HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

farmaway

37 karma · joined December 30, 2022

submissionscomments
farmaway··on The World’s Farms Are Hooked on Phosphorus
Relevant HN discussion from last month:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34182343

When it comes to recapturing phosphates from waste streams, Milwaukee provides an example to follow:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milorganite

farmaway··on Supreme Court allows Reddit mods to anonymously defend Section 230
If you care about the guidelines, enforce them consistently. This is the comment which spurred me to start posting yesterday:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34480065

>Whatever your politics: The reactionary conservative movement, with its campaign to politicize everything (now working on the FBI and Department of Justice, for example), has permanently degraded the country; we won't have these institutions back for generations.

It's such clear flamebait and "ideological battle"-ish that your reply to me, upthread from the above which sits there unflagged, feels like a slap in the face. In all likelihood I'd have gone on with my day if I hadn't stumbled on such a ridiculous, inflammatory, un-moderated comment.

Incidentally, even my very clearly rule-following comments on this link appear flagged:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34484182

I'm used to old high-karma accounts with clear biases abusing user flags and community moderation features. It's much more frustrating to see arbitrary, inconsistent enforcement from actual moderators.

farmaway··on Supreme Court allows Reddit mods to anonymously defend Section 230
>That was started during Trump's administration, just so you're aware. All of the dates in your own source document are in 2020, when Trump was still president.

The whole argument of "reactionary conservatives" is that these agencies operate according to their own agenda, regardless of who sits in the Oval Office. According to this argument, if the President's agenda aligns with that of career civil servants, they cooperate. If not, rogue civil servants a.k.a. the "Deep State" will make their own decisions, take their own actions, and define their own administrative policies under the concealment of secrecy laws and White House inattention. It doesn't help when the New York Times publishes op-eds like this one, while at the same time browbeating those who believe in the Deep State "conspiracy theory:"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Am_Part_of_the_Resistance_In...

I don't fully buy into the Deep State argument. That said, at least a few non-political employees at FBI, CIA, etc. have been caught expressing strong partisan sentiment in their official capacity. In my personal judgement and experience, college-educated upper middle-class Americans (i.e. agency employees in leadership roles) tend to be more susceptible to the sort of media bubble that might compel one to break the law, lie to the public, risk institutional trust, and so on if that's what it takes to "save democracy." Whether democracy is/was actually at risk, or whether the scale of the risk justified burning the FBI, CIA, IRS, DOJ, etc.'s institutional credibility, is another matter.

farmaway··on Supreme Court allows Reddit mods to anonymously defend Section 230
>Then your recall is terrible. Do you remember a certain presidential candidate that got publicly declared 'under investigation' days before the election in 2016? It arguably turned the election in favor of the Republican.

The man who specifically chose to announce that investigation, former FBI Director James Comey, was appointed by President Obama and fired by President Trump. He also (quite rightly in my opinion) pushed back against Trump's attempts to exert undue influence on the Justice Department. He testified against Trump before Congress. Calling Comey a conservative partisan strains belief.

Had Comey chosen to delay his announcement, it would've made the list in my comment above. As I understand it based on his public statements, that's exactly why he chose to go public rather than keep silent. He was caught between a rock and a hard place. I'm glad he opted for disclosure over concealment.

farmaway··on Supreme Court allows Reddit mods to anonymously defend Section 230
If it's an essential liberty then it should be available to all who file Supreme Court briefs, not just a privileged few.
farmaway··on Supreme Court allows Reddit mods to anonymously defend Section 230
Here's the relevance: when a privileged few extracts special concessions from the United States Supreme Court, the public deserves to know who they are and what they've been up to.

I've posted verified facts along with relevant circumstantial evidence. It's telling that your reflex is to make threats and reach for the banhammer.

farmaway··on Supreme Court allows Reddit mods to anonymously defend Section 230
>sorry no... We do not strip essential liberty simply because there are bad actors out there who abuse it.

That's not at stake. What's at stake is the power of a privileged few to get special concessions from the United States Supreme Court.

farmaway··on Supreme Court allows Reddit mods to anonymously defend Section 230
There's a lot more evidence than covered in the linked article. I find it absolutely convincing. Here's a recap of most of it:

https://old.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/hnfx0r/not_conf...

farmaway··on Supreme Court allows Reddit mods to anonymously defend Section 230
And you're ignoring relevant facts and replying with copypasta. If you have an argument to make based on the facts, don't gesture at where the argument might be, just make it.
farmaway··on Supreme Court allows Reddit mods to anonymously defend Section 230
This is your reminder that past Reddit powermods and hired staff allegedly include Ghislane Maxwell [0] (who Ellen Pao knew and socialized with in Pao's time as Reddit CEO [1]), alleged rape and kidnapping accomplice Aimee Challenor [2] (criticism of whose hiring Reddit censored for days before relenting), and convicted domestic abuser creeps like u/bardfinn who abuse their moderator powers and allegedly flood competing subreddits with CSAM material [3]. These people do not deserve anonymity, nor an assumption of good faith.

[0] https://www.the-sun.com/news/4460492/ghislaine-maxwell-reddi...

[1] https://nypost.com/2020/07/08/ex-reddit-ceo-ellen-pao-knew-g...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aimee_Challenor

[3] https://grahamlinehan.substack.com/p/theres-another-abusive-...

farmaway··on Pressures that have always existed for vertical farms have come to a head
You are correct:

>4. Sabatier reactor

>Inside this machine, a blast of roughly 750°F heat breaks the bonds inside CO₂, forcing it into its constituent elements. The carbon and oxygen combine with hydrogen from the station’s ­oxygen ­generating system to make H₂O and methane (CH₄), the latter of which vents into space.

https://www.popsci.com/how-iss-recycles-air-and-water/

farmaway··on Pressures that have always existed for vertical farms have come to a head
Thanks for sharing! Checking out the links from your profile, cool stuff. Relevant to where I live, far inland from fresh seafood and in a similar climate zone. With YouTube's auto-translation I can even understand much of what is said in Swedish in the Johannas farm videos. Impressive operation.

One question about this video— at 1:46 the speaker says, "fish provide all the nutrients [for] our vegetables, which means we don't have to add anything artificial." Is this accurate? My impression was that aquaponics mitigates, but does not completely eliminate, the need for industrial fertilizers/nutrient solution additives:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oGmJETrqzN4&t=1m46s

Another question— with aquaponics, how do you incorporate food waste into the circularity? Do you feed it to the fish, extract nutrients via an external physical/chemical process, or just dump it in the water and let it decompose? I've heard the latter approach described as "fermented plant juice", and its apparent simplicity is certainly appealing:

https://www.ctahr.hawaii.edu/oc/freepubs/pdf/sa-7.pdf

farmaway··on Pressures that have always existed for vertical farms have come to a head
On spectrum optimization: how much of the Sun's emissions spectrum is actually used by plants for photosynthesis? Are there efficiency gains to be realized by converting non-"bioavailable" solar radiation first into electric power, and then into LED output plants can use for photosynthesis? Quick Googling suggests "maybe, probably not", but it's been years since I took an EM physics course.

I realize PV panels are less than 100% efficient at solar to electric energy conversion. Wikipedia suggests 30% is a realistic figure for large-scale solar installations. Batteries also add losses, so let's assume LEDs only run while the sun shines. LEDs themselves add losses too, so our inefficiencies seem to be piling up... All the same, I'd love to see someone run the experiment of (yield per care of traditional farming) / (yield per acre of solar panels + vertical hydroponics).

farmaway··on Pressures that have always existed for vertical farms have come to a head
Yes, but if they're all dumped in the ocean, burned off as fuel, or buried in landfill then they aren't very useful to humans.
farmaway··on Pressures that have always existed for vertical farms have come to a head
>Fortunately, there will not be Moon or Mars colonists, or colonies.

Even if this pessimistic prediction comes true, the same nutrient-recycling solution could support human life in resource-poor regions on Earth, such as Antarctica or Detroit!

farmaway··on Pressures that have always existed for vertical farms have come to a head
Yes, they do. Modern industrial farming relies on the exact same fossil fertilizer inputs. When it comes to recycling phosphate etc., the rival to hydroponics and conventional farming is regenerative soil-based agriculture. The latter relies on composting and manuring to turn organic waste back into nutrient-rich soil. Among other functions, microbes in the soil and compost heaps break waste products like urea down into bioavailable forms like ammonium. Hydroponics generally doesn't involve composting and is by definition soil-free, so the plant's rhizosphere is more or less sterile:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhizosphere

To farm plants without soil, they must be supplied with a water-based nutrient solution. The solution contains a precise mixture of all chemical substances a particular plant needs to grow. Yield efficiencies can be realized by carefully tailoring this mixture to each plant. The problem is where to source the ingredients once extracting them from mineral deposits turns uneconomical.

Compost- and manure-amended soil theoretically has everything plants need, but that's not very useful for soil-free farming. The precise ratio of nutrients in a given patch of soil is also outside of the farmer's control. Perhaps the individual nutrients can be leached, distilled, or otherwise chemically separated from compost and biological waste products to enable their reuse in finely-mixed solutions? I don't know. Maybe someone with more knowledge can answer.

farmaway··on Pressures that have always existed for vertical farms have come to a head
Didn't know peak phosphate was nearly upon us! On the bright side, technologies to recover phosphate via industrial-scale composting are already mature. My home state of Wisconsin leads the way on this, at least in the United States:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milorganite

>Milorganite is a brand of biosolids fertilizer produced by treating sewage sludge by the Milwaukee Metropolitan Sewerage District. The term is a portmanteau of the term Milwaukee Organic Nitrogen. The sewer system of the District collects municipal wastewater from the Milwaukee metropolitan area. After settling, wastewater is treated with microbes to break down organic matter at the Jones Island sewage treatment plant (also called "Water Reclamation Facility") in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

>The byproduct sewage sludge is produced. This is heat-dried with hot air in the range of 900–1,200 °F (482–649 °C), which heats the sewage sludge to at least 176 °F (80 °C) to kill pathogens. The material is then pelletized and marketed throughout the United States under the name Milorganite. The result is recycling of the nitrogen and phosphorus from the waste-stream as fertilizer.

>The Milwaukee Metropolitan Sewerage District's Jones Island Plant had the largest wastewater treatment capacity of any in the world when constructed in 1925. It was the first plant in the United States to succeed in using the activated sludge treatment process to produce fertilizer.

Potassium is excreted by humans mainly in urine, which is easy to recover. But NPK fertilizer is just one piece of the puzzle. AFAIK, plants require 17 essential micro- and macro-nutrients to grow [0]. I'm just a lay gardener, not a chemist nor research scientist, so I'm not sure how to approach recovering calcium, magnesium, sulfur, or metals like zinc and molybdenum for nutrient solution manufacture. That's the nice thing about composting for soil-based gardening; so long as the right microbes are there to make it bioavailable, all the elements you need are in the used-up biomatter. If it was eaten and not exhaled, sweated out, nor incorporated into the body, it'll be there in the waste stream.

[0] https://www.researchgate.net/figure/There-are-17-essential-p...

farmaway··on Pressures that have always existed for vertical farms have come to a head
Another problem with hydroponics is its reliance on industrially-produced fertilizers, chiefly those containing nitrogen, phosphate, and potassium. The phosphate and potassium parts of this equation are today mined from finite mineral deposits. Sooner or later these mines will close, and we'll have to close to the loop on phosphate and potassium (and molybdenum, calcium, etc.) production and consumption.

How will hydroponic farmers adapt? Where will they economically obtain the necessary nutrient solution additives? Are there practical techniques to extract these nutrients from traditional sources, like urine or manure? The aspiring Mars colonist or hydroponic homesteader will need to figure this out, or return to traditional "regenerative" farming practices which compost biological waste and return all used-up nutrients and their constituent elements to the soil.

And for someone like a Moon or Mars colonist, even regenerative farming isn't simple. Composting relies on bacteria to convert waste products like nitrogen-containing urea, whose nitrogen isn't bioavailable to plants, back into useful and bioavailable forms like ammonium. Keeping cultures of bacteria alive and healthy indefinitely will be essential to a colony's continued survival. Are there practical chemical processes to replace the function of these microbes, e.g. to convert urea to ammonia without urease enzymes? I don't know. Maybe someone with more knowledge can comment on this.

I hope this problem can be solved. Hydroponics has many benefits, from dramatically lowered water consumption vs. soil-based agriculture, to higher yields driven by precisely-managed nutrient ratios. Spacefaring farmers will appreciate the weight saved by leaving all that excess water and soil on Earth. It'd be a shame to abandon this technology simply because we couldn't pivot away from fossil fertilizers.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2