(haven't tried it yet)
327 karma · joined May 18, 2009
My blog: http://blog.erezsh.com/
My github: https://github.com/erezsh
(haven't tried it yet)
Do you plan to add comments? Chat?
MongoDB already answered all these questions when they created the SSPL in the first place: https://www.mongodb.com/licensing/server-side-public-license...
(iirc they also wrote a lengthy blog post about it)
That's a meaningless statement, since it could just as well mean that they contributed back 2 hours of work.
> * is okay to switch to SSPL ???
Yes, absolutely. Why not?
The article you linked doesn't mention anything about foundations. But let's agree not every open-source project can become one.
But I read them and couldn't find anything addressing fields of endeavor. GNU's "four essential freedoms", which imho are a little naive in retrospect, don't say anything about this. They say anyone should be able to "sell copies", but SSPL doesn't disallow this either.
Debian obviously didn't address it either. They clarify: " They can even try to sell it. In practice, it costs essentially no money to make electronic copies of software. Supply and demand will keep the cost down."
I.e. they only allowed it because they thought the free market will take care of it, and didn't imagine how cloud provides will become monopolies of access.
"As a result, you can buy a Debian release on several CDs for just a few USD." - Lol.. that's like trying to apply lessons from the bible to modern life.
Just to broaden the discussion, "fields of endeavor" doesn't just mean cloud services, but also whether you can prevent your software from being used in weapons, or other such morally objectionable applications.
The OSI doesn't approve any license that "discriminates on fields of endeavor", which means you are not allowed to prevent cloud providers from competing with you with your own product.
Premium sponsors of the OSI include AWS, Google and Microsoft.
I'm also happy to see small start-ups rise faster by using my software.
But if those theoretical start-ups, whose business wouldn't exist without my software, grew to dozens of employees, made millions of dollars, and still I wouldn't see a nickel.. That's when I would start to wonder, why am I doing this for free?
Incidentally, the bigger the company, the less likely it is to contribute back.
To conclude, that sounds like false equivalency to me. It does matter who is using it for free and profiting.
Hopefully they won't, due to principles, or the fear of getting caught by the public, but I can't help but wonder that maybe having the right license would be much more useful than having an easy-to-pick lock.
If it depends on the compliance of the user, why not just bake it into the license?
teachers[age > 30].count
(Because I'm working on something exactly like this right now)Also, how is the support for windows? I couldn't find any mention of it.
A last note, if I may, is to put more time into the github README.md. That's where I usually go to read all the important technical details.
Most academic texts I've read will use something like
s = d/t
And sometimes not even explain what the components mean, because obviously 't' stands for time. That's what all their lecturers used, so why bother explain it.Some will even make up their own notation:
s = d(t)
And somewhere will say "f(x) in this article describes an inverse multiplicative relation", without explaining that it's actually simple division, so other academics won't find them too obvious or boorish.Some even take it a step further and use random greek letters (without exhausting the English alphabet first ofc.), where small gamma and big gamma mean completely different and unrelated things.
Social media is the contemporary tool of spreading information, yes, but you don't have to use it to see everyone else around you lose their mind. Also, there are good things coming from social media too, and literally everyone in it signed up for it.
Sounds like you hold political correctness very dearly, but here's an interesting thought experiment for you. Try to imagine that just maybe, she may be right, and see if you can actually disprove it.
Person { country => name }
And it will output the following SQL: -- target: postgres
SELECT country, array_agg(name) AS name FROM Person GROUP BY country