HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

fanzhang

944 karma · joined October 10, 2006

submissionscomments
fanzhang··on Advanced Placement – Because We Don't Trust Teachers
It's worth noting that the author here seems to be a teacher.

One design feature of AP classes is to indeed remove some discretion from teachers. This is a drawback when you have amazing teachers, and a godsend if you have bad or just plain lazy teachers. This is the same pattern as checks-and-balances vs dictators.

Since APs are a control mechanism for teachers then, I would take the article's opinion of APs with a grain of salt. A much more neutral party would be that of a student: a bad test causes pain similar to a bad teacher.

The good news about the student point of view is that most people here can draw from personal experience -- real data.

He cites an AP Calc teacher who was really stellar but got punished by not covering enough material by the time of the AP test.

In your experience, what fraction reflects that AP Calc example above (where discretion is used well at the detriment of the test), and what fraction reflect teachers using discretion badly (and getting caught by the test)? For me the ratio is like 1:3 if not 1:5.

I am open to the idea that there may be good ways to give teachers more discretion in positive ways, but I think it really needs to be acknowledged that APs exist in the first place to solve a problem, a problem that can't just be waved away without convincing data that show an alternative system performs better.

fanzhang··on How the rise of finance has warped our values
Imprecise thinking abound. The author starts with talking about the problem of big banks (fair enough) and then descends into longing for a command economy [1].

The author laments borrowing money to pay dividends, but the two are net-zero activities (investors are just shuffling their investment from stocks to bonds).

The author finally argues that real investment has fallen since the mid-century. This is not true in a real dollar sense [2]. As a share of GDP though, investment has fallen from the 1950s because we are no longer rushing to build up capital destroyed in WWII. As noted by Paul Graham [3] and more technically by economist Robert Solow [4], it was the decades surrounding WWII that was the exception and not the rule.

Finally, the finance sector has already been retreating as of circa 2005 [5]. The predicate of the article may then no longer be true. If it is, would the author agree we're seeing less issues and more social justice now than in 2005?

There are many precise, carefully thought-out treatments of inequality or the problems of financialization out there. I count Philippon's and Piketty's research among them. But this article seems to move in fuzzy concept space between "finance has gone up" and "we don't have a caring command economy".

I wish the author spelled out his thinking more clearly. It sounds like it would be an interesting argument if made well.

[1] "The state becomes submerged and hidden from our everyday lives, working through elaborate and blunted market mechanisms rather than helping citizens directly."

[2] https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/GPDIC96

[3] http://paulgraham.com/ineq.html

[4] https://newrepublic.com/article/117429/capital-twenty-first-...

[5] Figure 5 of http://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~tphilipp/papers/Finance_Efficien... Incidentially, Philippon's graph is used by the Wikipedia article on "financialization" but cut off at the 2005 peak to make it look like an unrestrained explosion upwards.

fanzhang··on The Heart of Deterrence (2012)
Let's put aside the likelihood of a exterminating strike (where the enemy achieves near-total destruction before you can even think about launching).

Now suppose you do also decide to retaliate to ensure 99% destruction to your foe. Would your foe's knowledge of that change whether your foe even tries an eliminating strike in the first place?

fanzhang··on A New Breed of Trader on Wall Street: Coders with a Ph.D
Here's an interesting question, even though I myself don't know the societal welfare impacts of trading.

Suppose for a moment the value traders create is real. Like the trader making $X a year also creates $X of value (like a farmer that works hard/smart to plant 10 times the number of potatoes as his neighbor). How would that make you feel? Would we accept that that was even possible?

fanzhang··on Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S.
Is that actually true? If Congress approves X by 51% but the president opposes X, then the default stays. In this case defaults have real meaning.

There must be other system asymmetries as well: filibusters, what else?

fanzhang··on Ask HN: Leaving as founder, what happens with equity?
It will be legally hard for them to "reset the entire equity metrics" if they're using similar ideas and codebase to your company. But if they work on a separate idea not related to the old company, this seems much more possible as then it's the same as them quitting, and then deciding to do another startup.

Another issue you need to think about is how much actual drag you'll cause by holding onto your shares. You should give up half your equity if this doubles their chance of succeeding. This seems more likely if you own a large vested chunk like 30% and less likely if you have just vested 10%.

Morally, you've put in a certain amount of work already, and it's not like everyone forgot about vesting. The vesting schedule is supposed to be designed anticipating that if someone leaves before vesting is over, the vested amount is kept by the leaver. It seems to make vesting pointless if you know for sure beforehand you'll renegotiate a substantially different amount.

fanzhang··on A Way to Detect Bias
The test pg suggests was also proposed by the economist Gary Becker [1]. Like many people here noticed, the catch is that the test only works if you compare marginal performance and not average performance. Economists call this the inframarginality problem [2]. There are a number of solutions to this problem to restore pg's result:

- As pg himself says, if we assume certain statistical distributions of ability and selection rules, the inframarginality problem goes away.

- We'd also solve the inframarginality problem if we can tell roughly who the marginal applicants were. If pg could ask the VC firm, see who almost got rejected, and compare these two groups, he'd be set. pg is well-positioned to test this on the YC dataset.

Likewise, he could solve this problem if he can observe another variable that reveals who the marginal applicants likely were (for example, the startups that had the fewest co-investors).

- There's also an entire literature out there that tries to solve the problem using other ways. For example if a system follows the "KPT" sufficient conditions then the inframarginality problem also goes away.

[1] One prominent approach ... is the “outcome test,” which originated in Gary S. Becker (1957). In the context of motor vehicle searches, the outcome test is based on the following intuitive notion: if troopers are profiling minority motorists due to racial prejudice, they will search minorities even when the returns from searching them, i.e., the probabilities of successful searches against minorities, are smaller than those from searching whites. More precisely, if racial prejudice is the reason for racial profiling, then the success rate against the marginal minority motorist (i.e., the last minority motorist deemed suspicious enough to be searched) will be lower than the success rate against the marginal white motorist. (From [3])

[2] "While this idea has been well understood, it is problematic in empirical applications because researchers will never be able to directly observe search success rates against marginal motorists. This is due to the fact that we cannot identify the marginal motorist, since accomplishing this would require having complete information on all of the variables that troopers use in determining the suspicion level of motorists. Because of this omitted-variables problem, we can observe only the average success rate of searches against white and minority motorists, and not the marginal success rate. Since the equality of marginal search success rates does not imply, and is not implied by, the equality of the average search success rates, we cannot determine the relationship between the marginal search success rates of white and minority motorists by looking at average success rates. In past literature, this has been referred to as the “infra-marginality” problem. (From [3]).

[3] Anwar, Shamena, and Hanming Fang, "An Alternative Test of Racial Prejudice in Motor Vehicle Searches: Theory and Evidence." American Economic Review. (2006)

http://economics.sas.upenn.edu/~hfang/publication/racial-pro...

← PreviousPage 7 of 7