HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ewjordan

2,337 karma · joined July 7, 2008

submissionscomments
ewjordan··on Silicon Valley Women, in Cultural Shift, Frankly Describe Sexual Harassment
> And the rate of growth really climbed after the middle of the 20th century, when the expansion of basic education became a global priority. You can read more about the expansion of education systems around the world in our entry on Financing Education.

(links to https://ourworldindata.org/financing-education#historical-pe...)

I don't know if that is proof of the statement or anything, but I don't think it's a particularly controversial claim to say that universal education impacts literacy.

As for the challenges women face as they try to enter industry, those are well established and real, for sure. They need to be fought viciously, and we are correct to spend a lot of time and money on those problems. I'd never deny that, it's extremely important to do that work and fight that fight, as this entire article and discussion proves.

But pre-industry, only 18% of CS majors are women, so the educational system has to be fixed as well, that's way too big of an early gap to hope it will magically close once the industry gets it's shit together. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.usnews.com/news/data-mine/a... has a good rundown of where the most valuable opportunities are (middle school is a big one) and how they should be addressed - it's not just about access, it's also about making sure that it's provided in a way that engages and targets young girls specifically, and making sure that more women are teaching these classes. Schools are a valuable point of leverage where you can affect preconceived notions about gender roles and career opportunities, and any effective program needs to break down those barriers. That requires a lot of curriculum design (the easy part) and retraining (the hard).

While you're right that plenty of women code, men outnumber them by 4:1 before they even face the challenges of industry. We need to throw everything we can at that, from every angle, and at every step in the pipeline, until we're much closer to 50/50. Educational interventions are straightforward and proven to work with fairly low cost at the early stages, so I can't imagine why we'd want to rule them out as being part of the solution. They're also massively helpful when addressing the racial imbalances, which are arguably even more vulnerable to asymmetric early exposure than the gender imbalance is (though that's a much bigger subject worthy of its own discussion).

ewjordan··on Silicon Valley Women, in Cultural Shift, Frankly Describe Sexual Harassment
Forcing all children to go to school has been an answer for a few generations now, and even with the crappy imperfect education system that we have, it's paid off immensely. I'm merely suggesting that tech is now important enough to warrant inclusion in that curriculum as a way of making it slightly more relevant and less crappy.
ewjordan··on Silicon Valley Women, in Cultural Shift, Frankly Describe Sexual Harassment
Except in the cases where it does work astoundingly well to solve issues that would have been labeled cultural before they were improved, like raising literacy rates across all races (achieved by massively increasing investment in education). See https://ourworldindata.org/literacy/#historical-perspective for some idea how well that worked. A similar situation is AIDS prevention via safe sex education.

If a cultural problem has lack of exposure and education at its root, then it is very easy to throw money at that part of the problem and just fix it. Right now girls and underrepresented minorities are woefully underexposed to coding, and via education we can right that wrong directly even if we can't figure out how to fix the underlying cultural issues (which definitely exist, and have made white and Asian boys much more likely to have early exposure to CS).

I'll note that students tend to rate CS as their favorite academic subject (it's slightly below art and theater) when they are forced to take it, so "force" in this context is mostly just about getting them to take the first step. They love it once they start, so whether or not it will solve the gender imbalance problem, it's such a critical skill for the future economy that it seems irresponsible not to spend money on it and prepare people to participate in that economy, doubly so when students enjoy it so much.

That's not to say at all that the cultural components should be ignored, they're just so much deeper and more difficult to fix than this particular side effect, which is amenable to solution-by-education (which necessarily means throwing money around, since training teachers takes money).

ewjordan··on Silicon Valley Women, in Cultural Shift, Frankly Describe Sexual Harassment
One obvious step is that we need to do what we do in every other subject: force all children to learn enough tech to figure out whether they are good at it or not by making it a required class. When schools do that, they find that tons of girls excel at programming, but probably never would have tried it if it hadn't been mandatory.

Dealing with harassment in the industry is also key, but even if that was eliminated completely it wouldn't close the gender gap that exists by the time kids graduate high school. And the educational bit is much more straightforward to implement, it just takes a lot of money to be thrown at the problem.

ewjordan··on Why I’m Remaking OpenAI Universe
Probably the same way everyone does, by pulling it out of thin air as a guess. When nobody even knows what theoretical breakthroughs are necessary, you'll always end up with a scattershot all over the place, even amongst experts. Try asking working mathematicians how long until the Riemann hypothesis is resolved one way or another, or look at what people were saying about Fermat's Last Theorem up until it was solved.

What we do know is that current techniques won't get us close to AGI, so something new is needed (or perhaps like backprop, something old will work once we have enough compute power). Personally I'm bullish on AGI because I have strikingly low faith in the ability of evolution to operate very effectively as a tool for algorithm discovery, so I suspect that once we've hit the compute threshold we'll find that many different algorithms can do the trick, and 40 years is probably not out of the question for us to hit that point (or 10, or 100), depending who you talk to about what the compute threshold might be.

I'd caution against putting too much weight in what experts say, though, since with a tiny few set of exceptions anyone working on "AI" today is actually just working on narrow AI, which is, as someone put it, just glorified linear regression. Those tools will almost certainly be part of the solution, but only in the sense that the classical theory of Diophantine equations was part of Weil's proof of Fermat's Last Theorem - they are not the core of the theoretical approach.

ewjordan··on The future is emotional
All of that seems to argue pretty strongly in favor of calling it "emotional labor" - caretaking involves a serious trade-off where the caretaker is expending a lot of emotional energy to do work for someone else. Much like physical labor involves expending a lot of physical energy to get stuff done.

I don't see anything either overly demeaning or glamorous about that descriptive term, it seems to describe exactly the value proposition that is on the table with that sort of work.

ewjordan··on We analyzed thousands of interviews on everything from language to code style
The article explicitly notes, though, that most excellent programmers were also excellent communicators.

Effective communication doesn't necessarily mean you talk a lot or are extroverted. It means that you say things that matter when they matter, and that is a crucial skill to have in almost any work environment.

ewjordan··on Chess.com stopped working on 32bit iPads because 2^31 games have been played
It's often not even an explicit choice, it's just default behavior.

Up until recently, Rails defaulted to 32 bit IDs, so there are a ton of apps out there that could have these issues, especially since Rails has always prided itself on providing sane defaults: https://github.com/rails/rails/pull/26266

ewjordan··on Ask HN: What are we doing about Facebook, Google, and the closed internet?
By making your email something custom instead of @gmail, you're spending some energy, time, and money to protect against a perceived threat.

I guess my real question is, what exactly is that threat, how damaging is it, and how likely is it to occur?

By my mental math, I can't really justify spending even a few bucks, or more expensively, a few hours, protecting against some consequence that I can't really quantify at any real level of risk.

For business, sure, because there are other benefits to having a custom domain, but for personal stuff, I don't really see the cost/benefit analysis making sense. The biggest threat seems to be that the government will have my data and I'll be advertised at, but having my own domain doesn't help either way. Am I missing something?

ewjordan··on On average, skipping college and investing tuition costs nets a higher return
The reality is pretty simple, though: a lot of people making decisions like this will look at their career options when they graduate and have to face the real world, struggle for a while, then realize that they're more than qualified to make twice the money as a junior programmer and make the switch then, recouping their costs easily unless they're really stubborn.

Half the people that I went to school with in physics, math, econ, bio, did exactly that. They're doing just fine now because TBH, those fields are vastly more intellectually challenging to learn at a research level than being a well qualified working programmer is (doing proper CS at a grad level is a different story, on par with those other fields, but you don't need to be a research-class CS PhD to be an above average programmer), and most of them already had to learn to program to get through their courses anyways, so it's an easy transition.

It's the people in completely non-technical majors that have the most trouble, because they don't know math, they don't understand proofs or algorithms, or even basic problem solving, let alone how to design systems, and worse, they've never really had to learn to effectively use software except in extremely limited ways.

ewjordan··on It's Never Too Early to Fire
You're pointing out an important difference: firing because of experience/performance vs firing because of behavior.

Being a bit naive, making mistakes, and needing ramp-up time is to be expected, especially from a junior hire. You absolutely need to give time to correct that sort of thing, and firing fast is not a good move. Some of the best devs I've worked with needed a few months to ramp upbefore they hit full stride.

On the other hand if someone is dicking around instead of working, being insubordinate, refusing to try to improve, upsetting coworkers, etc., then you've got behavioral problems on your hands. And those are absolutely good reasons to fire if they persist beyond an initial stern warning.

ewjordan··on What I've learned from 100s of interviews with candidates at top tech companies
While maybe it shouldn't be a strong signal, showing up for a tech interview in a suit is kinda like showing up for a finance interview in jeans and a hoodie. It indicates that you're either unfamiliar with the norms in the industry, or deliberately violating them, and neither one is a great first impression.

The typical interview rule, IMO, is a good one, at least for men (women unfortunately are under very different pressures): dress one (and only one) notch nicer than the people that will be interviewing you.

There are some rare situations where dressing down compared to your interviewer makes sense, but a normal dev looking for a normal job is not one of them.

ewjordan··on Scientists Tie 52 Genes to Human Intelligence
Let's be accurate about that quote, though - that Vox article itself says that a lot of what goes into IQ is heritable, and comes through DNA.

"No genes for IQ" is better interpreted as a statement that it's not just a small handful of genes that determine IQ (or any behavioral trait), but very, very many (plus nurture, but that goes without saying). It cites http://europepmc.org/articles/pmc4635473, which mentions:

The SNP rs9320913 is estimated to account for only 0.02% of the overall variability in educational attainment, but biometrical studies show that the total percentage of variability owed to genetic differences is three orders of magnitude larger (Heath et al., 1985; Rietveld et al., 2013). Since the SNPs with the largest effects are the easiest to find, these results suggest that educational attainment is a phenotype affected by thousands of undiscovered genetic variants, each responsible for a minuscule fraction of individual differences.

...which is not to say that Murray's claims that intelligence and race correlate strongly have merit, since as the article you posted points out, his argument has some severe deficiencies.

Specifically (and this is coming from me, not the article), when a measured trait (say IQ) is a function of a large number of genes, then unless that trait has highly variable selective importance depending on habitat, we would not expect it to diverge significantly between races. Traits that do diverge significantly tend to be either subject to different selection pressures between environments, or involve a small number of genes (with a small number of genes, it's easy for random noise to freeze unusual variants into segregated populations, but as the count goes up the law of large numbers kicks in and we see similar bell curves in all populations). This is almost trivial to prove.

ewjordan··on A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to $1750 per month
It's at least potentially valid to suggest that charging the same rate for SSL overhead as for normal traffic is maybe not the best system, though, since I'm assuming that the overhead does not affect load on the value-adding servers but rather at a much more straightforward piece of the networking stack (LB or wherever SSL terminates before data gets into the proper Firebase stack).

Say, the $0.12/GB that Google Cloud Functions uses, since there's no value to the user or cost to the provider beyond what you'd see there (and indeed, one solution seems to be to simply route through cloud functions).

Is that possible, mayop100, or am I misunderstanding the system? Obviously it's not up to your users to dictate your pricing, of course, but if it's feasible it would probably earn a lot of goodwill.

ewjordan··on Want to rescue rural America? Bust monopolies
I suspect that you already know the answer here: better !== better for everybody, and worse for you !== worse for everybody.

A lot of people even think that "more expensive for most" still qualifies as "better" as long as it means that people that previously could not get coverage at any cost are now able to, since none of us know when we might develop a "pre-existing condition" that pre-ACA would have made us uninsurable forever.

Whether a system is truly better or worse depends on how you account for all the different people that it helps or hurts. http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/article/2017/jan/05/... has some examples that suggest that things are better for a whole lot of people under ACA, but I'm sure other groups and analyses will paint different pictures.

ewjordan··on Uber said to use “sophisticated” software to defraud drivers, passengers
According to the complaint, this was part of the contract:

  52. The Uber Defendants and Plaintiff and the other Class Members had a
  contractual agreement regarding the collection, receipt, and payment to drivers of the
  fares paid by Users for the driver’s transportation services.
  53. The Uber Defendants agreed that they would collect and pay to the
  Plaintiff the fare by the User, minus a contractual service fee and booking fee.
  54. As a result of the misrepresentations and omissions alleged herein,
  including the Uber Defendants' failure to remit payment to the Plaintiff and other Class
  members of the full amount of the fare (after deducting the contractual service fee
  percentage and booking fee), there has been a violation or breach of the agreement
  between Plaintiff and the Uber Defendants. Accordingly, Plaintiff and the other Class
  members have been underpaid for their services and did not receive the benefit of
  their bargain.
If the contract with drivers did, in fact, say that Uber would pay out the fare that the user paid minus a standard service and booking fee, then it seems like this is pretty solid, though IANAL. I have no idea if that's what the actual agreement is, though.
ewjordan··on Planck.js – JavaScript rewrite of Box2D physics library
If you tie the frame rate to the physics step, then yes - that will be true for pretty much any physics engine.

The classic advice here is http://gafferongames.com/game-physics/fix-your-timestep/

ewjordan··on HTML5 Games Workshop: Make a Platformer Game with JavaScript
I think theoretically you're correct that the methods underlying Box2d could be used in such a way, but practically I don't think it's there, as that was never one of the engine's goals. Read up on the methods used (for instance, http://twvideo01.ubm-us.net/o1/vault/gdc2013/slides/824737Ca...) for some of the limitations that Erin chose to accept. In particular the fact that it misses multiple roots during the solve means that you can't use if for perfect tickless simulation; there are (were? I'm not sure to what extent they've been addressed since I was deep in that code) also issues with conservation of time that would be a problem, which are discussed elsewhere (for instance http://box2d.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=154).
ewjordan··on HTML5 Games Workshop: Make a Platformer Game with JavaScript
Box2d's continuous physics does not allow for a tickless simulation as I understand the term, because continuous interactions (stacking, sliding, rolling, etc.) are not reduced to discrete time-of-impact calculations. Joints are also in that category. If you run the testbed and crank the timestep way up, you'll definitely see problems with things like ragdolls.

Continuous collision detection definitely makes it easier to handle high velocities and bigger timesteps, but it's not a panacea.

ewjordan··on The AI Misinformation Epidemic
To reuse a point brought up quite often in this context, making predictions about when and if AGI might arrive based on extrapolations of current technological trends is like trying to predict when the atom bomb would have been created based on a chart of conventional explosive yields leading up to 1940. Undiscovered discoveries are not predictable, certainly not by extrapolating from the current progress. This applies to Kurzweil's highly optimistic predictions as much as it does to negative ones.

Whether or not it's likely we'll see AGI any time soon is, IMO, a matter of wild-ass-guessing more than anything else. There are no experts in AGI right now, only philosophers, because the field doesn't even exist. So nobody has any remotely educated guess about what algorithmic discoveries need to happen and whether they're in reach for human understanding, or when we'd have the computational power to exploit such algorithms if discovered.

All we can really say is that it's theoretically possible, we're living proof of that. Also that there must be a lot of intelligent needles in the algorithmic haystack if evolution was able to stumble across one without a clear fitness mandate to do so (most of the creatures that thrive don't have what we consider intelligence, so it's not that evolutionarily important). I'd probably bet on it being more a matter of "when?" than "if?", but I wouldn't make any assumptions about timescale other than "not this year, probably not next".

ewjordan··on An Illustrated Book of Bad Arguments (2013)
> I'd like to see more books about how people actually argue in life and how to change their view.

Rule #0 for changing someone's view is that they have to actually be open to changing their view. It's surprisingly common that people will explicitly admit, if you ask them, that there is no realistic evidence or argument that could possibly change the side that they're on.

ewjordan··on An Illustrated Book of Bad Arguments (2013)
> and often take more than minimal effort to dispute

This is where all ability to have a rational discussion breaks down in many cases, especially when people care a lot about their initial opinions.

Take an issue like evolution. You start with a source like https://www.khanacademy.org/science/biology/her/evolution-an..., which outlines a pretty good case for how evolution is supported by today's evidence. It gives plenty of lines to follow if you're curious to dig deeper, and absent other factors most people would just see it as a boring science thing that's probably true and they don't care much about.

But because some people are bothered by the idea, they've spent a lot of time thinking up objections. A whole lot of time. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Objections_to_evolution for summaries of just some of the complaints that people have come up with. These have all been thoroughly demolished, of course, but to do so often involves a lot of really labor-intensive science.

As far as science goes, that's all good - it's great to be detailed and thoroughly justify every piece of a theory, chasing any loose ends down at any cost. It's part of the job description.

But casual debate about the issue is devastatingly difficult, even if everyone is acting in good faith. All someone that has a problem with evolution has to do is throw out three or four big complaints (the eye! carbon dating! transitional fossils! micro vs macro-evolution!) and all of a sudden a proper response to their 3 minute "gotcha" attempt means a good half hour sourcing high quality rebuttals and summarizing them in the thread. Which will likely each bring up three or four points which the anti-evolution person can quibble with (and they'll be able to do so quickly). Assuming you make it through that gauntlet and the person accepts that you've shot down those points, a list of ten more fresh "problems", each of which requires detailed research and attention to shoot down, is a low-effort Google search away (say https://www.evolutionnews.org/2012/07/what_are_the_to_1/), so you can get "yeah, but!"-ted into oblivion until you're just not up to the task of responding anymore, even though you absolutely could address every complaint without difficulty, if you had the time.

Like you said, moving the goalposts. When you have an almost limitless sea of low-effort objections to draw from via Google (which you do, about almost anything, as long as a lot of people have spent time coming up with them), it's easy to put up a shitscreen so thick that nobody can ever break through, and not even realize that you're acting badly.

I know that rationalists very strongly believe that with enough good-faith discussion everyone's beliefs should ultimately align, and there should never be such a thing as agreeing to disagree, but I fear that in many cases the relaxation time to that state is prohibitively long.

ewjordan··on Nevertheless, She Coded
Is your claim that the pipeline is not completely fugged? Because there are very clear numbers indicating that it is, starting very early, at the K-12 level.

Or is it merely that the pipeline being fugged doesn't mean that everything else is fine and dandy? I'd agree with that, hell yeah, and that claim matches the actual content of those links quite well. But I don't think it in any way suggests that the problem is a myth.

I also don't think the pipeline is unfixable, but that's both my day job and another rant for another day.

ewjordan··on Should economists be more concerned about AI?
And every person that tells you that there won't be any jobs after AI passes a threshold has already considered your railroad question, and decided that for various reasons the AI shift is different.

There's a big difference between crossing a threshold where machines do one or two specific things better than we do and crossing one where they do everything better. There's certainly an argument about whether or not that's likely or imminent, but it's impossible to deny that strong, singularity-style AI, if discovered, would be a lot more of a disruption to our usefulness than railroads were.

ewjordan··on Scientists Predict Star Collision Visible to the Naked Eye in 2022
You're right that they're not conflating the phenomena, but to say that two events are only simultaneous if they're on the light cone is still incorrect - that's the boundary of the region of simultaneity, whereas the OP was suggesting that it's the entirety of it.

Since the light hasn't reached us yet, it's perfectly valid to state that in some frame of reference, the event is happening right now. 2022 is the last possible time at which we could make that claim because the events become causally separated, which is I think what OP was getting at, though the wording was a bit off.

ewjordan··on Ask HN: What did you do after quitting the IT industry and how have things been?
You'll have freedom to do the things that are fashionable in your field which you are qualified to research and are popular in your department. That's very different from "what you want to pursue" in many cases.

If those things match up with your desires, it will be great, otherwise you're going to be seriously miserable and feel penned in by the work that you're "allowed" (for on-campus political reasons) to do. In a lot of ways industry actually affords more opportunities, depending on the field.

ewjordan··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People
That "quantum leap in battery chemistry" is obviously physically possible, given that animals exist...
ewjordan··on Ask HN: Who is firing?
Firing gets rid of the worst. Hiring, at least in theory, pulls in the best.

Healthy companies at scale and size equilibrium should be doing both at roughly the same rate, averaged over time.

ewjordan··on Games on GitHub
And when you're actually taking games to market, all that non-game code makes up a huge percentage of the development cost. It's highly predictable code that most game devs have done many times before (which is why I always argue that once the gameplay is locked and loaded, which it should be before you go into large-team production [if there are still big changes to make, you should stay in prototype and not have a full team doing production quality art, UI, sound, servers, etc that might need to be replaced], mobile game dev projects should always be waterfall, not agile), but it's still a lot of work, and it can't ever be 100% reused.

Speaking just to mobile, you need to add, on top of "the game" itself:

  - scalable persistence that handles play on multiple devices and platforms (add load testing to this if you're "Doing It Right")
  - in-app-purchase integration
  - metrics instrumentation, collection, analysis, etc.
  - social integration: authentication, sharing, invites, leaderboards, etc., often with backend components, not to mention the hell that is integrating with social SDKs and keeping them all up to date
  - dynamic content loading, if your game is too big to fit in the ipa/apk
  - TOS, legal, COPPA compliance dialogs/data filtering
  - a proper audio integration (chances are your initial approach, whatever it was, won't work for a full game)
  - dynamically loaded variables system (can't do an App Store push every time you need to change something about the game tuning)
  - A/B testing
  - customer service mechanisms
  - ads
  - push and local notifications
  - user acquisition attribution (to know which ad networks are effective at pushing users)
  - landing page optimization
  - platform nonsense (a carrier just pushed a new version of Android to one of their phones that has a crappy GPU driver whose bugs are only fully exposed in the latest OS version? Congrats, now half of your shaders draw black squares, have fun tracking that one down, esp. since that particular driver/chipset combo only exists in phones sold in Canada and eastern Europe!) 
  - and so on, when I was in this field we'd end up with lists 40-50 items long of basic stuff that every game needs, along these lines
It gets really messy, "the game" is really just the barest start. All the stuff I listed above can easily take 50%+ of total man-hours in a dev cycle, even if you have well-factored code from other games to work off of, just because it all requires game-specific UI and design (both of which always have some non-zero code cost).

I imagine single-player premium desktop games are quite a bit simpler, but I've never had the pleasure.

ewjordan··on Project delays: why good software estimates are impossible (2015)
Except that if I'm hiring someone to build my house, if they tell me "well, I can guarantee you that we'll prioritize iteratively and get it done as fast as possible" I'd tell them to piss off, I can't throw good money at that. You at least need a baseline estimate, and some data as to how often things go over or under.

Apparently software engineers as a group seem to think "fuck you, it's done when we feel like it" is a valid answer?

I disagree, and have always offered estimates, probabilities and contingencies when talking to product owners when I was a lead. I tracked data, and adjusted accordingly, and ended up giving estimates that were statistically sound.

I don't necessarily expect individual contributors to do the same, but anyone that's a lead should be an adult and account for their team's actual productive capacity. This is absolutely expected of a building company, even if you don't expect a single dude with a hammer to be able to estimate how long the project will take.

← PreviousPage 5 of 18Next →