HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ex3xu

624 karma · joined March 15, 2015

There is a quality even meaner than outright ugliness or disorder, and this meaner quality is the dishonest mask of pretended order, achieved by ignoring or suppressing the real order that is struggling to exist and to be served.

-- Jane Jacobs, the Death and Life of Great American Cities

ex3xu at pm.me

submissionscomments
ex3xu··on America’s Monopoly Crisis Hits the Military
It's refreshing for me to see an article from a modern conservative outfit that actually seems to understand the adversarial relationship between the finance sector and the principles of economic conservatism. I particularly liked the section talking about historical precedents and bipartisan support for initiatives:

> Believe it or not, America has been here before. In the 1920s and 1930s, the American defense industrial base was being similarly manipulated by domestic financiers for their own purposes, retarding innovation and damaging the nation’s ability to defend itself. And American military readiness was ebbing in the midst of an increasingly dangerous world full of rising autocracies.

> Within the defense base itself, every example—from TransDigm to L3 to Chinese infiltration of American business—has drawn the attention of members of Congress. Representatives Ted Budd and Paul Cook are Republicans and Representatives Jackie Speier and Ro Khanna are Democrats. They are not alone. Democratic Senator Elizabeth Warren and Representative Tim Ryan have joined Khanna’s demand for a TransDigm investigation.

Outside of this article, the best writing I've seen on this topic of short-term incentives is from British economist John Kay's book "Other People's Money", for example when he compares the annual reports from chemical company ICI in 1987 and 1994.

1987: ICI aims to be the world's leading chemical company, servicing customers internationally through the innovative and responsible application of chemistry and related science...

1994: Our objective is to maximise value for our shareholders by focusing on businesses where we have market leadership, a technological edge and a world competitive cost base.

Kay goes on to explain how ICI, a leading British chemical company since its founding in the 1920s, attracted a short term flurry of investment activity but ultimately sold in 2007 just about a decade after their change of priorities.

Kay primarily blames an over-expansion of the finance sector and the revolving-door culture on Wall Street, fairly consistent with the premises of this article.

ex3xu··on Microsoft's Linux Kernel
With great power comes great responsibility, I guess. I agree it would have been nice for Linux to come with a few more sanity checks by default, like maybe a warning flag for rm -rf /* and dd commands...
ex3xu··on Microsoft's Linux Kernel
> The thing that annoys me most on Windows is Windows itself. After using Linuxes for almost two decades now, the notion of the OS taking tens of minutes to self update when all I wanted was to quickly reboot it is unbearable.

This is definitely a problem especially considering that the shotgun approach to some Windows updates actually hurt the performance of some machines, even breaking Windows on occasion [0]. However, in fairness I would say that I've spent just as much or more time fixing rolling release issues on Arch/Manjaro, or troubleshooting the package stopping me from sudo apt upgrade. The worst experience for me was having to reformat after the update from Ubuntu 14.04 crashed.

What annoys me most about Microsoft's overarching paternalistic philosophy is is how creepy their telemetry initiatives are. Granted plenty of companies do this now, for the same profit-driven motivations, but Microsoft goes above and beyond in terms of disabling or even ignoring opt out options [1]. I've found the Winaero blog [2] to be a good source of tools to stop some of the Windows telemetry shenanigans.

[0]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/daveywinder/2019/05/19/microsof...

[1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/Windows10/comments/a4lpg0/windows_1...

[2]: https://winaero.com/

ex3xu··on Attempts to Censor AntiPolygraph.org
Here's some previous popular HN threads about debunking or beating lie detector tests:

(2009) antipolygraph.org (first HN submission) - NSA polygraph experiences: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=428489

(2013) WaPo - Man accused of teaching anti-polygraph techniques faces prison https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6308878

(2015) NYT - How to beat a polygraph: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9481385

(2018) Gizmodo - Use of AI lie detector in EU: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18351733

(2018) antipolygraph.org - CIA Analyst on polygraph BS: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18155548

(2018) antipolygraph.org - book on how to beat polygraphs: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18431683

I wanted to provided the pro-polygraph side of the argument but literally could not find any popular threads in support of that case. Please correct me if anyone can find credible pro polygraph positions.

ex3xu··on Spike in Autism May Be Linked to Preservative in Processed Foods, Study Suggests
They mention the 5 ASD out of 8 PA sample size, and they explicitly cite the .005 rate of ASD, but I think their PA incidence number is different than the one available on Wikipedia, and I couldn't find it in the paper so that may be where the discrepancy is from. I may be wrong but I don't think we need the combinatorics for this particular calculation since their calculation is trying to disprove that these events are independent rather than calculate the joint conditional probability. Obviously I can't comment on whether any cherry picking was done, or if these just happen to be the available sample of available children with this rare metabolic disorder. I'd agree and I think the authors of the study would agree that the sample size is too small for any definitive conclusions, but I think the body of evidence when considering the rest of the available PPA studies make a reasonable case for it to be a finding of interest.
ex3xu··on Spike in Autism May Be Linked to Preservative in Processed Foods, Study Suggests
You're right that it's a low sample size, and the authors themselves do warn that diagnostic rates of ASD in children may be inflated:

> With the increasing reported frequency of ASD in the pedi-atric population one cannot rule out a possible coincidence of the diagnosis of ASD in patients with propionic acidemia.

Regarding the calculation, Wikipedia says 1 in 35000 for PA the US, rather than 3500, and the researchers use an incidence rate of .5% for autism rather than 1%. So the number of people is 1000, not 20000. The researchers say they're calculating off a 5/8 ASD/PA incidence rate, so the calculation is something like (1000/7 billion)^5*(some negligible amount)^3.

ex3xu··on Spike in Autism May Be Linked to Preservative in Processed Foods, Study Suggests
While propionic acid is used artificially as a preservative, it is a naturally occuring byproduct of fermentation of certain kinds of carbohydrates.

The article notes the link between certain kinds of bacteria in ASD children that overproduce PPA as a byproduct.

ex3xu··on Spike in Autism May Be Linked to Preservative in Processed Foods, Study Suggests
The elevated levels of PPA are linked to a dysbiotic gut bacteria imbalance, with ASD children exhibiting more bacteria that produce PPA. I'd imagine if you're not eating PPA in excess of your body's ability to metabolize it you're fine.

Regarding the second half of your comment, I'll cite from the etiology article I linked:

> In the concluding sentences of their analysis, Witters and Debold make their strongest argument for the connection between propionic acid and ASD by observing that, given the rates of PA [proprionic acidemia] and of ASD occurrence in the general population, the probability of there being no link between the two pathologies is 4.34 in 10 trillion. Put differently, comorbid incidences of PA and ASD are far more common than should be expected between two unrelated diseases, meaning that there is most likely a link between the two.

ex3xu··on Spike in Autism May Be Linked to Preservative in Processed Foods, Study Suggests
Thanks for sharing, I'll have to look into that book sometime. Also a real throwback to see Jonah Lehrer's name on a piece of scientific journalism.

Looks like in 2018 there's a few [0] interesting [1] papers [2] on the link between senescent glial cells and neurodegeneration, which I think would support a theory of glial cells playing some role in cognition. Seems to be a fairly active area of research.

[0]: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-018-0543-y

[1]: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Jay_Penney/publication/...

[2]: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S089662731...

ex3xu··on Spike in Autism May Be Linked to Preservative in Processed Foods, Study Suggests
I can't speak about benzoic acid, but the article notes that propionic acid is the most common compound produced by bacteria unique to the gut microbiomes of ASD children:

>Previous studies have demonstrated increased levels of PPA, a short chain fatty acid (SCFA), in the feces of children with ASD; we also know that the gut microbiome in these children is also quite distinct in terms of the type of bacteria that inhabit their intestines.

>Clostridia, Bacteriodetes, and Desulfovibrio bacteria are unique to patients with ASD. What’s interesting is that these bacteria are also known to be fermenters of carbohydrates that produce PPA, and other SCFAs as well. Ironically, while PPA is the most common compound produced by bacteria in ASD patients, it is also widely used in the food industry as a preservative due to its ability to inhibit grown of fungi (mold).

So following up I found an article on the etiological history of the PPA link [0]. From that article, there was a 2008 study of PPA injections in rats (spoiler, observed to cause ASD-like symptoms)[1], and a case study in 2012 of an ASD child with propionic acidemia, a rare metabolic condition that affects PPA metabolism [2], which led to more recent studies establishing a connection between behavioral disruptions and propionic acidemia, even in children who did not meet the diagnostic criteria for ASD [3].

ASD can also exhibit GI tract issues like constipation and IBS as symptoms, which would have supported some kind of gut microbiome hypothesis. Regarding what you're saying about how common PPA is, one research group speculates a "two-hit" mechanism behind ASD:

>Al-Owain’s group suggests that PA may thus act as one of the drivers of developing ASD under the two-hit model of ASD pathology, which posits that two separate factors must be present before ASD is developed. Under this model, one problem—such as PA in isolation—is insufficient to cause ASD, but when paired with another problem—such as another metabolic disorder affecting the gut-brain axis, like biotinidase deficiency—the combined detrimental effects of the two pathologies can cause ASD.

[0]: https://www.foundationalmedicinereview.com/blog/the-link-bet...

[1]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18395759

[2]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3573175/pdf/978...

[3]: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S109671921...

ex3xu··on Spike in Autism May Be Linked to Preservative in Processed Foods, Study Suggests
The preservative in question is propionic acid (PPA):

> In the current study, Saleh Naser, PhD and her team at UCF found that when neural stem cells were exposed to high levels of PPA, the neurons incurred multiple changes resulting in cellular damage and inflammation. One of the major effects of PPA they noted was the overproduction of glial cells, the protective outer cells making up the sheath covering neurons, with a corresponding reduction in the number of neurons themselves.

Here's another article covering some more of the etiological history behind this finding: https://www.foundationalmedicinereview.com/blog/the-link-bet...

On a side note: at the risk of both being slightly off topic and/or spreading bad science, there was that controversial assessment of Einstein's brain which noted that he had a higher proportion of glial cells than other brains studied (see Wikipedia for potential issues with the findings): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albert_Einstein%27s_brain#Glia...

I'm noting this only as a layman's speculation about glial cell concentration as a potential mechanism behind the phenomenon of higher intelligence and occasionally savant-like abilities in some of the high-functioning ASD population.

ex3xu··on The Simple Genius of Checklists
They are at the end, in appendix format. The final checklist is a checklist for checklists:

http://www.projectcheck.org/uploads/1/0/9/0/1090835/checklis...

ex3xu··on Mitch Kapor Introduces Lotus 1-2-3 Spreadsheet (1983) [video]
I share your frustration, and I have nothing but admiration for Mitch Kapor -- he would go on to be one of the founders of the EFF after all.

For me, what causes me the most pain in hindsight is how easily we could have ended up in a world where Lotus, with its ethically conscious leadership, could have ended up with the degree of influence on the digital landscape that Microsoft, Apple, Amazon, Google, and Facebook would eventually have over the digital world. Just a few million better spent dollars and a few more groundbreaking products shipped, and who knows...

ex3xu··on Mitch Kapor Introduces Lotus 1-2-3 Spreadsheet (1983) [video]
I'll suggest the book Dreaming in Code to anyone who wants to learn more about the history of Mitch Kapor and Lotus, particularly what went wrong with their attempt at "revolutionary" calendar software Chandler.

http://www.dreamingincode.com/book-excerpt/

https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2007/01/21/the-big-picture/

ex3xu··on Ask HN: Can we create a new internet where search engines are irrelevant?
Like others here I don't have too much problem with indexing.

What I would like to see is a human layer of infrastructure on top of algorithmic search, one the leverages the fact that there are billions of people who could be helping others find what they need. That critical mass wasn't available at the beginning of the internet, but it certainly is now.

You kind of have attempts at this function in efforts like the Stack Exchange network, Yahoo Questions, Ask Reddit, tech forums etc. but I'd like to see more active empowerment and incentivization of giving humans the capacity to help other humans find what they need, in a way that would be free from commercial incentives. I envision stuff like maintaining absolutely impartial focus groups, and for commercial search it would be nice to see companies incentivized to provide better quality goods to game search rather than better SEO optimization.

ex3xu··on How Discount Brokerages Make Money
Sure, if you axiomatically accept the Efficient Market Hypothesis as a feature of modern markets that isn't going to blow up the global economy, which I would if it hadn't already come close to doing that already. Facilitating price discovery on the assumption of no arbitrage is great until everyone buys the same secretly-dog-shit security and the resulting market correction martingales the whole thing.

I think at the very least we can say that there is a limit to the fairness of an exchange between willing counterparties when one party is exploiting an asymmetry in information to profit off the other party. $99 versus $100 is one thing, $100 versus $0 is another.

ex3xu··on How Discount Brokerages Make Money
You're right, the issue really has nothing to do with fees and I stand corrected.
ex3xu··on How Discount Brokerages Make Money
My issue with this approach is that the more this gets encouraged for naive investors, the easier it becomes to shift risk away from the players who actually ought to be holding the bag. Sure, the brokerage fees themselves might not be outrageous, but what ought to be outrageous to you is the long-term consequences of empowering opaque profit-driven actors who carry perverse incentives by definition. How about the aftermath of the 2008 crisis: $850 billion getting shifted out of American pension funds into the pockets of hedge fund managers?
ex3xu··on How Discount Brokerages Make Money
>1. the retirement funds you should be putting your money in won't require brokerage fees.

Ah, okay so there's another choice of waiting for retirement funds and pensions to get looted by bank and insurance bailouts in the next financial crisis.

> 2. don't leave your money with banks.

This is kind of missing the point -- I'm saying that by the time the finance world is done "allocating resources", there's not enough left over for the working middle class to put in the bank in the first place. This reflects in statistics that more than half of Americans have less than $1000 in the bank at all.

> 3a. your own ignorance is definitely a problem

I was using ignorance in a tongue-in-cheek way of saying that exploitation of asymmetries in information ought to be considered inherently unjust in the same way that insider trading should be theoretically illegal, instead of, you know, the foundational philosophy of HFT.

> 3b. VTI, SPY, VOO, etc is all the infrastructure you need.

Leaving aside the fact that all ETFs have fees and expenses, one of the primary criticism of these offerings is that they enhance losses for naive owners. ETFs now consist of a sizeable chunk of U.S. invested assets, and every sharp market drawdown that happens runs the risk of inducing more selling. But in the same way that nobody looked at the garbage packaged inside CDOs before 2008, no naive investor is going to be able to watch the Net Asset Value of the underlying securities of their ETF investments, and so people will continue liquidating at prices that will lead to deep underperformance for smaller players.

But let's just keep inflating the myth that ETFs are the savior of the middle class, because God forbid that institutional investors actually be required to have any skin in the game for themselves. Keep inflating it right up until the point where Bregman's bubble gets proven right and taxpayers get left holding the bag for the Great Recession 2.0.

ex3xu··on How Discount Brokerages Make Money
> Some people get mad about the financial industry for taking advantage of customers. I find it hard to get mad about a deal between willing counterparties, but if you think that Wall Street is soaking the US middle class, you should be monomanically focused on the interest spread between cash balances in brokerage accounts and high-interest bank accounts or money market funds. That is the cost that does not call itself a cost.

I'm grateful for this insight provided by the article. As someone interested in the takes on inequality presented by thinkers like Piketty, Stiglitz and McChesney, I think it's important to consider the fact that ultimately, the public good will remain hamstrung by the fact that those with the greatest know-how to create returns on investment are also those with the greatest profit-driven motivations. The middle class gets to choose between getting fleeced by brokerage fees, getting fleeced by the low rates of return offered by the banks, or getting fleeced by your own ignorance and lack of access to the infrastructure to generate market returns in the adversarial world of modern finance.

UBI and higher taxes I don't think can solve this problem, because as more and more of the market's growth is captured (extracted?) by the monoliths of private sector, who in a globalized world are not beholden to any one nation (just look at the effect of Brexit on Britain's financial sector), individual governments no longer really have the jurisdiction and leverage to capture enough of the market's return.

In the past I have been quick to blame stuff like the repeal of Glass-Steagall and other bipartisan deregulation efforts, as well as the dangerous assumptions of competence behind stuff like Black-Scholes and the Harry Markowitz approach, but ultimately I can't see any way around the fact that the profit motive just seems to be the greatest available driver of financial competence. What can even be done beyond impotently hoping for Gates Foundation-style philanthropy? Maybe the Chinese are actually ahead of the game with their State capitalism approach, and moving forward we should just all turn our governments into fintech companies with a side hustle of providing public infrastructure and services to the citizenry...

ex3xu··on The internet is increasingly a low-trust society
I'm a bit surprised this article has zero reference to any interdisciplinary work on trust metrics, and stuff like trust propagation algorithms. I'm even more surprised, with the blockchain having becoming such a buzzword these days, that Bitcoin's proof-of-work approach was not even mentioned, let alone evaluated for effectiveness. And where's the love for Bruce Schneier [0]?

I think the article's approach of referencing historic stragies from government and social infrastructure is a bit useless in this context because how much the problem changes when scarce information becomes abundant light-speed communication. I understand that they are trying to make the point that corporate overlords are bad, but maybe it would serve the purposes of the article better to just focus on the variables that matter, now that there's new capacities for transparency and accountability metrics based on some combination of historic behavior, web of trust node size, and other situational variables based on the medium -- like users that spend a lot of money, or consistently downvote known bad actors. Forcing users to have skin in the game with strict enforcement of transgressions is of course a reasonably effective, if coercive, strategy as well, and you can take the edge off this authoritarian approach if you pair it with some variant of restorative justice.

My approach is perhaps not rigorously useful, but for my personal conceptions of trust in a world of bad actors, I like looking at strategies from Axelrod's iterated prisoner's dilemma[1]. Tit for Tat is famously a good strategy, and there's also a good strategy where you forgive on multiple cooperations but gradually increase the punishment of defectors to n times for their nth defection [2]. Though I should mention that tribalist collusion with other bad actors is unfortunately a very viable approach as well.

[0]: https://www.schneier.com/books/liars_and_outliers/

[1]: https://axelrod.readthedocs.io

[2]: http://jasss.soc.surrey.ac.uk/20/4/12.html

ex3xu··on Productivity brought by Clojure [slides]
Outside of standard recommended resources like the ones offered here [0], I found that doing the problems on 4clojure.com and then comparing with the answers of top users was helpful for experiencing some of those kind of lightbulb moments in Clojure.

[0]: https://github.com/razum2um/awesome-clojure#guides

ex3xu··on Aphantasia
The linked Vividness of Visual Imagery Questionnaire (VVIQ) wikipage only provides a hard-to-read Youtube video or software download as sources. Here's a link to the 16-question quiz from aphantasia.com (JS required): https://aphantasia.com/quiz/

I'll add a YMMV, as aphantasia.com adds the following caveats: "...it can be hard to classify the vividness of a mental image on a scale from 1-5 when you have nothing to use as a reference point. It is difficult to rank your vividness of mental imagery when you can’t know how strongly other people visualize. The test asks you to compare the vision in your head with how you know it looks in real life in order to reconcile this somewhat: is the scenario you are being asked to visualize equally vivid to its real world counterpart, a little less vivid, or not vivid at all/non-existent?

Further, any test that relies on self-reporting will always be subject to some bias due to the fact that you are more likely to subconsciously (or consciously) choose answers that will give you the result that you want. "

ex3xu··on The internet is an SEO landfill
I think what frustrates me most about the current state of SEO is that it is a race to the bottom for both businesses and consumers. Below a certain threshhold of notability, traffic essentially becomes correlated with SEO spend. Even the business that wins the SEO war in its local community can end up with issues, as for certain industries the disproportionate number of eyes on the first few links can easily balloon into an unmanageable amount of service calls and customer support infrastructure needs, when all the while perfectly adequate businesses languish away on the second and third SERPs ends up fighting over the remaining 5% traffic scraps.

In an ideal world, traffic numbers would be correlated with some combination of product quality mixed with a sort of load-balancing effect so that each quality company could match their available supply to the demand. I still believe, perhaps naively, that search engines could have profitably built infrastructure to serve the needs of consumers in this way -- focus group-like services for commercial search that would require companies to pay for the privilege of submitting to objective evaluations of their products in exchange for more traffic. In a structure like this, the incentives of search engines and end users could be aligned.

Instead, Eric Schmidt and the rest of the market share MBAs came into the picture and we got precisely the opposite -- instead of holding businesses beholden to the needs of end users, now we have this insidious and dystopian perpetual advertising machine where not only are businesses now beholden to the needs of a faceless SEO algorithm, funneling money away from R&D and into this annoying waterfall of trite crap noted by this article, but IMO even worse is that end users are essentially beholden to the needs of the corporations -- either by getting creepily data-mined and harvested for the benefit of the highest AdWords bidder, or by getting inundated by constant ads, as anyone who has tried watching YouTube without AdBlocker on can attest to. I don't think I'm being hyperbolic when I say that nobody wins except the search engine stockholders.

I was totally heartbroken when Google sold out and created AdWords. I naively had thought it would never happen -- Brin and Page were literally on record saying, “Advertising funded search engines will be inherently biased towards the advertisers and away from the needs of consumers” (Anatomy of a Large-Scale Hypertextual Web Search Engine, 1998)[0].

So I've had embarrassingly heated discussions with Googler family members where I raise this issue, and their defense has been essentially that AdWords is a necessary evil that funds all their infrastructure expenses, as well as their cool R&D and "20% time" and all their ML advancements that they get to do, like AlphaGo, Waymo etc.

But I really think that when your company depends on perverse incentives in this way, the end result will ultimately drift away from their original job of serving consumers, and eventually exist only to inflate their own share price and run what amounts to a protectionist racket. The only difference is that the threat of withholding SEO traffic is much cheaper and efficient option than mafia shakedowns.

ex3xu··on Tiananmen Square: China 30 Years On
> I asked him whether he thought China's stellar economic record over the past three decades in some way justifies the crackdown. "I don't think so. It's like you cut off you know somebody's limb, and he's still surviving. And you cannot say that: oh, he's surviving because you cut off his limb. The person is actually crippled. And that's what China is."

This is an article reflecting on an event where several thousand innocent young activists were killed by the Chinese government. I think most "Westerns" within my filter bubble have zero reason to be disappointed by China's inspiring economic successes, but have many reasons disappointed with modern China's continuing record of human rights violations e.g. against the Uighurs, Falun Gong, political dissidents, and most recently victims of its draconian social credit score program. Though I suppose in the current state of geopolitical affairs, between Xi, Putin, Trump, May, Erdogan, Duterte, Morrison, Bolsonaro, etc. there is plenty of disappointment to go around.

ex3xu··on Meditations on Moloch (2014)
This was a mostly entertaining read, if a bit all over the place. I do have one point to offer -- I noticed this article quotes liberally from Bostrom, Nick, but misses another thinker who has relevant ideas about avoiding what this author refers to as "multipolar traps" -- Ostrom, Elinor. I recommend those who are interested in resources for the fight against Moloch to look into her book Governing the Commons, as she devised a set of principles for managing common-pool resources to avoid these types of traps, at least in specific concrete scenarios.
ex3xu··on Is Neuroscience a Bigger Threat than Artificial Intelligence?
I might be wrong, but I think I've seen the term "theory of mind" used in the scientific context. For example, Kurzweil's "Pattern Recognition Theory of Mind" and Heylighen's "Anticipation Control Theory of Mind"

Kurzweil: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Create_a_Mind#Pattern_R...

Heylighen: http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/Papers/AnticipationControl.pdf

Though I maybe should mention I generally agree with the use of "soup sandwich" as a description for the article.

ex3xu··on Is Neuroscience a Bigger Threat than Artificial Intelligence?
The weird part is that he specifically mentions behaviorism:

> Except for a brief period when psychologists embraced a wrongheaded behaviorism, the theory of mind everyone shares drove the 20th century research programs of child psychology and psychiatry, cognitive science, evolutionary anthropology, and neuroscience.

But then by the end goes ahead and suggests the premises of behaviorism as a conclusion...?

> By colonizing consciousness spoken language turned it into a monologue of silent speech, tricking us that the meaning of spoken words is given by thoughts’ content when its just silent sounds passing through consciousness. Neuroscience shows that that in our brains the neural circuits neither have nor need content to do their jobs.

Maybe I'm misunderstanding something somewhere? Is this guy really the one in charge of the philosophy department at Duke?

ex3xu··on Will Facebook's Grownups Please Stand Up
> Any talk otherwise is delusional hanging on to a mythical era of corporate responsibility that has never actually existed.

While I think this is correct in the most general sense -- examples throughout history of the old consolidative robber barons, GE destroying the streetcar for its own benefit, etc -- one thing that has changed in the last 30-40 years is the change in mentality and priorities of the average shareholder and the average corporation. John Kay gives an example in his book, Other People's Money, comparing the change in chemical company ICI's annual shareholder reports:

1987: ICI aims to be the world's leading chemical company servicing customers internationally through the innovative and responsible application of chemistry and related science... Through achievement of our aim, we will enhance the wealth and well-being of our shareholders, our employees, our customers, and the communities which we serve and in which we operate.

1994: Our objective is to maximise value for our shareholders by focusing on businesses where we have market leadership, a technological edge and world competitive cost base.

Kay goes on to attribute the change in the rise of financialisation and deregulation in the 80s and 90s, as well as the wide adoption of technically rigorous but conceptually questionable financial economics innovations like the efficient market hypothesis, Harry Markowitz model, Black/Scholes for pricing derivatives, and Ramsey/Savage's subjective utility. He also cites the rise of "I'll be gone, you'll be gone" trading culture on Wall Street, explaining traders are incentivized only to pad their own bonuses with no regard for the bigger financial picture.

It may be that there was no mythical corporate responsibility at the top level, but I think it's important to understand that there are underlying structural changes that have spread the poison of financialization to the point where even good actors in corporate America are now incentivized to behave in ways that don't support the public interest. And in my view, the most appalling changed, is the modern inability for muckraking journalists to create public outcry and political will to regulate the worst of the bad actors.

ex3xu··on A Brand New Interview with David Foster Wallace
> You know, a very simple answer would have to do with the idea of constant movement but within a rigidly defined set of constraints and also with the idea of two and twoness and things moving back and forth between two sides in such a way that a pattern is created.

Huh. Never thought about that before.

Wonder what connections to this idea that I am missing in the deeper themes of Infinite Jest. Does anyone know if there are any good websites for this kind of literary analysis? I'd be interested if there's a hub where people go to share the task in putting in the kind of "work" required to understand deep fiction that Wallace talks about. It would be nice to be able to read about the many other deeper symbolic connections that I missed...

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →