HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

estearum

5,153 karma · joined July 31, 2025

submissionscomments
estearum··on US inequality is getting worse in ways you might not expect
The wealthy pay the vast majority of taxes because they make so much more than everyone else.

Completely hilarious argument because the more asymmetrically wealthy the richest get, the larger proportion of taxes they’ll pay. Then they’ll whine some more about paying such a huge portion of taxes.

Anyway, the US government is designed to be inefficient. It is a purposeful safeguard against autocracy and more pedestrian corruption. It will not be as efficient as private enterprise because private enterprise doesn’t need to be accountable to everyone.

Surely government services can and should be more efficient than they are today, but “I’ve managed things more complex than healthcare.gov” is only true in a world of frictionless spherical cows and a bureaucracy-free government of 380 million people — that is to say: not reality.

estearum··on Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data center
Obviously you’re making this argument in bad faith, but just so other readers are clear:

Cutting down trees and replacing them with an industrial park is not a form of carbon capture.

The vast majority of logged biomass does not get turned into long-term wood products.

estearum··on Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data center
Because it’s a broader pattern that people are worried about…?

I’m confused about what you’re confused about.

Is a person who gets into 150 car accidents not a legitimately bigger story than a person who gets into one car accident?

estearum··on Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data center
It’s funny that we’re getting rid of cold climate places by 1) felling trees (small bundles at a time!) and 2) building data centers
estearum··on Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data center
How many times do we get to take “microscopic compared to total forested land” away?

Boy I sure hope it’s infinity times!

Anyway it seems like you’re incorrect. They actually didn’t have the approval necessary, and no, a zoning approval does not grant all other required forms of approval (obviously).

estearum··on Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data center
Typically things like zoning and environmental assessments are done by different organizations with different mandates.
estearum··on Jared Kushner Hacked Phone Reveals Secret Negotiations, Millions in Transactions
So when Hunter joined Burisma he also had a cushy job as counsel at Boies Schiller. Probably getting paid $1MM+. Boies Schiller is a US law firm, and Joe Biden is the VP of the US.

Does this also invoke appearance of impropriety to you?

estearum··on Jared Kushner Hacked Phone Reveals Secret Negotiations, Millions in Transactions
Yes, my view was adequately described here: "Obviously he's a nepobaby but nothing on his resume is atypical of the types of people who serve on boards for companies like Burisma. Top law school, cushy investor and advisory gigs, serving on boards, etc."

That would imply there are many similar nepobabies serving in such roles. "Nepobaby" does not necessarily mean someone is not qualified for a given role. It means they utilize their parents' status to grow their own. Obviously a Senator's child has massive advantages throughout their life. As described above... those advantages often produce exactly the life path he had (just like his Burisma board colleagues, and just like many board members of many corporate boards).

Perhaps you should say explicitly what you mean by "you should be careful about..." What specifically constitutes "being careful" about such a thing? And what exactly are they being careful of? The possibility of an appearance of impropriety?

Getting sweet gigs because your dad is a Senator and then a VP because people love hiring cushy connected people to cushy connected jobs is not, in and of itself improper. It's absolutely a reason to pay close attention to all such family members of all such politicians, but if the "paying close attention" doesn't yield actual evidence of actual wrongdoing, you can't just assume otherwise.

P.S. Don't put in quotes things that people didn't actually say. That was quite clearly not my line of questioning.

estearum··on Jared Kushner Hacked Phone Reveals Secret Negotiations, Millions in Transactions
Yes? As described above: it’s the type of educational and career trajectory that is typical of nepobabies. “Here’s another nepobaby” is not a refutation.

I’m not sure what evidence of impropriety one is supposed to derive from a publicly traded American company having a different board compensation scheme than a privately held Ukrainian company… perhaps you could connect the dots more explicitly?

estearum··on Jared Kushner Hacked Phone Reveals Secret Negotiations, Millions in Transactions
Several people on the Burisma board had little to no experience in the energy sector or Ukraine. In fact most people on most boards have no direct experience in the specific domain of the company. Boards are not operating the company, they aren't managing it. They are governing it. The most common way to become a board member is to invest in the company. Obviously most companies are not investment companies, ergo outside investors are not experts in the company's domain.

Here's the profile of someone who served alongside Hunter. Pretty similar: https://www.sofocleous.com.cy/en/people/christina-sofocleous...

The chairman of the board was a Columbia-educated lawyer from Sullivan and Cromwell (similar to Hunter's Boies Schiller role) who went into investment banking at Merrill Lynch and Morgan Stanley.

By what metric is $65,000 per month "pretty high?" Compared to other Burisma board members? Board members are typically paid the same base salary.

estearum··on France needs to read my paper
> description of verifiable economic facts

> "It seems you have already made up your mind. Good luck in life."

have a good one amigo

estearum··on France needs to read my paper
The entire Wiki article is a description of how alloidal ownership is not a lease from a higher owner. You are profoundly confused.
estearum··on Jared Kushner Hacked Phone Reveals Secret Negotiations, Millions in Transactions
Can you be very specific in how Hunter "defrauded the American public?" I genuinely have never heard a specific allegation (other than like drugs and hookers and guns, obviously)
estearum··on France needs to read my paper
> meaning the land value is mostly inconsequential when already built on except in a small number of cases.

Literally false. In high-cost areas the land value is the bulk of the value of a property. Properties that would have a high LVT burden are almost definitionally those where the structure on top of the land is of little or negative value. Negative-value buildings are extremely common in high-cost areas today.

I struggle to believe you’re actually having a hard time understanding this point, but “the people” who produce high land values are not the people who capture those land values. That’s the point. Just because they’re both “people” doesn’t mean they’re fungible in the question of who earned what.

estearum··on France needs to read my paper
No, they’re not “named differently.” They are different things. The government does not own all the land in the US. They have completely distinct mechanisms to take ownership of land.
estearum··on France needs to read my paper
So why would they have a high LVT burden?
estearum··on France needs to read my paper
You are incorrect.

The US has alloidal land ownership (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allodial_title). If you own the land in the US, you are the actual owner of that land.

However, the government still has the power to tax you, and they have the power to seize your property if you don't pay your taxes. But note that this is not dependent on some (nonexistent) concept of higher landlord, because the government can seize things like your car under the exact same general taxation authority. None of it is predicated on "higher ownership" because higher ownership doesn't exist, it's "just" taxation.

You can go ahead and do the whole "all taxation is theft" song and dance if you want. It's uninteresting to me and everyone else, so perhaps save the HN comment board for something more substantive.

estearum··on France needs to read my paper
UBI is a very stupid idea, in large part because it will get funneled into land values.

> Seems like supporters think it can fund anything and everything.

Well yes, money can be used to fund "anything and everything." This is actually a key characteristic of money. If your implicit argument is that LVT can't produce enough money to fund reverse mortgages, you obviously aren't really thinking about the words you're reading. Because using LVT to fund a reverse mortgage with the purpose of paying the LVT doesn't require any money. It's simply exchanging the latent equity in a building for a reduced land value tax bill.

> This isnt true in the least. Land value calculations would be require all sorts of regulations and appeal processes to set true land value and prevent gaming the system

No not really. Land valuation is pretty much automatable now.

estearum··on France needs to read my paper
No, people should own property that they created or that someone else created and willingly sold to them. Land values are by definition neither of those things.

> The government is much more likely to be the one using threat of force to take your property for lack of tax payment than anyone else is for any other reason.

Physical coercion is much more common to enforce evictions than nonpayment of taxes. This is because landlords offloaded the responsibility of enforcement and security back to the peasants in exchange for having rule of law.

> The value of land is only what people make of it.

This entire paragraph is meaningless. More valuable land is more valuable because it's more productive. It is more productive not because of the actions of the owner of that land, but because of either 1) nature's productive power, or 2) the surroundings of that land (nearby amenities, infrastructure, employers, etc). In either case, the owner of the plot of land did not produce the value of the raw land. They are not entitled to upside they did not produce.

estearum··on France needs to read my paper
What "industrious poor" people are you thinking of who own extremely valuable land but don't do extremely valuable things upon that land?
estearum··on France needs to read my paper
Singapore uses a system that is economically ~identical. Nearly all the land is owned by the state and leased to private parties on 99 year leases who pay "land rents" to the state.

An LVT is a way to produce the same economic effects without the starting point of "the state owns the land," which is hard to transition to from "the state does not own the land."

estearum··on France needs to read my paper
1) LVT suppresses rent growth

2) LVT can fund reverse mortgages

> Any discussion about taxes is a complete non-starter. France needs less taxes, not more. Their entire society and business environment is completely taxed out and they still can't afford their public welfare and benefits. They need to reduce public spending in order to maybe one day, also reduce taxes.

Yes, most developed countries are overtaxed. They should get rid of nearly all of them and replace them with a high LVT. Near-zero regulatory complexity, paperwork, enforcement burden, or economic distortions.

estearum··on France needs to read my paper
The obscene limitation on freedom and liberty is the idea that a person can stake a claim to earth's productive power and deny everyone else the upside under threat of injury or death.
estearum··on Ask HN: If the models are so good, why doesn't OpenAI just start 100 companies?
Don’t they have a fully committed preorder for like $500 billion in compute from Oracle starting in 2028? And Oracle is funding that buildout with junk debt?
estearum··on Jared Kushner Hacked Phone Reveals Secret Negotiations, Millions in Transactions
Yes? You're describing someone having a private sector job... like how private citizens do...

Did you know Hunter at the time he joined Burisma had an 18-year career as a Yale-educated corporate lawyer, PE and VC investor, and lobbyist?

Obviously he's a nepobaby but nothing on his resume is atypical of the types of people who serve on boards for companies like Burisma.

Top law school, cushy investor and advisory gigs, serving on boards, etc.

estearum··on Most Americans Say AI Is Bad for Society, Oppose More Data Centers
And surely “the public” doesn’t include “thepryz” though!
estearum··on Jared Kushner Hacked Phone Reveals Secret Negotiations, Millions in Transactions
IMO the pardon power was an absolute mistake and I’m totally fine with us just burning this bridge for good.
estearum··on Jared Kushner Hacked Phone Reveals Secret Negotiations, Millions in Transactions
Biden’s laptop was in the possession of “someone” who brought it to a blind computer repair person (seriously!), who then got in touch with Rudy Giuliani, who then leaked the contents to the media… and so we can’t really know who actually gained possession of it. The repair man was blind lol.
estearum··on Jared Kushner Hacked Phone Reveals Secret Negotiations, Millions in Transactions
The President’s son being a private citizen versus the President’s son in law being some pseudo-secretary of state?
estearum··on Jared Kushner Hacked Phone Reveals Secret Negotiations, Millions in Transactions
The reason that power centralizes is that decentralized powers tend to get outcompeted (in the short run) by centralized powers.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →