HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

enugu

457 karma · joined February 12, 2016

Google email id : harshavr
submissionscomments
enugu··on Tensors, the geometric tool that solved Einstein's relativity problem
Finite dimension tensors is interesting both in physics(ex: mechanics, electromagnetism, general relativity) and mathematics(ex: representation theory, differential geometry). Infinite dimensions is also used in physics(quantum theory) and in mathematics (Operator Algebras, representation theory again).
enugu··on Tensors, the geometric tool that solved Einstein's relativity problem
There is a way of defining a vector space without an explicit basis(just as a set with an addition and a scalar multiplication). Similarly, there is a way of defining a vector bundle without choosing an explicit coordinates (as an abstract vector space, as defined above, which varies with the point in the space).

Just as a (p,q) tensor is a multilinear object related to a single vector space, a tensor field is a section of a tensor bundle associated to the vector bundle. (A section is just a function on the underlying space whose value at a point lies in the vector space above the point.)

Usually, the vector bundle relevant in physics is the tangent bundle of a 4-manifold.

This abstract way of defining tensors and tensor fields is manifestly invariant under coordinate changes, but it takes some machinery to set up. Whereas the 'numbers associated to each coordinate system which transform in a certain way' is more direct, but the rules can seem arbitrary at first sight. Also, maybe this approach can generalize to allow more transformation rules which might take some time to put into an abstract setting.

Standard example is a matrix A which transforms as PAP^-1 (where P is linear coordinate change) vs a matrix T which is a linear map between vector spaces.

The same issue appears in software where you can expose a data structure as a tuple of numbers/string fields and then define functions on them, or you can expose it as an abstract data type where the user of the library can only apply certain functions on them and the implementation author can choose different representations(coordinate changes) in which to easily compute the functions.

enugu··on Tensors, the geometric tool that solved Einstein's relativity problem
Any given tensor has a type (p,q). Say d=p+q. Then d is the 'dimension' of the tensor in the sense that you would need nxnx...n=n^d numbers (think of an nxnx...n array) to describe the tensor where n is the dimension of the underlying vector space.

> or is it the generalized form of the structure encompassing all of it...Kind of like how an n-sphere

If you are asking whether there are examples of tensors parametrized by an integer d, you can cook up examples - like the (d,0) tensor whose input is a sequence of d vectors and just adds up all the components with respect to some basis in each slot and then adds this number across all the d slots.

But just like a n-spere is a special example, of a polynomial in n variables, the above tensor is a specific example - it is the tensor where all the components are 1 in the higher dimensional array.

Sometimes, one considers the algebra of tensors across all dimensions like the symmetric algebra or exterior algebra simultaneously (where there is multiplication operation between tensors of different dimensions), but that might not be what you were asking about.

enugu··on Creativity fundamentally comes from memorization?
Regarding Asian cultures and memorization, there is a recent change that has to be pointed out. The role of memorization classically was to aid manana/contemplation after shravana/hearing-the-teaching. The stage of manana is a kind of inquiry where you raise questions and clarify them or see how the teaching applies to various situations in your life(Like learning a principle in physics and solving problems based on the principle). In the case of poetic works the inner-feeling/bhaava sinks into you allowing one to access blissful states.

However, in the modern context, this has been transformed into memorizing arcane lists/tables, on which one is graded without any further manana.

enugu··on Bayesian Statistics: The three cultures
> What does this actually mean? It it a proposition? If so, is it falsifiable? And how?

If you saw a sequence of 1000 coin tosses at say 99% heads and 1% tails, you were convinced that the same process is being used for all the tosses and you had an opportunity to bet on tails with 50% stakes, would you do it?

This is a pragmatic answer which rejects P(X)=0.5. We can try to make sense of this pragmatic decision with some theory. (Incidentally, being exactly 0.5 is almost impossible, it makes more sense to verify if it is an interval like (0.49,0.51)).

The CLT says that probability of X can be obtained by conducting independent trials and the in limit, the average number of times X occurs will approach p(X).

However, 'limit' implies an infinite number of trials, so any initial sequence doesn't determine the limit. You would have to choose a large N as a cutoff and then take the average.

But, is this unique to probability? If you take any statement about the world, "There is a tree in place G", and you have a process to check the statement ("go to G and look for a tree"), can you definitely say that the process will successfully determine if the statement is true? There will always be obstacles("false appearances of a tree" etc.). To rule out all such obstacles, you would have to posit an idealized observation process.

For probability checking, an idealization which works is infinite independent observations which gives us p(X).

PS: I am not trying to favour frequentism as such, just that the requirement of an ideal of observation process shouldn't be considered as an overwhelming obstacle. (Sometimes, the obstacles can become 'obstacles in principle' like position/momentum simultaneous observation in QM and if you had such obstacles, then indeed one can abandon the concept of probability).

enugu··on In the Beginning Was the Command Line (1999)
You can skip ahead to his playful thesis > the universe emerging from the command line.

In his book The Life of the Cosmos, which everyone should read, Lee Smolin gives the best description I've ever read of how our universe emerged from an uncannily precise balancing of different fundamental constants. The mass of the proton, the strength of gravity, the range of the weak nuclear force, and a few dozen other fundamental constants completely determine what sort of universe will emerge from a Big Bang. If these values had been even slightly different, the universe would have been a vast ocean of tepid gas or a hot knot of plasma or some other basically uninteresting thing--a dud, in other words. The only way to get a universe that's not a dud--that has stars, heavy elements, planets, and life--is to get the basic numbers just right. If there were some machine, somewhere, that could spit out universes with randomly chosen values for their fundamental constants, then for every universe like ours it would produce 10^229 duds.

Though I haven't sat down and run the numbers on it, to me this seems comparable to the probability of making a Unix computer do something useful by logging into a tty and typing in command lines when you have forgotten all of the little options and keywords. Every time your right pinky slams that ENTER key, you are making another try. In some cases the operating system does nothing. In other cases it wipes out all of your files. In most cases it just gives you an error message. In other words, you get many duds. But sometimes, if you have it all just right, the computer grinds away for a while and then produces something like emacs. It actually generates complexity, which is Smolin's criterion for interestingness.

Not only that, but it's beginning to look as if, once you get below a certain size--way below the level of quarks, down into the realm of string theory--the universe can't be described very well by physics as it has been practiced since the days of Newton. If you look at a small enough scale, you see processes that look almost computational in nature.

I think that the message is very clear here: somewhere outside of and beyond our universe is an operating system, coded up over incalculable spans of time by some kind of hacker-demiurge. The cosmic operating system uses a command-line interface. It runs on something like a teletype, with lots of noise and heat; punched-out bits flutter down into its hopper like drifting stars. The demiurge sits at his teletype, pounding out one command line after another, specifying the values of fundamental constants of physics:

universe -G 6.672e-11 -e 1.602e-19 -h 6.626e-34 -protonmass 1.673e-27....

and when he's finished typing out the command line, his right pinky hesitates above the ENTER key for an aeon or two, wondering what's going to happen; then down it comes--and the WHACK you hear is another Big Bang.

enugu··on Every company should be owned by its employees
> fully employee-owned

There are more possibilities which open up, if we drop the 'fully' criterion, both for decision making power and share of the profits.

If employees had, say, a 30% share in board decisions (not share of profits), then the CEO would have to be more mindful of how their decisions affect employees, just like they have to constantly track the markets today. Or a more local version of this, where decisions/appointments in each unit of the company are partially handled by employees of that unit. Not enough for a badly performing group of employees to have a veto, but also not something ignorable by management.

Regarding share of profits, there were high tax regimes in Western countries in the 1950-70's. For instance, top bracket of income tax could sometimes reach 90% and corporate tax 50%. In effect, this is saying that the public has a non-voting share(sometimes even a majority share) of the profits of the company. Of course, a large organization like the government is itself often corrupt/inefficient and fails to represent the public, so the taxation could happen at a more local level.

'Market socialism' proposals sometimes involve public ownership of the stocks of privately run companies, but a high tax regime can have a lot of the same effect.

enugu··on What Is Entropy?
> If entropy is zero then all kinds of things break down.

Entropy is a macroscopic variable and if you allow microscopic information, strange things can happen! One can move from a high entropy macrostate to a low entropy macrostate if you choose the initial microstate carefully. But this is not a reliable process which you can reproduce experimentally, ie. it is not a thermodynamic process.

A thermodynamics process P is something which takes a macrostate A to a macrostate B, independent of which microstate a0, a1, a2.. in A you started off with it. If the process depends on microstate, then it wouldn't be something we would recognize as we are looking from the macro perspective.

enugu··on What Is Entropy?
Don't see how the connection is superficial. Even the classical macroscopic definition of entropy as ΔS=∫TdQ can be derived from the information theory perspective as Baez shows in article(using entropy maximizing distributions and Lagrange multipliers). If you have a more specific critique, it would be good to discuss.
enugu··on What Is Entropy?
Assuming each of the N microstates for a given macrostate are equally possible with probability p=1/N, the Shannon Entropy is -Σp.log(p) = -N.p.log(p)=-1.log(1/N)=log(N), which is the physics interpretation.

In the continuous version, you would get log(V) where V is the volume in phase space occupied by the microstates for a given macrostate.

Liouville's theorem that the volume is conserved in phase space implies that any macroscopic process can only move all the microstates from a macrostate A into a macrostate B only if the volume of B is bigger than the volume of A. This implies that the entropy of B should be bigger than the entropy of A which is the Second Law.

enugu··on What Is Entropy?
That's not a problem, as the GP's post is trying to state a mathematical relation not a historical attribution. Often newer concepts shed light on older ones. As Baez's article says, Gibbs entropy is Shannon's entropy of an associated distribution(multiplied by the constant k).
enugu··on Pattern of brain damage is pervasive in Navy SEALs who died by suicide
This is an obvious strawman('We cant deregulate X when we are heavily regulating Y which is much weaker than X' -> 'The government should regulate every aspect of life '), So bye.
enugu··on A landscape of consciousness: Toward a taxonomy of explanations and implications
A well simulated intelligence in a computer would speak and have discussions about 'conscious experience'. (Assuming that is possible, but that is implied by physicalism+Church-Turing)

If you think that the simulation has conscious experience/qualia.../X, then X gets properties like being non-localized in space and time - you can break the simulation into multiple parts in an essential way and run these parts on data centers across the planet which communicate with each other. Further, you can freeze the simulation for a couple of days and reload. As long as there is no connection to outer signals like the system clock, the simulation wouldn't notice the gap.

If you think the simulation doesn't have consciousness/qualia/X despite accurately replicating humans as measured by instruments, then the simulation is a p-zombie.

enugu··on Pattern of brain damage is pervasive in Navy SEALs who died by suicide
> transiency is irrelevant to autonomy

If you are allowing transient decisions for giving away a life, then transient decisions would be allowed for lesser stakes too.

Most societies are debating even something like unrestricted access to drugs. There are people who would take drugs as a conscious/long-term plan for whom the transiency distinction is irrelevant but there are also those who hate it while succumbing to it and would gladly sign a contract to stop access to consumption, if that were practically possible to enforce.

Contracts often involve trading away autonomy of a future self whether for the good or the bad. Signing such a contract is often not legally valid if the person is in a disturbed mental state.

A more common example, children are not allowed to buy alcohol or consent to a sexual relationship with an adult.

The issue being that the immediate decision of the child can be something they would reject if they have more experience and had the ability to make a more informed choice. Of course, the problem of impulsive bad decisions doesn't go away as an adult, but considerations of intrinsic freedom and the problems of giving power to a state become much bigger.

When a criminal commits a crime, a premeditated/planned action is treated more severely than an impulsive action which in turn is treated more severely than an action caused by a mental illness.

Taking one's life is a much more drastic step than drugs or signing a contract.

> not necessarily transient

Not assuming this, chronic examples don't rule out the existence of large families of cases where things can and do look better due to time and a change in circumstances.

enugu··on Pattern of brain damage is pervasive in Navy SEALs who died by suicide
My post was not meant to trivialize the problems you are facing or that there are easy fix solutions. Dont know how I can help as an anonymous stranger on the net, but just in case you want to talk to someone, you can always send an email.

FWIW, my point was that in many cases suicidal feelings can be relieved and the abuses (that you point correctly say exist already) can become more dangerous when directed towards getting rid of vulnerable people. But, that doesn't mean that chronic, hard-to-cure situations don't exist.

Best.

enugu··on Pattern of brain damage is pervasive in Navy SEALs who died by suicide
The issue is when there is overdetermination - fixing a single cause resolves 80% of the current cause of failures, but the process fails at another point which becomes the new bottleneck. Say, most people are failing at a task due to stress(A). But even if you solve that, then most people can start failing due to another cause, B, say laziness. Fixing A is not "a little bit" and any solution will have to face A(in order to have success rate > 20%) but it is not sufficient to fix stress alone.

You can of course agglomerate A & B into a single cause C but for that to be meaningful C has to be the 'root' of A and B, otherwise the solution for C also just becomes an agglomeration of the solutions for A and B.

enugu··on Did Turing prove the undecidability of the halting problem?
Quantum computers can't solve the halting problem but that is not Penrose's argument which is not summarized well in the quote.
enugu··on Pattern of brain damage is pervasive in Navy SEALs who died by suicide
Suicides do not just happen due to being in extreme, incurable pain. People commit suicides due to emotions which seem powerful immediately(failure in love life, academics, career etc.) but would not seem as such a big deal if they were to look back on it afterwards either due to the passing of time or due to finding something else which made life worthwhile.

This also is the problem with the autonomy argument - this is not what the person might themselves would choose if they were in a more sober mood. The autonomy argument is also seen as invalid in other situations like when signing oneself to slavery.

Money men being against suicide for economic reasons runs contrary another other point in your post - money might be saved by the suicide of the invalid and sick. Making suicide legal can easily be abused by powerful state officials incentivizing people to commit suicide for economic or political reasons.

So yes, create a good social support system, but don't encourage suicide.

enugu··on Pattern of brain damage is pervasive in Navy SEALs who died by suicide
In a multi-stage process, even if you fix the cause with 80% responsibility, the outcome may not improve by much, as there is failure now at another stage. Of course, fixing that single cause is still progress.
enugu··on Banach–Tarski Paradox
Is there a good write-up somewhere of the problems with discretization of space for physics?

Interestingly, some great mathematicians (including Grothendieck) thought that modelling space as continuum was an approximation and not the reality.

enugu··on 'Equals' has more than one meaning in math
Yes, {} is a subset(⊂) of all sets, but it is not a member(∊) of all sets. For instance, {} is not a member of {{{}}}. In the Von-Neumann definition, 1:={0}={{}}. So, 0∊1, but 0 is not a member of {1} which is the above set. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Set-theoretic_definition_of_na...
enugu··on Terence Tao on proof checkers and AI programs
Pictures can be directly used in formal proofs. See [1] for instance So, the problem is not in principle, but rather, pictures and more direct syntax has not yet been integrated into current proof systems. When that is done, proofs will be much more natural and the formal proof will be closer to the 'proof in the mind'.

[1] https://www.unco.edu/nhs/mathematical-sciences/faculty/mille...

enugu··on Calculus Made Easy
Reusing and blackboxes do appear a lot in higher level mathematics. Indeed, the idea behind abstract algebra is to hide 'implementation' details. The concept of abstract data type in programming is similar to structures studied in algebra.

  It is common for mathematicians to rely on theorems as black boxes(ex: classification of surfaces) even without knowing the proof. Secondly, people can even write research papers without knowing how to work with some object covered in the paper, by working with collaborators who are experts on a different topic.

  It would be helpful to isolate the essence of calculus itself from the symbolic techniques, for ex to actually calculate integrals(especially  magical seeming substitutions and nontrivial factorizations) as many of these symbolic techniques will appear in different topics even outside calclus.

Here's a criterion for testing this core understanding calculus - Can somebody given a problem (say optimization, or finding volumes) convert it into a standard type of differentiation or integral, then use symbolic software like Mathematica to do the computation and then get the right answer. Often, calculus students memorize standard recipes for problems and get confused by a problem which is not hard symbolically, but requires some thought to set up correctly.
enugu··on Physics for Mathematicians – Introduction
Thanks a lot for this effort! As someone wanting to learn physics from a math background, this seems to be at the right level for discussing critical high-level ideas mathematically. The article format is great as I get distracted reading book-length treatments whether they are written by physicists or mathematicians.

If you have a Patreon or similar account, let us know!

PS: The Rieman zeta function page seems to be missing a few enclosing tags leading to non-typeset latex formulae after "This gives us a nice way to pick out terms from a Dirichlet series..." and also after the Von Mangoldt function.

enugu··on Using spaced repetition systems to see through a piece of mathematics (2019)
Here's a different proof of the identity just thinking of M, M* as operators (not as matrices). So, the invariant way of 'diagonalization by a unitary matrix' means that we have to find an orthonormal basis of eigenvectors. We can always find one eigenvalue λ and the complex numbers. The strategy is to choose one eigenvector v and say that its complement subspace is also preserved by the action of M. This complement subspace, being of lower dimension, already has an orthonormal basis by induction and this basis extended with v will be the required basis. This strategy can be done in a straightforward way if we assume M is hermitian M*=M (or symmetric matrix for real numbers). <v,w>=0 ⇒ <v,Mw>=<M*v,w>=<Mv,w>=0. So, M preserves the complement and the matrix is diagonlizable. This is the Spectral Theorem.

For a normal matrix, we have to choose the vector v which is simultaneously an eigenvector for M and M*. Then the proof still works as <v,w>=0 implies <v, Mw> = <M*v,w> = λ'<v,w>=0 where λ' is the eigenvalue of v with respect to M*.

We can find such a shared eigevector v as M, M* commute implies that M* will preserve the eigenspaces of M.

enugu··on We need scientific dissidents
You can encode halting of a program P as a comparison of a computable real number Q with a fixed number R by defining Q as 0.111..1 where each step of P adds one digit of 1 to Q’s expansion. P will halt iff Q is less than R=0.111…

Any subset of reals is ordered as it inherits the usual order from reals. The existence of well ordering (related to AOC) is difficult issue).

But the trichotomy of A>=<B does fail for a different but useful logic - remove the law of contradiction. There is a number e which is neither equal nor not equal to 0, with e^2=0. This leads to simplifications of concepts and proofs - you can define derivatives without limits for instance. This topic is studied in synthetic differential geometry.

But the real response to the comment ‘everything is just a word game’ is ‘just’ is not apt. You are free to fix rules of the game, once done you face questions which are possibly beyond your ability to answer. A person could run a program checking id Fermat equations had solutions in 1950’s. Only In 1990’s we know after great advances (like discovering a route between mountain ranges) that this program wont halt (or ZFC is inconsistent which would be even more surprising).

enugu··on How blind photographers visualize the world
There is also this recently discovered phenomena of aphantasia which is fascinating. Lot of people dont have mental images and grow up not even aware that others can form such images. Here's one interesting account.

https://m.facebook.com/nt/screen/?params=%7B%22note_id%22%3A...

enugu··on A new experiment casts doubt on the leading theory of the nucleus
Having an standard of truth is important as a reputation for an organization(whether for commercial or non-commercial reasons). Besides, click-baitiness is not sustainable as in the equilibrium, readers will change expectations to assume artices are click-baity and information on the real breakthroughs will have fight all the fake breakthroughs.

BTW, This is not about Quanta which I find is a really good resource. Although, there might indeed be some click-baitiness not with the motive of profit(you could describe it as a charity run by Jim Simons), but in the sense of someone trying to get students interested with a provocative title for a science talk.

enugu··on The Reddit blackout has left Google barren and full of holes
The cause seems to be software from private companies gets more resources for features, feedback, maintenance etc.

If that is correct, the obvious solution is generating some substantive funding for important open source projects which develop software and protocols for billions of users.

Of course, there are organizations already doing funding for open source projects, but maybe moving the scale of funding by a few orders of magnitude can help.

enugu··on Noise is all around us
Here's the video, https://www.facebook.com/DattaKriyaYogaPage/videos/541068743... There is a Kriya Yoga app also for DKY.
← PreviousPage 5 of 9Next →