HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

enterprise_cog

180 karma · joined March 2, 2023

submissionscomments
enterprise_cog··on The Telegram app has been a key platform for Hamas. Now it's being restricted
Warped logic. The person dropping the bomb is always at fault. They know civilians are there.

And please post evidence of your claim they are moving civilians in intentionally. Turns out those buildings being blown up are also people’s houses and they don’t want to leave.

enterprise_cog··on Wikipedia Is Covering the War in Israel and Gaza Better Than X
Wrong. Israel is bombing and shelling a dense urban area. There is no crossfire. It’s intentional fire and they seem the civilian losses as acceptable.

Also what mutilation are you talking about? Lots of scare words there when Israel is mutilating children with high explosives right now, on purpose.

Not to mention Israel is also bombing its own hostages, and they consider that acceptable too.

They are not moral in any sense of the word.

enterprise_cog··on Wikipedia Is Covering the War in Israel and Gaza Better Than X
Murdering over 8000 civilians intentionally — over a thousand being children — is more moral than Hamas killing 1400 IDF soldiers, settlers, and some civilians? How’s that calculus work?
enterprise_cog··on The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete
Maybe take a brief timeout. When you start cherry picking stats and throwing out statements like a camp guard and prisoner are the same... you've taking in too many social media posts and you’re triggered. Take a deep breath and go outside. Whatever war you are waging on here is not working
enterprise_cog··on The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete
Time out? People don’t want to see innocent civilians intentionally slaughtered by a US backed country.
enterprise_cog··on The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete
Oh, so if only they went back to a total lockdown of Gaza and treated it like a more maximum security prison, then this wouldn’t have happened?

What if they didn’t treat it like a prison, or Palestinians like subhuman prisoners? Do you think that maybe then they wouldn’t want to go on raids and kill people? That those 1400 soldiers and civilians would still be alive?

enterprise_cog··on The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete
You keep missing the fact that Israel is actually, right at this moment, following through with their words. It is reality. Hamas doing a genocide is conjecture.
enterprise_cog··on The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete
“Right now, one goal: Nakba! A Nakba that will overshadow the Nakba of 1948,” - Ariel Kallner, member of the Likud party.

So we agree Israel is committing genocide.

enterprise_cog··on The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete
What if Israel stopped killing Palestinians and normalized relations with Gaza? Israel could choose a different path.
enterprise_cog··on The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete
I don’t know. Neither do you. Let’s stick to reality and what is actually happening right now.
enterprise_cog··on The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete
If this thing that has never and will never happen actually happened, do you think a thing that didn’t happen would be like a thing that is happening right now?

Did I get that right?

enterprise_cog··on The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete
It’s a 25x5 mile strip of land, where Palestinians aren’t even allowed to build near the border.

Where exactly are they supposed to operate out of?

And it turns out it’s quite easy to not bomb civilians. You don’t drop bombs in cities.

enterprise_cog··on US asks Qatar to 'turn down the volume' of Al Jazeera news coverage
Figure out why the much hyped IDF professional forces got clowned on by Hamas would be where I’d start.

Bombing infrastructure, hospitals, and a dense city filled with civilians is not.

enterprise_cog··on An aborted experiment with server Swift
You should probably list some concrete examples of how it is better. Otherwise it’s just an opinion with no insights.
enterprise_cog··on Ukraine's American Missiles Wrecked 21 Russian Helicopters in Single Operation
Second statement does not follow from the first. For all we know those tires are poorly maintained because they spend their limited resources on maintaining their nuclear arsenal.

Either way, you can’t call their bluff without risking nuclear annihilation. All it takes is a few dozen MIRV tipped IC/SL ballistic missiles to bypass anti missile systems and destroy a good chunk of the US population.

enterprise_cog··on Pro-Palestinian views face suppression in US amid Israel-Hamas war
You keep talking about everything but what has happened the last month.

First, yes, Israel has been blockading Gaza since the Hamas attack. This humanitarian crisis has been all over the news even in the US, so not sure why you’re saying it isn’t true. [2]

Over 5000 Palestinians have died so far since the Al-Aqsa Flood. So almost as many deaths as the last 15 years. 62% being women and children. 150k other casualties. [1] Also comparing death counts like that is not a logical way to view these situations. You can use the same line of thinking to deny the holocaust. “Only 6 million Jews? Do you really think that’s a genocide when Nazis killed over 20 million Soviets?”

No I did not mean the land belongs to the Palestinians. It belongs to all who live there, Jew and Arab. The UN is a political entity, the countries who voted had no right to say the Palestinians don’t get that land. The land has been lived in for thousands of years by all sorts of ethnicities. The current ethnostate does deserve to go away. Its existence will forever destabilize the region.

Last, I notice you had no response to how Israel doesn’t let Gaza build infrastructure. So I’ll assume you saw that was true.

[1] https://news.un.org/en/story/2023/10/1142687

[2] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/oct/19/gaza-aid-rafah...

enterprise_cog··on Pro-Palestinian views face suppression in US amid Israel-Hamas war
The Likud party supports the expulsion and killing of all Palestinians. We should make supporting them illegal next.
enterprise_cog··on Ukraine's American Missiles Wrecked 21 Russian Helicopters in Single Operation
So they don’t have nukes now because of fanciful thinking. Gotcha.
enterprise_cog··on Pro-Palestinian views face suppression in US amid Israel-Hamas war
How is not allowing food, water, and aid into Gaza not Israel doing those things? How is the indiscriminate bombings of Gaza not any of those things? You are just denying reality to suit your point.

That’s their land? Are you kidding? The entirety of what is called Israel now is their land, along with fellow Jews. Do you think people haven’t read the history of the area? To even say that shows an incredible ignorance of the history of the area.

As to your last point, Israel controls what goes in Gaza. They limit the amount of concrete so they can’t build, for example. They control water, Palestinians have to get a permit to build water infrastructure from the Israeli government. They rarely grant them. Rain catchers set up by Palestinians are destroyed by the IDF or settlers. Not to mention, anything they do actually build ends up bombed by the Israelis. To say they don’t like to build things is, once again, an incredible display of ignorance.

In fact, since your whole response is filled with such absurdly one sided takes that ignore reality, I have to assume you are trolling.

enterprise_cog··on Pro-Palestinian views face suppression in US amid Israel-Hamas war
Which side has forced the other into a 25x5 mile strip of land? What country doesn’t allow that land to be properly built out? Which country restricts movement, cut off food and water, disabled electricity, and has blocked most aid from entering Gaza?

That’s Israel in case you aren’t sure. And those are acts of genocide. So why are you saying Israel doesn’t act on it?

enterprise_cog··on Pro-Palestinian views face suppression in US amid Israel-Hamas war
Yeah, they want the end to the ethnostate of Israel. Meanwhile, Israeli leaders want to end the entire Palestinian ethnicity. Given that, why would there be anything wrong with wanting an end to that state? Are the Palestinian people just supposed to lay down and die?

I am genuinely curious what people like you expect them to do, and — if you were in the Palestinian position — what you would do.

enterprise_cog··on U.S. Deficit, Pegged at $1.7T, Effectively Doubled in 2023
Why would anyone care what lying David Frum says about BRICS?
enterprise_cog··on Instagram apologizes for inserting 'terrorist' into Palestinian bio translations
Why do you say that?
enterprise_cog··on Ask HN: Do tools like Copilot or ChatGPT4 help you code?
Do you work at coderabbit? Should probably state that if so.
enterprise_cog··on America Is Headed Toward Collapse
How about you show a country where a billion people were taken out of poverty while not governed by something westerners call a dictatorship?
enterprise_cog··on Israelis and Palestinians blame each other for blast at Gaza hospital
Disagree the explosion was only the size of two cars.

Airburst can happen wherever the fuse is designed to activate.

Here: https://twitter.com/BowesChay/status/1714654233847288050

Direct comparison of a JDAM and the hospital attack.

enterprise_cog··on Israelis and Palestinians blame each other for blast at Gaza hospital
Blast looked smaller than a car, nowhere near the payload that was used on the hospital. Also range isn’t payload so not sure why it’s being mentioned.
enterprise_cog··on Israelis and Palestinians blame each other for blast at Gaza hospital
Answer what I asked. If you’re going to respond to my question with more questions that avoid answering what I asked, it makes it clear you have no intention of actually discussing this and are only here to post pro Israeli takes.
enterprise_cog··on Israelis and Palestinians blame each other for blast at Gaza hospital
Article only mentions the payload of one rocket, the Badr-3, which wasn’t the rocket used here according to you. So it is a useless link.

Go find physical evidence of a Hamas rocket doing the amount of damage that was done to the hospital.

enterprise_cog··on Israelis and Palestinians blame each other for blast at Gaza hospital
Nope. But I’ve seen footage of other airstrikes that sound just like the attack on the hospital. So unless you can provide proof that a broken up rocket sounds like that, I’ll go with it being a bomb.
← PreviousPage 5 of 9Next →