124 karma · joined January 23, 2022
As for descendants of slaves in the US, please check out these lectures by Dr. Joy DeGruy-Leary, and her theory on Post-Traumatic Slave Syndrome. She did much research and readings into the history of American blacks and compared with other peoples. Her work focuses on how healing can occur after centuries of generational trauma.
1: https://youtu.be/g6H7gGUQIFs
Specifically, check out minutes 15:19 (bookmark “Systemic generational trauma” to 32:47 “Denigrating the Child”.)
2: https://youtu.be/BGjSday7f_8 This great talk on the history of slavery and Jim Crow in the US and explains how both black and white Americans have trauma leftover from the legacy of discrimination.
Finally, as a desi person I must add that our (especially older) communities are often quick to deride and hold racism against African Americans. There is much belief in exceptionalism in immigrants to the US contrasted against the “failed” minorities. Well, as the child of immigrants, I anecdotally see that much of the success comes from a continuity and sense of belonging from family, values, religion, etc which while colonized, still maintain memories former glories. In contrast, American slaves were ripped out from their historical context and shipped transatlantic.
So as the professor notes, talking about “culture” and saying “it’s their culture” is really a misnomer and attempt to distract from the very real trauma that continues to be inflicted.
Additionally, you’re selecting out of the population when you just look at the minorities that were able to immigrate to the US. You should compare minorities that came to the US in representative chunks of the greater population — perhaps war refugees although even these communities have skews based on the nature of their immigration to the US.
For a long time America has this belief of “exceptionalism” and sometimes to a crazy degree where its people act like they are the center of the world. That the cracks are showing and people are recognizing unfairness is a laudable thing.
Your first paragraph makes a great observation, that your culture is intrinsically tied to historical factors, in this case political dominance and religious and cultural spread.
So the habits a person of a certain culture has, these are rooted in what they inherited of this culture. These habits are a result of historical influences, which includes previously mentioned inequities, wealth gaps, etc.
But discussions of culture will inevitably touch on the factors that gave rise to certain features. So the fact that many black Americans have ancestry in slaves trafficked to the US, is not separable from the discussion on why Asian Americans are discriminated in higher education admissions.
Anyways, call what I say rooted in Americanism or what have you, the fact is Bangladeshi culture has a much different history than American culture, so calls to be accommodating of other cultures in America strike a different tone than it would in trying to change Bangladeshi culture (itself rooted in a reaction against erasure of language and culture).
Finally, all of this is to say, while culture has an influence in some regards, it’s not so separate from the wealth gaps and inequities which stratify folks.
And white Americans have an entire culture reinforcing their customs, way of life, ways of interacting, etc. All this contributes to how a corporate culture is very accommodating to the dominant culture. For example Sunday as a weekend is not a mere cultural relic but actively supports a particular culture.
I see people often point to hard-working of Asian cultures to contrast against the “under performing” minorities like black culture. But I think this undersells a lot of structural discrimination and history.
Anyways, this is why I have skepticism towards “model minorities” wanting to integrate into white culture customs and assume a dominant position in society. A lot of the narrative of “hard-working immigrant” and cultural exceptionalism ignores the sociopolitical context of why certain minority groups are underprivileged.
I imagine you can apply culture similarly to why white Americans would choose their own to advance up career ladders.
Perhaps you do not know so I will give you a history lesson.
Firstly, some of the early Umayyads were reluctant to encourage conversion to Islam for tax reasons, as a tax was levied on the non-Muslim minorities under protection of the Umayyad empire. The concept of Dhimmah let non-Muslims live peacefully under protection of the empire in exchange for recognizing their authority and paying a poll tax, jizyah. However, many people willingly converted to Islam, and the result is that some of the greatest Islamic scholars came from non-Arab lineage.
Next, Islamic conversions occurred in the Indian subcontinent in large part due to Sufis and merchants. This is similar for Indonesia and China which contacts with Islam came through merchants.
Next, the much of the Middle East converted to Islam far later than the original conquests by Islamic empires. You can read more here in this Oxford news article, so certainly you won’t be making accusations of apologism: https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/arts-blog/how-did-christian-middle...
> Laughable! In every Muslim majority state, minorities have been persecuted/forcibly converted almost to extinction. You just have to look at the data for some Islamic countries.
The fact that religious minorities survived to the modern day in the Middle East is proof that Islamic conversions by and large did not happen by force. Nearly 20% of Egypt is Christian, as a result of the Coptic community that remains in Egypt. You can compare this to European conquests of the Americas, where indigenous religions were nearly wiped out forcibly. Or see the Spanish Inquisition where Spain expelled, interrogated, and executed Jews and Muslims.
Similarly, in the Balkans ruled by the Ottomans, there was no large scale systematic genocide of non-Muslims over hundreds of years of history. Early nationalism caused a lot of strife in the region and ethnic cleansing, but the fact that Balkan Christians remained is because forced conversion to Islam was not the primary cause of conversion to Islam. In fact, Bosnians converted to Islam probably because their form of Christianity was closer to Islamic teachings, compared to the others Balkan folk around them.
Yes, there were cases of forced conversion in different places, but in no way was this the primary way for people to become Muslims over history.
Anyways, your main argument was based around forced conversion being the primary way people entered Islam, but this is without a doubt false.
As for the sources you sent, these are very biased sources and this is outside of the topic at hand. Islam has remained relevant for hundreds of years, and will remain relevant for Muslims, regardless of what some people engaged in presentism will say.
I hope you can learn to leave your ignorance and accept truth, I think I have decisively sent you a lot of examples on why forced conversions were not the main cause to enter Islam. Let’s be honest.
Conversions to Islam under Islamic empires like Umayyads and Abbasids did not in general occur by the “sword”. You can look up the historical demographics, it took a long time for some areas like the Levant and even Egypt for a majority of the population to convert. Conversions occurred for a variety of reasons, but being force by the sword is definitely not a major factor. Even still today many places retained their minority religion populations. As for blend of culture and religion, you can easily say same for Islamic cultures which harmonized with cultures as widely as Indonesia to West and South Asian under its fold.
As for mutazilism, that has nothing to do with the topic, and the mutazilites themselves had people killed for not following their beliefs when they influenced the ruler, so their downfall was only by what they perpetuated.
Next you sell Buddhism as perfect at peace, yet there is well known infighting between various branches in Buddhism. Not to mention it does not end ethnic strife (see the genocide of Rohingya in Burma).
Be honest not dogmatic.