HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

erenyeager

124 karma · joined January 23, 2022

submissionscomments
erenyeager··on ChatGPT: 4000 word University assignment got caught out. Wtf do I do
I think professors and schools need to realize learning and life will be different now with the mass utilization of AI. Humans are taking a role more of composers than generators of the raw material — writing in this case. And I think, ultimately, it should be ok to use assistive technologies like ChatGPT to write an essay. After all, a human still signs off on it. The human still has to creatively make decisions with respect to prompts and what to include.

And as long as it does not infringe on someone’s copyrighted work, then what is the trouble with using AI to write? I’m sure all scientific papers could be made far more comprehensible in parts with the use of assistive ai tech. It’s like spell check but better

erenyeager··on CNET Has Been Quietly Publishing AI-Written Articles for Months
Personally I love ChatGPT and think this should be implemented in schools in the future for writing courses. Many times people have concepts they wish to express but are not so proficient in what is the cultural “prestige” writing. I think it is much more important to creatively combine concepts and apply them, compared to the nitty-gritty of fine writing.

Also, I feel the rise of Chat GPT will result in more value for verified human-written or human-supervised content. I will much prefer hearing an organic, person’s personal experience in another country, for example, as a verification for things that actually happened, compared to a fictitious AI generated story. Now combine a verified human + AI assistance, you have a reliable narrator and good content.

The hardest hit will probably be to the anonymous writers and commenters, who cannot provide verification of being actual sources, and will be washed in the storm of AI content.

erenyeager··on Tell HN: Farewell letter of M. Hosseini – executed 01.02.2023 by I.R. of Iran
Go on, silencing voices calling to reason and forbearance. And now I am assumed to be malicious in my valid concerns? Many are those who have no issue making assumptions which lead to big troubles. You can be better than this.
erenyeager··on Ask HN: What is some good Arabic content on the internet?
Poetry —> https://www.aldiwan.net/

YouTube (so many Arabic channels to choose from)

Twitter (especially Saudi Twitter pops off)

More wholesome HN/Reddit clone: https://io.hsoub.com/

Surprisingly informative Facebook posts which you find through Arabic queries in Google search

erenyeager··on College that fired prof for showing image of Muhammad could lose accreditation
Serves disrespectful orientalist “scholars” well to have their own corrupted ideologies used against them. Presuming to analyze and dissemble the “other” while it is only projection of their own misconceptions.

Good job on Hamline for doing the right thing.

erenyeager··on Where does ChatGPT fall on the political compass?
Definitely on topics of sexual nature and sexuality, ChatGPT gives very biased “liberal” responses about it being ok for someone to explore their sexuality and eroticism and such. These are incredibly controversial and biased responses even from a US standpoint. I don’t think it’s ready to be a therapist yet; at least it needs sensitivity training to adjust to different users’ values and expectations.
erenyeager··on Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports
Many examples worldwide of people getting married happily and successfully without extended courting, cohabitation, and premarital relations.

And you are free to leave off arguing and jabs but seems that desire still pulls you in. I am done with this discussion, and freely choosing to end it.

erenyeager··on Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports
You and I are different and I have no agreement with your conclusions.

Eat and rest are also things that do well to be moderated.

You mention chains but modesty and purity is a form of freedom from basal desire and unpleasantness. And many times in society we make socially responsible decisions. For example, it is pretty much understandable that drinking culture in the US with driving has been dangerous, thus DUI laws.

Similarly, encouraging modesty in society and cultivating shyness protects against many harms to society, like increased relationships out of wedlock, greed (modesty is also about humbleness and avoiding looking at what others have), and objectification/commercialization of the human body.

erenyeager··on Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports
I would like to note the fact that some numbers of people comply or do not comply in accordance with divine law does not imply a disagreement with the validity of the law. Rather, it may be due to someone’s ignorance, or shortcomings that they make mistakes.

Many orthodox methodologies of deriving legal rulings (fiqh) from Islamic sources already exist. Scholars from all orthodox schools of thought agree on the woman’s hair being part of what must be covered.

One can come up with many interpretations of divine revelation, but unless someone is guided on the right path, they may come up with conclusions that go astray from the correct way. This is the last part of the supplication of Surah Al-Fatihah (opening chapter of the Quran): a request to be guided on the right path and not of those who are displeasing or misguided.

So I think when you say substantial disagreement, this is not correct. Someone may accept that what they are doing is wrong but are too weak to change. Also, if the people who disagree are not educated or well-studied, their opinion holds less weight than an expert in that particular field.

Reason is very important, which is why interpreting revelation without considering the scholarly tradition may lead to unreasonable conclusions.

erenyeager··on Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports
This is against the orthodox Islamic interpretations if you’re saying that a free woman can uncover her hair in public if that’s the social norm. It is quite well known what the limits of awrah are (the parts that need to be covered). If everyone is wearing bikinis, it doesn’t make bikinis permissible.

So if this is only your opinion, it is not an opinion based in sound evidence, or at least please bring some to support it.

erenyeager··on Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports
Is there truly freedom? This is a deep question beyond patronizing insults about primitiveness. What freedom is there truly, when humans are so prone to influences that would seem to chain them.

What freedom is there if one becomes addicted to some substance, for example? What freedom is there in being distracted from one’s purpose and higher rational aims due to being in a temptous environment?

I think you will not find “freedom” has much value if it is trapped in loops of dopamine

erenyeager··on Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports
It’s interesting when we discuss the concept of freedom, if u look I think some enlightenment thinkers considered freedom in terms of freedom from base desires and vulgarity, to liberate man into higher thought. Then there are also concepts of public/private.

From this regard, is not it freedom to have society less restrained by basal desires and the widespread practice of modesty makes it easier to be private with regard to exposing one’s body?

erenyeager··on Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports
I thought it’s not clear how she died… it’s really muddled. Clearly Iran leadership has many problems but maybe this is more a powder keg… anyways if you saw videos of Iran you’d see hijab rules were usually lenient at least in urban places it seemed.
erenyeager··on Life Is Short (2016)
When you say different versions of Quran, what you are talking about is very different from something like different Bible versions and edits and translations etc.

The Quran is multi form. Oral texts tradition and from the Hadith we know that the Quran was recited in different modes by the Prophet Muhammad pbuh. But these are all valid revelation. Actually one of the “miracles” linguistically about the Quran is how the authentic Qiraa’aat (the reading-out of the Quran) can be traced back to a chain of reciters authentically. And each Qiraa’aat adds eloquence to the Quran and it also speaks to the people of a certain dialect. Think about British English and American English and how the same word can be pronounced differently, and you begin to approach an understanding of Qiraa’aat.

Actually, different Qiraa’aat are essential to the revelation of the Quran and giving evidence about how it has been revealed as an “Arabic Quran” in which many examples of mankind and prophets are related.

These qiraa’aat add enhancement to the meaning of the Quran. For example, if you look up tafsir Al-Qurtubi [not sure if there is an English translation but you can find the Arabic text on Quran.com] (tafsir is an explanation of the Quran), of (verse 87 from chapter 20)[https://quran.com/20/87 ] you will find that the word ملكنا has three different readings مِلكنا ، مُلكنا، مَلكنا which when we transliterate to English we get: mulkinaa, milkinaa, malkinaa. Malkinaa and milkinaa translate to “our will”. Mulkinaa translates to “our power”.

And all together in the verse it enhances the meaning that shows that the Children of Israel were made to carry the burdens of weight of the jewelwery/ornaments from the Pharoah’s people.

Also in this verse, we have two readings for حملنا which are: حُمِّلنا and حَمَلنا which is hummilnaa, and hamalnaa, respectively. Hummilnaa is the passive voice and means “we were forced to carry”. While “Hamalnaa” translates to “we carried”.

Both of these convey a similar meaning of carrying, they enhance aspects of what is happening in the verse. Passive voice focuses on how people were forced to Carry while the active voice focuses on how people indeed did carry.

This is just one example of how important and helpful knowing Qiraa’aat are and Arabic.

erenyeager··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
I don’t subscribe to so called woke gender ideology so I will be calling “non binary” people by their “assigned at birth” gender pronoun. It’s my freedom to do so and I refuse to change my core beliefs for someone’s own personal deviances.
erenyeager··on It’s not Tourette’s but a new type of mass sociogenic illness
It is helpful because discussing a negative thing in society spreads it without need. Like if you find out everyone’s secrets and scandals, you become more uninhibited
erenyeager··on Notes on Saudi Arabia
Such an ethnocentric view. If you believe the one Creator commanded you to wear modest clothing, then indeed it is most rational to follow. And covering your face also gives a kind of privacy in society that many western women would not have the luxury of.

Anyways, many commenters here could benefit from a broader cultural perspective rather than a narrow minded, tunnel visioned view of the world.

erenyeager··on Notes on Saudi Arabia
Wow, this was interesting to read, especially about your own experiences. But I am astonished about the inaccuracies of the religion section. It is almost like the author misunderstands fundamental concepts and distorts them through what I can only term as a "western" lens.

For example, you characterized the Hanafi school of Islamic jurisprudence as "liberal" and the Hanbali school as "conservative". This is a completely inappropriate characterization of these schools and it makes a major mistake in equating them on spectrum of liberal to conservative (politically). They are orthogonal concepts.

As a brief explanation, in Islamic law (Shari'a), within the Sunni tradition of Islam there are 4 major schools of thought with regards to deriving rulings (these are called schools of fiqh, jurisprudence). All of these schools of thought accept each other as valid Islamically. They are named after the founders of the schools of thoughts, who all use the scripture (the Holy Quran), and the tradition of the Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم peace be upon him and his companions. These schools differ in their application of methods to derive the sources of shari'a. For example, the Hanafi school is known to more heavily use Qiyas, or a type of legal reasoning by analogy, to derive rulings. Other sources of Shari'a come from what is known as 'urf, or custom of a particular locality.

To show why characterizing Hanafi as liberal and Hanbali as conservative is laughably incorrect. For example, many Hanafi faqeehs (experts in Hanafi fiqh) will consider the only seafood allowed to eat is fish. On the other hand, the Hanbali school considers fish, shrimp, crab, other seafood, etc. to be permissible to eat.

So to characterize one as liberal and the other as conservative, in general, is incomprehensible.

Next, you did not give the context of the rise of what you term Wahhabism [itself a term considered offensive to use as a pejorative by those on whom this term is applied: because al-Wahhab "the supreme bestower" is one of the names (attributes) used to describe God (Allah). Thus, to use a name of God as an epithet is considered offensive.] The rise of the movement of Abd al-Wahhab stems from the context of Arabia and Muslim practices at the time. At that time, Sufiism was the more officially influential "strain" of Islam, having been embraced by the Ottomans to an extent, and many people in this movement went to the extremes of grave worshiping, visiting shrines, and even praying to the dead for intercession. These are all practices that are outside the mainstream of Islam, but are described as having become more widespread in even Arabia and the Levant (Bilad ash-Shaam). It is in this context that Abd al-Wahhab's movement arises as a reaction. And it is a mistake to talk about Abd al-Wahhab's movement without mentioning the eminent Islamic scholar Ibn Taymiyyah who lived in the time of the Mongol invasions. But I digress for brevity.

Next, to talk about Saudi Arabia's modern history without mentioning the movements among the religious scholars is not giving proper context. For example, you did not mention the Sahwa (awakening) [1] movement among scholars, nor did you give the context of the Muslim Brotherhood (Al-Ikhwaan Al-Muslimoon) and the Arab Spring, which is important to current Saudi religious clerics' attitudes towards dissent, democratization, etc. And it shapes how the Saudi government responds to these movements and those who went beyond the lines they set for them (for example the imprisonment of Salman Al-Awdah).

Next, you mentioned the claim by a cleric of geocentricity. But you are also misunderstanding the position of clerics with regards to fields they are qualified to speak about and the realm of their opinions. In their opinions they are not expert in, they can be incorrect just as an expert in history may not have authority to speak on physics. Actually you can find clips of the clerics deferring judgement of scientific facts to scientists; the authority the cleric speaks with is the evidence he brings from scripture and tradition. If a cleric says the Sun orbits the Earth, but new information comes to him, he can accept that as the realm of scientists while also upholding his own understanding from the evidences.

---

Also, I was hoping you would have a bigger section on foreign workers, because it is not simply "wage-slave" and "Saudi prince" in terms of the class structure of society. There is a rich parallel network of foreign nationals that operates under, around, and throughout the Saudi Arabian society. Anyone who has begun speaking to one of the foreign laborers in their native tongue will understand the concept of favors and advice given to one's own people.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sahwa_movement

For a medium-length but interesting introduction to Islamic scholarship: http://www.chriscaras.com/usul-fiqh/ijtihad/knowledge-schola...

erenyeager··on European teams ditch pro-LGBTQ+ armbands at Qatar World Cup
All these organizations showing the real “global” values — greed, fame, profit. At least saying one thing and doing the other seems to be a truly universal thing.
erenyeager··on Qatar Bans Beer Sales at World Cup Stadiums
Amazing move for social, health, and safety reasons if true. A country does not need to yield these aspects of their culture for an international event. Actually it would help a lot for sports culture to encourage healthier forms of having fun.
erenyeager··on Ask HN: How to deal with my team speaking a different language?
I think you should reflect on your views of the situation and consider that your attitude towards this does not demonstrate cultural humility. It is not the obligation of your team members to speak a language you understand. If you wish to participate with then, just speak to them in English or communicate when you would like to be included.

Nobody likes a tattletale or Karen-type person enforcing linguistic, cultural supremacy.

erenyeager··on American society is so focused on race that it is blind to class
Well perhaps we agree to disagree on this regard to an extent. My own experience in republican-white dominated areas includes attempts to block buildings for minorities, gloss over historical events to favor one side, suppress different viewpoints, forced participation in Christian religious activities even at the governmental level, and deeply ignorant, bigoted takes on the “other”.

Of course this is by no means limited to republicans or whites for that matter, but the effects I have felt most often come from people who are pushing their views in support of this regards; thus I am sensitized to checking overreach of these views.

Class also has a place in all of this. And I am certain from liberal places I have visited they have problems. But for me perfect is not the enemy of good. It’s simply a matter of who more negatively affects, my way of life and those of others, in the views they push. So far, the MAGA crowd will not be gaining my support until they change many of their views and policies.

If educated Asian-Americans want to gain institutional power like the white elites in this country, fine. But I think they’re making a huge mistake and allowing harm to come to others in their quest for “climbing the ladder”. And I will try to do what’s right either way, as many things are not in my control.

erenyeager··on American society is so focused on race that it is blind to class
Ostensibly to you it isn’t “fair” in the way you have described it. But from a different view, your son is very privileged to be in the position he is, I’m sure he will do well wherever he goes for school. You’re in the South Bay bubble that has put so much hype and pressure on these things. Of course, education is important to you as a cultural value and practical matter; but consider that students who are capable can even flourish better in, for example, the community college setting for a few years before transferring (also more financially savvy).

Anyways affirmative action for mostly white people (“legacy admits”) already exists. Removing AA based on race may not result in great outcomes for the underrepresented minorities. Huge disparities exist that cannot be corrected at the university level in entirely; but AA gives the opportunity for URMs to enter these spaces at higher rates than they would at a so called “level” playing field (it is never is the problem).

It’s time to start considering that there is far more to life than what “elite” colleges will have people believe.

erenyeager··on Ask HN: How to deal with regret of not having kids
Get a second wife. I’m not even kidding, this is an available solution to your problem. You can even move to a place where polygamy is legal to register it. Then you can have a relationship with both wives and support them and have kids with the younger one.
erenyeager··on Visitors to Qatar for the World Cup need to install spyware on their phone
Anyways, you speak with some harshness, I hope you can not hurt with it.

Safety is very important of course, but I don’t think for Qatar, Saudi Arabia, that is an issue for international travelers. I wonder how the morality of the place you live in is and if it aligns with you, because often we cannot control it.

I’m not sure about your morality, but to speak of knowing it doesn’t align with you, I wonder if you really know.

Anyways I can say from personal experience, the places are very safe, and amazing experiences I hope to revisit. Every place has problems, and we can all make choices. Just like Brazilian author Paulo Coelho’s protagonist in the Alchemist, we can choose to continue on in our journey or never embark in the first place.

erenyeager··on Visitors to Qatar for the World Cup need to install spyware on their phone
Perhaps an open mind can observe and receive with grace, to see a more whole picture.

Every place has something to teach us, something we can learn. There’s a lot of prejudice and distortion to work beyond, so curiosity does us well.

There are some things you must experience to understand. I think to write off a place completely for largely inflated reasons is missing this.

Even if you disagree with the administration of a place, you can meet a lot of people who may change your life for the better.

don’t let ignorance cut you off from growth

erenyeager··on Visitors to Qatar for the World Cup need to install spyware on their phone
It does matter when people believe and think (out of nationalism, ethnocentrism) that they’re in the paragon of virtue and civilization while everyone else is some backwards people entrapped in darkness…

Anyways you can be critical of a place without being arrogant of your own position. Most people writing here about Qatar act as if their own countrymen are amazing when they probably haven’t even visited the middle East!

Pure pontification, and no open-mindedness to seeing a holistic view. It dilutes the valid criticisms when people speak out of ignorance.

erenyeager··on Visitors to Qatar for the World Cup need to install spyware on their phone
Well how can you say much about a place without visiting? These descriptions can be used for so called “civilized” places. Especially Western countries not even standing by these “civilized” values shows a lot where their hearts are. They’d rather kill millions, exploit economic conditions, and pontificate about ideals they don’t even act in accordance with.

It’s propaganda you’ve been fed to assume the rhetoric of civilized vs uncivilized. Really every place has barbarism, some hidden behind arrogance, it seems.

erenyeager··on Scanning phones to detect child abuse evidence is harmful, 'magical' thinking
While I don’t support privacy invasions, I think, as a teen who was exploited online by adults, that there needs to be more protection for young people online. A client side scanning solution sounds ideal in this regard.
erenyeager··on Claims AI can boost workplace diversity are ‘spurious and dangerous’
What definition of normal do you operate on? Surely it’s a minority of people, compared to the number of people who do not identify as gay. In sociology this is called social deviance, a feature of human variation
← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →