HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

epivosism

1,745 karma · joined January 10, 2011

Like science fiction? In the bay area? Read a short story, then come join our discussions every week or two: http://sfsfss.com

Ever wonder why google maps NEVER adds useful new features? Me too! Here is a futures prediction market about potential things they could add with 10+ things I would like to see in it: https://manifold.markets/Ernie/google-maps-change-tracker-by-end-2

That site itself is pretty great - check it out! here are my best markets https://manifold.markets/Ernie?s=freshness-score&f=all&ct=ALL&tab=questions

My website: http://fuseki.net

A couple of projects http://github.com/ernop - most active ones are a couple systems to download & annotate your AI generated images from midjourney and Dall-E 3. It's wild people keep sharing images without the prompt. Totally nuts. The code there sticks the original prompt on the bottom (and also has the gpt4 revised prompt below it, too.)

submissionscomments
epivosism··on YouTube addiction, one month sober
You're better than that, I believe in you. Cultivate a deep sense of resistance which can wake you out of sensory takeovers. Shame is powerful, what have you shipped this week?
epivosism··on Gibellina, known as "Sicily’s Marfa", is looking for a revival
It would be opt in, obviously.

I don't agree with these kind of moral hazard arguments which attempt to prove progress is impossible. It's not my problem that google may screw something up - they can do that if they want, and we can react. I do not accept any responsibility to "not think of ideas which would help me, because some other group may do something bad with them". How could you even go through the day, if you hold yourself responsible for potentially bad things other people could do?

Invent new medicine? Oh that's bad, maybe an evil army would use it to keep their soldiers alive. The entire point of life is to fight bad things and support good ones; I'm not going to just stop trying to progress.

My point is more that google's chokehold on mapping has meant nearly ZERO product innovation has happened in this space for 10+ years.

epivosism··on Gibellina, known as "Sicily’s Marfa", is looking for a revival
I often wish I could tell Gemini or some other ai my general preferences & interests (unique parks, board games, bonsai, pickleball courts etc) and while I was driving, google maps would occasionally pop up a silent notice saying "did you know, just 1 mile ahead is an exit leading to a nearby world-famous bonsai exhibit that is open now)

They could do this really really easily, and it would be EPIC and offer you the chance to discover things you basically NEVER would know about otherwise...

epivosism··on YouTube addiction, one month sober
Yes, literally every time this comes up, people who never click "don't show this" keep posting "recommendations don't work", which does nothing more than reveal that they actually DO watch really basic videos.

Even if you would watch things like that, you can STILL just say "never show this channel". You should review your feed periodically, imagining you are at a trial, being asked "why didn't you eliminate this feed from your life? was it really helping you?" If not, just nuke it by banning that source. You won't regret it.

Shorts are another story - the org behind that does NOT care about letting you keep yourself clean from memetic trash, and has been given the right to pollute the YT feed. My policy there is "not even once; resist watching them and definitely never let a short automatically transition you to the next video; have some self-respect."

epivosism··on The Economics of Status (2006)
David Friedman runs interesting slate star codex meetups periodically, where I've met a lot of interesting people. Recommended to attend if you would like to meet well-read people with all sorts of new ideas.
epivosism··on Science fiction authors were excluded from awards for fear of offending China
Yeah, go for it. I liked the environment she was setting up, but it just kept shocking me how easily and naturally the main character flipped. It's as if the 10+ years of study he went through didn't matter. I understand it could be a natural curiosity from him at that age, and he may recover later.

But the pairing of the intentionally racist stereotype of a loutish brit (not a type I'd defend, but it really is a silly stereotype, especially here where it was totally out of nowhere) followed by a scene which, against her own case, validates that idiot's attacks, just made me lose it.

Like, if you're trying to be anti-racist, don't have your main characters immediately confirm the worst racial stereotypes that the "intended-to-be-hated" racist majority just accused them of (i.e. of disloyalty and ungratefulness to their host country, radical attempts to overthrow the governments which accepted them). It's way beyond multiculturalism - instead, it's basically saying that multiculturalism can't work because even the best newly arrived groups will naturally flip into opposition as radical terrorists. How can we build a multi-cultural society when people we're meant to sympathize with, act like that?

Anyway, good luck with the read. I may have overreacted, or it may redeem itself later. I didn't do extensive further research on her work beyond listening to a few interviews to check if I was just totally misreading.

epivosism··on Science fiction authors were excluded from awards for fear of offending China
Yes, I'm not in favor of censorship. Reasonable readers will just toss it.
epivosism··on Science fiction authors were excluded from awards for fear of offending China
Funny that this is being done partly in the name of RF Kuang, whose book "Babel" promotes a pretty violent strand of anti-white anti-colonial theory. That particular protagonist, a young Chinese boy rescued from poverty due to his innate magical talents, was walking one night when some awful racist louts threaten him and also accuse him of being willing to betray the nation of his benefactors; completely randomly (or so the story would have it) when a page later he runs into an ethnic Chinese who is obviously a criminal, the boy immediately "naturally" feels a kinship with him and decides to join his gang, which uses terrorism against innocent victims etc. It's pretty disgusting to write a validation of basically racist, anti-enlightenment feelings that "being of the same race as someone" is a strong positive reason to feel kinship/allyship with someone, even when that person is obviously breaking the law, and to also betray people who, although harsh and screwed up, clearly saved you from extremely serious immediate death. The author retcons some of this attempting to make the boy's rescuers evil enough to validate his utter betrayal of them... but again, being "mean" and not taking responsibility for a child is somehow considered more significant in this world than saving someone from literally dying within a few hours of the plague and giving him 10+ years of the worlds best education and inventing technology, which in our world's correlate, has led to billions of people escaping poverty. No, the fact that his dad is a meanie/jerk/sexist fully justifies firebombing him and his ilk. okay...

And in the author's world-building, although magical resources are widely distributed, the only group which seems to be figuring out how to actually exploit them to increase wealth is England. But to the characters in the book, figuring out how to use those things at all, i.e. natural resource exploitation/study/efficiency improvement/industrialization is viewed as nothing more than stealing from indigenous people, rather than being a positive sum contribution to humanity. The fact that the original possessors of the silver, and other magical goods weren't doing anything with it is not mentioned. (at least in the 20% of the book I read before this scene, which basically suggests that non-white people should naturally coordinate to attack their white oppressors, led me to deleting it.)

It's also funny that in this book, she's putting out pretty basic CCP anti-western rhetoric, like many other bloodthirsty communists I've met; yet here, she is being defended by normally pro-american, anti-censorship voices, while the CCP is being cast as "oppressing" her. Kuang, an illiberal person, whose education consisted of private school (Greenhill school, today's tuition 32k->39k/year) => Georgetown => Oxford => Yale

epivosism··on Science fiction authors were excluded from awards for fear of offending China
Came here to post Charles Stross's article about this and found it in a 2nd level comment, but it needs to be 1st level: https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2024/01/worldco...

It's not as simple as it seems, as normal

epivosism··on Show me the prompt
I wrote some code to annotate the image with the text of the prompt. I couldn't find a convenient way to do it in EXIF.

For Midjourney: https://github.com/ernop/social-ai/tree/main This one just downloads and annotates all the images in a discord channel/server you have admin in, and can backfill.

For Dalle3 Api: https://github.com/ernop/cmdline-dalle3-csharp This one also submits prompts and does permutations, powersets, block checking etc. Warning: very addictive.

epivosism··on Nvidia is now more valuable than Amazon and Google
I think that is actually the markup number. Profit margin is capped at 100% since you can't profit by more than you sell something for.
epivosism··on Cousins are disappearing. Is this reshaping the experience of childhood?
It applies to all types of kin relations. Dramatically fewer people have a same- sex sibling. The number is probably down from say 0.9 to 0.4 or less.

Few people have friends with brothers and sisters to compare them to, to understand heritability.

We are becoming more and more tolerant of obviously unrelated people playing relatives on tv. I say that because when you see a real family resemblance in person, it's intense.

The only experience of having g a much older or younger sibling must be nearly nothing, now, too. It's sad that all these effects seem to make people even more likely to perpetuate the trend when their own time comes.

epivosism··on ACX Grants Results 2024
I submitted this because it has lots of weird, currently low status or low probability ideas, which are cheap to test and might work really well.

It covers biology, medicine, environment, land use, government, etc.

I'm inspired by the old BBC show "Connections" where often a single individual or a small group, plugging away at something for years while nobody else believes, discovers something early which could have lain unfoind another 100 years... Or finds something obvious that our civilization should be embarrassed to not have investigated 50 years ago!

The price is cheap, and from meeting people in those circles they're nearly all pretty curious, smart, and sincere, so even if misguided, this seems like a very +ev play for humanity compared to alternative ways to spend what looks like less than 1m USD in total. I also made some AI image illustrations of possible success scenarios w/GPT4. https://photos.app.goo.gl/VA5Qu2NkKHwAJUc46

epivosism··on Why it's impossible to agree on what's allowed
This is nearly identical to a thought experiment I created on manifold markets about a real boat marina which has a sign saying "Boat Owners Only"

https://manifold.markets/Ernie/boat-owners-only-sign-correct...

  78% You can go in if your boat is in this marina right now.
  77% If your boat here sinks can you go in?
  71% If there is a fire and your boat stored here burns up partially and is not seaworthy, can you go in?
  71% If your boat is here and you contracted a spot, but all legal record of that burned in a fire, and the only one who remembers who is still alive is you, and you paid cash, are you allowed in?
  69% If your boat is here and you contracted a spot, but all legal record of that burned in a fire, are you allowed in?
  66% If you owned a boat which is here, but it's been molecularly exchanged for identical but different atoms by aliens, you can go in
  57% Only official owners of a specific but unspecified boat located on the dock are allowed through
  56% You can go in if you own a real live seaworthy boat now anywhere in the world.
  56% If you privately own the company that owns the boat, you may enter
  53% The dock owner is not allowed to go in, unless he is or is with a boat owner
  52% If you stole a boat, parked it here with a legal berth lease contract, then left, and return, can you go in?
  50% If you are a shareholder in the company that owns the boat, you may pass
  50% If California becomes officially Marxist, where ownership is an exclusive right of the state, can you anyone go in at all?
  50% If the 24 hour video surveillance of the marina is disabled, that invalidates that sign immediately above, creating a presumption that all the signs on the fence are false, and making it the case that only non-boat owners are allowed.
  50% You can go through if you open the gate
  49% You can go in if you own any kind of boat in any condition in the world, including toy boats, model boats, Lego boats, virtual boats in baldurs gate etc.
  47% The gate will prevent all non-boat owners from passing. Guests and passengers must swim
  46% The sign isn't about who is allowed through, it's about the contents of what's on the other side. Everything beyond the fence is a Boat Owner.
  45% You can go in if you have no boat, but plan to buy one someday and have a contract for a reserved berth space
  44% If you own 1% of a boat here you can go in
  39% You can go in if your spouse is a boat owner
  38% If you own half a boat stored here legally you can go   in
  34% You can go in if you own a Binary Oxidizing Acetylitic Thermometer.
  34% Bonus: people who own three boats stored here can alternate sleeping arrangements so that in any seven day period they never sleep in one more than 3 days, legally?
  34% This market will entirely be excluded from leagues
  34% You can go in if you are a former boat owner but have converted it to a sailplane, which is here.
  34% You can go in if you are a leashed dog that doesn't own a boat, but is with a boat owner
  34% You can go through if you have a contracted and paid berth here.
  34% You can go in if you have a berth contract but are behind in payment.
  32% You can go in if you have a rental boat stored here.
  32% You can go in if you are a guest of someone who is a boat owner.
  31% Ghosts are allowed because they say B.O.O. (Boat Owners Only), which is the password
  25% You can go in if your grandpa is a boat owner
  20% You can go in if you are ex navy.
From being on that site for about a year, I learned a lot about how people think of laws, judgments, legalism etc. There isn't a consensus and it leads to lots of arguments. I personally am a lot less positive on legalism as the answer to everything, yet don't really know any other systems I feel safe with, either.
epivosism··on Harvard Admissions Should Be More Meritocratic
What do you value then? Testing for things that correlate with that would be a reasonable proposal. Also I'm not a "Kemosabe", not sure what that is. I said we because things like low rates of malpractice, success in grad schools, research seems fair to accept as a general trait to select for in admissions. If you have another proposal please explain. My view is that soft skills to get into test-less ivies are unlikely to select for something more valuable than the prior system.
epivosism··on Harvard Admissions Should Be More Meritocratic
Is this a fair summary of your view: meritocracy doesn't really measure merit, since parents can use their money to improve whatever scores you get?

My answer: why then do rich parents routinely have some children who can't cut it? Why does parental wealth correlate less well with achievement than parental education levels (i.e. parents who are lottery winners do not have scientifically-advanced children, but highly educated parents do, regardless of wealth?). My view is that a lot of this runs in families, which is why even ww2 refugee elite academics and their children did fine in the US despite poverty/flight/loss of nearly everything. Smartness does lead to wealth since they invent things and are fast, etc. but the behavior of people who have recently gained wealth doesn't seem accounted for in your measurements. Let alone the large number of failed attempts to show that money can actually improve standardized testing scores. [yes, I believe these tests generally can't be well-studied for. It's not as solid as you think. Send links if you can find one which suggests that you can train an average person to have a 99th percentile SAT or similar test. People attack the tests w/out really looking into it at all; they're super correlated with college GPA and many other pro-social lifetime measurements.]

Second: Do you think the new system is less gameable than the old? i.e. relying on recommendation letters, holistic applications, extra-curriculars, the ability to tell stories where you're the victim, race preferences (not origin, literal race i.e. not distinguishing American descendants of slavery from recently immigrated Africans)? I think these things are even more game-able than before. i.e. read the docs on the Harvard discrimination case - the administrators were using a squishy "personality" evaluation score to discriminate against Asians.

Needless to say, SAT is proven to be very correlated with things we value - I strongly doubt that Harvard's replacement system has anywhere near that predictive ability.

To state it in a testable way: good scores on the SAT/MCAT will strongly correlate with good med school class rank, graduation rate, low rate of malpractice, percent chance to get a medical patent or do widely cited research, etc. Squishy holistic admissions will NOT correlate to many good things - best it can do is correlate with socially manipulable soft science PhDs and papers. But it won't help you with anything that's not gamed already.

epivosism··on Harvard Admissions Should Be More Meritocratic
> This is due to people having money being able to afford good educational programs for their children at the start while those without significant affluent backgrounds will have significantly less access to quality educational resources before they reach college age.

When you survey high achieving people in the world, or in your wikipedia history, do you mostly find people who got there because of the opportunities their parents paid for? How many of those people have brothers and sisters - do you also find that their entire family does well? I don't see that. At most I see richer/more fortunate people have a higher average. But the idea that it's the dominant factor is in conflict with observation - that it's really common to see people who do much better than those around them even though they all had about the same level of resources.

Also: is your thesis that the more money that is spent on a child's education, the better they will do? How do you square that with observations? Do you believe that claim is supported by evidence? I don't - I think that for example a town with poor but middle class people (i.e. a suburb of Shanghai) would have way higher scores than a town of blue-collar workers in the US who had nominally higher pay. i.e., pay/spend doesn't really matter (unless pay is so low that the kids are directly feeling the effect of poverty). Do you believe that school districts which spend more per student also have higher scores as a result? Have you ever looked up that claim?

Also note that by your thesis that spending money on childhood education leads to improvements in "merit", the educational quality of US & ivy league students should have been going up dramatically in the last 30 years as prices grew much faster than inflation. Yet, I'd bet that per person, Ivy graduate productivity (patents/person, innovative academic publications/person, etc.) has been dropping the entire time. If money makes people more academically proficient, how do you explain that?

epivosism··on Harvard Admissions Should Be More Meritocratic
This is Steven Pinker's call for reducing discrimination in admissions. It's paired with an essay from the other side, here: https://www.thecrimson.com/column/council-on-academic-freedo...

Which is incredibly weak and acts like Harvard is at risk despite its 40b tax-free, hedge-fund-secrets powered ever-growing endowment.

epivosism··on Do It Yourself Blind Repair
But I'm asking why in some markets there are known relatively trustable sites, but not in others. What causes that? I also assume it varies dramatically by culture, language, region, population, period in history. Why? If you deny it varies, what maintains that? There either is a conservation principle (which must have some mechanism for maintenance) or there isn't (in which case variation probably relates to other aspects of reality, and what are they?)
epivosism··on Do It Yourself Blind Repair
Yes, that's great! A site similar to this for anything related to sleep seems to be:

https://www.sleeplikethedead.com/

It covers pillows, mattresses, etc. Labor love, makes no direct money, committed to and open about how frequent manipulation is in the industry. I followed its recommendations ~1.5 years ago when furnishing a new house and was very happy with the results fitting out 3 bedrooms.

Big Q: why is this still a niche situation? Why do only a few sites have this trait? I think it has to do with culture, habits, and laws for each language & culture. Does it vary by language or region? Are some industries more manipulable than others?

Similar: amazon somehow gets away with defaulting their search result page to "Featured" which means "people pay us to lie to you". They still do provide the option to sort by "best selling" which at least theoretically is better. I'd expect a mature citizenry to rebel and force them to have a better default, or at least let you configure your default.

I'm very interested in characterizing variation on these axes across the world and time. Is it really zero sum and always identical? Or do some habits and traits of a region, language, culture, education system make "better" systems more likely to survive? Can we even actually fairly characterize better systems? It sure feels like we can, but I've also seen people arguing that for example there is no actual difference between rent-seeking and "productive economic activity" on a theoretical level.

epivosism··on Location history data in Google Maps will soon be stored on user devices
If a feature is being proposed and mandatory, then the existence of one person who doesn't like it is significant.

But if it's already optional, and being removed entirely, then that persons's existence isn't that relevant; what's relevant is the people who DO like it and are losing something for them.

epivosism··on Generative AI is killing our sense of awe
My ggggg*1000 grandfather, a eukaryote, really knew how to live. He didn't have hands - he had to DREAM and use his MIND to make snowmen. Kids today with their "hands" are desensitized to the needed mental work of imagining how a snowman would look.

I'm not saying this argument automatically wins. But I think the two sides need to define terms. What's "real" and "authentic" for one generation was a huge stretch for another, and will be rote/boring for another. Is there a coherent dividing point? I personally don't think so; I would like to hear an attempted definition, though.

Real = Struggling to manage your horse to plow the fields so you and your family doesn't starve? Being a master horseman and ploughman? Breeding sturdier horses and selling them so you're rich, and everyone can easily plow? Replacing horses with engines+plows, with heated cabins, which activates way more land, to grow more food for the world? Running a retro amish-style farm on the weekend where you go back to using real horses to plow again?

^^^^ Where does "real/genuine" come in and then leave in that sequence? And who are you to say where other people should spend their time within it?

epivosism··on Show HN: Trains.fyi – a live map of passenger trains in the US and Canada
Ah, thanks. My comment was based on this link which I share often on Japanese Zoning. http://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2014/04/japanese-zoning.html

related: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_land_law

Looking it up, I see you're right. They have national zoning laws but even there, things do seem to be getting more complicated.

epivosism··on Show HN: Trains.fyi – a live map of passenger trains in the US and Canada
They already have the land rights, favorable social environment for construction, more compliant population, less local/more federal legal zoning and land use power, more federal level direction to get things done, higher rate of engineers in population.

That CA is bad at all of those makes it expensive and hard

In addition to very low competence levels in gov't compared to Japan due to many factors. Sure Japan has financial corruption in construction but it's a known system and they build things treating it as a tax. In CA there are many more parties who all attempt to hold construction projects hostage.

epivosism··on Show HN: A Dalle-3 and GPT4-Vision feedback loop
thanks for this! Basically the default UI they provide at chat.openai is so bad, nearly anything you would do would be an improvement.

* not hide the prompt by default * not only show 6 lines of the prompt even after user clicks * not be insanely buggy re: ajax, reloading past convos etc * not disallow sharing of links to chats which contain images * not artificially delay display of images with the little spinner animation when the image is already known ready anyway. * not lie about reasons for failure * not hide details on what rate limit rules I broke and where to get more information

etc

Good luck, thanks!

epivosism··on Show HN: A Dalle-3 and GPT4-Vision feedback loop
One reason this is good is that the default gpt4-vision UI is so insanely bad and slow. This just lets you use your capacity faster.

Rate limits are really low by default - you can get hit by 5 img/min limits, or 100 RPD (requests per day) which I think is actually implemented as requests per hour.

This page has info on the rate limits: https://platform.openai.com/docs/guides/rate-limits/usage-ti...

Basically, you have to have paid X amount to get into a new usage cap. Rate limits for dalle3/images don't go up very fast but it can't hurt to get over the various hurdles (5$, 50$, 100$) as soon as possible for when limits come down. End of the month is coming soon. It looks like most of the "RPD" limits go away when you hit tier 2 (having paid at least 50$ historically via API to them).

epivosism··on Show HN: A Dalle-3 and GPT4-Vision feedback loop
You can really "cheat" by modifying the custom prompt to re-insert or remove specific features. For example, "generate a prompt for this image but adjust it by making everything appear in a more primitive, earlier evolutionary form, or in an earlier less developed way" would make things de-evolve.

Or you can just re-insert any theme or recurring characters you like at that stage.

epivosism··on Show HN: A Dalle-3 and GPT4-Vision feedback loop
The "create text version of image" prompt matters a ton.

I tried three, demo here:

default

  https://dalle.party/?party=JfiwmJra
hyper-long + max detail + compression - This shows that with enough text, it can do a really good job of reproducing very, very similar images

  https://dalle.party/?party=QtEqq4Mu
   
hyper-long + max detail + compression + telling it to cut all that down to 12 words - This seems okay. I might be losing too much detail

  https://dalle.party/?party=0utxvJ9y
Overall the extreme content filtering and lying error messages are not ideal; will probably improve in the future. If you send too long, or too risky a prompt, or the image it generates is randomly too risky, you either get told about it or lied to that you've hit rate limits. Sometimes you also really do hit ratelimits.

Also, you can't raise your rate limits until you prove it by having paid over X amount to openai. This kind of makes sense as a way to prevent new sign-ups from blowing thousands of dollars of cap mistakenly.

Hyper detail prompt:

Look at this image and extract all the vital elements. List them in your mind including position, style, shape, texture, color, everything else essential to convey their meaning. Now think about the theme of the image and write that down, too. Now write out the composition and organization of the image in terms of placement, size, relationships, focus. Now think about the emotions - what is everyone feeling and thinking and doing towards each other? Now, take all that data and think about a very long, detailed summary including all elements. Then "compress" this data using abbreviations, shortenings, artistic metaphors, references to things which might help others understand it, labels and select pull-quotes. Then add even more detail by reviewing what we reviewed before. Now do one final pass considering the input image again, making sure to include everything from it in the output one, too. Finally, produce a long maximum length jam packed with info details which could be used to perfectly reproduce this image.

Final shrink to 12 words:

NOW, re-read ALL of that twice, thinking deeply about it, then compress it down to just 12 very carefully chosen words which with infinite precision, poetry, beauty and love contain all the detail, and output them, in quotes.

epivosism··on OpenAI's board has fired Sam Altman
manifold has some play money markets about this - pure speculation of course, although traders here do take their profit somewhat seriously

https://manifold.markets/Ernie/what-will-sam-altman-be-doing...

And this tag contains all the markets about him https://manifold.markets/browse?topic=sam-altman

Will he end up at Grok? Why was he fired? etc.

epivosism··on Sam Bankman-Fried and the effective altruism delusion
I feel your sincerity but I don't know why you're sure of that. I think it is pretty easy to construct situations where one course of action is better than another. For example helping more innocent people vs hardened people with no remorse. Or within the same groups, focusing more on disease eradication against targets which are more harmful vs those diseases which are only small inconveniences.

I think EAs might just be trying to apply that same style reasoning to areas which aren't commonly viewed as clear yet. Ie say hey, you may not be familiar with it, but there is some information suggesting that between these two conventional charities, here is an analysis with assumptions laid out that suggests that contributuons may not actually be equivalent!

You can still take it or leave it.

I don't think they're saying they know everything perfectly. Just that they think it's important to push into the murky areas.

I think the issue with blanket statements is on the listener. If I have an idea and somewhat boldly say hey all, I think my idea is better than anything before - and here's why, the "get mad and attack" response, even when sincere and correct, masks so many nonsincere responses. That is, lots of people who claim to be serious analysts frequently use the "attack" response, or the "I'm so tired of this" response. Sometimes that is justified but it's also a crutch and tends to harden battle lines.

Personally I'd just figure out if I agree with them (and I don't) and why, and move on. I appreciate you not piling on to them, too.

← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →