HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

elefanten

3,113 karma · joined October 7, 2016

submissionscomments
elefanten··on UCLA computer grad constructs “crown jewel of cryptography”
Seems some of those cases (backdoors and classifiers) could be prevented by regulation and/or social convention (eg- don’t use programs/services obfuscated in this way).

The malware seems trickier. Maybe systems will need to require proof of unobfuscated source to run code?

elefanten··on Taxonomy of Procrastination
I can corroborate this method and perspective on why it might work. With a backstory similar to yours but earlier in the journey to transformation / success, I’ve found that locking in “wins” and completing the cycle of intent to follow-through turned out to be much more valuable and helpful than I ever imagined when I was slogging through the long era of seeking change but preemptively dismissing all visible paths.

Thanks for sharing and thanks for putting possible future obstacles / challenges on my radar!

elefanten··on The techlash that never happened
Idk that economic “attack” is good phrasing but the bundling of video content combined with tools/platforms/monetization for user generated video content absolutely had a devastating effect on legacy video media. Maybe, in your words, the initial money-burning provided a lift, but now Hollywood writers are striking for more pay and Netflix is one of they key bogeymen.
elefanten··on Ask HN: Paychecks from a failed startup?
In retrospect, you were correct my tone and rhetoric were out of line. I think siblings to my original comment (written by cogitoergofutuo and itsthecourrier) did a better job by more directly problematizing the "good faith hypothetical" itself. Mismanaging your way to missing payroll twice with no satisfactory communication about it and no promises to make it up is hard to classify as "good faith", even if bad luck was involved.

But I also concede that, in some cases, the cost of recouping might not be worth it.

elefanten··on Ask HN: Paychecks from a failed startup?
Ok, fair enough. Sorry.
elefanten··on AI vs. Hollywood: Writers battle “plagiarism machines” in union talks
Are the writers themselves not “plagiarism machines” from this perspective?
elefanten··on Ask HN: Paychecks from a failed startup?
The comment I replied to said OP should take the loss if they think the failure is “in good faith”. This implies that OP should give up what they’re owed to take pity on the failed business’ owners.

That would be giving the owners a pass on the risk that should be inherent in starting a business venture at the expense of OP’s already-delivered labor.

I stand by my tone. That kind of risk shuffling is cancer to the whole realm of private ventures and contributes to general distrust of business as a means of organizing and motivating collective human action.

elefanten··on Ask HN: Paychecks from a failed startup?
They absolutely shouldn’t “take the loss on this one”, what kind of an asinine comment is that?

OP performed labor at an agreed-upon rate. The hypothetical broke and failed founder should “take the loss”, even if it requires taking on further financial burdens.

Externalized risk is one of the most rampant and harmful moral hazards of this age.

elefanten··on Ignore Microsoft’s whines about the Activision takeover. The CMA did its job
For a living, I influence high level corporate strategy in the games industry. I’ve consulted for all the biggest companies in the space, including all the tech giants’ various gaming-related groups.

Let me be abundantly clear: the decision is utter nonsense. I’m not going into the details here, but the decision is an abysmal abomination and should be very concerning to all technology businesses, both because it signals that a relevant regulatory body is willing to make arbitrary and horribly-justified decisions with major material impacts, and because a story is emerging about the international regulatory collusion that drove this. It ABSOLUTELY IS an undemocratic power grab from politically-driven regulators that abrogates their core duties in favor of empowering themselves and their own political factions.

Additionally, it’s extra embarrassing for the UK because it signals an overly cozy relationship with Sony (which has more operations / employees in country) that reeks of regulatory capture by a local lobby. That and a willingness to jump through hoops for an ambitiously activist US FTC. Unfortunately, the net result is the UK coming off as a complete joke. I’m strongly advising clients to avoid expanding operations in the country and to genuinely consider abandoning the market.

Take it or leave it, but I write this all as someone who had otherwise been strongly arguing AGAINST the deal, because I think it’s bad for the games industry. But this kind of sloppy and arbitrary behavior from regulators is even worse, for all gaming and tech businesses… and, to some degree, for all business in general.

Edit- I can’t elaborate on my reasoning here, but the full picture is out there for anyone interested in looking into it. This is a long and thorough rundown of the situation that serves as a good starting point: https://naavik.co/digest/microsoft-activision-blizzard-timel...

elefanten··on Whistleblowers are the conscience of society, yet suffer gravely
The only difference I see between your perspective and gp’s is timescale of change. Gp says current conditions are product of current human nature and the bounds can shift slowly. You’re more optimistic that the change can come fast. As you point out, we’ve changed a lot in the past few thousand — a small fraction of the species history. But gp is also sound in being skeptical of expecting radical change in a single-digit number of human lifespans. So for those of us with an opportunity to respond to this thread, for better or for worse, being able to engage with “corporations” and other extant shapes of power structures may be adaptive and strategic.
elefanten··on CATL has announced a new “condensed” battery with 500 Wh/kg
A lot of other comments are saying 2x as dense (that current norms are around 250Wh/kg for mass produced and widely available product)… can you square that with your 3x claim? Am I missing something?
elefanten··on In China, Germany’s foreign minister does not hold back–and is still welcomed
If ethics are the driver, how does France feel about China’s neocolonial expansionism, its geo-ethnic concentration camps and its insistence on terminally annexing a peaceful independent democracy off its shores? And if we’re talking about hypocrisy and reliability, what about China’s hypocrisy and naked lies in diplomacy (decades of promises to reform with zero intent to follow through) and its opportunistic all-spectrum IP theft-by-coercion?

How does France feel empowering and collaborating with a functionally-totalitarian centralized government operating on Han ethnonationalism which sees the existence of large democracies as a threat to its internal affairs (all Xi Jinping Socialist Thought For International Relations global PR campaigns notwithstanding)?

I’d think that even if commitment to those principles turn out to be French agitprop, at least France remembers how it goes to let that kind of governance complex rise to (near-)hegemonic power.

elefanten··on In China, Germany’s foreign minister does not hold back–and is still welcomed
Do you think this bothers Germans enough to want to change it? Or is all global, humanity-scale ambition gone (for generations, let’s say)?
elefanten··on The man who didn’t invent Flamin’ Hot Cheetos (2021)
It seems you didn't read the article. There was no defunct brand that Montanez revitalized. He was involved in some marketing efforts and may have played a role in a derivative "Flaming" line product and some other Latino-targeted flavors.

But the confirmed lies that he chose to spread, with the bumbling help of his mentor (who clearly has personal commitments to the community the lies are most meant to appeal to), are beyond excusable.

There's nothing to hand-wave here. It's the nakedly cynical, anti-social effort of an egotistical con man. It should be shamed off the air, the movie should be shamed out of production and their names should live on in infamy as pathetic liars. Richard Montanez and Al Cary, the pathetic liars who think you're all chumps.

To do anything else is to contribute to the degradation of vital social fabric.

elefanten··on Lessons from America’s astonishing economic record
You’re mixing different levels of abstraction and equivocating across them.

Sure, no human could produce anything modern on their own, without knowledge, training, support, materials, products, labor, etc. that comes from others. A child raised by wolves will never launch a new line of tennis shoes.

At the same time, no complex effort comes to be without someone’s motivation and effort to take the risk, coordinate the activity and see it through. It doesn’t have to be one primary person to do so, but it certainly can be. It is not difficult to look at the history of a given project and conclude who most acutely put it into motion. The choice to incentivize this acute influence has trade-offs, but many different societies across history have tried many variations of what / where to incentivize. Abstracted, that’s one of the main points being discussed here.

That doesn’t mean all stories about who started / created / produced something are told accurately. But to throw your hands up and say “everything comes from everyone” is completely useless when designing society with the goal of solving problems, providing for its members and improving the human condition.

elefanten··on EVE Online player uses obscure rule to pull off biggest heist in game history
>EVE would have been a neat place for smart contracts and programmatic corporate structures and so on

I don’t know if you’ll laugh or cry to hear this… last month, CCP accepted an investment led by a16z to develop a blockchain-enabled game.

In the press release, they say: “With key game systems developed on-chain, this new project will also leverage smart-contract blockchain technology, focusing on persistence, composability and truly open third-party development to create a new relationship between virtual worlds and players.“

[1] https://www.ccpgames.com/news/2023/ccp-games-has-secured-usd...

elefanten··on The first game ‘Easter eggs’ were an act of corporate rebellion
Thanks for sharing, fun anecdote.

Works both ways. There are publishing functions and development functions.

A "studio" does development. It can be independent or owned by a bigger company.

A "publisher" focuses on handling distribution / sales & marketing functions. It can publish games from studios it owns ("first party") or from external studios it has business contracts with ("third party").

There are companies that do various mixes of these functions, but the biggest tend to do them all.

elefanten··on One of the world’s largest investment banks: ‘Greedflation’ has gone too far
I favor a market-based economy and I broadly favor incentivizing and rewarding effort and performance.

But you have to consider that no economy exists divorced from politics. So, in the same vein, if too many people are having too rough of a time… your political messaging will get undercut with populist appeals in the political messaging economy.

So, there’s a balance of concerns to be struck.

elefanten··on To supercharge learning, look to play
I’m only half-joking (maybe barely joking) when I say your comment made me think:

“The movement that wants to pause AI development should just tell school boards and DEI activists that AI will allow every child to learn at their own pace. Probably no faster way to put a total ban in motion than an appeal to toxic ‘anti-racism’ activism.”

elefanten··on A Case Study on the Uber Alumni Network
Irrelevant to what?

One could argue what the thesis or purpose of this piece might be, but the call to action seems to be this part:

“If you’re interested in supporting, joining, or investing in a company founded by Uber alumni or you’d just like to learn more, full details are below”

If you want to support, join or invest in someone on the basis of them being an Uber alumnus, you may want to know how much value was created by other alumni. The more sustainable (and, ideally, appreciating) that value is, the more likely you are to actually get to enjoy it.

elefanten··on Dang is going to have 65,535 karma points soon
I find consistently higher quality commentary and discussion here than any other open access, broad topic forum out there. Sure, it’s not perfect but nothing is.

Can you name any alternatives that you’ve enjoyed more? Genuinely curious.

elefanten··on Tell HN: iOS lets carriers add WiFi networks that you can’t stop from joining
How gracious. In exchange, I invite all of the 3GPP stakeholders to respect people's technological autonomy and refrain from enabling solutions that force crap down their throats.
elefanten··on Experts warn yearly checkups carry risks and do not reduce mortality
The accident sounds like an awful experience and really bad luck.

Regarding the enzymes, I'd caution against feeling too certain in "doing your own research" for medical diagnoses. I'm definitely NOT saying doctors are always right (or conscientious, or competent). But it's hard to just go off published papers because even if you can parse what they're saying and even if you're exhaustive in searching all papers (two big ifs), there is relevant / accepted / important medical knowledge NOT really captured in papers.

You'd need niche textbooks, trade reports/publications and (in some cases) a network of experienced practitioners to expose yourself to all the possible information you'd need to make the right call in certain cases. And, related to your point, even really GOOD doctors who've formally studied ALL the right sources, keep up to date on new developments and have long experience can't reliably make the right call on the first try.

Certainly educate yourself and do research on your specific situation if you're inclined, but I'd be extra wary because you don't know what information is invisible to you. Find a doc who's willing to talk about their reasoning -- there certainly is an old tendency in the profession to be authoritatively prescriptive without sharing the logic (unfortunately, if understandably).

elefanten··on Do large language models need sensory grounding for meaning and understanding?
I haven't even given it a deep read, so I unfortunately can't help shed any light. From my quick read, it didn't seem to me that laying out a digestible or rigorous philosophical perspective was really the point here. It seemed more directly biology inspired than philosophy.

I also don't seek to valorize Lecun. But he was a very early figure working on these technologies and from the beginning there was a neuroscience-inspired impetus to machine learning.

My point was sort of the opposite: that assuming Lecun doesn't clear the bar of having "exposure to the prior work on philosophy of mind and philosophy of language" seems like a weak bet.

edit: For clarity, I'm making the assumption that lifelong AI researchers who put time into learning from neuroscience... would also gravitate towards and seek to learn from the nearest relevant branches of philosophy.

elefanten··on Nvidia Unveils CuLitho: A “Breakthrough in Computational Lithography”
Come on, this is a weird overreaction. The other poster's being a bit intense, but you opened the interaction by calling a majority of their comment completely false. Ironically, you made some weak sweeping claims in the process; namely that 'th' is never latinized 'z' and that 'th' is always pronounced 't' in practice.

Look up and down the topic, plenty of examples of people sharing contradictory experiences on these questions and referencing the variety of types of Spanish (anywhere from a dozen to dozens, depending how you slice it).

And the comment, even if taken literally with no rhetorical effect intended, was that "most" of the Spanish-speaking internet was garbage. I'd say most of ANY language internet is pretty garbage. You inflated that way out of context then clutched your pearls

elefanten··on Do large language models need sensory grounding for meaning and understanding?
Appreciate your take, not arguing with it.

But I’d imagine Lecun has more than passing familiarity with those. This deck was put out with the Philosophy dept and he had a panel debate with NYU profs across depts (inc phil) recently on this topic.

I suspect this is all pushing the top Phil Lang and Phil Mind to their limits too. Besides, if those subjects were anywhere near resolved (or even… decently understood), they probably wouldn’t be in the Phil dept any more.

elefanten··on Things I’ve Learned from Charlie Munger about Moats (2015)
There are a lot of good points contained in this post, if a bit basic. The Munger quotes are mostly fun and reasonably illustrative.

But the poor organization and the repetition were very frustrating. The lede is buried in about half of the numbered points, obscured by increasingly repetitive connective tissue.

It started out as an interesting read and ended up quite annoying.

elefanten··on Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008
Agree on Schiff.

Got any names or search terms for the 0 interest point? What political economy does it work with?

elefanten··on You can't tell people anything (2004)
Agree with sibling comments asking for search terms.

What body of work / what field are you talking about?

elefanten··on How Not to Tell the History of Science
I like your point, but most of it does not seem in tension with gp. Given that, your opening line was pretty hostile and dismissive.

Defining “science” precisely and narrowly is not a dismissal of other forms of knowledge.

But pretending that centuries-old cultural knowledge conforms to a well-defined modern method doesn’t achieve much, other than lending further credibility to the method.

← PreviousPage 5 of 28Next →