HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

esoteriq

222 karma · joined February 6, 2011

cristina.hartmann [at] gmail
submissionscomments
esoteriq··on Investor Concern Grows Over Founders Cashing Out Too Much, Too Early
Admittedly, I'm a cynic, but I'm a bit suspicious of the investors' motivations behind their alleged concern.

Sure, it may loosen the founders' ties to the company, but it also loosens the founders' ties to the investors. Investors cannot influence founders with more liquidity (by say, diluting the founders' shares if possible).

Then again, I am a bit of a cynic.

esoteriq··on The rise of the 99-cent Kindle e-book
I'm not sure if Amazon's policy of 70% royalties for 2.99+ books will make any difference. Expectations are dramatically lowered (and reviews are inversely related) for 99 cent books compared to 3-dollar books.

I was amazed to read the overflowing positive reviews of a 99 cent book that was so poorly edited and written that I had to stop reading it. The reviews lauded the author's ability to entertain at such a low price. I'm not sure how many authors can give up such positive reviews (fueled by low expectations).

esoteriq··on United States v. Google Inc. and ITA Software, Inc.
IN a way you're right. I assume it's because once a monopoly exists or once antitrust practices occur, the damage is irreversible. A company wiped out because of some other company's illegal actions can never return to its "former glory".

Also, it's a "reasonable probability" that the illegal actions would occur and that's enough in this context.

That's my guess anyway.

esoteriq··on Ceglia v. Zuckerberg returns, with a bang - biglaw representation, lots of email
Well, the legal sector isn't doing too well right now. Perhaps DLA Piper has too many idle lawyers right now - at least this is work.

Not saying that this is the case, but it's possible.

esoteriq··on Judge to copyright troll: your "business model" isn't my problem
Ah, but by the time the tech-savvy law students become judges, they may not be tech-savvy anymore.

This is only from my own experience at law school. There were relatively few truly tech-savvy folks out there. Almost everyone I knew still used Microsoft Word to type their lecture notes and outlines. (MS Word is terrible for this purpose - its internal formatting gets weird after a certain amount of bullet points.) I used special software for my lecture notes from a startup, and other students viewed me as "weird". I was also the first law student to use Dropbox to back up my work - seriously. (There were some other law students who were programmers before, but they are a different class of lawyers.)

I'm not entirely sure that a legion of new lawyers who know how to use MS Word, computers and the internet are "technologically-savvy". More tech-savvy than old lawyers? absolutely. Compared to the rest of society? Eh.

esoteriq··on Judge to copyright troll: your "business model" isn't my problem
Maybe, maybe not.

David Kerr, the defense laywer, was going to file numerous motions to dismiss/ change venues. That would have ran up the copyright troll's legal bills. I suspect that the judge would have happily gone along with Kerr's plan, but who knows?

Doesn't really matter in this case anyway. The mere threat of actual litigation scared Righthaven away.

esoteriq··on Judge to copyright troll: your "business model" isn't my problem
It's interesting to note that one of the defendant's decent laywer ended up scaring off the copyright troll. Apparently, the IP lawyer involved was going to argue RightHaven into the ground, by raising many motions, running up the copyright troll's legal bills (wrong venue, failure to make a claim, etc.) It's the penultimate case of turning the tables!

The judge said some nice things about abuse of the courts, but look at the lawyer for the real victory.

esoteriq··on Court says Winklevoss twins must accept Facebook deal
That would imply self-awareness, which does not seem to be their strength.
esoteriq··on Court says Winklevoss twins must accept Facebook deal
No - this is an appeal, no juries involved. Judges rule the appeal-land.

But I'm sure Kozinksi (sp?) saw the social Network. Heh.

esoteriq··on How an informal IM exchange cost one business a million dollars
That's certainly one way to do it. The Federal Rules of Evidence is pretty flexible on ways to authenticate different documents. If you look at Rule 901, a party who offers the document as genuine can authenticate it by witness testimony, expert testimony, process (the document could only be obtained via a specific process), etc.

See: http://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/fre/rules.htm (search for 901).

esoteriq··on Are the Self-Made Rich More Generous Than Heirs?
This may just be me, but the article did not answer the question at all. At the end, the author basically washes his (her?) hands of the question and says that there is no reliable data to make a decisive statement.

So, I'm not so sure about Bill Gates' statement about the "noveau riche" being more generous. Maybe at the billionaire level, but what about the measly millionaires? Are they also generous? Also, what kind of charities do they give to? Giving money to their alma mater to build a statute or to name a building is quite different than what Bill Gates is doing.

esoteriq··on Colleges Discriminate Against the Blind With Google Apps, Advocates Say
Thanks for that - I shouldn't have said that what I said about IT departments. You're right - there are a lot of external factors that comes into play whenever these types of decisions get made.

I'm pretty sympathetic with the need to cut costs - hosting email gets expensive. I just hope that higher education pushes Google Apps and other education-based services to abide by Section 508 Accessibility Guidelines (and the guidelines are not even as sophisticated as they could be). You gotta start somewhere, yes?

esoteriq··on Colleges Discriminate Against the Blind With Google Apps, Advocates Say
It amazes and shocks me that colleges still don't check the accessibility of their educational tools. Ever since the ADA and the Rehab Act of 1973 (Rehab Act only applied to schools getting federal grants), schools have been required to provide students with disabilities with equal access. But there are still foul-ups all over the place.

This reminds me of the Kindle debacle last year. Some universities provided Kindle DXs to students for course reading. Guess what? The text-to-speech feature is not enabled for all of the kindle books (copyright issues - a whole seperate story). The universities had to settle with the DOJ and DOE.

Here's a legal opinion letter from the Department of Education Office of Civil Rights - http://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/letters/colleague-... (tl;dr: don't use inaccessible technologies for classroom learning). .

esoteriq··on Startup Visa has a bill number: S.565
Well, I'm not sure about the partisan thing...

But, when I worked on the Hill (yes, I was one of those) as a staffer, we did look on the internet to gauge the public reaction towards a particular issue. If (and only if) it matched with the congressperson's political agenda, we could suggest that the congressperson "push the issue" in caucus or debates.

Although, internet comments and news aggregators would never swing a politician's perspective on an issue (only money does, kidding...kind of).

So, there is some political weight in internet comments, but if you really want to ensure your contribution, call up your representative. (Seriously, they have people to handle these calls - it takes 5 minutes.)

esoteriq··on If I haven't succeeded in my mid 20s, could I be successful?
Yes, excellent point. I was thinking about that as well. Just to expand on your comment, it's interesting to think more about the generational differences. I know that my generation (I'm in my mid-20s) was one of the first generation that had kids learning programming and starting internet businesses in high school.

My dad who is in his 70s now studied computer science, but he sees computer science as more of an academic area rather than practical.

I think you're right - the younger generation will continue cutting their teeth on the internet phenomenon throughout their 30s, 40s and (gasp) 50s.

Once again, just because most of the famous billionaires-by-age-25 are internet wunderkids doesn't mean that youth is a necessary ingredient for entrepreneurial success.

esoteriq··on If I haven't succeeded in my mid 20s, could I be successful?
The more interesting question is why there is incredible pressure in Silicon Valley and other tech hubs to be successful by 30. In other professions, particularly ones that require graduate education such as law or medicine, it's almost impossible to be "successful" by 30.

I suppose the easy and simple answer is: one must be young to "understand" what the youth market wants. Facebook went after the college market at first, and Zuckerberg was a college student, so that makes sense, right?

Well, life is what you make of it. Sometimes circumstances prevent young successes. That doesn't mean that anyone should give up. In fact, it may be a self-fulfilling prophecy - people are so enamored with the idea of being a billionaire by 25 that if they don't make it by age 28, they give up.

Life is your own story and you are the only writer.

esoteriq··on Sleep is more important than food
Yes, but that doesn't refute my point. My point was sleep deprivation doesn't make better doctors or even encourage better doctors to stay.

Frankly, I'm surprised that as many doctors make it through - the working conditions are pretty terrible. Maybe the pay makes up for it, but you only get paid well once you get out of your residency or fellowship.

Better conditions will probably produce better doctors, not subpar doctors.

esoteriq··on Sleep is more important than food
Does it have to be? There are only 133 Medical Schools in the U.S. and there is a marked shortage of doctors in some areas, most notably general family doctors.

The only area that learning how to deal with sleep deprivation would be a benefit is surgery and critical care areas (ICUs). But then again, if you could schedule things better and get more doctors in, maybe these doctors don't have to learn how to function on 5 hours of sleep.

I think you're right to the extent that the current medical service system requires doctors to learn to sleep less and less while functioning on an acceptable level (note that I didn't say satisfactory or even exceptional). But I think that's begging the question. Shouldn't we be able to change the current system and allow doctors to focus on building skills/knowledge, not the ability to function without sleep.

tl;dr: sleep deprivation is not a necessary part of being a doctor if we change the system, so saying that doctors must learn how to deal with sleep deprivation is a circular argument.

esoteriq··on Lack of regulation is the main reason for huge success of the web
Absolutely. Regulation can kill an emerging industry in its infancy. But, now I wonder - is that assumption still true? The internet has been mainstream (and I use the word loosely) for the last 10 years or so. Hell, I'm in my mid-20s and I remember using Internet when I was eight (hi Prodigy...haven't seen you around in a while!).

I was wondering if the internet has become so widespread that some regulation (but very little, since it is indeed very difficult to regulate). For example, last October, Congress passed the 21st Centry Video Accessibility Act, which among other things, requires pass-through captioning for videos on the internet (http://www.fcc.gov/Daily_Releases/Daily_Business/2010/db1207...).

I'm undecided on the matter. More than any other industries, internet-based companies seem to respond to privacy and security concerns. Of course, the issue is that there are usually big screw-ups inspire such responses, such as leaking personal data by mistake.

Well, I do think some regulation is inevitable though - considering how important the internet is becoming. Once something becomes crucial to a segment of America's economy, the government wants to step in and protect people's interests (or at least what they perceive to be people's interests). I would prefer such regulation be limited to requiring open standards/access and net neutrality.

esoteriq··on How Deaf People Think
Really? Interesting. All these years, I've been wondering "what in the hell do hearing people HEAR?" Good to know that perhaps my hearing is not as drastically different from others as I feared.
esoteriq··on How Deaf People Think
You know, I was thinking about this recently. Since the operation is quite expensive (tens of thousands of dollars), insurance coverage is a must. It's hard to get insurance coverage for a new internal component if mine is still functional. Also, today's technology - in terms of the internal component - is not that much better than what I got in 1991. For example, right now I have 22 channels, but the best that one can get today is 24 channels. The improvement is relatively small for the amount of hassle that I would have to go through to get that improvement - surgery, recovery time, etc.

Like all surgeries, cochlear implant surgery has risks. I don't want to take heedless risks, so I'm content with what I have for right now. Although I think I would get the surgery if the implant was 100% internal - no more external parts!

esoteriq··on How Deaf People Think
Yeah, that comment didn't really make sense to me either.

I'm fluent in ASL, and I have a working knowledge of BSL. What I can tell is that ASL is more conceptual than BSL. BSL tends to track the English language more closely. For example, ASL will have one sign that expresses an entire sentence, but BSL will most likely have individual signs reflecting the individual words in the sentence. (This is not always true, of course.)

All of sign languages depend primarily on gestures and facial expressions.

esoteriq··on How Deaf People Think
Neat! I've never bothered to go to these websites before.

Although I should point out that most people today who have cochlear implants have 22 or 24 channels, not one. I have 22 channels in one ear and 24 in the other. (You have to click through to get to these channels though).

As I mentioned before, I never really developed appreciation for music. It's probably a result of never really hearing music as it should be heard. Oh well.

esoteriq··on How Deaf People Think
Sure - no problem. Just to give you some context, I got my implant in 1991, and technology has advanced by leaps and bounds since then.

Cochlear implants are quite different than hearing aids. Hearing aids just amplify sounds. Cochlear implants actually directly stimulates your auditory nerve via a surgical implant, mimicking sound. Normally, sound waves pass through your cochlea and stimulate the multiple hair cells, triggering different "sounds" (as interpreted by your brain). Since the cochlear implant stimulates the auditory nerve more directly, once a person is implanted, the person loses all of his or her residuary hearing. Obviously, only people with profound or severe hearing losses are allowed to get a cochlear implant.

My cochlear implant has two components - the inner and external portions. The external portion is the speech processor and it looks somewhat like a hearing aid without the ear mold and it has a magnetic part that attaches to your head. The speech processor converts sounds into electrical signals that goes through a magnet that is attached to my head. The electrical signal will pass through the internal parts of my cochlear implant (the implants itself) and stimulate the nerve, causing me to hear sound. I should add that the conversion process filters out most background noises and focuses on frequencies used for speech. As a result, I can't really appreciate music because with the limited frequency range of the cochlear implant, music sounds all muddled to me.

Of course, that's the technical part. I can hear, but I can't hear anywhere as well as a hearing person. I still have a lot of difficulties hearing in a noisy situation, such as restaurants, bars, etc. I can't really differentiate between certain sounds such as b/ps, g/hs and the like.

I can, however, converse with most people. I have an "accent" because I learned how to speak relatively late - 8 years old. I have met people who got their implants when they were two or three and they barely have an accent.

One thing I should also add - most people who receive a cochlear implant need special training to use it. Since I was one of the first 500 children to receive a cochlear implant after the FDA approved it for children, I underwent intensive speech-and-listening training. I had to learn how to listen since I had no frame of reference for sound. I'm sure you can imagine how hard it is to get a six-year old to sit still and practice listening for hours at a time. It took me two years before I could start learning how to speak. I didn't feel comfortable speaking in public until I was thirteen or so.

Of course, the process is quite different for someone who heard before they got an implant because he or she has a frame of reference. After talking to younger implant recipients, I get the impression that the technology and training methods have improved, so the whole process isn't as onerous anymore.

Hopefully this wasn't too much information and if I misstated something (probably biology-related) I apologize in advance! If you have more questions, feel free to ask!

esoteriq··on How Deaf People Think
Long-time lurker here - this is one of the first articles that I've felt compelled to respond to. I have a unique perspective on deafness and language.

I was born profoundly deaf (so deaf that audiologists proclaimed me as the deafest child ever - what an honor). I learned ASL when I was six months old. To preface - I was incredibly lucky to have parents who learned an entire new language for me (they were immigrants, so it was no easy task for them) and noticed my deafness early. I also got a cochlear implant, which enables me to hear speech fairly well. Over the years, I've learned how to speak and listen well enough to converse with most people. I've also managed to maintain my fluency in ASL - it's a very important part of who I am.

According to my mother, I was able to express my desires (I want orange juice, my diapers need changing, etc.) as early as 8 months. So, I was able to talk to my parents at a different level than hearing infants of the same age.

I have plenty of deaf friends who were not as lucky. Some of them had hearing losses that were not discovered until they were more than two years old. Some of them just had parents who didn't want to or could not learn ASL. Their performance, academic and otherwise, has lagged behind their hearing peers. I find that their thoughts are not as organized as someone who learned language early on (regardless of form), so some of their actions don't have "common sense." Frankly, the benign neglect I see with deaf children is shocking and quite depressing. It makes me grateful for what I had growing up.

This article also made me think about how different my thought process is from hearing people's processes. Even after years of using speech as my main mode of communication, ASL still influences my thoughts quite heavily. For example, I tend to think about spatial matters in ASL - i.e. how a street is laid out. Also, I tend to think about emotions in ASL, complete with facial expressions. On the other hand, with more technical issues such as the law (I'm a lawyer), I'll think in words, even spoken words sometimes.

In all and all, I'm grateful that I was able to learn ASL so early and transition to spoken language. ASL really enriched my life - culturally and mentally - and I'm very glad that ASL was my first language.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2