HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

falsaberN1

624 karma · joined May 20, 2020

submissionscomments
falsaberN1··on AniSora: Open-source anime video generation model
Disclaimer: I'm an artist with 30+ years of experience.

Downgraded to AI training? Nonsense. You forget artists do more than just draw for money, we also draw for FUN, and that little detail escapes every single AI-related discussion I've been reading for the last 3 years.

falsaberN1··on Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests
What distresses me about all this is that we are handling children like if they were a separate species....just use your memory! Of course they can reason better than we think, did everyone forget making plans and having chats with other preschoolers as a preschooler? Everyone has been one! No exceptions! And yet we act like if kids were a separate state of matter or something.

This strange mental separation can only bring in bad results.

falsaberN1··on Mitochondria Are Alive
I don't know why this is being downvoted. It's quite apropos for being a piece of fiction toying with this very concept.

It is a videogame based on/continuing a cheesy scifi novel that played with the concept of mitochondria being alive (also sentient). Sure it's not quite scientifically sound, but it still explains the concept with enough actual facts (very easy to distinguish from the fictional ones), and the ludicrous nature of it all makes it so you won't *ever* forget that mitochondria are in fact a part of the cell and their normal function is being involved in energy production.

I can warrant 90% of people who ever thought about the mitochondrion's existence and function (beyond basic school formation) that aren't working or studying in related fields are just people who played this game. I can bet there's a non-zero amount of scientists that got into this stuff because they played the game as kids or teens.

falsaberN1··on Roblox is the biggest game in the world, but is unprofitable
It's hilarious how plain Mortal Kombat becomes without the K.

I'm not calling you out for making a typo, I'm simply amused at how much punch (no pun intended) it loses when spelled "right". I guess it's true that Ks are Kool.

falsaberN1··on Discord runs Powershell on load to find Nvidia binaries
I agree a million times. Specially because if you aren't seeing things happen live or semi-live (couple days of delay) there's a huge risk the entire thing will be gone when you go check it out (or have it flooded with memes, drama and general nonsense making it a headache to parse the relevant bits).

Twitter is just really bad for persistent information. In a perfect world we'd have articles filtering the massive noise-to-data ratio and serving as a persistent archive of whatever happened in there.

falsaberN1··on Japan's Leader, Fumio Kishida, Will Step Down
Doesn't sound like something exclusive to Japan. Sounds like you are describing my country and it's nowhere near Asia.
falsaberN1··on The Well-Off People Who Can't Spend Money
I am immune to marketing, and I'm not letting the marketing guys figure out my brain so they can increase their stranglehold over society! I'll take my secrets to the cremation oven!
falsaberN1··on 52,000-year-old woolly mammoth chromosomes reconstructed from 'jerky-like' skin
Gotta reproduce that mammoth jerky somehow.
falsaberN1··on Another AI company wrote us and here’s our response
I'm both an artist and a programmer, and indeed my opinions about them are very different. I work as sysadmin so both are activities are detached from my earnings, as a disclaimer. The artist opinion is a lot more abstract and feeling-based, while the programmer opinion is more pragmatic. Also note that I condemn anyone using AI for "evil". Anyone using it to deceive or harm is despicable and just makes things difficult for everyone.

---

As an artist I see stuff like Stable Diffusion to be very interesting, a fun toy or a potential tool to unclog your brain when needing ideas, and much faster than something like pinterest, specially with niche topics. Its ability to randomly combine concepts can be an starting point for inspiration as well.

I usually like to draw robots, which aren't a common thing in popular media anymore (at least not in the aesthetic I favor, think Armored Core) so having the AI generate a bunch of random robot slop is a good way to get my brain "in the zone", maybe stuff like "oh that pose is cool" or "I can try something with this type of joint". Or even "wow this is a hot mess but the way it placed that odd shape in the arm gives me an idea for a weapon" and let my brain juices flow and do the rest. If nothing else it can help you discard things that don't work.

However, I wouldn't let it replace my work, because the process of designing and drawing is what's fun to me. My favorite subject also requires a degree of consistency the poor thing just can't pull off even with assistance, specially when animating said robots with all the moving parts and stuff that splits and folds, so I'm on my own anyway.

Double however, the idealist in me also believes that anyone that can produce a fine piece, by whatever means, by putting effort and finesse with a tool IS an artist. I have seen some people intentionally working with the tools to do stuff and the results can be impressive. This however disqualifies most AI art you might be familiar with, because most stuff spammed in the internet is stuff that anyone (on the know) can tell is just default settings slop, done in batches with no soul, or even intent to deceive. The process I'm talking about involves multiple hand-made edits, knowing the quirks of the system and knowing what to do. I've seen it used, for example, by TTRPG nerds (not an insult) to generate images tailored for a scene in campaigns. Those people have imagination and a sense of aesthetics but no art skills, and the way they put together a full scene by editing, making multiple passes, repainting areas until it looks right, training the characters involved... is something I can respect because it's coming from a place of passion and is sincere.

I guess intent matters. Some people are just trying to do fun stuff, others are trying to scam you and putting out basic slop while asking you to subscribe to their Patreons like if they were real artists, or making deepfakes. I'll always side with the former out of principle, even if they are a minority overshadowed by the shenanigans of the later.

---

Now, as a programmer I see Copilot with utter disdain. I know for a fact that LLMs are extremely prone to mistakes, inconsistent, unreliable. Code is something that can easily have hidden gotchas that only an expert can notice. The consequences of people who have no idea what they are doing asking for code from a thing that has no idea what it's doing can have reaching effects that can, in the worst case scenarios, end up having consequences such as severe time, data or money loss. Or even death. I'd even question its use from seasoned programmers, because everyone can have a bad day and overlook a mistake.

falsaberN1··on Anna's Archive Faces Millions in Damages and a Permanent Injunction
The problem with the later is reliability, or rather it's efficient but unreliable. I'd rather overdo my offline storage and figure out some way to script/code my way into searching it in a convenient way.
falsaberN1··on Taking away iPhone made daughter a better person
Heh, the only reason I complain about my phone is because I can't do enough things with it. Or at least not comfortably (and without requiring root, which is easier said than done depending on model). It just annoys me how bad the UX is compared to a proper computer with a keyboard and window management. I was once hospitalized and unable to move, with only my phone to pass time, and the experience was SO frustrating!

I don't use my phone a lot, all I got for entertainment is Retroarch, Lichess and a generic sudoku app I got from F-Droid, so obviously my opinion is highly subjective, but it feels like having a supercomputer that can only run MSDOS. One thing at a time in fullscreen with maybe a few passive resident processes. I know some phones let you split things in two or so, but not all of them and the implementation is never flawless or limits what apps can be split.

If you mean hating the phone as a social thing, I am a bit self-conscious about being seen using it too much or taking it out in front of someone unless warranted. I wouldn't do stuff like crossing the street or driving with my eyes glued to it. But that's a people problem and not a phone problem, I think.

falsaberN1··on Biodiversity enhances immune regulation among daycare children (2020)
Yeah I don't think allergies depend on external factors that much. My mother and I have pretty equivalent childhoods even down to same locations and she's wrecked with allergies and I have none, yet my health is worse overall (despite me having a healthier lifestyle).

While I believe some exposure helps build resistance ultimately your overall health will be influenced by stuff beyond your control AND your lifestyle/activities combined.

falsaberN1··on Biodiversity enhances immune regulation among daycare children (2020)
What? Shoes in the house is a bad thing? Isn't it worse to go with no shoes because you are adding sweat and maybe fungi to the mix?

I always lived in very clean houses and no one of us ever went barefoot. (We did change shoes for slippers or equivalent rather quickly though).

falsaberN1··on GNU Nano 8 comes with modern key bindings
mcedit is the closest one in general look and feel. It's installed together with Midnight Commander. Of course it can be used as an independent editor.

EDIT:Sibling post proved me wrong, Tilde also exists. How interesting.

falsaberN1··on GNU Nano 8 comes with modern key bindings
I wouldn't complain for sure. I always loved edit.com and have such fond memories of it.

I used mcedit as terminal text editor for a while, but it was never installed anywhere but at home, so ended up defaulting to vi and nano for consistency. If nano became a bit more like edit.com that'd mean it'd be almost everywhere by default once versions catch up...one can dream.

falsaberN1··on GNU Nano 8 comes with modern key bindings
Welp, this is big enough to make Nano my default editor. While it'll take a while to become "ubiquitous" (as in version 8.0+) it's trivial enough to build for any systems I manage.

The new mousewheel behavior is particularly nice. It's totally up to my taste with --modernbindings and --mouse.

falsaberN1··on Apple apologizes for iPad 'Crush' ad that 'missed the mark'
I always understood the whole point of political correctness was to not spew hateful words about anyone and that should be the standard.

Criticism is one thing, but the poster felt the need to "educate" all of us about how an entire country's opinion is invalid because "it's not an utopia". Nobody brought that up, and disregarding an entire culture's opinion of an advertisement campaign because weebs have unrealistic expectations, in a discussion with a valid and informative point about said culture, is tastelessly petty. And why belittle liberal arts majors anyway?

falsaberN1··on Apple apologizes for iPad 'Crush' ad that 'missed the mark'
I'm honestly shocked. This is not okay, specially when the parent post is not even praising that country in any exaggerated way, just stating a fact.

There are no acceptable targets when it comes to culture.

falsaberN1··on Insects and other animals have consciousness
Yes, because there's no option to negotiate, placate or convince the mosquito to leave. The bites can cause allergic reactions, and even just a nasty itchy bite lasts a quarter of their lifetime. I get nasty reactions when they bite my hands that last for longer than the mosquito lives as an adult!

And it can be even worse, in some areas of the world a mosquito bite can indirectly kill you. I think it's pretty much the only situation where it's justified. Unless we can invent a better solution at least.

falsaberN1··on Are Japanese anime robots isometric or allometric?
And then the production models show up.
falsaberN1··on Are Japanese anime robots isometric or allometric?
My favorite mecha film is Ratatouille.
falsaberN1··on Are Japanese anime robots isometric or allometric?
Or Boss Borot vs Anti-Spiral.
falsaberN1··on Are Japanese anime robots isometric or allometric?
I watched Shinkalion purely out of desperation and was pleasantly surprised despite being a show for kids and having "terrible graphics".

And yeah there's not much mainstream, but you always get some Mazinger spinoff, some Gundam and other "minor" stuff. The genre is definitely not popular but it's alive.

Super Robot Taisen is also still ongoing, and while it's not a show (although it's been adapted a few times) it's a good way to find stuff that might have escaped your radar. And the originals can help quench the thirst for new cool robots with flashy moves. Lately they have been adding "never animated" stuff like Mazinger ZERO, GaoGaiGar Vs. Betterman and Getter Devolution which is nice too.

falsaberN1··on Insects and other animals have consciousness
I'm still not going to feel bad when squashing mosquitos.

Spiders are friends though. And bugs like moths just get evicted if they are a nuisance. I feel bad about killing those.

But screw mosquitos. Well I guess I could let the males live, but I have no way to know.

falsaberN1··on Google ordered to identify who watched certain YouTube videos
Huh. I guess it's obvious I don't use TikTok (I'm past 30, I have no business going there) but I had no idea it had actual political content.
falsaberN1··on Google ordered to identify who watched certain YouTube videos
TikTok has a narrative? I thought it was all about cooking recipes that may or may not destroy you if you make them as instructed.
falsaberN1··on What does Alan Kay think about LLMs?
Try looking at things from my angle: A few errors in an image can be not much of a big deal (with modern tools, the mistakes are within human margin of error on average), but errors in delivery of textual data such as facts, dates or code can be far more severe and subtle. There are ways to work around or reduce the shortcomings of image generation, and the quirks you mention have drop-in solutions for local installs, but you can't quite fix wrong facts in text automatically, or the context going off-rails. It can be much harder to catch than a hand missing a finger, too.

It's also worth mentioning you can run a heavily customized Stable Diffusion setup at home with fairly modest hardware with satisfactory results if you know what you are doing, but anything you can run at home for LLMs in the same hardware is dog slow and actually kind of terrible.

falsaberN1··on What does Alan Kay think about LLMs?
Transparency won't help a lot from a technical standpoint (seems more like a solution to a legal issue than a technical one). I can't trust LLMs because they just...recombine text by probabilities and aren't deterministic. I get incorrect information every time I ask them a thing, and it's incorrect in different ways every time. The only things they seem to get consistently correct are very widespread facts that are much faster and trivial to google.

I still find it funny we managed to get image generation working so much better than text.

falsaberN1··on How big is YouTube?
Funny, for me it's the opposite, I hardly ever set foot outside of my subcriptions page except for searching, which is how I find new channels to add to subs.
falsaberN1··on Open source rules engine for Magic: The Gathering
Not quite, there was another developer that quietly made a lot of work in the time he was around, after Grimm just vanished shortly after those posts, and basically left the entire thing in an usable state for later. Unfortunately he left after a series of personal tragedies that rendered him unable to function for a while.

That guy never gets any credit which is rather sad. I really don't know how he still has a will to live after all that has happened to him.

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →