3,113 karma · joined October 7, 2016
This comes from limited first-hand experience and more extensive second-hand cross-generational experience. Take it as you will.
I have skin in the game on this one and in my own experience sloppy diagnostics have caused way more suffering than stigma. I was nodding along with gp’s entire point. Your confidently dismissive chastisement is what feels out of line.
I can’t comment on the claims here, but if MSFT is skirting the intent brazenly enough, the predictable regulatory reaction is no bullying. Everyone involved is well aware of that dynamic. No need to pity MSFT.
Horrifying. 2 years investigating and they’ve commented on two images?
Here’s a rule that will not serve you poorly for the indeterminate future: avoid it all costs whenever and wherever you can. It’s never steered me wrong, the discounts were never worth it.
This line alone proves all my points on the topic. That you find it _unfathomable_ that Israel has goals other than the destruction of Palestine shows how one-sided your view on the subject is. There's nothing I can write in this forum that will change such a deeply warped perception, but I'll state for the record: no serious international observer believes that claim. Ironically, that claim is usually made much more convincingly in the other direction -- that various regional factions have sought the utter destruction of Israel -- but even that is considered an extreme view (of the present) by most experts.
>I have looked at these arguments, listened to opposition to these arguments, and determined that Israel is indeed committing a genocide.
Good for you, but there is a lot more information than you alone have processed, and much more information about the current conflict is not available and will not be for some time. So by declaring your personal "determination", you are really just declaring an amateurish opinion via malapropism.
>What are you looking at that I'm not?
The frame of reference (as the other poster indicated) is post-WW2. That's when the current international order was established and also when globalization kicked into high gear. Since then, world trade integrated free market economies simply haven't started wars of conquest designed to change the ownership of territory. Yes, there are wars of intervention, regime change, etc. which have almost exclusively been precipitated against regimes that are deeply hostile to and out of sync with the international order. I'm not saying those are all just, or harmless. But the scale of destruction caused by WW1&2-style total war / wars of conquest is incomparable to the expeditionary wars described above. Bound the claim correctly and it's very simply true: free market states in the current order don't start the most devastating and costly kinds of conflict, whereas authoritarian states still do, to devastating effect. Both kinds of states do other types of bad things, but that's a non-responsive non-sequitur to this particular point about the advantages of market steering vs. centralized steering.
Buncha low activity accounts posting marketing copy style testimonials.
I’m not saying it was necessarily intentional manipulation, but it feels off for a Show HN.
Also, "current genocide in Palestine" is a provocative / activist assertion, not a correct consensus use of terminology. It would at least open to debate, for example, that the situation started with a "genocide in Israel". Clarity won't be achievable for a while on that one -- but you can certainly signal that you've pre-judged the situation or can't be objective about it, with phrasing like yours.
If TikTok is banned for geopolitical reasons, reciprocity reasons or whatever you want to call it, that doesn't change anything about free speech in America. It's not the unrestricted speech that was deemed a problem with TikTok, but rather the specific geopolitical risk (or whatever).
The wikipedia page implies the opposite of that argument.
Perhaps that’s changed since 1984, but the proposition was about current practices.
The demand / revenue side might be another obstacle, especially if the easy money environment for school loans evaporates
A dollar you own today has zero risk of not being delivered tomorrow.
You can invest that dollar one day sooner.
If there’s a general expectation of inflation, it exchanges for more today than tomorrow.
(see: Lina Khan’s management of the FTC, or “New Brandeis movement”)
A foreign entity would have no obstructions to using collected information as ruthlessly as possible, whereas even a corrupt/politically-motivated/unrestrained domestic entity would have to weigh the comparatively massive risk of being implicated or exposed.
“what are they going to do with it?”
If you have valuable information or responsibilities, that could be motivation enough for foreign agents to seek leverage. If you don’t, then it’s equally fantastic to think the CIA gives a shit about you for some reason.
That oughta hold off the brain parsers for a while.
It seems incredibly risky and foolish to try, to the point that I don’t expect them to. But this post leaves room for other attempts.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8716538
Edit: and coming up on 40 times on HN! https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
GP was just saying (given their assumptions / understanding) that it's a bad trade-off to allow people to take these particular risks. That the costs outweigh the benefits.
You, on the other hand, claim gp's (supposed) slippery slope will lead down the path of banning anything... in other words, that if we ban people from taking [these risks] it creates a slippery slope to arbitrarily banning all kinds of things with any risk involved.