HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

exfatloss

94 karma · joined February 12, 2023

submissionscomments
exfatloss··on A Tale of Two Caloric Deficits
Oh hi :) Thanks for posting, AMA
exfatloss··on Eating 2,294kcal for $5.20/day on the ex150 diet
I had so many problems on carbs before, not sure there's much to add to them haha

But yea I'd been doing keto for years before this so that part isn't new. Just the amount of cream.

exfatloss··on Eating 2,294kcal for $5.20/day on the ex150 diet
I've lost almost 50lbs in 6 months on it :)
exfatloss··on A Tale of Two Caloric Deficits
AMA :)
exfatloss··on Semaglutide Now Approved by NHS
Wow, 40kg is super impressive!

Could you share a little bit about the experience? My experience is also that it is just super difficult to eat less/exercise more when your metabolism is already wrecked. Sounds like that just "went away?"

Maybe these drugs really are "it" if they found that button to push.

exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
Not always, but if it's super drastic. Feels like a massive sugar rush (or maybe it is actually just the sugar rush I'm experiencing when I accidentally eat hidden sugar?)

Get super hot, feel like my blood is rushing, heart beats.. not faster but.. louder?

exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
Or pigs. Basically inedible after they bred the fat out of them in the 80s/90s :(
exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
Seems like a legit criticism :)

Care to expand?

exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
Still. So much fiber, so much chewing.

I'm not saying diabetics should go out and make banana smoothies. But I tried going fruitarian for 30 days in my 20s and I simply couldn't. I couldn't eat enough food to meet energy balance.

Maybe if you made banana puree all day but it gets real disgusting real quick.

I find fruit pretty self-limiting.

exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
I mean maybe if you wanted to you could ;)

But not in practice, I agree. I was actually fruitarian for a few weeks and man it's HARD to chew enough food to even get your calories in, lol. Plus it's all cold so it's extra annoying cause you never get the thermal heat of cooked food!

exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
It is ridiculous to get mad at someone who doesn't eat fruit for not eating fruit.

You like fruit? Great, eat fruit. Enjoy!

If OP was anorexic or undernourished or deprived of some essential nutrient there would be a point in pointing that out. But fruit?

exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
I haven't used it as a sweetener per se but it's used in a bunch of products I like. E.g. energy drinks or protein. Those don't list erythritol. You're right that it's tricky (impossible?) to find on its own. I suppose it needs to hang onto something to get it into crystallized form?
exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
Yes. And?
exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
Monk Fruit!
exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
I think it also depends on the types of sugars. I can seem to tolerate way more lactose and still maintain ketosis, for example.

Plus there are different "levels of ketosis" and I'm not sure there's much research on it. E.g. my Non-24 is in remission even when I eat more of a VLCD. My ketones aren't as high but it works just as good for my purpose. I don't know if that level would be enough for an epileptic, for example, or someone who gets other benefits from keto.

exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
Haha I think that's a common keto response.

Person 1: I do keto

Person 2: I just eat <moderate/balanced/adequate/healthy/clean>

This seems to imply to person 1 that person 1 could do the same, which is often not true. Ketogenic diets have a whole bunch of benefit that no amount of moderation/balance will get to a person with those issues.

So ketoers often take issue with such comments when they seem to imply to be just as useful for dealing with said issues.

exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
Many such cases
exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
I don't have epilepsy but keto fixed another sleep condition (Non-24 wake/sleep disorder) that is not generally "known by science" to be fixable.
exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
Yea a lot of it is that your palate actually changes after a few months. It usually takes 4-6 months for me and then, when I go back, I notice that I don't enjoy the foods as much any more. Instead I've found new favorites to enjoy on my new diet.

Definitely happened with keto. You notice too that even when you get really hungry you don't fantasize about candy any more but about steak :)

exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
I doubt you could give yourself diabetes from fruit without really trying. The chewing just gets old real quick.

But I also don't think you miss much by cutting fruit out entirely. It's a bunch of sugar, a lot of fiber, and a few vitamins that you can easily get from other places like green, leafy vegetables.

Really nothing unique about fruit unless you just really like fruit.

exfatloss··on Trouble with Erythritol
Fellow keto-er here. There is definitely some hidden ultra sugar in some of those restaurant sauces. I've had a similar experience with takeout Chinese that was "just" chicken & vegetables. Two bites and I felt myself catapult out of ketosis, including the sugar rush you describe and even heart palpitations.

Another thing is that some artificial sweeteners instantly kick me out, too. Worse than sugar. I forget which one it is but I grabbed a "sugar-free" energy drink one time. I spit out the very first sip but still got kicked out of ketosis including the heat and sugar rush, that's how strong it was.

That said, stevia and monk fruit are totally fine for me. No effect whatsoever. I slightly prefer the taste of monk fruit.

exfatloss··on A new class of drugs for weight loss could end obesity
:)

Thanks for clarifying!

exfatloss··on I can't wait to be Overweight
Interesting. For me, the tape measure bounced around way more than weight. I have a post on that coming up.

I disagree on having to love being hungry. I strongly believe a diet will not succeed long-term if it makes you hungry. The only times I've ever been able to lose significant weight was when I was never hungry during the diet.

exfatloss··on I can't wait to be Overweight
Whoops, thanks!

Shows what I know about metrics :D

edit: fixed it

exfatloss··on I can't wait to be Overweight
AMA
exfatloss··on A new class of drugs for weight loss could end obesity
High sat fat + starch might actually be fine if you cut out the PUFAs and maybe sugar: https://fireinabottle.net/introducing-the-croissant-diet/

Have not tried it yet, but it's on the list (https://exfatloss.substack.com/p/hypotheses)

But yea the diet as listed is keto AF. I test 1.7-2.7mmol/L most of the time when on it.

exfatloss··on A new class of drugs for weight loss could end obesity
Studies from the 20s thru 40s for somewhat sedentary office workers in NYC show that they ate more the less physically active they were, often eating up to 4,500kcal/day. Large portions of that from white bread, lard, butter, milk, and pork.
exfatloss··on A new class of drugs for weight loss could end obesity
Also not a medical professional but I recommend you eat lots of heavy cream :D https://exfatloss.substack.com/p/ex150-diet-macros-2294kcal-...
exfatloss··on A new class of drugs for weight loss could end obesity
So I should spend 8h per day farming rice?

Doesn't seem like a productive comment.

There are certainly countless viable options, but I've yet to see someone suggest one that doesn't require me moving to another continent to become a physical laborer.

exfatloss··on A new class of drugs for weight loss could end obesity
> Don't have a clear picture of what "better" mean? That's also simple. Look at what people were eating 100 years ago, and how much physical activity they were doing then.

Do you mean fructose? PUFAs? Be specific. What do I eat/avoid?

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →