HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eminent101

171 karma · joined December 6, 2021

Passionate about the theory of computation. I come here to learn about the latest tech hype!
submissionscomments
eminent101··on C is not Turing-complete (2018)
Thanks! I stand corrected.
eminent101··on C is not Turing-complete (2018)
> not sure if this matters?

Sure, it doesn't directly affect any practical programming tasks to matter in real life... but sometimes it's good to indulge in intellectual curiosity. It sharpens our understanding of how far a language can go, no matter how futile that understanding is. This is HN after all and "anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity" is on-topic on HN.

eminent101··on C is not Turing-complete (2018)
> are we allowed to read/write to external storage?

They did restrict the scope of their article to the standard only:

"This is an argument about the specification of C, not any particular implementation."

I don't think the spec has any representation of external storage in it.

eminent101··on Written by a 16 year old, a book on how computers work
Fair enough! Thanks @dang!
eminent101··on Written by a 16 year old, a book on how computers work
[flagged]
eminent101··on Decline of Indian vultures
>The authors estimated that between 2000 and 2005, the loss of vultures caused around 100,000 additional human deaths annually, resulting in more than $69bn (£53bn) per year in mortality damages or the economic costs associated with premature deaths.

Isn't this a giant leap of faith to claim that the increase in the number of deaths must be caused by loss of vultures? Correlation is not causation! How did they rule out other confounding factors? How are they so sure that this increase is definitely due to loss of vultures? Some more details on the research methodology and these technical details would be nice!

eminent101··on Cloudflare blocking my IP (2023)
I can clearly see a response from "hafida Cloudflare Team" with a green checkmark next to it.
eminent101··on Please maintain eye contact for the duration of the ad
> "Incidental inclusion" does not cover walking right up to someone and putting a camera in their face. Like, "incidental" is literally in the term.

Correct! I don't see where I implied otherwise!

eminent101··on Please maintain eye contact for the duration of the ad
> If I walked up to several individuals (maybe even you) on the street with a camera and tried to take a close-up, a lot of them would object. I don't think "why not let me take it, it's already online someplace" would be a convincing reason to allow it.

In many jurisdictions including where I live in, taking pictures at public places is allowed by law whether or not some other human happens to be in the frame of my picture. It is called "incidental inclusion".

Others can request me to exclude them from my picture but they can only request, they cannot force me to do so. Of course, if someone asked, I am going to be nice to them and try and exclude them from the picture. Others could also try and move a bit this way or that way so that they don't get included in my picture. We live in a society and we can work it out.

In reality though, nobody makes such a request because most people know the law and they know that if they are out there in the public, they could become part of other pictures by incidental inclusion.

eminent101··on TfL's simple pop-up message led to a significant drop in paper ticket sales
> The London→Brighton bit is only valid that day, but the Brighton→London bit is valid for 30 days. Get through the barriers at Brighton with a Brighton→Hassocks ticket.

Wait, if you already have a Brighton→London return ticket, why would you bother to buy Brighton→Hassocks and Clapham Junction→London tickets? Couldn't you just use the Brighton→London return ticket?

eminent101··on Show HN: Play the game I'm developing directly on its website
> It does, and it's a very good game, but this feels like plagiarism with how similar it is -- artwork style, mechanics, even UI is essentially identical to the GBA games

"Plagiarism" does not mean what you think it means.

eminent101··on PdfGptIndexer: Indexing and searching PDF text data using GPT-2 and FAISS
Is it going to send my personal data to OpenAI? Isn't that a serious problem? Does not sound like a wise thing to do, not at least without redacting all sensitive personal data from the data. Am I missing something?
eminent101··on Red Hat 30th anniversary
> I guess like many folks here i’ve sat a ton of exams over the years

At the risk of sounding like a caveman I have to admit that I haven't sat a single exam in my professional life. Am I losing out on something? What benefits have these exams brought to you that could not have been happened without them? Seriously considering if I should start signing up for them. And if I want to sign up for them, where do I start?

eminent101··on Tell HN: MailChimp blacklists your IP if you open the browser's dev tools
Does the computer really send requests to their server when I open dev tools? I checked and I couldn't find any request that was sent from Firefox or Chrome when I opened dev tools.

Aren't they using a JavaScript based detection mechanism like listening for browser events on the client side or latching on to debugger to pull this information? Sounds to me like they are going out of their way to pull private information from my system that I or my system or my browser had no intention of sharing with them.

eminent101··on Tell HN: MailChimp blacklists your IP if you open the browser's dev tools
Isn't this spying on the user without user's consent? Me opening dev tools to view the source is a private activity. Is it okay to collect this kind of info and use it to block access? Are there no regulations against this?
eminent101··on Show HN: OpenBB Terminal – Investment research for everyone
> FWIW, I find the founder's apologies in the issue thread [0] believable.

The comment thread here looks fishy enough that I am disinclined to give the benefit of doubt here.

eminent101··on Show HN: OpenBB Terminal – Investment research for everyone
> Can’t afford Bloomberg Terminal? No prob, I built the next best thing

Why has the title been editorialized to make it so much clickbait? Can you not use the simpler title from the README or About of the project?

EDIT: Does this comment thread look fishy to anyone else? Multiple new accounts created <= 10 days ago coming up and commenting here to answer other commenters, or praise OP/related commenters. Is this some kind of covert, unethical marketing going on? Wouldn't be suprising because they have done it before too. [1]

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35028675

eminent101··on Erlang: The coding language that finance forgot (2022)
Finance companies were doing distributed systems even before Internet existed. Yes, finance has a lot of numerical work but it has a lot more data pipeline work. The reason for this is to move market data from one geographical location to another. To make profitable investments, finance companies need accurate market data from all over the world available and processed at its datacenters as quickly as possible. For this reason in the early 1980s finance companies were laying down their own cables and writing their own link layer protocols to move data from one location to another.

Now in the 21st century this has only got more intense. There is much more competition in this space. So finance companies that can make distributed systems right and reliable stand a good chance to the most money from the markets.

eminent101··on Tech Nation’s fall must not mean the end of UK’s global talent visa
Previous related story:

Tech Nation shutting down as UK government pulls key funding:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34613408 (85 points, 73 comments)

eminent101··on PayPal data breach notification
> If a company has your livelihood, bank balance, etc by the balls

Whose fault is it that people are relying on free email service (with no human support) for critical things like livelihood, bank balance, etc.? Is the provider of a free email service liable for the damages they can cause? What do their terms and conditions say about it? Do they have a disclaimer in there for this kind of things?

eminent101··on Ask HN: Is there a GDPR compliance privacy statement template for small blogs?
Thanks for the answer! The blog has visitors from other geographic locations (both in EU and outside EU). Those visitors also post comments with their names included in comments. Those comments are then made available on the internet. So I am doubtful if it falls in purely personal use category.

https://gdprhub.eu/Article_2_GDPR says:

> According to Lindqvist in particular, the publication of personal data on a blogging site made available to an unlimited number of people would 'obviously' not be subject to the household exemption.

For now, let us assume that the commenter name and IP addresses fall within the scope of GDPR. Do you have any comments about how the right to erasure would be implemented in the scenario I described in my comment above?

eminent101··on Ask HN: Is there a GDPR compliance privacy statement template for small blogs?
Thanks! May I ask how you would handle this scenario - A blog has a commenting feature where users can type in their name (possibly full name) and a comment. There is no user registration or email address collection/verification. Any user on the internet can type in a name (an anonymous name or a real name like Bob Yan) and their comment and submit it. Web server access logs are kept in the server for 30 days.

Does it fall within the scope of GDPR? If yes then how is the right to have personal data erased implemented? How would you process a request from someone with the name Bob Yan asking you to delete all comments posted by 'Bob Yan' on your website? Without a user registration or an email, how would you verify that the Bob Yan contacting you is the one who posted all those comments? This part seems to be very confusing. I'd appreciate any knowledge or tips you can share about this.

eminent101··on Ask HN: Is there a GDPR compliance privacy statement template for small blogs?
IP address seems to be personal data here: https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/law-topic/data-protection/refo...

Many other articles I read also agree with above.

eminent101··on Ask HN: Is there a GDPR compliance privacy statement template for small blogs?
Because name field in a comment form is personal data in GDPR. IP address is also considered personal data in GDPR. And GDPR requires that we publish a privacy statement about how personal data is going to be stored/used/shared. I am not going to share this data with any party. But due to access logs and showing comments, this data is going to be saved on disk. A good template for privacy statement can help a lot.

This is a solved problem for open source licenses. It would be great if there is something like that for privacy statement too.

eminent101··on Ask HN: How do small personal website/blog owners comply with GDPR?
Thanks! This clarification helps! Are there any standard privacy policies one can import into their website? I am looking for something along the lines of standard open source licenses. Thanks to a wide range of open source licenses available, we don't have to invent our own while publishing open source code. Anything like that for privacy policy?
eminent101··on Ask HN: How do small personal website/blog owners comply with GDPR?
From some reading I have done online I gather that just the act of logging IP addresses to my server's disk requires some legal safety nets such as a privacy statement that says what will be done with that data. Sounds like too much work for running a simple personal website.
eminent101··on Ask HN: How do small personal website/blog owners comply with GDPR?
Added an edit to my post. I am based in EU and UK. But answers for other locations and regulations welcome too because those answers can help other people.
eminent101··on Why Racket? Why Lisp? (2014)
> ((if (< 1 0) + ) 42 100)

This gives me an error in SBCL. Error below:

  ; in: (IF (< 1 0)
  ;      +
  ;      *) 42
  ;     ((IF (< 1 0)
  ;          +
  ;          *)
  ;      42 100)
  ; 
  ; caught ERROR:
  ;   illegal function call
  ; 
  ; compilation unit finished
  ;   caught 1 ERROR condition
Why does it not work and how to make it work?
eminent101··on Open source is not about you (2018)
> it was written by an attorney not someone that cares about sharing ideas open and freely

Of course it was written by attorneys. Do you know how FSF, DFSG and OSD even began? They found a legal solution to the problem of sharing code while guaranteeing certain rights for the user who use the code! The open source licenses are written by attorneys too.

You are free to distribute under whatever terms you want but your code does not become open source just because it is shared with the public. Some countries do not even recognise "public domain". In such countries it becomes necessary to attach a valid open source license to your code. That's why the various open source licenses are drafted by attorneys to ensure they can provide appropriate rights to the user of the code.

eminent101··on Open source is not about you (2018)
Open Source is already defined here: https://opensource.org/osd
← PreviousPage 2 of 2