HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

epistemer

222 karma · joined January 17, 2023

submissionscomments
epistemer··on The plateauing of cognitive ability among top earners
It also disregards the type of lottery game that is a part of wealth accumulation.

Of course, it is not all luck but to believe wealth accumulation is a type of purely deterministic meritocratic game without a giant stochastic factor is ridiculous.

That might even be the dumbest aspect of our society. Believing the powerball lottery winner is a genius for picking the numbers they picked is obviously stupid. Yet we basically have that view with everything else besides the actual lottery.

epistemer··on Effective altruism has a sexual harassment problem, women say
A big problem is we have gone from Feynman saying "science is the disbelief in experts" to "What experts say is true right now is the science".
epistemer··on Effective altruism has a sexual harassment problem, women say
I was pretty into that level of skepticism but all it really showed me is that people are natural "believers".

We are ultimately story telling apes. To believe we are going to stop telling each other and ourselves fictional stories is the height of delusion. There is this highly negative aspect too when you start believing the fictional story is actually non-fiction. That opens up all kinds of additional problems that is actually solved at the society level by believing in fiction like religion.

I am a total atheist but it seems really stupid to me to not see the role fiction plays in coordinating society. That level of skepticism was overly focused on the individual with near disregard for collections of individuals at the level of society.

epistemer··on MIT engineers develop a new way to remove carbon dioxide from air (2019)
I would think it all depends on the initial energy source.

This is just one of the myriad of ways our malinvestment in cheap nuclear energy condemns us to try to build a type of perceptual motion machine.

epistemer··on Critique of the mind/body problem
I suspect people of the future will view our view of the jumble of heuristics as a type of medieval place holder for the "soul".

Most people are just interchanging the word "consciousness" in place of "soul" but meaning exactly the same thing. Leaving the door open for something to persist after death while fooling themselves with more scientific sounding language for a medieval belief.

One is either alive or dead. There is no such property of "aliveness". One is either conscious or unconscious. There is no such property of "consciousness".

It is just such an unpalatable belief but I would think that is partially because belief in the soul is a defense against psychopathy at the level of society. I am not sure we could form such large societies without belief in the soul.

epistemer··on Ask HN: What can you do or learn to experience a better love life?
All you have to do is get use to initiating conversation with strangers out and about.

People have no problem swiping literally every person on Tinder/bumble but I have had lovers specifically tell me that no one ever hits on them in person. "Hitting" on them meaning starting exactly the same "get to know you" conversation in person that would be done on a dating app.

There is literally this dating app called "real life" that all single people are on but 99% of suitors are blindly swiping left no matter what.

epistemer··on The paper that made ChatGPT possible
If anything this is why someone like LeCun isn't good at shipping a product people want.

It seems like we lack a word in English for knowing too much about a subject that you can't see the forest for the trees.

To say chatGPT is not revolutionary is as good an example of not seeing the forest for the trees that I can think of.

epistemer··on The paper that made ChatGPT possible
IMO you should just start playing with them. Midjourney gave by far the most impressive results with images but I also got bored fast with seeing amazing art.

chatGPT you just have to interact with it and get a feel for its strengths and weakness.

epistemer··on MDMA and psilocybin are approved as medicines in Australia
We really need this to be legal someplace in the world. Fentanyl at this point makes any street pill an insane proposition to me.

I am surprised a country hasn't already embraced a type of psychedelic and MDMA drug tourism.

Fentanyl ultimately changes any moral argument for keeping these drugs illegal.

It is really completely immoral at this point to be nudging people towards fentanyl overdosing.

epistemer··on MDMA and psilocybin are approved as medicines in Australia
5 grams is the idiotic recommendation from Terence McKenna that people blindly follow because he was a good writer and had an almost psychedelic stand up routine with public speaking. He was basically a type of cult leader.

It is absolutely terrible advice. The advice should be "less is more" not this McKenna "heroic dose" bullshit like some kind of dosage sport.

epistemer··on MDMA and psilocybin are approved as medicines in Australia
You must have not thought this through very hard to believe it wouldn't be a net good.

I mean we are in a crisis of opiates with fentanyl.

It would be a massive net good.

epistemer··on Stop developing this technology
The idea technology is completely neutral is obviously stupid and obviously wrong.

Neil Postman has two amazing books on this subject.

It is not even that technology is good or bad, any technology will have good and bad aspects but the main issue is that we have surrendered culture and agency to technology as a society.

There is no going back or fix now. The fix for all was a culture that devalues bad uses of technology so that there is no money in creating something shitty. We basically have the opposite of that. Even completely useless technology is worth a ton of money because of our culture.

The solution is not Luddism either. Especially a ridiculous techno-Luddism.

For me, the Faustian bargain with technology has already been signed in blood and there is nothing to do other than enjoy the roller coaster ride.

epistemer··on How to control your smart home without yelling at a dumb voice assistant
All this to me is pure technological kitsch and bullshit.

My coffee maker has had automation built in for years, it makes a ton of sense for it to automatically make coffee in the morning yet even for free I have never used it even once.

The light switch? Give me a break.

epistemer··on Show HN: AI Cover Letter Writer
I think people underestimate how often their cover letter is a negative even without this.

I wouldn't doubt that often the cover letter causes people to be eliminated in about 5 seconds because it says the same meaningless bullshit that HR has read a 100 times already that day.

epistemer··on Connecticut parents arrested for letting kids walk to Dunkin' Donuts
There is no going back though. No politician is going to risk repealing this type of law and then have their career destroyed when a single crime happens against a kid that this law would have "prevented".

People bashing the cops for this is bullshit too. The cops are the bad guys either way. They enforce the law and they are the bad guys. Something happens to a kid with this law in place and then they are also the bad guy for not doing their job.

The solution to all this is simply to not have children. It is just another of the near daily reminders of how great it is to be child free.

epistemer··on ChatGPT Plus
$20 is completely reasonable to me.

I have come to see it as a brilliant savant friend that loves to tell bullshit stories.

At first , I was hung up on the bullshit stories but the brilliant ideas are so good that I can put up with the bullshit.

I am at the point that if I am thinking about something I want to know what my crazy friend thinks of it too.

A totally moronic use case I have tried is writing one liners about marriage in the style of Rodney Dangerfield.

prompt: Write a one liner about marriage in the style of Dangerfield

"I told my wife she was drawing her eyebrows too high. She looked surprised."

I think it is a stolen joke from the internet but the level of understanding from such sparse language is astounding to me.

epistemer··on An astonishing regularity in student learning rate
Jim Simons is a great example. Has made 28 billion from algorithmic trading, has Chern–Simons form named after him in math but has said he sucks at computer programming because he can't remember syntax well enough.

If he was 50 years younger he probably would just be a very mediocre programmer and not have "wasted" his time with this other intellectual activity.

Einstein would be a data entry clerk trying to get a job writing javascript.

I suspect with so many more educated people we have so many more true genius level minds than a 100 years ago but we have narrowed economically useful intellectual life to such a degree that 99% of them are doing well paid sub-optimal bullshit with their genius unexpressed.

epistemer··on Market headed for a 'tinderbox-timebomb' worse than the 1929 crash
This is typical bad financial journalism. Spitznagel is not "predicting" this.

Jennifer Sor either has no clue what Spitznagel is doing or knows no one will click on a headline about tail hedging unpredictable events.

epistemer··on Is remote work bad for the economy?
IMO this whole nonsense argument stems from poor high school economics education and not teaching Schumpeter in high school.

Per Schumpeter a 100 years ago, the economy is an ever changing process from technological change and entrepreneurship.

Of course remote work is going to have good and bad aspects that come with the change.

Practically the golden rule of economics is that everything is a trade off.

epistemer··on Is AM radio dead?
If you try to tune to AM stations though it is literally 90% noise.

It may as well be dead because if you removed the regulation it would still be 90% noise.

epistemer··on Do we live in a society without a counterculture?
The whole argument is stupid on both sides.

There is no "mainstream" culture anymore to counter. Everyone is living in their own little cultural bubble that they believe to be a counterculture to a non-existent mainstream culture.

The hysterical thing is the OP said what they said exactly because everyone knows someone would respond with your exact rhetorical devices like an automaton or a bot.

epistemer··on BioGPT: A language model pre-trained on large-scale biomedical literature
I have had experiences like this several times also so it is interesting to look at an example from someone else.

Probing it about CenPCA it gave these two definitions:

"CenPCA is an abbreviation for Centralized Principal Component Analysis. It is a dimensionality reduction technique used in data analysis for compressing high-dimensional data into a lower-dimensional representation. The centralization step of CenPCA involves centering the data, making the first principal component aligned with the mean of the data. This makes it possible to capture the overall structure of the data and to highlight the most important patterns in the data set. CenPCA has been used in various applications such as finance, image processing, and bioinformatics to analyze large and complex datasets."

"CenPCA refers to "Centered PCA", which is a variant of Principal Component Analysis (PCA), a widely used method in machine learning and data analysis. The key difference between regular PCA and centered PCA is that in centered PCA, the data is first centered around the mean before performing the PCA, while in regular PCA, the mean is not subtracted from the data. This has implications in the interpretation of the results, as centered PCA can sometimes provide more meaningful principal components."

I would think there has to be something to this but it is confusing exact titles although I have had it make up python code that simply is nonsense also.

Another type of example I had was during a language philosophy discussion it recommended the paper:

"Language Evolution: The Hard Problems" by Morten H. Christiansen and Simon Kirby is a paper that explores some of the challenges and limitations of current theories of language evolution."

It was actually just a book called "Language Evolution" by Morten H. Christiansen and Simon Kirby but trying to find that exact paper title made me think it made it up.

I am tending towards becoming addicted to it still after massive frustration with it for things like this at first. It seems you just have to be careful when probing the outer edges of knowledge and to not get led down these nonsense paths.

epistemer··on Spotify is first music streaming service to surpass 200M paid subscribers
The old music business thrived on vinyl then 8 track then cassettes then CDs.

$15 in 1985 is about $40 adjusted for inflation and they convinced people to buy the same music multiple times. To even find that music you liked enough to buy multiple times too you probably bought 5 albums that you thought sucked.

I can remember as a kid in the 80s too that my father and all his friends easily had 500+ vinyl albums on display in their homes. Then those started collecting dust as they bought hundreds of cds.

It is just so different now. Imagine spending $40 bucks for 10 songs and have no idea if you will even like them. That is a totally different racket.

epistemer··on Peter Thiel: Address and Q&A – Oxford Union
I use to enjoy Peter's talks but he seems to be a bit out of new ideas himself.
epistemer··on Beta Testers required for my book-recommendation website
Interesting, I like that clicking on Thinking, Fast and Slow recommends Barry Schwartz and Judgment under Uncertainty. Still though, I would probably just stick with "Customers who viewed this item also viewed" on Amazon as it feels like wider recommendations are in that group than what the algorithm is recommending here.

What I really want with any recommendation system is more control with how wide or narrow the net is cast. Some genres/subjects I have completely over fished and need a really wide net. Something like Russian literature though you could just recommend me Dostoevsky because I don't know much of anything about the subject.

epistemer··on UK expected to be only major economy to shrink in 2023 – IMF
The economy is so high dimensional as to be basically stochastic but people like to make up bullshit stories about this stochastic process?

Of course that is not satisfactory. "The market went down because of X". For whatever reason people need to read that even knowing that X is nonsense.

Not to mention, it was only like 3 weeks ago that every outlet was predicting a global recession. This prediction is almost certainly wrong as well.

epistemer··on I made a website for lonely people, and got >100 people to log their locations
A person claiming to be lonely because they are too smart/wealthy/good looking sounds incredibly narcissistic. I highly doubt that is actually the issue with their loneliness.
epistemer··on Ask HN: What's the best lecture series you've seen?
That Sapolsky class is one of my favs as well.

Anything I have watched from Open Yale has been fantastic too. I feel like they have done a great job of curation and not just creating a list of random new class recordings.

https://oyc.yale.edu/courses

epistemer··on The high cost of expensive housing and how Auckland fixed it
It just isn't that complicated to build a bunch of smaller cheap homes and pass a law that says you can't buy one these types of homes if you already own other property. You can't own these homes within a corporate structure. A single family home for a single family.

This wouldn't be much different than the post WW2 construction boom.

The difference now though is we all know the system is so captured that this could never happen in the US. Wallstreet would never let this happen. There would be bullshit arguments about market efficiency and how this would be harmful to single families. The right political palms would be greased and the whole idea would be dead on arrival.

Problem solving at this level is literally a type of kayfabe from Pro Wrestling style performance art in 2023.

epistemer··on Internal Tech Emails: Mark Zuckerberg: “VR / AR Strategy”
I don't see how AR will be useful without face recognition. The killer app is something like I go get a coffee and instantly know the barista's real name and they know my real name from AR face recognition.

People are not interested though in that level of personal interaction.

VR with a headset is an obvious dead end. The real litmus test is that blind people find VR interesting. It is incredible how we have solved basically nothing in this space and still only have a better version of VRML.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →