5,154 karma · joined July 31, 2025
It’s an ultra-high productivity region which naturally drives up land rents, and California has simply opted out of collecting those rents, which then perversely amplifies the land values even further.
The “this” that LVT solves is not “billionaires exist,” it’s “a state can be the most productive place in the world and end up with spiraling COL and revenues ultra-concentrated in just a few individuals.”
Classic HN to take a problem like this and just assert it’s easily solvable while proposing no such solutions. Even SCOTUS couldn’t define porn and you’re expecting content platforms to define (without discretion!) a far broader set of far squishier concepts at far higher scale.
Truly classic HN.
You are (mistakenly) substantiating it though: there has not been new evidence in favor of the lab leak in several years! You're right!
Meanwhile, evidence in favor of a natural origin has continued to pile up.
It's telling that you refuse to just follow your own logic and rationale even just a single step further.
Ah this must be why you're confused. You think the hazard that platforms are trying to manage is from "individuals within the community" and not, for example, foreign intelligence services.
> information now accepted to be true or likely (such as that COVID most likely originated from a Chinese lab)
Lmao uh oh. The mark of the terminally-online has been revealed! Hilarious how many Twitterites have come to simply believe that COVID originated from a lab over the last year or two despite zero new evidence emerging in favor of that theory, and actually tons of evidence against it emerging since then. It's almost like if read false information enough times, you'll just presume it to be true... Curious ain't it?
If you disagree with the logic, then identify which part you disagree with. Here are your options:
1. Content moderation teams should not have been suspicious of an unsourced, anonymous story on NYPost based on allegedly stolen material
2. Content moderation teams should not impede content that they suspect are election interference attempts
Which is it?
But since you apparently have a better one, how about you propose a standard?
Is it that anyone can post anything?
The boundaries around vanilla are certainly blurry, but I don’t think No Kings comes even remotely close to any of those blurry boundaries.
It was absolutely reasonable to suspect (in the early hours) that a salacious, bombshell story involving stolen documents published on NYPost without a listed author could potentially have been an actual disinformation attack.
Under that set of facts, the “we should try to limit interference in the election” can reasonably yield the behavior that it did yield.
I agree this would be even more egregious if it was thought to be a real story, but even the tabloid that published it didn’t think so.
Pretty sure the link suppression was turned off within like a day, right?
Hate speech, porn, bullying, doxxing, disinformation, Islamist propaganda, violent imagery, revenge porn, animal abuse imagery, incitements to violence, criminal planning, drug dealing, arms dealing, gambling, fraud, etc
As a free speech maximalist, are you willing to defend all of those with the same vigor as the COVID case? Or do you too actually draw a content-based line somewhere (while pretending you don’t?)
These conversations often end up in some weird motte and bailey where you argue that you care about free speech, but it turns out that you actually just thought COVID was not real/not significant/not dangerous/not an emergency. So your issue ends up not being that they made a decision on it (free speech concern), but that you feel it was the wrong decision (content-specific concern).
So before we go back and forth on the intricacies of content moderation, can you briefly describe your beliefs on COVID?
It seems like you’re trying to avoid dealing with the substance of the issue for some reason.
I certainly don’t “expect” (in the normative sense) countries to continue relying on these services. Breaking network effects is hard, but I wouldn’t blame a country for trying and I’d probably be happy with them succeeding (to the extent they facilitate free expression of their people).
But characterizing opposition to Trump as “just leftists perma-complaining,” is incorrect. He’s the least popular POTUS in American history.
This administration has been repeatedly found in court to be violating the law and the US Constitution. It is not a partisan expectation or leftist complaint that the government must follow the law.
There’s a reason autocrats hate protests. It’s because they’d much rather that opposition become doubtful of whether other opposition exist out there.
TFA (and you) are just discounting the power of network effects. Tells me that your judgment is poor and I should not listen to you ;)