which is most of them.

A few days ago there was a discussion about Termux (https://termux.com/) on Android here, and with things like USB OTG and removable storage that are commonly featured in Android, a Kindle Fire tablet (which cost about $50-150, regularly on sale) would be more usable, even, than an iPad.

elagost··on Reasons Not to Use Apple (2018)
Stallman is very much on one of the far ends of the technological spectrum, with, say, normal people with Android phones and Gmail and a Windows laptop on the other.

I think most people, given enough explanation, would recognize that Stallman and the FSF are 100% correct in their extremism and zealotry - but most aren't able to live without the convenience they've come to know and love.

It's important to have him on his end, so that him and those like him can balance out the other end, and that most people can reasonably fall more towards the middle. Can't have shadows without bright light.

elagost··on How Discord Went Mainstream
Discord is primarily "gamer" focused, so macros are often pointed out as a means of cheating or otherwise gaining unfair advantage. AutoHotkey (https://www.autohotkey.com/) could be used to chain a bunch of actions in a game together and perform some sort of difficult action with minimal effort, so that's discouraged.

But the rule is very odd. Most "gaming" focused mice/keyboards have software and buttons dedicated to performing macro functions, and they're present on major brands like Razer and Logitech equipment.

elagost··on How Discord Went Mainstream
This is the most well-thought-out response in the thread. My initial knee-jerk is too extreme. Thank you for the sanity check.
elagost··on How Discord Went Mainstream
Hacker News is publicly viewable without an account. Totally different.

Discord tricks the user into using it as a private messaging platform. Its main draw, as I understand it, is the IRC channel clones ("Servers"), which can be public or private/invite-only. It's also got no privacy or security options for the direct person-to-person messages, which people use essentially as an SMS/iMessage/WhatsApp replacement. Encrypted chat at scale is hard, but this is a relatively new product and was built in an era where privacy concerns were well known. The benefits of encryption/privacy/security etc (and drawbacks from the lack of it) are clear.

I understand they need to be able to transmit the data, but they also clearly state that the developers of the product can look at your messages in cleartext. That's absolutely not required. How do you think Signal operates?

elagost··on How Discord Went Mainstream
I agree, but that's sad, and not the way things should be.

We should hold ourselves to a higher standard instead of blindly shuffling into the tar pits. Does that mean life is harder? Yes. But no one great ever took the easy way out.

elagost··on How Discord Went Mainstream
From the TOS:

By uploading, distributing, transmitting or otherwise using Your Content with the Service, you grant to us a perpetual, nonexclusive, transferable, royalty-free, sublicensable, and worldwide license to use, host, reproduce, modify, adapt, publish, translate, create derivative works from, distribute, perform, and display Your Content in connection with operating and providing the Service. The Company does not guarantee the accuracy, quality, or integrity of any user content posted.

They also have a ban against distributing or even talking about macro/autohotkey programs, and, of course, they can see every single message and piece of content you put on the service.

It's 20XX; why is there anything but harsh condemnation for services like this? Modern communication platforms should not be set up this way.

elagost··on Spotify to Apple: Time to Play Fair
My dad has had iPads since the first one, and it is still jarring for him to not be able to just click a "store" button in the Kindle app. (I believe it used to have a webview for the store built-in; I do not use the Kindle app)

He was very confused when it disappeared. I imagine most users feel this way. I had to coach my mom to sign up for Pandora on the website so she saved a couple bucks a month, and it was baffling to her why it costed more in the app.

elagost··on Spotify to Apple: Time to Play Fair
I'm no great fan of Google, but it's a little harder to point the finger at them.

F-droid works perfectly well on any Android device, and is a viable alternative to Google Play (for some users). Android .apk files can be installed on any Android device with one switch flipped - and the first time you attempt to install an .apk file, it points you to the setting. Chrome extensions can similarly be packaged and distributed from another source (i.e. GitHub) and are treated as first-class chrome extensions alongside their store-installed counterparts. Apps installed on an iPhone via Xcode (only available for macOS, which is only available on Apple hardware) expire after 7 days and refuse to open unless they are re-deployed. They last for a year if the user pays Apple $99/year for a developer certificate.

Google's platforms don't have people spending money as much as iPhone users do, but they are not nearly as locked down or restrictive.

elagost··on Graying Out
Pidgin has OMEMO support.

https://github.com/gkdr/lurch

This works fairly well for me.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →