HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ewoodrich

2,349 karma · joined October 23, 2011

submissionscomments
ewoodrich··on Anthropic: Developing a Claude Code competitor using Claude Code is banned
> prompts where we'd ask for e.g. 15 sections, would only do 10 sections and then ask "Would you like me to continue?".

I can’t speak to any kind of identifiable pattern but man that behavior drives me up the wall when it happens.

When I run into a specific task that starts to trigger that behavior, even a clean session with explicit instructions directing it to complete ALL sub steps isn’t enough to push it to finish the entire request to the end.

ewoodrich··on Anthropic made a mistake in cutting off third-party clients
That seems a bit dramatic.

What I learned from all this is that OpenAI is willing to offer a service compatible with my preferred workflow/method of billing and Anthropic clearly is not. That's fine but disappointing, I'm keeping my Codex subscription and letting my Claude subscription lapse but sure, it would be nice if Anthropic changed their mind to keep that option available because yes, I do want it.

I'm a bit perplexed by some comments describing the situation like OpenCode users were getting something for free and stealing from CC users when the plan quota was enforced either way and were paying the same amount for it. Or why you seem to think this post pointing out that Anthropic's direct competitor endorses that method of subscription usage is somehow malicious or manipulative behavior.

Commerce is a two-way street and customers giving feedback/complaining/cancelling when something changes is normal and healthy for competition. As evidenced by OpenAI immediately jumping in to support OpenCode users on Codex without needing to break their TOS.

ewoodrich··on The struggle of resizing windows on macOS Tahoe
I recently mentioned in another comment that Fedora 43 on my Ideapad is the first “just works” experience I’ve had with my multi monitor setup(s) on anything other than Windows 11 (including MacOS where I needed to pay for Better Display to reach the bar of “tolerable”).

Zero fiddling necessary other than picking my ideal scaling percentage on each display for perfect, crisp text with everything sanely sized across all my monitors/TVs.

I gave up on Linux Mint for that exact reason. I wasted so much time trying to fine tune fonts and stuff to emulate real fractional scaling. Whenever I thought I finally found a usable compromise some random app would look terrible on one of the monitors and I’d be back at square one.

Experimental Wayland on Linux Mint just wasn’t usable unfortunately and tbh wasn’t a big fan of Cinnamon in general (I just really hated dealing with snaps on Ubuntu). I did tweak Gnome to add minimize buttons/bottom dock again and with that it’s probably my favorite desktop across any version of Linux/MacOS/Windows I’ve ever used!

I kept reading endorsements of Fedora's level of polish/stability on HN but was kinda nervous having used Debian distros my entire life and I’m really happy I finally took the plunge. Wish I tried it years ago!

ewoodrich··on Microsoft May Have Created the Slowest Windows in 25 Years with Windows 11
The first time I’ve had my multi-monitor setup(s) “just work” on Linux is recently installing Fedora 43 on my Ideapad. (After becoming exhausted trying to tweak Linux Mint to get tolerable sizing across all the screens).

Wayland per-monitor fractional scaling is delightful and after a couple gsettings tweaks restoring minimize/bottom dock I’ve been loving the polish and snappiness of Gnome. I also had to switch the WiFi backend from wpa_supplicant to iwn due to connection problems on one specific WiFi network but now it’s totally stable.

macOS multi-monitor support and scaling is a constant thorn in my side that was marginally improved by paying for Better Display. Windows 11 really is the most solid option for various monitor combinations not in Apple's happy path of resolutions/sizes.

But I don’t really like the ergonomics of using even clean de-bloated Windows as my main dev machine, so was very pleased to have such a great out-of-the-box experience trying Fedora for the first time.

ewoodrich··on Microsoft May Have Created the Slowest Windows in 25 Years with Windows 11
FYI, nearly all of that UI/app garbage can be removed (or re-enabled like the Start/context menu) in <5 minutes with:

https://github.com/Raphire/Win11Debloat

It persists across updates, can be customized with extremely granular control over what is removed/re-enabled, or using the default mode which works fantastically for most users with minimal risk of disabling something many people might prefer to keep (e.g Xbox app).

I’ve been using it for years on every machine/VM with Windows 11 installed. The OS gets out of my way completely both in terms of functionality and distractions like ads.

I cannot recommend it enough, I am eternally grateful to the maintainers for making Windows 11 feel like a modernized Windows 7 experience.

ewoodrich··on Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscriptions
Ugh, well at least this was the nudge I needed to cancel my Claude Pro subscription... I've already had a bad taste in my mouth watching the rate limits on the plan get worse and worse since I first subscribed and I have a few other subscriptions to fall back on while I've been evaluating different options. I literally never use the regular Claude Chat web UI either, that's pretty much 100% Gemini since I get it via my Google One plan.

OpenCode makes me feel a lot better knowing that my workflow isn't completely dependent on single vendor lock-in, and I generally prefer the UX to Claude Code anyway.

ewoodrich··on How to code Claude Code in 200 lines of code
Exactly, if a comment just feels a little off but you're unsure, do a quick scan of the profile, takes 15-30 seconds at most to get sufficient signal.

If it's actually AI, the pattern becomes extremely obvious reading them back-to-back. If no clear pattern, I'll happily give them the benefit of the doubt at that point. I don't particularly care if someone occasionally cleans up a post with an LLM as long as there is a real person driving it and it's not overused.

The other day on Reddit I saw a post in r/sysadmin that absolutely screamed karma farming AI and it was really depressing seeing a bunch of people defending them as the victim of an anti-AI mob without noticing the entire profile was variations of generic "Does anyone else dislike [Tool X], am I alone? [generic filler] What does everyone else think?" posts.

ewoodrich··on Opus 4.5 is not the normal AI agent experience that I have had thus far
I’m well aware, as I said I am regularly using CC/Codex/OC in a variety of projects, and I certainly didn’t claim that can’t be used productively in a large code base.

But that different challenges become apparent that aren’t addressed by examples like this article which tend to focus on narrow, greenfield applications that can be readily rebuilt in one shot.

I already get plenty of value in small side projects that Claude can create in minutes. And while extremely cool, these examples aren’t the kind of “step change” improvement I’d like to see in the area where agentic tools are currently weakest in my daily usage.

ewoodrich··on Opus 4.5 is not the normal AI agent experience that I have had thus far
Fully agreed! That’s the exact kind of thing I was hoping to find when I read the article title, but unfortunately it was really just another “normal AI agent experience” I’ve seen (and built) many examples of before.
ewoodrich··on Pebble Round 2
That happy path works okay for a while but provides very little margin for when the battery inevitably starts to degrade. I’m a few years in and now every few days it’s started to die at around 8pm (yet claims the battery health is still just barely outside replacement range which is … quite convenient for Apple).
ewoodrich··on Pebble Round 2
I literally only use Siri on my Apple Watch, I’ve only triggered it accidentally on my iPhone and have the hot word disabled on all my other devices. Of course, all I ever use it for is setting timers and alarms on the watch, but still…
ewoodrich··on Opus 4.5 is not the normal AI agent experience that I have had thus far
Right, I am a daily user of agentic LLM tools and have this exact problem in one large project that has complex business logic externally dictated by real world requirements out of my control, and let's say, variable quality of legacy code.

I remember when Gemini Pro 3 was the latest hotness and I started to get FOMO seeing demos on X posted to HN showing it one shot-ing all sorts of impressive stuff. So I tried it out for a couple days in Gemini CLI/OpenCode and ran into the exact same pain points I was dealing with using CC/Codex.

Flashy one shot demos of greenfield prompts are a natural hype magnet so get lots of attention, but in my experience aren't particularly useful for evaluating value in complex, legacy projects with tightly bounded requirements that can't be easily reduced to a page or two of prose for a prompt.

ewoodrich··on Video Game Websites in the early 00s
And for the Elder Scrolls games:

https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Main_Page

ewoodrich··on Murder-suicide case shows OpenAI selectively hides data after users die
That may keep them preoccupied for a while. But eventually they'll try to upload their post-relativity recursive quantum intelligence unification theory magnum opus to arXiv as a neatly LaTeX-formatted paper so they can spam university physics departments and subreddits.

So then we're back where we started, except unlike in the past the final product will superficially resemble a legitimate paper at first glance...

ewoodrich··on 2025: The Year in LLMs
Yes, I use it with a regular Claude Pro subscription. It also supports using GitHub Copilot subscriptions as a backend.
ewoodrich··on 2025: The Year in LLMs
Exactly. There was a stretch of 6 months or so right after ChatGPT was released where approximately 50% of front page posts at any given time were related to LLMs. And these days every other Show HN is some kind of agentic dev tool and Anthropic/OpenAI announcements routinely get 500+ comments in a matter of hours.
ewoodrich··on Karpathy on Programming: “I've never felt this much behind”
https://xcancel.com/karpathy/status/2004607146781278521

(FYI: you can easily bypass the awful logged out view by replacing x.com with xcancel.com, I use a URL Autoredirector rule to do it automatically in Chromium browsers)

ewoodrich··on Karpathy on Programming: “I've never felt this much behind”
That's a dishonest framing of their argument. There's nothing logically inconsistent in believing wide adoption of AI tools causes developers' skills to atrophy and that the tools also fail to deliver on the hype/promises.

You're inserting "destroy humanity" when OP is suggesting the problem is offloading all thinking to an unreliable tool (I don't entirely agree with their position but it's defensible and not as you stated).

ewoodrich··on Last Year on My Mac: Look Back in Disbelief
As an Android user since the T-Mobile G1, I tried switching to an iPhone 15 Pro as my primary phone from a carrier deal as the hardware looked nice plus Android/iOS has converged so much over the years with all the same apps available on either. I was pretty used to iOS from iPads and as a backup phone so the switching costs were minimal and the better MacOS integration seemed cool.

But man, the notifications are a constant thorn in my side. I have missed so many work notifications due to the lack of persistent notification indicator (other than on the lock screen), and the overall weirdness of iOS lockscreen notification panel (segmentation between "old" notifications that can be mass dismissed and "new" notifications that pile up individually-ish). I use an Apple Watch and somehow still miss Teams notifications as they come in, I'm not even sure how that happens...

I'm so close to abandoning the iPhone as my main phone and going back to my S23 Ultra pretty much entirely because of notifications, it's been a disappointment...

ewoodrich··on Toll roads are spreading in America
So does the family of four driving the speed limit that gets killed in a head-on collision.
ewoodrich··on Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI
Hah, I was listening to a similar conversation that began with family members working in the school system complaining about AI slop that began (relatively) harmlessly in day-to-day email conversations padded with time wasting filler but now has trickled down into "professional" education materials and even textbooks.

Which led to a lot of agreement and rants from others with frustrating stories about their specific workplaces and how it just keeps getting worse by the day. Previously these conversations just popped up among me and the handful of family in tech but clearly now has much broader resonance.

As can be observed in my comment history, I use LLM agentic tools for software dev at work and on my personal projects (really my only AI use case) but cringe whenever I encounter "workslop" as it almost invariably serves to waste my time. My company has been doing a large pilot of 365 Copilot but I have yet to find anything useful, the email writing tools just seems to strip out my personal voice making me sound like I'm writing unsolicited marketing spam.

Every single time I've been using some Microsoft product and think "Hmm, wait maybe the Copilot button could actually be useful here?", it just tells me it can't help or gives me a link to a generic help page. It's like Microsoft deliberately engineered 365 Copilot to be as unhelpful as possible while simultaneously putting a Copilot button on every single visible surface imaginable.

The only tool that actually does something is designed to ruin emails by stripping out personal tone/voice and introducing ambiguity to waste the other person's time. Awesome, thanks for the productivity boost, Microsoft!

ewoodrich··on Unifi Travel Router
I've been able to do WiFi-WiFi connection sharing on my last four Samsung phones as well
ewoodrich··on Ask HN: What are the best engineering blogs with real-world depth?
I bookmarked to take a closer look later, but I'm a little unclear on the premise, could you explain what you mean by "slow"/how it is filtered/curated?
ewoodrich··on Scaling LLMs to Larger Codebases
I mean, we typically architect systems depending on humans around an assumption of human fallibility. But when it comes to automation, randomly still doing the exact opposite even if somewhat rare is problematic and limits where and at what scale it can be safely deployed without needing ongoing human supervision.

For a coding tool it’s not as problematic as hopefully you vet the output to some degree but it still means I have don’t feel comfortable using them using them as expansively (like the mythical personal assistant doing my banking and replying to emails, etc) as they might otherwise be used with more predictable failure modes.

I’m perfectly comfortable with Waymo on the other hand, but that would probably change if I knew they were driven by even the newest and fanciest LLMs as [toddler identified | action: avoid toddler] -> turns towards toddler is a fundamentally different sort of problem.

ewoodrich··on GLM-4.7: Advancing the Coding Capability
I've gone down that route already with Roo/Kilo Code and then OpenCode, but OpenCode with the z.ai backend and/or the CC z.ai Anthropic compatible endpoint although I've been moving to OC in general more and more over time.

GLM 4.6 with Z.ai plan (haven't tried 4.7 yet) has worked well enough for straightforward changes with a relatively large quota (more generous than CC which only gets more frustrating on the Pro plan over time) and has predictable billing which is a big pro for me. I just got tired of having to police my OpenRouter usage to avoid burning through my credits.

But yes, OpenCode is awesome particularly as it supports all the subscriptions I have access to via personal or work (Github Copilot/CC/z.ai). And as model churn/competition slows down over time I can stick which whichever end up having the best value/performance with sufficient quota for my personal projects without fear of lock-in and enshittification.

ewoodrich··on GLM-4.7: Advancing the Coding Capability
It's a perfectly serviceable fallback when Claude Code kicks me off in the middle of an edit on the Pro plan (which happens constantly to me now) and I just want to finish tweaking some CSS styles or whatever to wrap up. If you have a legitimate concern about losing customers than yes, you're probably in the wrong target market for a $3/mo plan...
ewoodrich··on Scaling LLMs to Larger Codebases
Not OP, and haven't had it flat out rm the entire .git, but I have had Claude get flustered and pull a "Wait, no! what was I thinking? that idea doesn't work at all here, I need to revert that attempt and try something else..."

.. and then ran a fatally flawed "git checkout" command that wiped out all unstaged changes, which it immediately realized and after flailing around for five minutes trying to undo eventually came back saying "yeah uh so sorry, but... here's the thing..."

ewoodrich··on Scaling LLMs to Larger Codebases
I recently ran into two baffling, what felt like GPT 3.5 era completely backwards misinterpretations of an unambiguous sentence once each in Codex and CC/Sonnet a few days apart in completely different scenarios (both very early in the context window). And to be fair, they were notable partially as an "exception that proves the rule" where it was surprising to see but OP's example can definitely still happen in my experience.

I was prepared to go back to my original message and spot an obvious-in-hindsight grey area/phrasing issue on my part as the root cause but there was nothing in the request itself that was unclear or problematic, nor was it buried deep within a laundry list of individual requests in a single message. Of course, the CLI agents did all sorts of scanning through the codebase/self debate/etc in between the request and the first code output. I'm used to how modern models/agents get tripped up by now so this was an unusually clear cut failure to encounter from the latest large commercial reasoning models.

In both instances, literally just restating the exact same request with "No, the request was: [original wording]" was all it took to steer them back and didn't become a concerning pattern. But with the unpredictability of how the CLI agents decide to traverse a repo and ingest large amounts of distracting code/docs it seems much too over confident to believe that random, bizarre LLM "reasoning" failures won't still occur from time to time in regular usage even as models improve given their inherent limitations.

(If I were bending over backwards to be charitable/anthropomorphize, it would be the human failure mode of "I understood exactly what I was asked for and what I needed to do, but then somehow did the exact opposite, haha oops brain fart!" but personally I'm not willing to extend that much forgiveness/tolerance to a failure from a commercial tool I pay for...)

ewoodrich··on Flock Exposed Its AI-Powered Cameras to the Internet. We Tracked Ourselves
In the US for the past 5+ years Xfinity/Comcast, Charter, and whatever CenturyLink is called these days have all heavily pushed the "self-install kit" option vs traditional tech install each time I've moved.

Worked 4/5 times (all with cable), only time it failed was because I had apparently subscribed to a DSL plan from CenturyLink without realizing and they needed to wire up the extra lines upstream for the "modern" version of DSL to work in my apartment. After insisting multiple times that the self-install kit was 100% plug-n-play at my new address despite my intense skepticism since I really needed reliable internet from Day 1 during COVID remote work.

I was seriously missing Comcast/cable by the time that 1 yr contract was up, the devil you know and all...

ewoodrich··on I can't upgrade to Windows 11, now leave me alone
If you decide to dual boot:

https://github.com/Raphire/Win11Debloat

I run this as the first step on any new Win 11 machine, the recommended defaults remove nearly all annoyances I care about. It's a popular tool that's been around for years with a lot of users so isn't some random repo, and it's just Powershell so pretty easy to understand what it's doing if you want to audit the code yourself.

After running it once, I've seen nothing that I would consider an "ad" on Windows 11, and search looks only at the filesystem without any web/store trash. Somewhat ironically, it makes for a cleaner experience than MacOS where I regularly get spammed by Apple trying to cross-sell me something (iCloud, Apple TV, Apple Music, etc).

(FWIW, I have also never needed to re-run after an update or anything, based on 6+ full Win11 installs across three different devices.)

← PreviousPage 2 of 24Next →