HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

elsjaako

894 karma · joined August 26, 2014

submissionscomments
elsjaako··on All AI Videos Are Harmful (2025)
I didn't mean to say all hiphop is like what I mention. I'm 100% sure that hiphop also does sampling in really interesting ways, I'm just not as familiar with the examples. This was not not meant as a diss, and I wasn't saying all hiphop does things the same way. I was just mentioning examples that I'm personally familiar with of "Sampling Slop", "Different kind of creativity", and "Using Sampling as a completely new instrument".

For the middle category, I meant things like Gangsta's Paradise. I really like the song, I think Coolio really adds something. But you can hear much more of "Pasttime Paradise" in there than you can hear "More Spell On You" in Daft Punk's "One More time"

I mention Daft Punk because it's really accessible: there are videos on youtube that can show a layperson like me exactly how they chopped up the samples.

elsjaako··on All AI Videos Are Harmful (2025)
I agree. My problem with AI produced media is that a lot of the things I've seen are really bad. If someone uses AI, but has taste and takes the time to curate and fix the output, then the output can be fine.

Just like with digital effects in movies, plastic surgery, and makeup - if it's done well, there's a good chance I didn't even notice it. If it's clearly noticeable, it's often because it's not done well.

I think you can compare to another "uncreative" way of making music: sampling. The way the Timelords do it in "Doctorin' the Tardis" is pretty terrible (in their case on purpose, I believe). There are plenty of hip hop examples where I think musically not much is added to the music, but the lyrics and maybe the act do add a lot. And then there are bands like Daft Punk that will chop up and recontextualize the samples to the point that it's clearly a completely new thing.

elsjaako··on Round and Round
By the same logic that the man goes around the squirrel, I go all around the world every day.
elsjaako··on Why are 38 percent of Stanford students saying they're disabled?
Why would snorting be so much worse than just swallowing the pill? The goal is to get the chemicals in the blood. Snorting apparently works quicker, giving you a stronger but shorter lasting effect. But the difference is not night and day.

A lot of people do recreational drugs while at college and go on just fine. George W. Bush, for example, is alleged to have taken cocaine.

elsjaako··on Thoughts on Go vs. Rust vs. Zig
The first two is the same article, but they point out that certain structures can be very hard to write in rust, with linked lists being a famous example. The point stands, but I would say the tradeoff is worth it (the author also mentions at the end that they still think rust is great).

The third link is absolutely nuts. Why would you want to initialize a struct like that in Rust? It's like saying a functional programming language is hard because you can't do goto. The author sets themselves a challenge to do something that absolutely goes against how rust works, and then complains how hard it is.

If you want to do it to interface with non-rust code, writing a C-style string to some memory is easier.

elsjaako··on Hyperoptic: IPv6 and Out-of-Order Packets
> My ISP provides me with upto 8 ipv4 addresses if I want them.

It's great that your ISP does that. Mine doesn't, maybe it would for an extra charge if I got some kind of business account. Which makes sense, as the IPv4 addresses your ISP own are a valuable resource.

At the hacker space I'm part of we need to use a reverse proxy to run all our services on a single IPv4 address we get from our ISP.

> I have to put firewall rules in anyway (as I don't want a random device on the internet to be able to talk to my bathroom speaker), so what's the difference?

If, for example, two friends want to play a FPS game with each other they could connect directly. They still need to "punch" out to get the firewall open, but you lose the step where you have to guess at which port the message may end up. Right now I hear that with some ISP's you don't even get a public IP on your router, so even NAT hole punching doesn't work.

Not a lot of games currently provide the option to connect directly, but that's because it often doesn't work well behind NAT on IPv4 networks.

> I get an RTP stream pushed from a source

This sounds like a pretty niche application, but sure. I don't have the immediate best Ipv6 solution for you. Maybe you could switch which device has the RTP-receive IPv6 address (one device can have multiple IPs), you could do NAT on IPv6 for this application.

Right now you're using the NAT as a kind of forwarder to send the data to different hosts, so if you have a router you can run software on you could just have it forward to both devices on the local network.

> I also have the advantage of being able to steer outgoing traffic via either my DSL or via my 4g depending on various rules

Aren't these features of your router, not of your IP stack?

> In any case I still have to maintain an ipv4 network as some services still won't work on ipv6 only subnets.

You're right, it doesn't always make sense for an individual to switch. That's why we're still stuck on old technology.

But prices for IPv4 addresses are going up. There are already VPS's that charge less if you don't need IPv4. Availability of IPv6 for consumers is going up; In India it's near 80%. At some point, some kind of service in India is going to not bother to get IPv4.

elsjaako··on µcad: New open source programming language that can generate 2D sketches and 3D
From my quick tests, it seems to rebuild the OpenSCAD objects using FreeCAD part workbench primitives.

But I also quite quickly found examples that don't work. I don't know if that's the import not being very good, me finding weird examples, needing to install more libraries, or PEBKAC.

elsjaako··on Hyperoptic: IPv6 and Out-of-Order Packets
I would argue that having to pay more than $20 for an address, having to do weird NAT hole punching to get a direct connection between two machines, and having an internet that can easily be completely scanned by hackers are all things that are not "working".

Working for you != working for everyone

Basically functioning != Working as well as it could

There are more advantages to IPv6. We don't see all of the advantages because we can't use them, because we are still largely stuck in an IPv4 world. This is a problem caused by not enabling IPv6.

elsjaako··on µcad: New open source programming language that can generate 2D sketches and 3D
If you're talking about CAD in general I can see your point.

For FreeCAD specifically, there looks to be an OpenSCAD import process directly. I don't have experience with how it works, but that may be better than going through STL

elsjaako··on Tesla Robotaxi had 3 more crashes, now 7 total
From the article:

>I expect a few because humans generally have a crash, whether they are at fault or not, every 700,000 miles. Tesla has 7 in probably ~300,000 miles, which should be worrying to anyone, whether the Robotaxis were responsible or not.

elsjaako··on Israeli-founded app preloaded on Samsung phones is attracting controversy
Yes, but to make it worthwhile you need a lot of data and the price scales linearly.

Let's say my phone gets $10 cheaper because of all this crap ware. If you have the aggregate of 1000 people that cost someone $10000. Is that really worth it? Is 100000 people worth $1000000? Is there some point at which the aggregate data becomes so valuable it overtakes the per-user cost?

That's what I mean - the marginal value of one person needs to be quite big for this whole thing to make sense.

elsjaako··on Tesla Robotaxi had 3 more crashes, now 7 total
For me FSD means they are legally allowed to operate it on a public road with no supervising driver.

Obviously no crashes ever isn't expected. Even roller coasters have accidents sometimes.

Tesla will get there I'm sure. But I know at least two people that are in Musks influence sphere that believe it to already be the case.

elsjaako··on Tesla Robotaxi had 3 more crashes, now 7 total
I had a discussion with a colleague today. He claimed Tesla had Full Self Driving, and had for years, and they were the first. That's the message some folks believe.

I look forward to telling him about this.

elsjaako··on Blender 5.0
I love QGIS, but ArcGIS is still the major industry player.
elsjaako··on Israeli-founded app preloaded on Samsung phones is attracting controversy
I've heard this theory before, but is an individual data point really worth enough to make this argument?
elsjaako··on How to Get a North Korea / Antarctica VPS
There are effective North Korean hacking teams. They seem to operate from China, but one assumes that there are ways to train North Koreans in this stuff before sending them abroad to do the work.

I will agree that for most people in North Korea access to the outside internet is limited, but your claim that "All computer access is gated" is a stronger one, that I haven't seem evidence for.

Also, we know that Red Star OS exists, but I haven't seen any information about it's actual use. I can imagine it's used in certain sectors (e.g. education or certain ministries), but if you have information about it's usage I'd be interested to see that.

My gut feeling is that there is probably still a lot of cracked windows PCs also used in industry, but I have no evidence for that either. This is just based on how in my experience China works, and the fact that there is some business exchange between North Korea and China.

elsjaako··on What Happened to Piracy? Copyright Enforcement Fades as AI Giants Rise
I couldn't quickly find a definition of "commercial piracy", so I will assume it doesn't have a specific technical meaning.

Facebook is a commercial company, so if you're working for Facebook doing piracy, that would be commercial piracy.

If I go by piracy as "the unauthorized use of another's production, invention, or conception especially in infringement of a copyright", and if Facebook is infringing on copyright in using these books (which the article alleges), then it follows that Facebook is engaging in piracy.

So it looks like Facebook is partaking in piracy of a commercial flavor.

I don't know why distributing bootlegs to people on the street would be worse than distributing PDFs within a company, but let's say it it. We are talking about 100s of cases vs millions. Is distributing on the street really 10000 times worse?

It would have to be even more than that. Because millions of copyright infringement within a company apparently has no punishment, but 100's on the street has prison. So, if you go by the punishment, 100's on the street is way worse.

elsjaako··on What Happened to Piracy? Copyright Enforcement Fades as AI Giants Rise
It can be both, there have been people criminally prosecuted for copyright infringement.

I will admit that it's not something that I follow daily, so I had to look for an example. But it wasn't hard to find one.

https://www.ca4.uscourts.gov/Opinions/Published/055157.P.pdf

elsjaako··on Geoutil.com – Measure distances, areas, and convert geo data in the browser
The worst distances you can expect are around 1.5m (comparing australia in 2001 when gps accuracy was improved to now). But that number can be hard to figure out if you don't have a tool that allows you to set the time of conversion :)
elsjaako··on YouTube is taking down videos on performing nonstandard Windows 11 installs
The videos being taken down here are about how to avoid: Windows requiring a Microsoft account to install, and Windows only being installable on compatable hardware.

AFAIK an apple account isn't strictly required, but a lot of MacOS won't be functional without one.

How is a Macbook better than Windows in these senses?

elsjaako··on Geoutil.com – Measure distances, areas, and convert geo data in the browser
Some coordinate conversions need a date (as the plates shift over time). Are you planning to add that?
elsjaako··on Zero ASIC releases Wildebeest, the highest performance FPGA synthesis tool
I think we're reading the same article differently.

They start out by describing all the work that has been done by other people to make open source synthesis possible.

Then they say they've added some well known, industry standard optimizations to the existing open source tools. In addition, they made use of the abc tool in a way that maybe wasn't being done much before.

My view is that if you think someone taking your software, changing some parts, and releasing it under a different name (while still giving you credit in an about section) leaves a bad taste in your mouth, don't release your software with a permissive license. You are explicitly giving permission for someone to do this.

I don't like companies doing this, so I tend to release under GPL. Even then, I'm happy for someone to rebrand and sell it, as long as the source is still shared. I gave them permission to do that.

Don't give someone permission to do something, and then say it's in bad taste when they do that thing.

elsjaako··on Zero ASIC releases Wildebeest, the highest performance FPGA synthesis tool
When you release something as open source, a third party grabbing it and releasing it is explicitly something that can be done.

I can't speak for them, so I'm not sure, but I feel like new FPGA suppliers coming around having open source tooling being the default is something that the authors of Yosys would like.

Zero ASIC even credited the original authors in the press release and released the source code, which they didn't need to do. If you release your code under a permissive license, like Yosys did, a company taking it and selling a closed source version of it is something you are allowing. If that's not something you want, choose a different license.

elsjaako··on After 50 years, The Magic Circle finally inducts Penn and Teller
It's a bit of a fossilized error. Like "this begs the question of...", "head over heels", "sleeping like a baby", and "Have your cake and eat it too" everyone should understand what it means, even if it doesn't stand up to technical analysis.
elsjaako··on Folks, we have the best π
I think lcantuf has looked at the first two and decided that the answer is too complex for a post like this. He linked to the article.

The third one we can reason about: For all cases where x and y aren't 0, |x|^n goes to 1 as n goes to 0, so (|x|^n + |y|^n) goes to 2 , and 1/n goes to infinity, so lin n->0 (|x|^n + |y|^n)^(1/n) goes to infinity. If x and y are 0 it's 0, if x xor y are 0 it's 1.

To phrase this in a mathematically imprecise way, if all distances are either 0, 1, or infinite the concept of distance no longer represents how close things are together.

elsjaako··on Unfortunately, the ICEBlock app is activism theater
Sure, but there's also a minimum quality required before the product is safe to use.

If I make gas masks, they can be useful even if they aren't resistant to every single chemical out there. But if they are really bad, they may encourage users to take risks without providing adequate protection.

From what I've seen, taking action against ICE can be a risky activity and many people will want to protect their privacy while doing it. This app promises to protect privacy. However, if the Joshua (author of the app) fails to protect privacy (e.g. hosts on an insecure server that someone from ICE can get into, or becomes subject to a warrant with gag order) the app may do harm.

I'm not saying the app is harmful right now, but there are definitely signs that it could become that. If Micah spots issues in that area, and the Joshua fails to respond to criticism, I think it's completely right for Micah to publish their concerns.

Obviously in a polite, constructive way and while specifically pointing out that they believe the app author means no harm. The way I read Micah's article it seems fine.

elsjaako··on Unfortunately, the ICEBlock app is activism theater
The app makes specific promises ("the app ensures user privacy by storing no personal data, making it impossible to trace reports back to individual users") while the Hope talk shows that the writer of the app is not familiar with very common techniques that are required to keep these promises. Warranty canaries, reverse engineering, and security though obscurity are all concepts that anyone making legally sensitive secure software should be familiar with.

To make an analogy, if someone wants to start a taxi service and you say they're not qualified because they don't know about different types of tires and how to change the front lights, that would be gatekeeping. If they don't know you should sometimes change tires and turn the lights on when it's dark you should have doubts about their ability to safely run a taxi service.

You could argue that he doesn't need open source and a warranty canary, but from what Micah says, it sounds like the app author doesn't have the required knowledge to evaluate the option.

elsjaako··on Why are anime catgirls blocking my access to the Linux kernel?
There's a lot of people that really don't like AI, and simply don't want their data used for it.
elsjaako··on Open Source Maintenance Fee
I completely agree! My comment about bugs was only in response to the parent poster mentioning that they would want a company to still report bugs that affect a lot of users.
elsjaako··on Open Source Maintenance Fee
I think this is one of those issues that only exists in theory, not in practice.

If a company reports a bug in a clear and helpful way, it's probably going to get looked at anyway.

Also, if a company cares enough about Wix to bother finding and documenting a bug, they should be willing to pay $60 for the software.

So this is only a problem in the case where a company finds a bug, decides to report it, refuses to pay a minimal fee, and the maintainers are strict enough with themselves to ignore it because of the source. That feels unlikely to me.

← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →