HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eropple

27,070 karma · joined April 12, 2011

Lead architect of Verizon's next-generation API platform. I know--I'm as surprised as you are.

https://bsky.app/profile/ed3d.net

Favorite follows: toomuchtodo, JumpCrisscross, woodruffw, tptacek, pjmlp

Given the rate at which Hacker News sprouts green-text commenters who tend to really, really like bigotry, I read HN with a plugin that automatically folds all green-text comments. I apologize if you're a new user acting in good faith and I don't read your post. Please feel free to get in touch with me via the above email.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/eropple; my proof: https://keybase.io/eropple/sigs/o9U8phHSrpBd_HL4r_Fb_hutO3mrRucKWwIFL7dquhI ]

submissionscomments
eropple··on PiVPN v4.6.0: The End
So to me that says you want it both ways, for while I appreciate what the codeshelter folks are trying to do, it is a task that is going to turn out Sudden But Inevitable Betrayals. Instead of contacting a maintainer directly, they just look sufficiently polished that codeshelter says "yeah, sure, OK" and hands it over.

Forking the project and earning your own trust really is the safe path forward.

eropple··on PiVPN v4.6.0: The End
That scenario is exactly what PiVPN is avoiding by refusing to nominate a new maintainer and telling interested parties to fork--so what is your actual and concrete objection?

Fork the project. Earn your own trust.

eropple··on A History of Source Control Systems: SCCS and RCS
I've never used RCS; what do you feel like you're getting from that?

My editor can tell me committed-on if I want it to, so it's a bit of a head-scratcher for me.

eropple··on Ask HN: What is the most useless project you have worked on?
"these EDA firms hire scientists and mathematicians, but no one who really knows about UI design, unlike CAD companies" is going to sit with me for a while.
eropple··on Cloudflare R2 IA storage tier
Bolting a Cloudfront distribution onto a S3 bucket is pretty well-trod territory, though, and doesn't have these sharp edges. (Has a couple other ones, but they're less common.)
eropple··on You won't find a technical co-founder
I was being a little tongue-in-cheek there, but I think there's truth there too--while excellent tech workers absolutely capture too little of their value, that's, uh, not a universal thing in my experience.

But, yeah, walking away from a very solid $150K+ job--especially outside of the Bay Area, I make way less than a Bay Area principal but simply do not think about money!--to play the lottery is not an economically rational decision, and so if you want somebody to do that, yes, you absolutely do need to come correct.

eropple··on You won't find a technical co-founder
> That means there's 270,000 amazing engineers this mythical sales-machine-with-a-big-audience Founder could partner with.

But that founder isn't talking to 269,999 of them, in that situation. And the BATNA for not jumping on the technical cofounder train is "darn, keep my overpaid job".

This arrow mostly goes one way.

eropple··on Adaptive RAG – dynamic retrieval methods adjustment
I think so. Mostly:

- Hosted solutions charge you for tokens. More tokens, more money. Keeping money in your pocket: generally recognized as rad.

- 1M tokens wouldn't hold the entire codebase I have open in my other window.

eropple··on X (Twitter) Is Funding Lawsuit Against Block (Square): Chloe Happe vs. Block
"Law" (whatever that means to you) does not, in the main, protect you from the private consequences of your speech.

It turns out that when you say shitty things about your coworkers in ways themselves violative of the law, people have no obligation to keep you employed!

This is a lawsuit decrying the reality of finding-out post fuck-around.

eropple··on Mamba Explained
I could be wrong, as I haven't used Mamba, but it seems to remain similar to transformers in that it doesn't "decide" anything and streams tokens to follow the existing ones; attention isn't a thing in the same way, but recency does still have impact. To that end, putting context after the question makes it more likely to follow the context, not the question.
eropple··on A living replacement knee to be tested in clinical trials within five years
Meta-studies seem to indicate that the preponderance of the evidence is against, not for, scary side effects. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3481923/
eropple··on A living replacement knee to be tested in clinical trials within five years
Yeah, some of them work, at least for some people. Almost every male in my family, and all the direct-line male relatives on both sides, went bald by their late twenties. Maybe I just got some good dice rolls and so this is a tiger rock, but when I noticed my hair just beginning to thin around age 23 I got on finasteride and have been taking it ever since. I'm 36 now, full head of hair, and if anything my hair grows fast enough that it's kind of annoying how often I need a trim.
eropple··on “Emergent” abilities in LLMs actually develop gradually and predictably – study
> Instead we must make sure somehow that LLM performing arithmetic operations using corresponding rules and axioms.

It isn't. It's stringing together likely tokens that approximate (often very effectively!) what its data corpus has done in the past. And, relatedly, the best way I've found GPT4 to solve a word problem is to tell it to write some Python code to spit out an answer; the actual computation part is an easier thing to figure out when it's just running code.

eropple··on The ü/ü Conundrum
Yes, but "reactji" is also weird and yet people use it for Slack reactions. It's fine.
eropple··on The ü/ü Conundrum
This shows up in other places, too. One of my Slacks has a textji of `groß`, because I enjoy making our German speakers' teeth grind, but you sure can just type `:gross:` to get it.
eropple··on People hate the idea of car-free cities until they live in one
> EDIT: And to be perfectly clear: I am not against cities building themselves toward car-freeness. I support citydwellers making their cities bikeable and walkable! I just don’t want to live there.

Are you willing to pay to account for the externalities that your preferences create? If so, I'm all for it, but let's be real: most folks aren't.

eropple··on People hate the idea of car-free cities until they live in one
Yeah, sorry, I meant to reply to 'smeej's post, not yours. :)
eropple··on People hate the idea of car-free cities until they live in one
You described pretty well my almost-suburban New England spot. I walk everywhere, because there's stuff everywhere. There's a guy down the street who built an add-on to his house and his wife runs a convenience store out of it. It's great. The problem is that there are (particularly American? I don't know) pathologies around ejecting from the idea of a community that you see in even those relatively tight-packed suburbs, and what you describe, while great, flies against that.

My parents (who are themselves not really the sort of folks you'd expect in an urban core, ha) didn't last in Iowa very long. They moved back to New England and while they live on like three acres now, they're friendly with all their neighbors in a way even I'm not in my relatively approachable community.

eropple··on People hate the idea of car-free cities until they live in one
I think this is kind of overstating the case, tbh. I don't even live in Boston anymore--I live on the South Shore--but I drive my car maybe once a week, usually to Home Depot or rarely on a pilgrimage to Micro Center. I bought a place where I could walk to a commuter rail stop (it's how I get to my office) and multiple supermarkets are within walking distance, so I bring a backpack. About half a dozen restaurants within a twenty-minute walk, another dozen or so if I go another ten minutes further. A couple weeks ago I walked to a museum in Quincy in like 45 minutes, it was really nice.

I wouldn't not want to have access to a car, but if car/truck rental wasn't such a mess, I would be happier without one. (When I bought this place I cut back the 4+ car driveway to two cars and reclaimed a bunch of yard, and it was great. I wish it could've been more!)

eropple··on People hate the idea of car-free cities until they live in one
> Or perhaps you wish to have a single family home with a yard, but work for a company with an office presence downtown, and need to take your kid to daycare on the way to work. You could do that on mass transit, but would spend less time if you could plot your own course and just go. Your ideal situation may not need a car, but it's not a universal situation.

These are definitely preferences that exist, yeah. How do you propose we account for the externalities created by executing on these preferences?

eropple··on People hate the idea of car-free cities until they live in one
If your single car is rivalrous to several other people's ability to live and work in the urban core, yes, that's a pretty good reason to discourage the car.

Massachusetts has park-and-ride, and it's pretty great!

eropple··on People hate the idea of car-free cities until they live in one
This is weirdly projective and I'm happy to be an obvious counterpoint to it. I grew up in the middle of nowhere. I moved to a city and didn't have a car for years. It was great and I wish I could've sustained it.

As-is, I have a car (the absolute cheapest thing I could find, for Home Depot runs during home renovation) but drive it once a week and commute to the city center by public transit because New England lets you do that, even if it's not as convenient as I'd like.

eropple··on People hate the idea of car-free cities until they live in one
This is true, but that model of suburban development still tends to push necessities out of walking or even biking distance. I visited my folks in the Des Moines suburbs while they were out there and it was an hour's walk to almost anything bigger than a corner store. Of which I found, I think, one that was closer than that.
eropple··on People hate the idea of car-free cities until they live in one
Who exactly do you think maintains the roads that cars need to run on? Or are you bombing around your carmaxxing city in a lifted 4Runner all day just in case you gotta Go Off-Road Because The Government Closed The Roads?

The whole concept is silly on its face.

eropple··on Oh shit, my app is successful and I didn't think about accessibility
A small base of users at any given time. Almost everyone needs "accessibility" eventually. You will, too, if you're lucky enough to live that long.
eropple··on What I wish I knew about ESPP and RSUs sooner
The newfound hype around DRS arises as a meme directly out of the Gamestop crankfest/fever-dream. It is harmless, but also meaningless; equities are not any more "yours" because of undertaking the timewaster of DRS and the concept is in current discourse as a shibboleth for membership in weird fin-cult silliness, which is exemplified really well in the parent poster's link to breathy, red-Arial-on-black "Central Bankers" fearmongering.

Dan Olson covers it effectively in "This Is Financial Advice", which is a sober and well-researched drubbing of the meme-stock culture from which this nonsense comes. Worth watching in its entirety, both for entertainment value and for its thorough treatment of the subject. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pYeoZaoWrA

(If you want to see a real-life BSOD, get one of these people into a corner and ask them how equities are going to survive the "market collapse" they magically-think is right around the corner, regardless of method of registration.)

eropple··on What I learned from looking at 900 most popular open source AI tools
I don't think that's true at all. I think most "CS majors" would need to study how to do those things, but none of them are conceptually difficult and build on the same algorithmic and data structures knowledge you learn for other tasks.

I never built a compiler until I did. I never built an operating system until I did. (I don't remember when I started doing computer graphics, though, because that was a long time ago.)

eropple··on Direct File officially opens in 12 pilot states
Federal workers are not project-fungible in such a way as to make what you suggest possible. And it's not just the federal government, either; ask any large corporation. There is no path to "well the IRS's developers should just go make Login.gov happen faster", even if you get a hall pass from the mythical man-month.

So, now that we've acknowledged reality--what now? Do nothing, while the active harm continues, because of fear of a hypothetical future (but with a limited time horizon) one?

eropple··on Direct File officially opens in 12 pilot states
Why? Iteration is something to be embraced rather than stigmatized in moving towards a more responsive set of government services. Login.gov is the future of government identity in the United States, but IAL2 is a higher bar than most government services need; waiting for IAL2 implementation is a tradeoff in favor of understandable-but-abstract risks against addressing a concrete harm that exists now.

You have an opt-out (use the existing methods of filing, including mail), and you're not harmed or even treated less preferentially by the existence of the ID.me option.

eropple··on IRS has launched its free tax filing service, Direct File, in 12 states
Such is the price of a lot of lobbying from those who stood (and still stand) to profit from capturing the audience.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →