184 karma · joined January 21, 2025
Creator of Vigilance.
vigihq[dot]com phended[dot]com
The first is that yes, you can make it harder for the frontier makers to make progress because they will forever be stuck in a cat and mouse game.
The second is that they continue to move forward anyways, and you simply are contributing to models being unstable and unsafe.
I do not see a path that the frontier makers “call it a day” cause they were defeated.
Positively ridiculous.
1. It’s happening on my machine, in the browser I would use to access my accounts, not a middleman that is given access to my accounts.
2. Scheduling! This is a god send to be able to get a digest of everything I need to know for the day.
Pop open my apps that I would start my day with anyways and summarize all the shit I have going on from yesterday, today, and tomorrow. No risk of prompt injection in my own data. Beauty.
Secondly, the concrete example is not generative UI, it’s just generated data getting put into a schema.
I think the hard part of design is that you must consider the trade off between a new user and a power user. Overwhelm against progressive disclosure. It’s an art form in and of itself.
My point was actually to say, AWS bills are expensive, IF you are using their built for purpose and scale technologies. If you don’t need scale, rent an EC2. The graphs I’m seeing from the billing dashboard clearly show a number of different services. So it’s comparing apples to oranges.
I am still confused by the logic of this entire post because purpose built, scalable, pay per use services, do not equal a simple server.
I’m also not saying he is doing it wrong, I am saying collapsing all those services into a single box could have been done at any point regardless of it being Cloud or not. I don’t actually care about defining cloud. I’m fundamentally challenging the paradigm that the author himself is challenging.
This is simply collapsing the built for scale tools into a cacophony of open source tools.
You didn’t need it to begin with, you just didn’t know any better.
How does one handle that with tact and not lose their minds?
I think I saw a benchmark on HN for formats of text files given to an LLM to see which would give better results. I wish that study had thrown in images to the comparison.
1. Congratulations on getting a product into a major chain’s distribution network. That is a feat and is something to be proud of.
2. Do I think this product should exist? No. There are services that do this already, the only thing different is making it standalone. I fear it’s just another toy that will sit on the shelf and eventually contribute to the e-waste problem.
3. The capitalist in me thinks I would have also done subscriptions and “buy more minutes”, but in practice I don’t think I would have been able to execute on that.
4. Confusing to see a “build your own” in the same breathe. Are you a part of the Mr. Christmas team that built this? Or just contracted to build it based on your experience in hardware?
5. Were you really hooked? Hooked on the technology stack? Or hooked talking to Santa? Do you have kids that you built it for?
Many thoughts rattle around in my head on this one.
I also think it’s important to not get stuck in the sunk cost fallacy to avoid a rewrite. Take your lessons learned and bite the bullet.
I am in a position right now watching 3 years of tech debt get refactored into the same spaghetti garbage because leadership waited too long before calling a rewrite, and now they are under immense pressure to get it done but picked a warm body to rewrite it because everyone else is busy on other important things.
In another life, I was able to see the writing on the walls after initial implementation and spent two weeks rewriting the MVP to then be able to add new scalable features at a much higher velocity.
Needs analysis is crucial here, but I don’t disagree with OP.
I am so shocked at the amount of people that think someone who wants to siphon your livelihood in a parasitic fashion is equivalent to a corporation that you have to conceivably opt into using. Users can make choices in the products they use. This person injected themselves as a man in the middle in user’s lives. Completely different circumstances and not at all the same intention.
Malicious to me is intent. Microsoft does not store my emails to snoop or to potentially steal my assets. It Is a side effect of the systems they have created to ease user friction.
Some might argue that they want my data or behaviour (which is snooping) but exactly what has been said, my subscription fee is the value they extract from me and their enterprise value is the stickiness and the experience they provide.
To be clear, I am not a Microsoft fan, but I think it is safe to assume that Microsoft would not scrape my crypto wallets or bank account information to steal the entirety of my liquid assets. I can’t say the same for actors that plunk in a rogue email address to BCC themselves.
I have no idea how far the crew at Microsoft or any other large tech giant is willing to go into the grey area, but I can tell you they won’t attempt to drain my bank account without providing SOME kind of value to me in return.
They explain in the comment why it was risky (new thing instead of tried and true methods, not a large user base, etc.) and yet you minimized their explanation, over simplified and seem to not understand the risk involved in writing one of the most important pieces of literature in one’s career.
> why? they wont give you a phd if a single pixel is off by one bit in the alpha channel?
They meant pixel perfect as in matching the template to infer the importance of this. Then for some reason you went down the “off by one bit in the alpha channel” which is a bit of wise-assery and not meaningful nor necessary to the conversation.
As I said before, please dig deeper and use your well meaning System 2 to contribute, and not your Reddit-Tainted System 1.
What people miss is since the creation of Splice, basically all new music that isn’t from an already established artist is paint by numbers. You can get any sample in any key that are given to splice by artists. You probably hear a lot of the same sounds in most modern music. This breaks that open.
The Suno team has been doing this exactly right and this is just another step in their evolution.
Major congrats to the product team for this, I can’t wait to see the next iteration!
I am not quite a fan of the “professional software development” elitism in some posts like this because it points to me vs you or highly skilled vs unwilling to learn, which I have found to be not true.
Also to say “attention to detail” while also having grammatical and spelling mistakes in a blog post is kind of poignant.