HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

fastneutron

455 karma · joined May 10, 2020

Principal R&D engineer - Deeptech, nuclear energy, scientific computing, quantum technologies, artificial intelligence.

fastneutron235 -at- gmail -dot- com

submissionscomments
fastneutron··on Quantinuum H-Series quantum computer
In their present state, yes. These things are basically sophisticated physics experiments with a cloud API. This is fine for research, education and training, but currently insufficient for problems of economic value.
fastneutron··on Quantinuum H-Series quantum computer
A qubit is any addressable 2-level quantum system. Think spins, oscillation modes, energy levels, polarization, etc. All of these have been implemented and demonstrated to varying degrees, with superconductors and trapped ions (this article) being the farthest along.

Noise is indeed a problem, and right now these systems can’t execute more than a few hundred operations at most before decohering to the point of randomness. There is an error rate threshold (~1e-3 - 1e-4) at which error correction becomes possible, and the field has been hovering around that threshold for the past 3 years or so. I think we’ll know within the next 5 years whether or not it’s possible to engineer these error correction schemes in a scalable way.

fastneutron··on Quantinuum H-Series quantum computer
Anything involving simulation of quantum mechanical systems. Think materials, molecules, nuclei, general field theories, etc.

The fixation on asymmetric encryption vulnerability is overblown at this point. The near-completion of the post-quantum cryptographic standards and the still long road to fault tolerance make this essentially a non-issue to anyone that hasn’t been living under a rock for the past 20 years.

fastneutron··on Olivine Weathering Can Reverse Global Warming in Our Lifetime
Un-burning all the fossil fuels we’ve burned obviously requires a level of industrial infrastructure on par with what it took to get to this point in the first place. The olivine method seems to be the most effective from the standpoint of thermodynamics and technological complexity, but one wonders what the side effects of dumping trillions of tons of olivine dust into the ocean in a relatively short period of time would be.
fastneutron··on Seven Rules for Internet CEOs to Avoid Enshittification
Revenue-Motivated Quality Degradation (RMQD) doesn’t quite have the same ring to it.
fastneutron··on Welcome to Fusion City, USA
The NRC does not plan to regulate fusion power the same way it does fission power [1]. Rather, it’s handled under the same framework as particle accelerators, which in many cases, falls under the jurisdiction of state health and environmental regulations. My partner was a state regulator involved in the rule making process for this, and the rules are intended to be far less restrictive than what fission requires.

Regulatory requirements are the least of fusion’s problems, compared to the technological challenges of actually working reliably in the first place, let alone with the high uptime that fission power enjoys.

1. https://www.nrc.gov/cdn/doc-collection-news/2023/23-029.pdf

fastneutron··on Why is ChatGPT becoming more stupid?
I haven’t noticed much degradation, and I ask it fairly technical questions related to code and physics topics. What I have noticed though is needing to qualify my statements more, to avoid having it go down the wrong chain of conversation and getting stuck in a suboptimal context. By this I mean having to say things like “I have installed <package XYZ> per the documentation and am familiar with the API” or “assume the reader is already familiar with <foundational topic>, do not simply your explanations.” Otherwise I get stuck in a situation where it talks to me like a kindergartener or spends 3-4 additional rounds of querying just getting through the basic boilerplate. Maybe this was always the case, and posts like these are just subconsciously influencing me.

Plugins like AskYourPDF and Wolfram have been a huge boost though. I can feed it whole textbook chapters and have it summarize sections, solve problems, generate new exercises, and generally help with learning in ways previously unavailable.

fastneutron··on Ask HN: What are some of the most elegant codebases in your favorite language?
Shewchuk’s Triangle code for Delaunay mesh generation is some of the most elegant C-code I’ve ever seen [1]. It even won the SIAM Wilkinson Prize for numerical software at the time it was written. It’s written in a literate style, and builds up from the most fundamental arithmetic operations and data structures, all the way to one of the most efficient mesh generators of its kind. He has a few other codebases written in a similar style [2, 3]. It’s very different from what you see in the wild, but it’s been great for understanding what’s happening under the hood for complex algorithms like mesh generation.

1. https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~quake/triangle.html

2. https://github.com/ctlee/Stellar

3. https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~quake/robust.html

fastneutron··on Atomic Tourism
For a time, Argonne National Laboratory was raffling off lucite-encased blocks of CP-1 graphite at conferences. They probably have a stockroom somewhere of the stuff to give to VIPs, etc.
fastneutron··on Random Number Generator Recommendations for Applications
All this, and the nuclear business is still using variants of LCGs from 60 years ago [1] for Monte Carlo simulations.

In this case, their speed, repeatability and “good enough” statistical properties haven’t motivated much to change.

1. https://www.osti.gov/biblio/976209

fastneutron··on The metaverse was never alive in the first place
And this right here was one of the biggest problems. Unless you had read Snow Crash, most people would automatically assume that Metaverse was a Facebook product, and disengage for that reason alone. Actually, even those who had read Snow Crash disengaged for that reason alone (guilty as charged). At the time of the announcement, we were still emerging from Covid and the post-2020 election circus. Who in their right mind would want the Qanon flamewar experience that Facebook was providing at that time, but in full VR?
fastneutron··on The metaverse was never alive in the first place
It seemed like the only people who could remotely have been considered excited about the concept was a very particular slice of the tech media echo chamber.

The Snow Crash Metaverse was kind of fun to think about. The Mark Zuckerberg Metaverse was DOA given the trashed reputation Facebook had by the time the pivot was announced.

fastneutron··on Young adults in the U.S. are reaching key life milestones later than in the past
It was extremely stressful at the time, but we made the strategic decision to have kids young while we have the energy. I can’t imagine being 10 years older and being able to keep up with everything.
fastneutron··on Young adults in the U.S. are reaching key life milestones later than in the past
I moved out of my parents’ at 18, finished undergrad and started my PhD at 21, married and had my first child towards the end of grad school at 26, and currently have 3 kids. Total household income is about $325k in a MCOL area.

We became homeowners in 2019 during a narrow window of affordability and available housing inventory in our area. Had we waited, covid and the subsequent inflation and decreased inventory would have kept homeownership out of reach.

fastneutron··on The Quantum State of Affairs
Submission statement: Quantum computing is in the unique position of having received a large amount of private investment relative to its technological maturity. This editorial poses the question of whether government funding will pick up the slack in the event of a “quantum winter.”
fastneutron··on Why is my dryer radioactive?
At the high end, the standard workhorse for really serious hobbyists and rock hunters is the Ludlum Model 3 with a 44-9 pancake probe [1,2]. Throw in a scintillation probe [3] if you really want to find needles in haystacks. There are perennial bidding wars on ebay for these things surplus, but the manufacturer has a very hobbyist-friendly reputation. They've walked me through a few DIY repair jobs on ancient equipment they were under no obligation to support.

1. https://ludlums.com/products/all-products/product/model-3

2. https://ludlums.com/products/all-products/product/model-44-9

3. https://ludlums.com/products/all-products/product/model-44-1...

fastneutron··on Why is my dryer radioactive?
This is similar to a fun trick I used to show people back when CRTs were the predominant television screen. The face of the TV would build up a static charge and collect dust over time. I’d wipe the screen off with a damp paper towel and place it under a alpha/beta/gamma-sensitive Geiger probe. It would hit 500 counts per minute easily(background was about 250).

I knew people who took this to an extreme by putting a high-voltage static charge on a needle, then placing the charged needle in a closed bell jar with a pile of thorium-doped lantern mantles. The tip of the needle would pick up enough radon daughters that it made a great rechargeable point source for cloud chamber demonstrations.

fastneutron··on Ask HN: Quantum Computing Textbook Focus on Physics/Chemistry Side
Not as rigorous at Nielsen and Chuang, but “Quantum Chemistry and Quantum Computing for the Curious” [1] is alright for hands on tinkering. Beyond that, things are still pretty much in the realm of academic literature.

1. https://www.packtpub.com/product/quantum-chemistry-and-compu...

fastneutron··on Walkout at global science journal over ‘unethical’ fees
The fact that a coordinator like a publisher exists isn’t necessarily in dispute. Sometimes it’s necessary to have a 3rd party coordinate reviewers, maintain quality standards, and settle plagiarism disputes. The issue is the price. It’s wholly unreasonable to charge $30 to read a paper, to charge a PI upwards of $2k-$7k to remove the $30 reader charge, or to charge whatever ungodly amount they charge libraries to offer free access to researchers.

Like I said, I’d value the service I get at a factor of 10-20x less than what they charge.

(Edited for formatting)

fastneutron··on Walkout at global science journal over ‘unethical’ fees
The closest analogy I can think of is a highway billboard. Say there’s a really good spot with lots of traffic, and you want drivers to see your ad. The billboard company provides a venue for you to put up the ad, and takes care of the printing and real estate. Other than that, the rest of the process of making that ad poster is up to you, your company and any partners you rely on.

The publisher is like the billboard company in that they provide the venue, maybe with good visibility, handle the printing and hosting, and connect you with unpaid peer reviewers.

The only one making money off of all this is the publisher. The benefit you get is that someone else gets to read your work, and maybe you got a “good billboard spot” to get the most impact.

The extra part of this is that academic researchers are a captive market, similar to users who have only one ISP to choose from like Comcast. You have to publish on That Specific Billboard or you risk career suicide. If you were the billboard owner, you have a strong incentive to charge outrageous prices because you know that your customers rely on you, and have nowhere else to go.

fastneutron··on Simulation Intelligence: Towards a New Generation of Scientific Methods (2022)
It’s certainly true that much of this stuff has been around a while to those familiar, and I didn’t attempt to frame this article as anything beyond a survey in my original statement. The title is what it is. I’m most interested in hearing perspectives from people who are actually using these methods to do real work, and to hear where the cutting edge actually is these days.

That said, a review like this is still significant to people who are starting out in this field or otherwise not previously familiar, and this is the most recent distillation I’ve seen that is written at a level accessible to a broader science and engineering audience.

fastneutron··on Simulation Intelligence: Towards a New Generation of Scientific Methods (2022)
I don’t get, nor appreciate the low-effort dismissal.

In the world of traditional science and engineering that I come from, these kinds of methods are relatively unknown, let alone used to any real benefit. A document like this aggregates and distills the relevant methods, references, and beneficial applications in one place, which is helpful to decision makers and R&D leads who would otherwise not have known where to look or what to look at.

fastneutron··on Simulation Intelligence: Towards a New Generation of Scientific Methods (2022)
The lead author is from a nonprofit called the Institute for Simulation Intelligence: https://simulation.science/

It must be fairly new, since their website is a skeleton compared to this article. I wonder what publication this is ultimately going to wind up in. Either way, this is exactly the kind of stuff I’m trying to integrate at my lab, and I’m glad more people are taking interest in this field!

fastneutron··on Ask HN: Math books that made you significantly better at math?
Another document with the same flavor is “Larry’s Speakeasy: A Handbook for Spoken Mathematics.” Basically a notation-to-English translation guide.

It’s actually listed as a technical report from Lawrence Livermore National Lab, but the only online PDF I can find is here: https://www.academia.edu/28253460/Handbook_for_Spoken_Mathem...

fastneutron··on Simulation Intelligence: Towards a New Generation of Scientific Methods (2022)
From a pragmatic perspective, being able to use AI to accelerate or otherwise enhance computations for science and engineering has a pretty big value proposition. Being able to turn around high fidelity calculations in a fraction of the time would yield much better product designs and scientific results.

On the flip side, like you suggest, the cost of being wrong can much higher than many current uses of AI. This is where research into AI interpretability, robustness, and uncertainty quantification can really help.

fastneutron··on Simulation Intelligence: Towards a New Generation of Scientific Methods (2022)
Submission statement: I came across this article earlier today and it hit home on a lot of things that have been swirling in my head lately on the current direction of scientific computing methods. I work in R&D in this space, and would be curious to hear the perspectives of others on the methods surveyed in this paper.
fastneutron··on FEA Solver that doesn't need defeaturing
Parts of this company were originally spun off of Sandia national lab, so I imagine the staff has at least some familiarity with the importance of V&V. In general, it’s on the engineering users to do their due diligence and develop the right validation cases for their design products. The code developer can get as far as coming up with the mathematical and numerical verification of the code, but the possible end uses are too numerous for it to be feasible for them to develop validation cases for anything beyond some basic industry benchmarks.
fastneutron··on Ask HN: Where to find performance engineering work?
You might look into HPC related roles. That often involves optimizing complex orchestrations of CPU, GPU, network and I/O.
fastneutron··on US Department of Energy: Fusion Ignition Achieved
Activation products are of a different nature than the fission products and minor actinides you get in fission reactors, and are not necessarily as fearsome to handle, nor is the total activity comparable at all to what you get in spent fuel.

However, those high energy neutrons do a ridiculous amount of damage to the structural materials, and if there are constant outages to swap and repair components, I don’t see an easy way of making energy economically.

fastneutron··on Ask HN: Interesting Jobs Outside of Tech
Renewable energy, and agriculture come to mind. This includes established industries, as well as the emerging ones (eg. Ag-tech) come to mind.
← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →