HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

elbasti

2,024 karma · joined December 20, 2015

submissionscomments
elbasti··on A psychiatrist who didn’t believe in mental illness (2013)
Until 1973, homosexuality was considered "mental illness", with diagnostic criteria in the DSM.

Then it was removed. What happened? Did it stop existing? No. Were homosexual individuals "cured"? No.

Quite simply, the psychiatric community decided that individuals with same-sex desires were not, _and never had been_ mentally ill. The illness was no more.

The same is not true of physical illness.

Different argument:

The diagnostic criteria for "mental illness" overlap. So it's possible to be diagnosed with say, ADD and "Bipolar type 2" and "generalized anxiety disorder".

Which is it? Which illness does the patient have? How does one decide? Which _physical_ mechanism is responsible for one vs the other two?

Physical illness has no such ambiguity.

Nobody knows. Because the map does not map to reality. It's like asking if a hot dog is a kind of sandwich. Maybe. Who cares. It's the wrong question.

Last example:

People suffering from grief/bereavement match many, if not all, the diagnostic criteria for "Depression". Are they depressed? Or are they merely grieving? The answer (if you're a psychiatrist) depends on which volume of the DSM you use (the latest one does not exclude bereavement from the diagnostic criteria).

Is there similar subjectivity with physical illness? No. So they are clearly categorically different kinds of diagnoses, and Thomas Szasz's argument is that for that reason we should not use the word "illness" to talk about these kinds of very real problems.

elbasti··on A psychiatrist who didn’t believe in mental illness (2013)
> but I don't like confusing people by trying to deny the common understanding of a word.

I think that's actually the crux of the argument. The phrase "mental illness" IS the perversion of a common understanding of a word. When people hear "illness" they think "thing that is broken". Is a runny nose an illness? No, the flu is an illness.

I don't think it's about whether we fully understand the cause or not; I think it's about whether or not we think there probably is a single, physical cause.

So we absolutely should call Cystic Fibrosis an illness even if we don't know the cause, because we think there probably IS one. And heck, there may be two causes! And then... well, then it would be TWO illnesses with similar symptoms, not one.

At this point I'm straying from the book because I don't remember it too well, so this is editorializing: I don't think that holds for many mental illnesses.

"Depression"--do we think there's one, or few, underlying physical causes of it? Highly doubtful. And we know it's highly doubtful because the treatments that make the symptoms go away are so varied in their mechanisms of action and effectiveness. Exercise. Sunlight. Changing jobs. Medication. Time. Talk therapy. All these things "work", to some degree or another, but the odds that they are targeting the same underlying, malfunctioning, physical mechanism are very slim. So one would say "depression is not an illness, the same way a runny nose is not an illness. It's a pattern."

elbasti··on A psychiatrist who didn’t believe in mental illness (2013)
But mental illness _is_ different from physical illness. That's the whole point.

The dangerous thing is to presume that's not true. Or even worse: to lie about it. The phrase "chemical imbalance" comes to mind. Complete and utter fabrication of a physical cause.

It may be that a physical cause is discovered for some conditions which today are considered "mental illnesses"... say, schizophrenia. Well, when that happens it will stop being known as a mental illness and just a physical illness.

elbasti··on A psychiatrist who didn’t believe in mental illness (2013)
Szasz's "The Myth of Mental Illness" is one of those works which is completely and utterly misinterpreted simply because of the title.

I don't have the book available at the moment, but in the introduction he says something to the effect of "I don't regret writing this book, but I regret calling it what I did, because people judge it without reading it."

The gut-reaction to such a title is to think the writer is saying "depression doesn't exist" or "schizophrenia doesn't exist" or "manic depressives are lying."

This isn't what he says in the book at all. Rather, his argument is more along the lines of:

1. The word "illness" should be used to represent a cause-- and resolving the cause should cure the illness. Cancer, the flu, hyperparathyroidism--all map to causes.

2. The conditions which we call mental illness don't have a knowable cause. They are symptoms which we pattern match against.

3. Corollary: Illnesses should be hypothetically curable. There may be a cure for cancer. But there cannot be a "cure" for most "mental illnesses" because there is no shared, physical cause that underlies say, all cases of "bipolar disorder".

3. So we shouldn't call them "illnesses". We should call them something else.

Unfortunately that's about as much as I remember of his argument, but it's very different than the common accusation... And it also strikes me as accurate.

The problem with naming things is that it makes them real. I think often the hacker news crowd forgets how ill-informed most of the world is, and the degree to which people crave certainty.

When a person is told by a psychiatrists "Your 8 year has depression so we'll put her on X pill" or "You have bipolar type 2, so I recommend Y medicine", it has a certain finality.

Most people don't think "The doctor is telling me that my behavior matches some patterns. That is it. She does not know why, and we may never know why, there may not even be a reason why. So we should think about what we can do to mitigate this."

No. The we think "I've been diagnosed with a disease. (Sorry I'm being an a-hole|I won't go to your party|didn't get out of bed), I suffer from bipolar and there's no cure".

elbasti··on We Also Failed to Build a Billion Dollar Company
The logic is roughly as follows, for a consumer product with a short sales cycle:

- Iff your market is very large, and

- Iff you have well-known customer acquisition channels that are deep, with well known customer acquisition costs

- THEN you should be able to grow 20% MoM simply by spending 20% more on customer acquisition every month.

To grow 20% MoM means you're grow 9x over the course of a year...and when you think about things things this way it makes sense why a seed round of VC is ~$1MM and a series A is ~$10MM.

So why limit oneself to 20% monthly growth? Well, because it takes time to learn how to deal with the scale.

More realistically, what (should) happen is that you have SOME known channel that will grow you say, 5x, if you spend 20% more on acquisition every month. So the next five months are spent doing two things in parallel: learning how to deal with the new scale, and desperately looking for a new channel. Fail at either and you die. Succeed at both and you've maybe built a very valuable business.

elbasti··on My hiring experience as a submarine sonar operator in the Norwegian Navy
West earplugs! I know this sounds counterintuitive but bear with me. This knowledge changed my life.

So, there is a deep misconception about what it is to "hear", even among doctors; perhaps this can help you.

A quick primer on how the ear works, in an eli5 way: in order to have a large dynamic range, all inner ear cells are "tuned" to be responsive at different volumes. (The response curve of any one cell is like an S, which means it is exquisitely tuned to a very narrow volume range. Anything quieter than this and the response is 0, anything higher and it saturates). Your brain then ignores anything that is "saturated". This allows you to hear both a cricket and a person talking next to you, sounds that are about 1000 times louder/quieter.

And your ear has a _lot_ of these cells, which together cover the entire volume range, which for humans is many orders of magnitude.

Unfortunately, when hearing gets "damaged", what happens is that the cells tuned for higher volumes are permanently saturated, _so the brain ignores them_.

The worse the damage, the lower the volumes that are stuck "open".

So then imagine being in a loud restaurant. The cells that fire for the volume of conversation are "saturated" so the brain ignores them, and all sounds are perceived as being equally "loud"--the world sounds muddled.

The solution, paradoxically, is to lower the volume of _everything_ (by wearing earplugs), which puts the conversion volumes back in the area where you have dynamic range remaining.

If you don't believe me, try it out by just covering your ears with your fingers next time you are at a restaurant--the conversation should be clearer.

Sidenote: the problem with hearing tests is that they test "the lowest volume you can perceive"--assuming that if you can hear a quiet thing, you can hear a loud one. But this isn't how hearing loss manifests itself among most people; we can hear quiet, we can hear loud, we just can't tell them apart!

elbasti··on How cities can fix tourism hell
Quite the opposite. If the worry is "too much tourists" well, just raise the tax until you have the desire amount of tourists! (and a lot more money in the coffers).

What am I missing here?

As an example, the country of Bhutan has zero desire for tourists, but instead of banning them they just charge a $250USD tax per day.

elbasti··on How cities can fix tourism hell
At risk of being labeled a "neoliberal idealist," why isn't the answer here simply taxing tourists more?

Pigovian taxes have been a thing for fifty years, yet they are still seldom used. It seems like such an obvious solution to me that the fact it's not used more often (ex: towns banning airbnb vs taxing it) suggests to me that I'm missing something obvious.

elbasti··on Time to End Factory Farming?
Of course, there are environmental reasons to avoid (some, most?) fish, but I consider wild-caught fish (and all wild/hunted game) fairly neutral from an animal welfare perspective. Perhaps this is a bit naive.
elbasti··on Time to End Factory Farming?
About three months ago I decided to stop purchasing factory-farmed meat. It's been pretty difficult for a few reasons.

The biggest reason, by far, is access to information. Roughly, I would like to purchase only meat from animals that lived a "happy" life and had a relatively short death. Animals that lived outdoors, basically. But there are no credible labels or certifications for this, which means buying meat at the grocery store is pretty much impossible.

So I have to buy meat from a farmer. Recently I've been using crowdcow.com, but even there, the messaging seems to be all around _flavor_ and not _welfare_. Farmers will tell you what they feed the livestock, not how they treat them. So the best you can do is research the farm and hope their website isn't lying.

Another difficulty has been flavor and texture--pasture raised meat tastes more gamey and is much tougher than "normal" grocery store meat. I've actually found that I prefer the flavor of "humane" pork and chicken but not beef.

Lastly there's price. It's about 2/3x more expensive. This isn't that big of a problem, because we simply spend the same amount as a household and just eat less, substituting for vegetables. It does mean that I buy a lot more of the "cheaper" cuts, which require more skill in preparation. I haven't yet bought a pasture-raised ribeye--it's simply too expensive.

As for eating out, it's basically impossible. No restaurant I know where I live (Chicago) credibly serves only ethically sourced meat, as far as I know. To be honest I still eat "normal" meat when I eat out, although I have reduced my consumption somewhat. There are, unfortunately, some products of dubious ethical provenance that simply have no substitute, like fine cheeses and cured meats.

It seems to me like a huge opportunity. I would gladly pay 2/3 times for meat if I knew it was raised more ethically. In fact, that's what I think meat _should_ cost (and _all_ meat be ethically raised).

elbasti··on 'Siri I'm getting pulled over': New shortcut can automatically record the police
Swedish police fires a gun, on average, about 30 times per year, with about half of those being "for effect" as opposed to being shot with the intent to kill.

The united states doesn't track the number of times police shoot a gun, only the number of times police murder somebody. That number is over 1,000 people per year.[0]

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police_firearm_use_by_country

elbasti··on How an International Hacker Network Turned Stolen Press Releases into $100M
Insider trading isn't illegal because it's unfair to retail investors--it's illegal because it's unfair to _existing shareholders_ , which is a much more defensible position.

Imagine you're an executive with inside information that you think will make the stock go up. So you buy some stock (from an existing shareholder, obviously), and then the stock goes up. That shareholder rightly will feel stiffed.

Conversely if you sell stock and it goes down, the person you sold it to--now a shareholder to whom you have a fiduciary responsibility--is left holding the bag.

elbasti··on Introduction to Augur, an open-source, decentralized betting marketplace
What does being "predictively inaccurate" mean in the context of the stock market? I assume that any time a stock jumps or falls is a symptom of inaccuracy--investors were surprised by some previously unknown--and unpriced--event.

So the low volatility of the stock market would indicate that it is actually predictively accurate, and that it is getting more so.

Then again, volatility is kind of a silly measure, because we also care about the frequency domain. The market could be very good at predicting the very short term or the very long term or both.

I wonder what a Fourier transform of the market would show?

elbasti··on Losing Earth: The Decade We Almost Stopped Climate Change
Of course it's a thermodynamics problem. It takes less energy to split a hydrocarbon chain into CO2 + Water than it does to capture the CO2 out of the air and turn it back into solid carbon.

In essence, what we have to do is "all the energy output since the industrial revolution--do it again (plus then some), except this time instead of building civilization, capture co2 out of the air. And you must get all that energy from clean sources."

"Growing massive tropical rainforests" just means "inefficiently use solar energy (via photosynthesis) to bind carbon out of the air". We could do the same with solar panels and a carbon-binding chemical process.

But the issue is, again, the sheer magnitude of the problem.

elbasti··on The Decline and Fall of the American Empire
Well, to be technical the US does have colonies and territories--the largest of which is Puerto Rico, whose residents have no vote in US elections. There are a number of other small colonies with varying degrees of independence and representation (Guam, American Samoa, and the Virgin Islands).

And of course the US almost in it's entirety owes its size and natural resources to very real "empire building" in the 19th and 20th centuries.

Admittedly the territorial expansion of the US has slowed/stopped in the past 100-200 years, but it's not hard to understand how for someone belonging to a group that lived in a given place for many, many multiples of that duration, the current situation might feel, even today, like occupation. (see: hawaii sovereignty movement, native american reservations)

I suppose the question is "when does an empire stop being an empire?" Is it the day it stops expanding? 100 years later? When nobody remembers how things were "before"? I think it's an interesting question.

elbasti··on The Wrong Abstraction (2016)
s/his/her
elbasti··on Airlines Are Backing Volantio (YC W09), a Startup That Could Fix Overbooking
There's already a well-proven technique for price discovery: it's called a _market_.

But because there's no real market for airplane tickets--the airlines basically forbid secondary transactions--we're forced into a world of centralized planning, and by an entity that's fairly incompetent at that.

This entire thing would be solved if plane tickets could be bought and sold in some sort of marketplace. The airlines could even take a cut of every transaction!

It's baffling to me that the overbooking problem is solved at the airport, minutes before take-off.

Imagine instead a world where you could buy and sell plane tickets.

- On purchase, I could set a reserve price for which I'd be willing to sell my plane ticket, and have the price go up as the time of flight got near.

- Late to the airport--perhaps I could trade tickets with someone on a later flight that wants to leave sooner?

- I have a flexible lifestyle. Standing order for tickets to the beach|family|wherever at a low price, as long as I have 5 hour warning before flight time. Gonna miss your flight? I'll buy it.

Let the airlines take a cut of every secondary transaction and let app developers & market makers figure out the use-cases.

elbasti··on In our eyes, Google’s software sees heart attack risk
Well, not really. The tool used by the optician is a $5 dollar lantern connected to a brain that had to go through a $300,000 dollar education.
elbasti··on Why Don’t the 20 Cities on Amazon's HQ2 Shortlist Collectively Bargain?
Because cooperation only happens in the repeated version of the prisoner's dilemma.
elbasti··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (October 2017)
Kin.com | Ruby Developer | Chicago, IL | ONSITE

We're a technology / big data insurance startup fixing the $100B home insurance industry. We are looking for experienced Ruby Developers to join our team.

We are looking for a ruby developer who is:

- A Fast learner. - Comfortable in a Startup environment. Either having worked for a startup directly, or other comparable experience. - Minimum of 5 years of experience as a professional developer. - Experience with Rails - FinTech experience a plus but not required.

We offers competitive salaries including health insurance and stock options.

If you're interested ping us at dev-jobs@kin.com

elbasti··on I’m Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA
Lucky(?) for you Mexicans and Canadians are not eligible for the diversity lottery :)
elbasti··on I’m Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA
I've been told by attorneys that applying for the Green Card lottery does not come without risk--in fact it can prevent you from obtaining a non-immigrant visa.

For example, when applying for an F or J visa (student/post-doc, say) the consular officer will ask you if you have intent to emigrate. The only allowed answer is a firm "No and I have permanent connections to my home country."

If you've applied for the green card lottery in the past, the consular officer could interpret this as having intent to emigrate and then deny you on any other non dual-intent visas.

elbasti··on Manifold Garden (Escheresque Puzzle Game) Teaser
I've played development versions of the game. Hopefully I'm not spoiling too much, but there are certainly puzzles. They are super mind-bending and _different_. Definitely gave me the "now you're thinking in portals" feeling.

The other thing the puzzles reminded me of were the mechanics of Braid, where solving the puzzles requires a lot of un-learning about the way video games are supposed to work.

elbasti··on Options vs. Cash
> counter the offer with a requirement that the company offer to buy back the equity at the most recent preferred share price, if the company accepts investment at a valuation exceeding $100mm.

As a founder I wouldn't ever agree to that term as written. For starters, your options are common stock whereas investors have preferred. That just means you have to apply a discount though.

More importantly, I've seen first hand the change in team dynamics that happens when some "early" employees get a windfall. Not so much jealousy as this weird sense of complacency which permeates the entire co.

The truth is that at $100mm (heck, even at $1B valuation) the company hasn't "made" it yet. There is still tremendous risk on the table.

I think your idea is interesting, but I might add some step functions. At $100MM the co offers to buy back 1% of your shares, at $500MM up to 5% of your shares, at $1B up to 10% of your shares, and so on.

Realistically what happens is that in large, very late-stage rounds, the company gives employees the chance to sell some of their shares to the new investors at a discount (because of the common vs preferred situation).

elbasti··on US quits Paris climate pact
.
elbasti··on How an undocumented immigrant from Mexico became a star at Goldman Sachs
The mood affiliation is strong here... do you feel as strongly about the rule of law when it comes to, I don't know, medical marihuana (the smoking of which is a federal crime, since it's a schedule I drug).

The analogy is not entirely facetious: immigration is--like pot--a crime with real economic benefit, and where any negative externalities are exacerbated by knee-jerk prohibition. Take as an example wage depression due to immigration. The less that undocumented immigrants can report unfair labor practices, the more they are likely to be exploited for extra-depressive wages.

The same dynamic is present, for example, when it comes to prostitution (also a crime). If you punish the prostitute instead of the john, prostitutes are more likely to be abused, exacerbating the negative consequences of prostitution.

(Again, the analogy goes deeper: the answer to immigration is the same as prostitution or drugs or whatever: _tax the externalities_. If you really think that some honduran woman scrubbing toilets for less than minimum wage at a motel 6 is "bad for america", then you should jus _tax her_).

One other comment: you seem quite upset about the use of the phrase "undocumented immigrant" instead of "illegal." There are Really Good reasons why the first term is preferred:

1. Not all undocumented immigrants are criminals. The only criminal act is crossing the border without permission. Overstaying a visa, or coming here as a child, is emphatically not criminal. Yes, it's a deportable condition, but not a criminal one. Undocumented seems to be a better description of that situation--and unless someone has been tried, how do you know? 2. Semantics matter. Undocumented immigrants have rights, just like all people in America. To refer to a human as as being "illegal" anchors the situation in a way which makes it easier to treat them in a way where those rights are violated, and _no one cares_. For example, alleged illegal immigrants are not offered counsel in immigration courts. Flagrant violation of their sixth amendment rights. It somehow seems to be ok in the public consciousness because they are "illegal."

I'm not advocating for open borders, or for amnesty or whatever. I'm just asking you to think, critically, about the situation, and leave your mood affiliation aside.

elbasti··on Scaling Financial Reporting at Airbnb
There seems to be an accounting equivalent of Greenspun's tenth rule:

"Any sufficiently complicated financial reporting system contains an ad-hoc, informally-specified, bug-ridden implementation of double-entry accounting."

It's such a powerful yet simple way of thinking about money that anyone who builds a billing or accounting system should be intimately familiar with it.

elbasti··on Ask HN: Best books on meditation?
I very much enjoyed "Mindfulness in Plain English"
elbasti··on Confirmed: Walmart buys Jet.com for $3B in cash
That is correct.
elbasti··on Confirmed: Walmart buys Jet.com for $3B in cash
The point is that the stock was exchanged for something (referrals, marketing, etc), and that the contest was announced (ie, general solicitation). That no cash traded hands doesn't matter.

There is precedent of an almost identical enforcement action by the SEC, but my google fu is failing me.

← PreviousPage 7 of 8Next →