HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

etripe

639 karma · joined May 27, 2019

submissionscomments
etripe··on Which jobs most often pair together among married couples
Interesting. Too bad it doesn't also provide specifics on bisexuals or the gender axis.
etripe··on Nobel Prize: We will not have gender or ethnicity quotas – top scientist
My most charitable read is that women's issues have gotten more attention and the quality is otherwise the same. A less charitable read is that the number of female political fall guys has increased, although that could just be a case of women having the same "defect rate" as men. Despite regularly following the news, I couldn't tell you whether (on average) female characteristics have made a difference.
etripe··on Nobel Prize: We will not have gender or ethnicity quotas – top scientist
I would have thought it obvious that sex quota are inherently sexist. Benignly sexist perhaps, but sexist nonetheless. Apparently not?
etripe··on Nobel Prize: We will not have gender or ethnicity quotas – top scientist
Here in Belgium, quotas were introduced in politics in eighties IIRC. According to prominent women at the time and now, that was the reason we are closer to parity in politics nowadays. Their line of reasoning, obviously from a feminist perspective, is that the quotas ensured that not all women could be excluded and enough of them made it through to positions that mattered in a sexist apparatus. Survivor's bias will of course confirm that this is the reason they made it. After the fact, up and coming women could see examples/representation in the women that made it in, which I do believe helps.

I have lived and worked in a foreign country. When I got my first job there, my new boss joked I'd gotten the job because of diversity quotas. I was horrified at the idea that my skills wouldn't matter but only my status of a being an non-native. So I can see where you're coming from with the "quota-thing".

I am sceptical, like you. Quotas are inherently discriminatory, but I am open to the idea that if the entrenched elite is bigoted or biased too it might be the only way to break things open.

etripe··on When users never use the features they asked for
Ask them flatout how they reward initiative and accomplishment. If they start fumbling, there's your answer. If they don't, ask them for a concrete example. If that's when they struggle, there's your answer.
etripe··on Domain-Driven Design
Good post. The technical patterns are nigh useless unless you're going all in on event sourcing and/or CQRS - and perhaps even then. KISS > DDD.

To me, what matters are the strategic patterns, i.e. how you think and talk about your domain. What a lot of (microservice) software gets wrong is bounded contexts and APIs, which can be improved through event storming (discussing what kind of things happen in your domain) and context mapping (how that [sub]domain interacts with others). And then there's ubiquitous language, or calling the thing what it is to the business, not some programmer gobbledygook.

etripe··on MDMA reopens child-like “critical periods” in the brain
IIRC: historical trade deals that included opting into the war on drugs.
etripe··on A generation of American men give up on college
It's closer in meaning to "no one really knows what they're doing". Half-assing implies lack of effort. This expression implies lack of insight or direction.
etripe··on I went to the office for the first time. I fucking hated it
That only really happens if the on-site people neglect to provide the remote workers with a summary. Even when everyone still came in to the office, this happened to sick workers, people on different shifts, locations, teams, etc. In other words: it's about emotional intelligence and seeing yourself as part of a team, not working in an office.
etripe··on For developers, Safari is crap and outdated
It's also worth mentioning that Apple is a hardware company and that you need a Mac to even compile native apps for their platform.
etripe··on The Insecurity Industry
> Isn't that the point?

If the money is supposed to go towards people preventing damage, wouldn't that include devs?

> How much of this is due to liability law and how much is due to natural aspects of the relevant technology?

I can only speak from my own experience in biotech, but moving slowly was due to a lot of compliance box-ticking that didn't actually contribute a lot to either safety, reducing defect rate or meeting requirements. Conway's law applied: since bio engineers and lab techs move slowly, so did the software org.

etripe··on Ad men sacked to improve gender pay gap win sex discrimination claim
How is hiring along innate characteristics going to increase diversity? Are you of the opinion that a group consisting of Oprah Winfrey, Mike Tyson, Dave Chapelle and Barack Obama is homogenous just because they're all black? Do you think a randomly picked candidate from that pool would equally increase diversity in a team of college educated middle class programmers, or might there be a difference between their perspectives that goes beyond "African-American"?
etripe··on Ad men sacked to improve gender pay gap win sex discrimination claim
> Obviously as a white male I experience incredible privilege overall.

Only if you limit privilege to negative reward (suffer less discrimination and exclusion) instead of positive reward (getting actual benefits) and as you say, the tide is turning. Positive reward is still mainly tied to class and generational wealth.

> I'm not mad

Do you think it makes sense for a for-profit enterprise to have hiring policies based on the political sensibilities of the staff, let alone mainly those of SJW middle class white women?

etripe··on Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else.
While you largely have a point, I think you're perhaps a little too optimistic about the big picture, especially when factoring in timelines.

Simply saying no to cars doesn't solve the problem of transporting goods of any kind, e.g. a family load of food shopping for the week, furniture or building materials when doing a house renovation.

And while covid has nudged employment towards a more decentralised model, some countries (the US comes to mind, especially in rural areas or AFAIK cities like LA) don't really have a public transport alternative, for instance.

etripe··on Wikipedia co-founder: I no longer trust the website I created [video]
Truth being relative is a recent phenomenon, but only from a historian's perspective. Post-modernism has been mainstream for three, four decades. I don't see it going away any time soon, because it's awfully compatible with our marketing driven economies. What matters (and coincidentally, sells) is not what reality is, but the stories you can tell about it. Not vanilla or chocolate, but liberty (0).

Covid became a very partisan issue across the world, despite the numbers being clear. So have climate change, incarceration versus rehabilitation, drug legalisation versus prohibition, increasing minimum wages, single-payer healthcare systems, quantitative easing or austerity. It doesn't seem to me the data was ever the problem. Are you arguing basic scientific literacy is?

[0] https://www.quotes.net/mquote/129661

etripe··on Building a vision of life without work (2015)
That's not a problem. The difference is you put the thoughts on the back burner during off hours, which will often lead to greater insights than mulling over them constantly. Inspiration requires inactivity.

This is also something you can learn through techniques that fall under what HR might call mindfulness. After a while, you have a mental git stash that you can just pop. It's not entirely lossless, but the benefits to life are immense.

etripe··on EU withheld a study that shows piracy doesn't hurt sales (2017)
To me it looks like either "cleft palate wide smile" or "twirly moustache grin".
etripe··on EU withheld a study that shows piracy doesn't hurt sales (2017)
> Good, that's what competition is about between services.

Except the competition isn't between services but between streaming services and local TV channels. It's between artificially maintained "content regions" that have no basis in technological reality. The choice to host content isn't up to consumers. The period of availability is hardly ever displayed. There are platform and operating system constraints.

Finally, the pricing model doesn't allow you to say you want to watch one series and that's it, either - you'd have to sign up for a month of services, a cable package, etc. In fact, it can't reflect the price of individual content at all given that everything is a package.

You have the right to disagree, but calling a dissenting opinion ridiculous is uncalled for, given that there are actual service and distribution failings in the sector.

etripe··on I Stopped Using Emojis
Interesting. Do you think there's no place for ethical discussions in tech, or is your objection closer to the "unelected elite" side of things?
etripe··on You need Software Developers to believe in your project (2020)
Are you finding, getting and keeping the professionals you want? In other words, do your employees seem to agree with you?
etripe··on Defeating Cookie Banners
The GDPR is explicit about that: non-functional stuff should be turned off by default. No, marketing isn't functional. If companies follow the law, the default is set at "I don't want to participate in your bullshit".

It's just that a lot of companies are employing dark patterns or getting it wrong on purpose, and it's working because people are now annoyed at GDPR instead of the companies doing this.

etripe··on Check If Email Exists
I don't know if it's always spam, but it's up the same creek as trying to brute-force your way into someone's heart.
etripe··on GitHub Copilot
With an AI assistant, in the best scenario, you'll get a "wisdom of crowds" effect on implementation details and program architecture. At worst, you'll get a lot of opinionated code bloat and anti-patterns as suggestions.

For most backend programming jobs, the challenge is not in writing complex code but figuring out what the business wants, needs and should have in the first place and distinguishing between them. Figuring out how to integrate with existing systems, processes, fiefdoms and code. Knowing when to say yes and no, how to make code future proof, etc. This is a task fundamentally unfit for what we currently call "AI", because it's not actually intelligent or creative yet.

On the frontend, it becomes even more nebulous. Maybe Copilot can suggest common themes like Bootstrap classes for a form, CSS properties, the basic file structure and implementations for components in an SPA, etc. As I see it, the main challenge is in UX there, not the boilerplate, which again makes it about understanding the user, figuring out how to make UI feel intuitive, etc. Again: unfit for current AI.

I cannot offer any opinion on the utility for actually complex, FANG-level code, for lack of experience.

etripe··on Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine
What seems to be missing from the list of classes is sexual orientation. Is this just how it appears from the outside?
etripe··on Why Computing Students Should Contribute to Open Source Software Projects
It isn't the education system's job to produce model employees. Nearly all the "modern skills" mentioned in the article all squarely fall under the moniker "industry knowledge", which is... the industry's job. Those that don't fall under the umbrella of maturity, which only experience can teach.

In my opinion, employers should start investing in their employees again, as they once did. It's neither morally laudable nor enlightened self interest to throw someone in the deep end and expect them to swim. And in our capitalist system, it's self-indulgent to say that you want something without paying for it. That is ultimately what the article is proposing: that open source contributors sacrifice their spare time to be the mentors companies should provide.

etripe··on I was let go for refusing to deploy a dark pattern
> Each file had the same change - they had added code that makes an ajax saveEmail() call onBlur. In other words, email addresses were being saved to the database when a user inputs an email and the input loses focus.

> I told my client - apologies, but I don't want to work on this task because it's a dark pattern. And they reply - no, no, we are just sending people 3 email reminders. And then I try to explain that it's basically saving email addresses secretly.

Perhaps because this is a short post, but it seems to be missing context. The email addresses are saved, which may or may not be questionable. It's unclear whether there are any mechanisms to auto-remove the email addresses once three reminders have been sent.

It doesn't seem immediately obvious what the dark pattern is here. What am I missing?

etripe··on Stop using your work laptop or phone for personal stuff, because I know you are
> Do you charge your company for your commute to the office?

Companies tend to pay people for their commute here in Belgium. This can take the form of paying your train pass, a reimbursement per kilometre travelled or even a company car + fuel card.

That doesn't cover the hours spent travelling, of course.

etripe··on Opinion-Driven Design
> YAGNI isn’t a rule, it’s a dismissal. A dodge. A cop-out.

Only when the abstractions proposed actually have a pragmatic use. As developers, for a lot of us, the immediate instinctual reaction is "add another layer of indirection". Each of these makes the software more complex, adds cognitive load and increases tech debt, making it a risky proposal.

Those risks are often glossed over for purely philosophical benefits and - for lack of a better term - personal taste. Maybe you don't actually need factories, strategy patterns or even DI just because the Gang of Four book mentions it. Maybe worry about problems when they occur, not because the might occur.

YAGNI is just a concrete implementation of KISS. I prefer the approach it proposes: question everything, say yes only when it makes sense. That is what YAGNI symbolises and reduces use cases, scope, feature creep and abstraction creep. For most companies, code isn't what's sold and merely enables (parts of) the business. What matters is whether it's fit for purpose, not whether it smells nice.

etripe··on Deloitte tells staff they can work from home forever
Tapping on the shoulder can mean two things: "riddle me this" and "drop everything because I'm more important". The former can be replaced by a chat app. The latter is a stopgap for a failure to plan and goes with an adhocracy.

If a company became less efficient due to a lack of "drop everything" taps on the shoulder, it wasn't efficient in the first place.

etripe··on Europe's Software Problem
> If there's one thing that consistently fosters innovation and progress it's competition.

That statement is a bit of a truism, isn't it? If you squint hard enough, you can call most things a competition. If all else fails, in the sexual marketplace because financial success is an indicator of romantic success for males, who happen to have driven a lot of the innovation up to this point.

It also ignores the nuance to be found in whether and where to focus on public investment versus private investment, for one. I don't think you can really sensibly frame all public investment as competition, unless you're stretching it to the amorphous "international competition", in which case the principle is dangerously close to being unfalsifiable.

I'm not saying competition has no role to play, but where are inspiration, the joy of creation, altruism and wanting to abolish frustration and greater problems? We don't just have selfish genes.

← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →