HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

enchiridion

985 karma · joined March 28, 2019

submissionscomments
enchiridion··on I'm quitting my PhD
I think this is a bit narrow. I’d say it’s a credential that shows you know how to conduct research.

In my case it was less of an apprenticeship and more of a lot of stumbling around until I found a way to create research that matched my standards. My standards are modeled after the clearly explained and verifiable work in my field.

enchiridion··on I'm quitting my PhD
Don’t be terrified, just keep pushing. That’s what separates those who finish from those who don’t.

I say this as someone who nearly did not finish a PhD and had terrible mismatch with my advisor. If you have a mismatch with your advisor, I have three pieces of unsolicited advice.

1. Find the community of your research topic early and get involved. Partially due to covid there are now many ~weekly seminars that meet online and post recordings on YouTube. They tend to be welcoming, and getting to know the people drives home the idea of “if they can do it so can I”

2. Pick a problem with extremely clear benchmarks. If you exceed the benchmarks, then congrats on your state of the art work! If not, write about the good parts and explain why the bad parts exist.

3. Write about your topic early and often. You don’t have to publish it necessarily, but writing has a clarifying effect acknowledged by every PhD student I know.

Stay positive and remember to take care of yourself! Good luck!

enchiridion··on Memorizing Transformers
Yep, this is correct.
enchiridion··on Coloring computers: non-electronic computers that work when you color them
I used to do this with a graphite pencil, battery, simple 1 transistor amplifier, and a piezo buzzer.

Lots of fun. Makes me yearn for the days of radio shack.

enchiridion··on Visualizing quaternions: an explorable video series (2018)
Did you view the site? It’s the best way to describe it.
enchiridion··on Elon Musk makes $43B unsolicited bid to take Twitter private
That’s what the first amendment does.

Free speech is a fundamental human right, outside of any document.

enchiridion··on Slide Rule Simulator Emulator Replica Collection
These are pretty old, so if I had to guess, probably ease of manufacturing? It’s a lot easier to get square grids than hexagonal using simple machinery. Just a guess though.
enchiridion··on Slide Rule Simulator Emulator Replica Collection
If you like this you’ll like Chris Staeker’s series on analog computing devices.

Here is on on longimeters I like.

https://youtu.be/-ZE2Iv-8tsA

enchiridion··on The United States Digital Corps
Semantically maybe they are similar, but in the sociological parlance they mean very different things.

Yes, equality of opportunity is a good thing. If you have the qualifications, anyone should be given equal consideration. Changing or relaxing requirements in order to attempt some societal good is wrong. Those issues should be addressed upstream of any employment decisions, mainly by removing impediments to success, not by preferential treatment.

enchiridion··on The United States Digital Corps
Yes I am. What you describe is equality, which I think is great!

What they are advocating for is equity, a much different goal. Equity involves giving preferential treatment to certain groups of people who are perceived as persecuted in the current social climate. It has no basis in law, and is antithetical to a meritocracy.

enchiridion··on The United States Digital Corps
Is anyone else frightened to see equity explicitly spelled out as a goal of a US government office? Equity implicitly requires enforcement of equal outcomes. I do not think the federal government is capable or benevolent enough to carry out that enforcement
enchiridion··on Measurement of the W boson mass reveals 7σ deviation from calculations
I disagree with the parent post about the use of Greek letters, but it seems like a valid point worth of discussion. Certainly in the spirit of HN.

I’ve seen an increasingly worrying trend of using downvotes to voice disagreement, rather than as the intended purpose as a kind of crowd-based moderation. And before anyone lambasts me for complaining about downvotes, I’m complaining about the trend, where the above comment is just a exemplar.

enchiridion··on Measurement of the W boson mass reveals 7σ deviation from calculations
Would it be the same in a hypothetical completely homogeneous gas?

My assumption is that turbulent changes in pressure cause diffraction, causing the light to not take a perfectly straight path. I don’t know enough about physics to know if that’s right.

enchiridion··on Hit with hard times, American bakers turned to tomato soup
Nice! What’s your favorite recipe.
enchiridion··on Hit with hard times, American bakers turned to tomato soup
Now Mayo is mostly just soybean oil.
enchiridion··on Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Largest Trial to Date
"Platform", as in allow free speech, a core founding idea of liberal democracies everywhere. I'm aware speech on private platforms is not protected from the actions of the platform by the First Amendment. That doesn't mean it is morally acceptable for these platforms to infringe.

"Conspiracy riddled garbage" which has turned out in more than one case to be right (the effectiveness of masking, effectiveness of social distancing, the effectiveness of lock downs). Just because the evidence currently looks to be in favor of vaccination doesn't mean we should shutdown dissenting opinions.

Millions of people have given their lives to protect the ideal of free speech and similar freedoms. I have no issue with the fact that exercising that right may cause some harm. I fundamentally believe that free speech leads to better outcomes over the long term.

Additionally, in this particular case the harm is not immediately obvious to me.

If you are in a position to affect outcomes in this area (as many on HN probably are, given ties to social media), I hope you reflect on the environment of freedom you currently benefit from. Are comfortable restricting freedoms for future generations, who's situations and trials are unknown to you?

enchiridion··on Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Largest Trial to Date
I disagree. The dangerous issues are precisely the ones that need more debate. The consequences of blindly following a single push are potentially cataclysmic.

Your last statement relies on the assumption that the authorities actually know what information will save lives. I do not believe that is true.

I do believe in the reasoning and self preservation instincts of most people. The way these experts have acted shows very little respect for the sanctity of the individual.

enchiridion··on Researchers train an algorithm to interpret pig grunts as emotions
A human cannot exist without eating. That means I must eat other living things, plants, mushrooms, and animals.

If you believe all living things are conscience to an extent, like I do, then why do we draw the line at animals.

I’ve made peace with the idea that othering things have to suffer and die in order to provide for for me to survive.

That’s not to say we can’t try to reduce the suffering, but ultimately existence is suffering.

enchiridion··on Researchers train an algorithm to interpret pig grunts as emotions
That’s fair, you’re right. I suppose I’m just tired of the same arguments.

I’m all for personal agency, so eat whatever you want, but it irks me when carnivores are admonished.

enchiridion··on Researchers train an algorithm to interpret pig grunts as emotions
Nope, I’d like to continue eating meat. If this can help it be done more humanely than great!
enchiridion··on Transformers, originally designed to handle language, are taking on vision
Where is a good place to look for algorithms/math for solving problems similar to the ones you mentioned?
enchiridion··on Reducing the risk of nuclear war should be a key concern of our generation
Probably because of the risk. MAD is stable.
enchiridion··on Two new ways of extracting lithium from brine
Maybe that’s partially why Tesla moved?
enchiridion··on What does it mean to listen on a port?
Interesting divide on the writing style here.

As a person who doesn’t do much networking, I appreciated the context.

I wonder if the people who didn’t like the post style are networking experts who are already steeped in this stuff?

Anyone care to comment if the fall into either group?

enchiridion··on Ask HN: What is one book you would recommend everyone to read?
The Enchiridion, aka The Handbook.

Simple language. Simple lessons. Life changing guidance that has stood the test of time.

enchiridion··on Gut microbe linked to depression in large health study
Interesting result about the fiber plus probiotic. To me that’s saying that’s your body mostly knows how to maintain a micro biome if given the right building blocks.

I wonder how the immune system comes into play to actively shape the microbiome, vs our typical understanding of just “fighting bad bacteria”.

enchiridion··on Frank Rosenblatt's perceptron paved the way for AI 60 years too soon (2019)
What really made the difference was non-linear activations.

Without a non-linearity depth doesn’t buy you anything.

enchiridion··on Spotify deletes 70 Joe Rogan episodes
Ya sure. But there are literally decision makers who frequent this forum, so if I object to something for sound reasons it’s worth saying so.
enchiridion··on Spotify deletes 70 Joe Rogan episodes
Where did I say that? I can personally object to something without invoking the government to action.
enchiridion··on Spotify deletes 70 Joe Rogan episodes
This argument is so tired. You’re saying they have the right to censor, so say it.

The counter argument is that censorship is bad in all its forms. It’s one I and many others support.

← PreviousPage 2 of 15Next →