HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

emacdona

843 karma · joined December 31, 2007

My name is Ed MacDonald.

I own the domain that is the same as my firstname and lastname concatenated... in the .net TLD.

If you want to contact me, the username within that domain that I have an email address attached to is _the_ administrator account in any *nix distribution I've ever used.

If you need validation before sending an email, know that the sha256 sum of the email described above, when typed in all lowercase, is:

49713c8a4827c2c4e4c54fb97eea301ac5e76efe86c211a4fa8b805b8cdaa35d

Yes. I know. Your LLM can trivially determine my email address. Still, maybe that's just enough to hold off the spammers for a little bit longer...

submissionscomments
emacdona··on Enhancements to the Kagi Search Experience
> How would you change the wording to make this clearer in a way that does not strike you as dishonest?

"Includes enough searches for X% of current Kagi users"

emacdona··on We glued together content moderation to stop soccer pirates
Thanks for pointing that out -- I guess I should have realized that (maybe I did at one point). At the very least, then, I wish the UCI would make it EASY to figure out what services I needed to subscribe to in my country to watch which races. Just a page on their website with a big table would be great.

Figuring out that I need to subscribe to GCN+, Peacock, and Flobikes in the US was no small feat (and it changes from year to year!).

emacdona··on We glued together content moderation to stop soccer pirates
BTW, that sums up my ask for sports leagues/governing bodies:

Let me pay ONE company ONE price and get ALL the content.

Pick the price! I don't care. If I like the sport enough, I'll pay it. If I don't, then I'll find another sport.

Just don't make me spend hours wading through online articles trying to answer questions like "How many streaming subscriptions do I need in the US to watch all UCI events?" (I did this, it was painful).

emacdona··on We glued together content moderation to stop soccer pirates
I was actually considering becoming a WRC fan... especially after I was watching some YouTube highlights and saw that Cyril Abiteboul is a team principal! Where do I subscribe? And... you promise that it's similar to F1 -- where I pay one company one price and get all the content?? :-)
emacdona··on We glued together content moderation to stop soccer pirates
Infuriating. I was pissed because I couldn't easily watch "all games in a given league". You only want to watch your team, and you STILL have to pay for four services to get "most" of the games.
emacdona··on We glued together content moderation to stop soccer pirates
That's fair. My main objection is labeling _everyone_ as "pirates". Technically, yes, they are pirating the steam.

But some of those people are also PAYING to watch plenty of games in whatever sport they are "pirating" streams for. Calling these people "pirates" fails to acknowledge that they are also "paying customers" who are frustrated with how complicated it has become to pay for the product they want to watch.

emacdona··on We glued together content moderation to stop soccer pirates
Ah, sorry then :-(

F1 is great in the US. I can't speak to NFL -- I don't watch it. However, I suspect it may be a better deal in Europe (where they are trying to get new fans) than in the US (where it's one of, if not "the", most popular sports).

This is similar to GCN+ for cycling. In the US, it doesn't get you much -- but from what I understand, in some (most?) European countries, GCN+ gets you most (if not all) UCI cycling evnets.

emacdona··on We glued together content moderation to stop soccer pirates
Sigh... f*ck sports leagues/governing bodies. The reason some honest people pirate streams for sporting events is because they make it so annoying to pay for them. Some examples...

I live in the US.

I briefly took an interest in the EPL. If I wanted to watch all EPL games (or have the option of watching any particular EPL game), I'd have to subscribe to Peacock _and_ Fubo -- and I'm still not sure that gets me all games.

I briefly took an interest in the NHL (this was years ago, granted -- things may have changed). If I would have subscribed to their service, the ONLY team whose home games I couldn't watch would have been the TEAM OF THE CITY I LIVE IN (i.e.: "my" team).

My two favorite sports, though, are Cycling and F1.

I LOVE cycling. To watch every UCI race, I'd have to subscribe to GCN+ (they have the Giro), Peacock (they have the Tour de France and La Vuelta), and Flobikes (they have most of the Classics races).

THE ONLY sports governing body that has figured this out (for sports I like, anyway), is F1. I pay F1.com $80 a year and get MORE content than I would if I watched the races on ESPN. I can see EVERY RACE, EVERY QUALIFYING, EVERY PRACTICE. I can even choose WHOSE car I want to see the first person view from.

If you want to "stop pirates", make it easy for them to give you money and watch their favorite sport.

emacdona··on We achieved a 6-fold increase in Podman startup speed
Hmmm... maybe this thread will have an answer to the question that has been on my mind for a while. Sometime in the next 5-7 years, I think I'm going to be in the market for a new car. Are there any manufacturers out there whose niche is "dumb cars"? If so, they can have my money.
emacdona··on The FBI now recommends using an ad blocker when searching the web
Yeah, I should have mentioned that Kagi isn't free. I was _thrilled_ to pay for it, though base on just two things:

1. I was all but certain it couldn't provide worse search results than Google (that bar is pretty low now).

2. I knew it would let me exclude websites from search results.

The fact that it provides pretty decent search results and a nice user experience were just icing on the cake.

emacdona··on The FBI now recommends using an ad blocker when searching the web
> If you like a site to go back to it repeatedly don't you think it would be fair to "pay the fee" of seeing the ads, thus supporting that site...

I struggle with this. Of course I want the producers of content that I like to make money. And it seems obvious to me that if I'm one of the people consuming (and liking) that content... some of that money I want them to make should come from me.

But the pipeline that the "modern web" provides to complete that transaction is openly hostile towards me. It makes content creators that I want to support participants in a giant machine designed to build a dossier on me (and every other user of the "modern web"). It also encourages VERY LARGE numbers of content creators I do not want to support -- those whose primary goal is to be participant in that machine; who only produce content because the machine requires it.

I would argue that this machine has never built this dossier with my "informed" consent (but lawyers could make the case that it has). But now, the machine builds it without even bothering to get my "uninformed" consent. For example: Facebook is known to build profiles on people that don't have Facebook accounts -- ie: people that could never have agreed to their TOS.

The top priority of this giant machine is putting ads in front of my face. Helping me discover content that I want to consume is only a secondary priority.

And there is a GOOD reason for why this machine evolved: people don't want to pay money _directly_ to content creators, so a way evolved for them to receive compensation _indirectly_. So yes, this is -- at least in part -- my (our) fault.

But I really feel like things have shifted to the point where the large majority of compensation that content creators receive is a function of their value to that machine... not a function of the value they create for the people who consume their content.

This is all a very long way of saying: I don't believe the value of a content creator _to me_ should be calculated based on their value _to this machine_.

I don't know what the solution is. Find a way to accurately assess the value _to me_, not _to the machine_ -- and then provide a way for me to pay the content creator directly. If I like the content enough -- and IF I'm not shown ads or tracked once I'm a paying customer -- I will pay. This is how newspapers worked for... centuries? (Save that newspapers did show ads, though they did not track you).

The problem is... I think that being part of the machine is more lucrative than selling content directly to consumers. And the hostility of this machine towards me has turned this into a fight. Of course I'm going to fight back.

> ...however annoying they are?

This is where you start to lose me. I don't think "annoying" captures just how "hostile" this machine has become.

I'm old enough to remember switching from Yahoo Search to Google Search -- NOT because the results were better, but because Google's ads were less intrusive. I never blocked those ads. I even clicked a few...

emacdona··on The FBI now recommends using an ad blocker when searching the web
Heh, you got me. A password manager is the ONE plugin I have installed in my profile that I use to access my banks.

Simply put, I trust the password manager. Recently, however, I have considered uninstalling that plugin and using only the desktop version of the password manager -- and then copy/pasting username/pw from the password manager to websites.

One reason I don't do that, though... is because having the password manager as a browser plugin guarantees (?) that the password it presents to me is for the site I am visiting. If I end up on a webiste with an IDN that was chosen very carefully to look like my bank's domain, my password manager plugin won't present me with a password -- which will trigger my paranoia.

If you can't tell, I wrestle with this decision pretty regularly...

emacdona··on The FBI now recommends using an ad blocker when searching the web
I don't think so (I looked). Best I could find was some articles online claiming you can add "-unwantedChannel '...'" to your YouTube search to exclude individual channels. I didn't even test it because it would be WAY to cumbersome. Maybe that's all Channel Blocker does under the covers -- add a bunch of those switches to my search.

What frustrates me the most is that this is one place where mine and Google's interests actually align! Let me help train them to not show me crap I don't want to see... then I'll use their products (YouTube and Search) more and give them more opportunities to show me ads! (Well, theoretically -- I block as many ads as I can right now).

That was one of the big reasons I looked for an alternative to Google search. IIRC, you used to be able to exclude results from Google search. In order to do so, you HAD TO LOGIN TO GOOGLE (another huge win for Google!). Now I use Kagi -- primarily because they allow me to exclude sites from their search results.

emacdona··on The FBI now recommends using an ad blocker when searching the web
That's a good question. I don't know -- I never considered private browsing. If I close a private browsing session, are all traces (ie: cookies, history, etc.) of it erased? If so, I don't think that's what I want. I'm okay with my bank (and websites I trust) setting cookies, for example.
emacdona··on The FBI now recommends using an ad blocker when searching the web
For anyone curious as to how I solve the problem right now, I just have two separate Firefox profiles. One has a ton of plugins; I use it to browse the web. The other has no plugins; I use it to visit my bank's website.
emacdona··on The FBI now recommends using an ad blocker when searching the web
Thanks for the tips. I will check out the filter lists you mention.

You might be wrong about PopUpOFF, though. I started using it as a solution to websites that pop-up an overlay asking me to subscribe to their newsletter when I mouse-out of the window. It is fantastic at putting an end to that.

emacdona··on The FBI now recommends using an ad blocker when searching the web
I recommend using an ad-blocker while visiting that site :-/

Lately, I find myself using more and more plugins to make the "modern web" tolerable. To list a few:

Channel Blocker (lets me block channels from search results on Youtube); uBlock Origin; Disconnect; F.B Purity; Consent-O-Matic (auto fill cookie consent forms); Kagi Search; PopUpOFF; Facebook Container; Privacy Badger; ClearURLs; Return YouTube Dislike

Basically, if I visit a website and don't like the experience, I either never go back (Kagi lets me exclude it from search results) or find a plugin to make it tolerable.

What I really want now is the ability to exclude entire websites from any permissions I grant to plugins. I feel like in the last year, I've read a couple stories about companies buying successful plugins and then using them to track you or show ads or whatever. I'm worried this will be the next stage in the battle for our attention -- best case: companies will buy popular plugins to track us and show us intrusive ads; worst case: nefarious actors will buy them to scrape information we think is private and collect it.

IE: I just want to be able to say "Hey, Firefox... those permissions that I granted to plugins x, y, and z? They don't apply to www.myfavoritebank.example.com"

Is there a browser that has that feature yet? I spent a few hours trying to figure out if Firefox did. It did not appear to.

edit: Added semicolons to separate plugins in list b/c HN stripped the newlines from my comment.

emacdona··on Ask HN: In iOS, why can't I allow access to mic and camera “Only when using”?
Thanks for the info. I'll have to try to run some experiments with other devices in my house that have microphones. I swear, there are some things that I mention casually in conversation with my wife... that end up in my Twitter or Facebook feeds. I thought my phone was the common denominator, but I must be wrong.
emacdona··on Ask HN: In iOS, why can't I allow access to mic and camera “Only when using”?
I mean, it's not like the apps advertise what they are doing somewhere easy for me to see. Yes, I'm sure that somewhere in their ToS they indicate that they may "collect data".

Are you certain you are not using such apps? If so, please tell me how I can easily determine which apps that request access to my microphone are not selling my data :-)

emacdona··on MacBook Pro featuring M2 Pro and M2 Max
DisplayLink is a daily source of frustration for me. If I disconnect my DisplayLink hub, and then plug it back in... I have to open and close my 13" M1 MacBook Pro a few times; restart the DisplayLink software; and sometimes reboot my computer before it will work again. For some reason, Zoom will just _hang_ after all of this. I just keep repeating the above until Zoom works again.

This is my employer provided MacBook Pro. I hate the experience so much that when it's time for a laptop refresh, I'm going to ask for the Windows option if they haven't upgraded their Mac offering to one that supports two monitors.

I love Apple products -- but I never understood how they could release a "Pro" laptop that supported only one external monitor.

emacdona··on We reduced our server costs by moving away from AWS
Agree that lowest common denominator is a VM.

But... I'm curious: has anyone here made an attempt to go "cloud-agnostic" by targeting managed kubernetes offerings? (GKE, EKS, AKS).

Just curious how much pain I'd be causing myself if I ever attempted it ;-)

emacdona··on GitHub Copilot is generally available
Ah, victims of their own success? Glad to see people are lining up to pay for it :-)
emacdona··on GitHub Copilot is generally available
Has anyone been able to sign up since this announcement?

I get to a "Confirm your payment details" screen, but there is no further action I can take (ie: no button to press or link to click to "confirm"). It does say "You will be billed $100/year starting August 20, 2022" -- but when I view my "settings", it tells me I haven't signed up for copilot.

I tried various browsers, including Edge on Windows 10 sans plugins (the combination I would expect to be the most supported for MS owned github.com).

emacdona··on Why “process substitution” is a late feature in Unix shells
> There are situations where named pipes fail, where you actually do need a plain file

In general: If the command you are passing the named pipe to expects a file which it can randomly access, a named pipe won’t work.

I ran into this today using a python tool, yamldiff. I was trying to diff a local yaml file with one from a cluster obtained via kubectl, eg:

yamldiff localManifest.yaml <(kubectl get … —output yaml)

and it failed with python telling me the file wasn’t seekable. Then I remembered this thread which I had initially read a few days ago and tried =() (since I use shell) — and it worked!

emacdona··on Sci-Hub Is Now on the ‘Uncensorable Web’
Okay, but how does Handshake solve that problem? It seems like the answer is "everyone buys their own TLD", right?

That works great until the only names that are left are all too long to remember.

And if you buy space from someone else's TLD, well... you've just given someone the power to censor you.

Or am I missing something here?

emacdona··on Sci-Hub Is Now on the ‘Uncensorable Web’
But you can buy a new TLD in the DNS, right? Granted, for more money and pending approval. How is the TLD you get from Handshake different? You still control it, right? And you have the power to revoke sub delegations within it, right? That's what's confusing me... the article seemed to indicate that by switching to Handshake, you won't get your name revoked ever again. But the detail that seems to have been left out is "... if you buy a Handshake TLD, as opposed to 'renting' space from a Handshake TLD holder".
emacdona··on Sci-Hub Is Now on the ‘Uncensorable Web’
Maybe the value is that b/c it's on the blockchain, you can see to which IP address a name referred to at ANY point in its (the name's) history?
emacdona··on Sci-Hub Is Now on the ‘Uncensorable Web’
But now that I think about it, the registry IS already decentralized. IE: .com is managed by an organization separate from .org. And the whole reason for "renting" from .com is because .com owns the space. If you "buy" a TLD on the Handshake blockchain, do you lose the ability to rescind delegations under that TLD once people have "bought" them?
emacdona··on Sci-Hub Is Now on the ‘Uncensorable Web’
Followed by this: 'Handshake is “is effectively a decentralized domain name server,” Roquerre said.' -- thus implying that DNS is NOT decentralized? The article is pretty bad. For his sake, I hope they are taking his quotes out of context. Because I had a quick look at https://www.namebase.io/ -- and it does look interesting. It appears that they have decentralized the REGISTRY by putting it on the "Handshake" blockchain.

Can I configure my resolver to use this "Handshake" blockchain?

emacdona··on Show HN: I made a macOS app to let me draw on the screen while on video calls
Wish you had posted this yesterday! I could have used it this morning. I bought a copy so I could use it for a presentation on Friday. Thank you for making it!

Suggestion: Make the diameter of the cursor highlight an option I can tweak.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →