I currently assert that it's not, but I would also say that trying to follow your suggestion is better than our current approach of measuring everything by money.
668 karma · joined October 5, 2010
I currently assert that it's not, but I would also say that trying to follow your suggestion is better than our current approach of measuring everything by money.
The only thing that seems to get the fiefdoms to work on an issue is if a big enough customer calls enough of an attention to the issue so that no leader/fiefdom wants to be blamed in such a "high profile" issue that everyone got their work in gear for. This leads to organizational dysfunction since now everyone understands that there's no point in trying to fix anything until there is enough attention on it, and that is mainly achieved when a big customer complains.
I've even had projects that took months of engineering work that would resolve many user complaints about a lack of really basic functionality, and different elements of leadership would block the launch. I can only guess that some fiefdom did not like change and would not state their objection publicly, so I only got stonewalled, and I never got an explanation to throw away months of work. I am as certain as I can be that if a big customer complained loudly enough about the problem that such basic functionality was missing, the organization would demand that the fix be launched.
These security vulnerabilities, if exploited, could cause massive suffering. But the people who caught them modestly corrected the issue by exercising their competence and decency.
To be clear, the law changes over time, so newer laws have less precedence, and I expect courts to respect new laws even though no courts have made ruling based on such a law before.
"Scott says he was kind of overworked and unhappy with his job, so everything felt a little less important. Maybe that had something to do with it. But he says crossing over that line was somehow just not as hard as it should have been."
- Planet Money, Episode 671: An Insider Trader Tells All https://www.npr.org/transcripts/460689797
It's not a perfect comparison/analogy, so I'd rather not get nitpicked, as the overall thrust of my argument is that $200/hr is not outlandish imho.
I think we really need to define "risk" and the "hurt" people might experience. I've been at Google for 5 years, and I don't believe Google is at an existential risk. From my perspective, the biggest concerns I've heard people express were forms of not maximizing compensation: whether from not getting promo, not getting big bonuses, amenities being reduced, etc.
I confess that the layoffs change things, but 1) I'm not really sure how people can protect themselves other than rising to senior leadership position who seemed more insulated from the layoffs and 2) I am in the pool of people who wouldn't have minded 6+ months severance (including accelerated stock vesting).
I think the nebulous fear of hurting people is another way that the status quo secures itself. If this fear of "hurting people" is the fear that motivates Googlers to maintain the status quo when Googlers are among the most privileged people upon the Earth, I'm not sure who else could buck the status quo.
I dunno if Google as a whole can change itself. But I hope that enough individual Googlers do decide that they can change the status quo. I hope there are enough people who aren't so vulnerable and can thus risk getting "hurt", whatever that means in this case, while protecting the truly vulnerable people around us.
The risk to maintaining the status quo is real; there is a real risk that this massively powerful company sacrifices our people and our opportunity to maximize the good we could do on a truly planetary scale only to strive to maximize quarterly earnings through short term thinking.
"since 1980, right around the time the electronic spreadsheet came out, 400,000 bookkeeping and accounting clerk jobs have gone away. But 600,000 accounting jobs have been added." Planet Money, May 17, 2017, Episode 606: Spreadsheets!
This makes a lot of sense. The same thing happened in the past with new technology, such as the electronic spreadsheet:
"since 1980, right around the time the electronic spreadsheet came out, 400,000 bookkeeping and accounting clerk jobs have gone away. But 600,000 accounting jobs have been added."
Episode 606: Spreadsheets!, May 17, 2017, Planet Money
The main concern seems to stem from making the discussion off limits. No "fixes" have been proposed. The first step to solving a problem at all is to admit that there is a problem. Being apolitical is privilege. For the unprivileged, simply defending ones rights and dignity is a political issue.
Recovery, however, is hardly ever a straight path. Sometimes people get stuck. Sometimes, people shift their viewpoint to something else that's extreme and unhealthy. In the grand scheme of things, this journey lasts our entire lifetime.
If it's just your authentication system hashes that are compromised, the damage can be contained.
> cooking has economies of scale and specialization, so it’s cheaper to cook for many families at once
I'll try to add a little more value to the conversation - there are a lot of hidden costs in cooking at home. A kitchen could take up valuable real estate that is significantly underutilized compared to a commercial kitchen. A personal kitchen also has maintenance costs on top of cooking and cleaning each meal.
I do acknowledge a lot of value - you get to cook exactly what you want, how you want, when you want. For many, cooking itself is valuable (and not a loss of time) because it is enjoyable.
> (These operating systems in both Smalltalk and Lisp were both better (claim) and easier to write (simpler to demonstrate) than the standard ones of today.)
Or is the comment only tangential to OP?
or is it
"Advertising company will block ads (obviously except its own)"? "Content providers - use Google's ad network if you want to make sure you get ad revenue from Chrome!"
Will Google try to remain "fair"? Does the profit-maximizing moves align with "fairness"?
I wonder if these could have been expediently implemented as VIM plugins - perhaps each feature could have been a VIM plugin so that people can pick and choose which feature set they wanted.
Making a blanket statement about countries that eat less is hard to discuss meaningfully. But one example of interest may be Japan which eats less than those in the U.S. while having much greater life expectancy[1].
[1] http://www.choicesmagazine.org/2006-4/grabbag/2006-4-12.htm
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prime_number_theorem
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benford%27s_law#Multiplicative...
I've never heard the term myself, so I am speculating.
My takeaway was that many people produce warm feelings about an entity that doesn't necessarily reciprocate or find those warm feelings important in it of themselves.
I personally like Google (so far). E.g. I could have seen them siding with ISPs, trying to dismantle net neutrality, and using their capital to stifle innovation keeping them at the top.
But if sometime in the future, Google enacts policies that aren't so "nice", people may do well to avoid confusion by remembering that Google isn't inherently "nice", but they are inherently "for-profit".
It's nice when Google does things that benefit a lot of people, but they're a for-profit corporation and not motivated primarily by altruism. People might not fully understand that or its significance and simply enjoy Google products, but I think it's useful knowledge.