HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

enugu

457 karma · joined February 12, 2016

Google email id : harshavr
submissionscomments
enugu··on What if we set GPT-4 free in Minecraft?
Actually, this comment makes sense and is used in logic to derive true but non-provable propositions withing the current axiom system assuming it is sound.

The problem is that you dont know if the checker that you use to detect if a program halts will itself halt on your given input or continue forever. But given a sound checker with some assumption, one can find non-halting programs which wont be detected by the checker using the diagonalization trick.

enugu··on Noise is all around us
There is a yoga kriya I learnt called "Dura Shravana"(Far Hearing) which is meant to help one zone out of the surrounding sounds and maintain focus. What one does is to place attention on the farthest sound from one's self then successively move to closer sounds in order culminating in the sound of one's breathing. And then, mentally recall the sounds in order. (For example, ambient background subtle sounds, car on road, bird outside window, neighbours door, the fridge, the breath). With practice, surrounding sounds dont affect you. If someone is interested, I can send a link to a teaching video. It is meant to be practiced after doing the alternate nostril pranayama as it enhances the effects of the pranayama.
enugu··on How to quit cars
Reading comments on this page, the problems with public transport are listed - not safe or clean or uncrowded enough.

But, the only alternative considered is private individual/family transport.

Why is private mass transport not more widely available given that it can solve a lot of these problems?

Having an Uber for buses which does smart scheduling based on current demand, possibly involving transfers so that frequent local routes connect with each other without long delays, should be possible.

Of course, prices will fall when things scale. So, the government can be involved as a facilitator but operations are mostly run by companies which can pay a fee to the government rent necessary infrastructure.

You still have the problem of higher prices for odd hours/locations but sharing costs ahould make it cheaper than uber.

enugu··on Bruce Schneier’s Plan to Reinvent Democracy
Something like the accountability interpretation has been championed by David Deutsch, who bases a lot of his thought on Karl Popper.

So voters kicking out an incumbent is seen as analogous to scientists abandoning a hypothesis after falsification by an experiment.

enugu··on My mindfulness practice led me to meltdown (2021)
As someone noticed, you are trying to say something similar the private language argument of Wittgenstein.

But notice that this isn’t really private to a person.

How are we sure about external events like a ball falling down? Are they not processed by our minds and then expressed in language. A ball falling down is fairly standardized and accessible, but for other events there is a lot more background which is needed. But human experience and culture is filled with phenomena which require a much larger shared context - which is acquired after walking in a shared territory. Like long time explorers of the seas who can have a a conversation on far away lands.

Explaining many current physical concepts or how to interpret the experiments which are conducted at a non-superficial level requires years of training (leave alone research). Even someone who finishes high school algebra is at a rarefied stage compared to people thousands of years ago.

Getting a shared context in meditation related explorations might actually require much lesser time.

For similar reasons, negative stages itself have been meticulously documented in manuals like Visuddhimaga which are referenced in the books mentioned in the article.(fwiw, my 2 cents on the article - maybe instead of promoting intense concentration on sensory phenomena, love based practices like bhakti or metta might be a better popular practice).

A good counter argument is that in the physics example there are gradual stages in learning where at each stage you can test what you learn and match it with the world, not spend 15 years of education to get to QFT and then match with experience.

But that ladder is present even in the case of traditions which explore the mind.

enugu··on Type constraints in 65 lines of SQL
Any idea of how to implement tagged unions in Postgres. For example, Tree a = Leaf a | Branch (Tree a, Tree a)

This is one data type feature which would be great to have. I know you can create separate tables for each option in the type and use an id, but is a direct type implementation possible?

Dont need polymorphism(say a = String). Even a non recursive tagged union would be helpful.

enugu··on Apache AGE, a PostgreSQL extension with graph database functionality
Wish Postgres had an optional data type (tagged union), Does someone know an extension which implements that?
enugu··on Noether's Theorem in a Nutshell (2020)
> * There is a function L(q,q'), the Lagrangian. How do I compute this function? Does it have an analytical expression? How does it depend on p or F?

L can be a function which changes with the system(a spring or a free particle will have different formulae), just like the Force in classical physics changes with the system. The goal here is to find properties independent of any particular expression for L only assuming that L is invariant under certain symmetries.

> * There is a parameter s, "sending q to some new position q(s)". Do you mean q is actually a function q(s)? Do I define q(s) any way I want, or do I solve q(s) given the constraints of the system?

There is a bit of overloading of notation which can cause some confusion, q is not a function of s, but s is a parameter for a symmetry Tₛ which moves points in the space, here the line (For example, Tₛ(q)= q+sv is the translations in the v direction parametrized by s). So, one can read q(s) as Tₛ(q) and d(q(s))/ds as the derivative d(Tₛ(q))/ds. For the translation, the derivative will be v at all points, but it can be different at different points for instance when we are in a plane and Tₛ(q) is rotating q around the origin by s units, then the derivative with respect to s will be a tangent vector to the circle containing q. This derivative vector field is called the infinitesimal symmetry, as the symmetry Tₛ is just the flow along the vector field.

BTW, you are in good company with your question. Many mathematicians and cs people also get confused with physics notation where the type of functions is not clear (where the domain and range of the function is not clear). This issue is prominent when deriving the Euler-Lagrange equations. Read the preface of the referenced book http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/gjs/6946/sicm-html/boo...

enugu··on Magnus Carlsen to give up World Championship title
How about a very short gap, say a week, after the Candidates tournament to the Championship match to avoid long opening preparations?
enugu··on What game are you playing?
Given that lot of politicking is socially damaging (but promotes interests of a person or a small group), it can be valid to feel good about not engaging in it(maybe not proud) - just like say one might feel good about being honest.

Of course, one can use political skills in a beneficial way(for which purpose it is worth learning). That is rare.

Secondly, being innocent or straightforward is itself a political strategy even if not deployed consciously. This signals that other people can read you directly and hence rely on your words and that you wont backstab etc. Societies which have this level of trustworthiness also tend to flourish.

enugu··on With Category Theory, Mathematics Escapes from Equality (2019)
> One does not need to learn anything about the foundations of mathematics to read and understand Lurie's work.

By foundations here, I didnt mean foundations of mathematics, rather the amount of material a student needs to read to become familiar with the basic definitions of what a space means. We can teach topology to undergrads, can we teach higher categorical notions of space? Even schemes themselves had a daunting reputation some time back, now we have derived stacks which involve infinite categories.

> You can just pick up Higher Topos Theory and start reading

Yes, but my point, as illustrated in SDG example, was that definitions can be easy or hard depending on which foundations you use. You havent mentioned whether you disagree with this and if you see Kock's book, I think you will agree.

When dealing with higher categories, a foundations which uses '=' symbol in a different way, with an equivalence relation(modelled on homotopy equivalence) playing a much more prominent role could make the theory much more natural.

Note, that I am not even emphasizing sets vs type theory here, but excluded middle and a good notion of equivalence(and equivalence between equivalences... like in homotopy theory) in the foundations.

Maybe a lot of this debate will get dissolved if we just use two different words for 'examining consistency of axioms' and 'naturality of theory as encoded in a given system' instead of using the same word - foundations - for both of them.

At the very least if discussions begin with an awareness of this distinct usage, there would be lot less talking past each other.

Urs Schreiber makes the same point about naturality here - https://golem.ph.utexas.edu/category/2016/03/foundations_of_...

enugu··on With Category Theory, Mathematics Escapes from Equality (2019)
Not downvoting,in particular there are useful links in your post.

But note that by foundations one has atleast two different meanings. One meaning being examining the consistency of axioms or finding weakest set of axioms for a theorem.

The other meaning being - finding a foundation in which a given mathematical theory is naturally and easily described, analogus to designing a programming language in which the programs are easy to describe.

Most of the time in mathematics, this is done by defining high level concepts and working from there - no need to change the foundational axioms or rules of inference.

But sometimes we need more - for instance, if you read the book "Synthetic Differential Geometry", infinitesimals are naturally embedded in the theory by working in a cartesian closed category of sets. One can either embed this in ZFC using cumbersome models, or change the logic itself(remove the law of excluded middle).

The logic in HOTT deals with equality in a more careful way than the usual foundations. This is not restricted to algebraic topology alone - it certainly includes algebraic geometry and tackles a general issue which will plausibly have many more applications once the technology is available. The field of noncommutative geometry, in the style of Connes, is also about this as the problem of taking quotients is another way of the stating the issue with equality.

It is a work in progress and might take some time before bearing substantive fruit, but note that the current alternative is that any student learning higher level mathematics at the level of Lurie's books has to go through a huge amount of foundational material while the ideas themselves may not be intrinsically complicated. Instead, this complexity is an artifact of embedding the theory in current foundations like the SDG example mentioned above.

With a new foundations, there is the possibility that we can teach the material at this level to students except that there are some tweaks in foundations.

enugu··on Microsoft is tied to hundreds of millions of dollars in foreign bribes
Election money is important but the role it plays is somewhat different.

Politicians do often woo companies to come to their sate.

A job (particulary a well paying one) creates a lot of economic activity and can make that region prosperous. Politicians want this both for votes created due to prosperity but more importantly, once the region becomes rich, they have more money for their social schemes and freebies which is a prominent part of how they come to power. Not to speak of more bribes obtained in richer areas.

enugu··on Microsoft is tied to hundreds of millions of dollars in foreign bribes
One issue in India is that local governance at level of cities and towns is very weak(very few know who the equivalent of the mayor of their city is). The state(as in say US states, not federal level) government basically runs the show.

So, the state government does woo corporations with incentives to come to their state, but once the company reaches the level of permissions and deals with local officials who are looking for a cut(and in general, it is hard to fire these officials), the companies have to face the bribes process.

You can transfer bureaucrats even if you cant fire them(and this does happen though sometimes for the wrong reasons). But the bribe network also involves local politicians.

The intractable issue is that the journey to power of the top leaders in the state government involves taking support of local level leaders who either have some local support base or money which can be used for campaigning. In return, these local leaders demand a cut of bribe money which the top leader is obliged to allow or else risk losing their support.

Of course, this is not an all encompassing explanation and some leaders are much worse(corrupt far beyond any political necessity) and some better.

enugu··on Summary of Atomic Habits
There is a role for summaries with different levels of detail. The short capsule summaries are useful(for one thing, it is easier to remember) and your link itself is a great example.

But, there is also a role for longer summaries, which are still short relative to the book, but include useful points and some of the illustrative examples not present in the shorter summaries. Reading a 250 page book has ample scope for the mind to wander and lose track of the important issues which is not an issue with a 10 page summary.

Further, summaries at this level are less available, and it would be a good thing if more books had such summaries. (The downside being people might be more likely to skip the original book and the author is not rewarded - this can be corrected to an extent if the author themselves give these shorter summaries at the end of the book or as a separate short book. Also, some others might be motivated to get the original book after reading the summary).

enugu··on The quest to build a general-purpose thought decoder
That was a fascinating article, I liked how you covered the human element in how it helps the paralyzed and the intuitions/visuals of the researchers in the field.

Future applications can be good or bad, but of course that makes it even more important to record the early history of the field and these kind of articles will also help in start the ethics discussion at an earlier stage.

enugu··on The Problem of Evil (2015)
This is indeed a standard response. But one issue is that courts do make exceptions for provably insane persons from being convicted of crimes. Nor do they punish accidental deaths as severely as intentional crimes.

When all actions are an outcome of environment(inherited or cultural), the non-trivial issue is to make a clear demarcation in different kinds of influence on a person who commits a crime.

A natural process which flows through conscious reasoning and motivation is different from a uncontrollable malfunction in the mind.

enugu··on The Problem of Evil (2015)
You can imagine a robot actively planning to cause damage to others. The fact that this it is programmed doesnt change that it is an evil act. We can see evil as a property of action rather than an agent - this means we dont need to involve free will. But it does mean we have to account for intention.
enugu··on Notes for courses taken at Harvard (2015-2019)
Thanks for linking to such a great resource. I am somewhat awed by how much he has learned in his undergrad years.

Also, thanks to other posters too. The two other notes sites are also great.

enugu··on An Elementary Introduction to Information Geometry [pdf]
Great post.

Equation 20 defining curvature has a typo in the first term on the right - It should be ∇_X∇_Y Z instead of ∇_X∇_Y X. Might be useful for anyone reading it the first time to avoid confusion.

enugu··on A Child’s Guide to Spinors (2016) [pdf]
Thanks for posting this! For someone introduced to spinors via Clifford algebras, with the applications to physics distant, this was very helpful to read.

Some small points - The remarks on 'double cover' in Section 5 can be improved. 'Double cover' usually doesnt refer to the dimension of the vector space which the groups acts on, but rather the geometric fact there is map from SU(2) to SO(3) which takes 2 points to a single point. For example see, https://indico.cern.ch/event/243629/attachments/415251/57698... Writing SO(4) as SU(2)+SU(2) also doesnt make sense for this reason.

The simplest example of double cover being the map z → z^2 for unit circle in complex plane or in terms of angles θ → 2θ. This also relates to the 'square root' and 'half' remark in the first paragraph of Introduction. The general definiton of 'covering space' in a topology text book can be useful to read.

Also, I think there is a typo in RHS of Eqn 3.1.2.

But again, this was really helpful to read for someone who learnt the formal definition long time ago and was out of touch with spinors.

enugu··on Indian robot climbs trees to harvest coconuts
If you want to read more about this, please look at the 11th chapter of James Tooley's book https://www.amazon.in/Beautiful-Tree-James-Tooley/dp/0670083... on "the uprooting of the Beautiful Tree". Tooley was researching low cost private schools in different parts of Asia and Africa.

He follows up the references in Dharampal in British Home Office records, which catalog the reports sent on native education by collectors to the governor Thomas Munro (including 'caste' statistics).

Tooley also read the work of Andrew Bell, on how mass education in Britain and later Europe was strongly influenced by what Rev Andrew Bell(who had come to Madras to manage a school) learnt about the methods of peer learning in native schools in Madras.

Dharampal's book is available online for free, and Arvind Neelakantan has a review of Tooley's book.

Some other disagreements, its not just 'few kings' but majority. The 'priest' claim is also not true. Majority of the mathas in say Karnatak and TN are run by non-brahmins, and there are plenty of pujaris from other jatis, not that that is a position of social privilege given how poorly paid they are and difficulty in getting married.

enugu··on Indian robot climbs trees to harvest coconuts
Education statistics were compiled in the British era, and these were referenced by Dharampal in his book 'The Beautiful Tree' which records the extensive education present in South India. Like a lot of claims, this doesnt stand up.

Nor does the claim of 'caste system started in colonial era' make sense.

Aside: For people interested in learning more about what I am talking about, read up Nicholas Dirks, Balagangadhara or Jalki, Pathan.

In short, hierarchies existed between different groups in India, but these do not follow a 'ancient thousand year old varna system'. For instance, Majority of the kings(and dominant land owning jatis to this day) are not Kshatriyas,(nor Brahmins or Vaishya) who were initiated into thread ceremony. This includes famous Hindu kings like Vijayangara era Hakka/Bukka who came from shepherd jatis.

enugu··on Video Games Are the Future of Education
Just played it and it was quite fun in the begining. Skipped ahead to fractions via blue path, an issue which came up was it was easy to travel into dead paths endlessly navigating the sea or running around. Went back to beginning of level and turning right instead of left cleared that issue. Another issue was that when moving back after an unproductive path, it is hard to see what was behind the character, you cant see a wall until you hit it. Moving the camera back helps.

But the game itself seemed very interesting.

enugu··on Friendly Feudalism: The Tibet Myth (2003)
Just the existence of mass movements like the above(which is not isolated) refutes the Buddhism -> karma -> fatalistic acceptance that was postulated in the first comment try to establish a link with tyrannical governments.

Just living in any of these countries, one will see the constant effort of people, even hustling, to get ahead in life, far from any fatalistic conceptions one might have about their life.

I can, in fact, think of other examples of worse brutality, even in the last few centuries, for instance the American slave system and treatment of labourers in Congo. Not quite the same extent, but still terrible, the British had an indentured labour system transporting Indians whose local lands were devastated by colonial rule. I wouldnt casually attribute these to religion of the westerners.

enugu··on Friendly Feudalism: The Tibet Myth (2003)
OTOH, I am surprised that a comment like this is first on the page.

Lets look at some of your points

> 'not despite Buddhism but because of it.'

This is your main thesis and to support this you say -

> At least these two make a point of encouraging charity and kindness towards others.

Directly, (not subtly), implying that Buddhism does not do this.

A basic search would give you something like the basic virtues of Buddhist teachings - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brahmavihara and how these virtues are popularized via stories where the protagonist gives up lives to save tiger cubs or say, the story of Angulimala.

Note that there is no condemnation of non-believers to eternal hell - a belief which has caused tremendous violence and looks at lot of cultures as essentially devil's work- a belief is still not repudiated today (it cant as it is a core doctrine).

Also, modern industrialized societies are still having a hard time accepting an elementary insight that animals can suffer intensely and creating montrosities where this is noted quite early in Buddhist and similar traditions.

> misfortunes such as being born poor (or worse) are seen as being justified somehow

Another point you bring up is karma and the word you use is 'justified'. When a thief or a killer attacks and causes suffering to a Buddhist, they might take it as the result of past bad karma, but that doesnt make the action 'justified'. Indeed, that action itself generates bad karma. A ruler inflicting suffering on people also gets bad karma.

The notion that people are fatalistic about misfortune is false can be seen at multiple levels -

Firstly, at the whole point of the tradition itself is to overcome karma, secondly, popular cultures are filled with practices aimed at changing karma.

At the political level, try reading James Scott on how peasants resisted states which became tyrannical https://www.amazon.com/Art-Not-Being-Governed-Anarchist/dp/0...

A more subtle but important point is that 'justification' is bringing in a different framework - the notion of normative ethics which is inherited from Christianity - whereas the concept of karma is seen more like a natural property like a bodily sickness.

enugu··on Two Forms of Mathematical Beauty
Thanks for the comment, was an interesting lookup and I learnt something. Have to figure how it connects to optics/ML.
enugu··on India builds detention camps for up to 1.9M people not on citizens register
Bengalis were attacked, but Hindus were specifically singled out by the Pakistan Army. Just look at the sources.
enugu··on India builds detention camps for up to 1.9M people not on citizens register
India is far from being a fascist ethnostate, unless you have been reading media reports which are filled with false details and crucial ommisions. In fact, there are colonial laws which prevent Hindus from even running temples or schools without being taken over by the state. Also, they are routinely the targets of violence which dont come to prominence in western media reports.

One of the outcomes of this post is that the extreme bias in reporting in the media has reached HN. For any Hindus reading this, stop responding emotionally and instead try to document the various kinds of bias in media thoroughly. People like Vamsee Juluri have written about coverage of Hindu issues in prominent western media. Anand Ranganathan has logs of media bias on incidents of violence etc.

enugu··on India builds detention camps for up to 1.9M people not on citizens register
Exactly, so it is a good thing that Hindus who have emigrated from an actual genocide(not a speculation) with scant notice in major media both in India and abroad, are finally getting a chance at citizenship

Given the opposition, the CAA law might be struck down. The absurdity of much of this thread is that measures which help active victims of genocide are being opposed.

The book Blood Telegram, by Gary Bass about a state department memo, documents one aspect of how this genocide was buried. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Blood_Telegram:_Nixon,_Kis...

← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →