HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

feralimal

-15 karma · joined May 9, 2020

submissionscomments
feralimal··on Fasting improves chemotherapy results and protects from side effects: study
Thanks for your thoughtful reply.

I don't say that there are no good things coming out of the medical industry. Sometimes there are good things, and when it comes to bodily trauma, I think the medical profession is excellent at stitching people back together again.

But I'm especially interested in wellness and optimal living. I genuinely don't feel the industry has anything to offer on that front. Food is probably the most important 'treatment' we can do, but the industry is pretty silent on this.

My anecdotal experience, is with a relative who was diagnosed with diabetes. It was never explained to them that if they don't eat carbs they won't have the disease - cutting out bread, rice, etc was too 'out there'. The advice was about how to manage the process, cut back a little on the bread, inject insulin etc - the relative ended up on a high level of medication. I think all that could have been avoided by eating appropriately for the disease, advice which that person has taken (a bit) with a corresponding drop in symptoms + medication. To my mind, it is not so radical to cut those foods out of the diet completely if they are harmful!

Its not that doctors intend to be mean or harmful, but they are taught in such a narrow way with medication at the heart of what they do. If they advise 'off menu' they stand to lose their license. The medical industry is in fact captured and beholden to big pharma.

Did you even know that there are alternative theories of disease? Namely - the terrain theory (Beauchamp). That what you eat and how you live is the main cause of disease. That disease (of all sorts) is a natural bodily process, as your body tries to heal - including cancer. Eg, at a lower level, when you have a cold, this is your body clearing your system. There is mucus and a fever. The worst thing to do is to take medication to suppress this process - but that is the first thing most of us will do.

Anyway, for that and other reasons, I find the terrain theory makes a lot of sense, and it is something that does not require an intermediary to tell you what you need to do (eg a doctor, testing, etc). If you get it right you enjoy optimal health. That is the position that I'm arguing from - that food and proper management of what and how we eat (inc breaks such as fasting) is probably the best healer. If I were ever seriously ill, my first course of action would be as per my initial comment - a prolonged juice fast.

Cheers

feralimal··on Tracking users via CSS
Yes, but we all know what it is to go to a public place. We choose that.

When you are on your own home, looking a website, you think you are on your own, reading something, like a book. You do not have a sense of interacting, or of being in a public space. You would have that sense of interacting if you were on an Internet forum, or discord, etc.

A book does not report on you (and I'm talking about paper books not kindles!). But all websites monitor you. This is to say that the user is gamed. They are misled into thinking they are looking at a private thing like a book, whereas the reality is that they are being monitored. It's the biggest anti-pattern. It's absolutely without meaningful consent and it is absolutely baked in to the internet. There is no privacy online.

But, in my perfect world, we should be allowed privacy and be able to go online. Oh well, maybe in the next life!

feralimal··on Fasting improves chemotherapy results and protects from side effects: study
Absolutely. Let's look at the claims.

What is the first claim though? Is it that extraordinary evidence needs to be provided for the claim that a poison (chemotherapy) is a cure for cancer?

You will likely say that there is evidence in "multiple strong, well-vetted and well respected studies in peer-reviewed journals".

But then I would question the authority of peer-reviewed journals. Do know about replication crisis?

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-39054778 : "According to a survey published in the journal Nature last summer, more than 70% of researchers have tried and failed to reproduce another scientist's experiments."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis : "a number of efforts have been made to re-investigate classic results, to determine both the reliability of the results and, if found to be unreliable, the reasons for the failure of replication."

Another reason I dismiss most scientific authority is on account of funding. If funding is controlled by government, the military and private corporations (as it is), then this triad can cooperate to fund or de-fund whatever studies they like.

To see what I mean about funding, we can look at my imagined idea that 'you want to prove the health benefit of cold potatoes'. First you can fund 10 studies. Let's say 2 support the thesis, 2 refute it and 6 are inconclusive. You can then further fund the 2 that support it. And rinse and repeat. Pretty soon you could have enough studies to create a whole new field exclaiming the wonder of cold potatoes.

Unfortunately, this really is how science works. Science is a money making operation, and is politicised. A common sense idea like fasting for cancer, or not eating carbohydrates to get rid of diabetes, has no economic benefit. Scientists themselves can work within the system with good intentions, but can be more or less unaware of the machinations and agendas at play.

If you want to talk about solutions, you would take a totally different tack. At present we have a sickness not a wellness industry. Companies get money from you when you are sick. The more sick you are, the better it is for their monetary return. The ideal patient is someone who will be ill for a long time, which is a perverse incentive. Really, you want a wellness industry, where if you are well, those ensuring your health get paid. As they are incentivised to keep you well, you should expect good advice - their financial well-being depends on it.

feralimal··on Tracking users via CSS
> almost all users won't care, and the rest few won't disclose anything out of suspicion of abusing that data

Yes, I wouldn't disclose.

But because the users don't want to give their data to you, that doesn't mean that it is ethically OK to take it without them realising.

That's the rub with privacy. There needs to be some acceptance and tolerance of an individual's decisions.

Instead though, we have engineered disclosure. In a pure sense its an act of aggression against another.

feralimal··on Fasting improves chemotherapy results and protects from side effects: study
Well, there are lots of types of fasting. Juice or water or nothing. Skipping a meal, or not eating solid foods for 3 months. IMO not eating during the day but then eating a lot at night might not be the best type of fast.

But even so, it would be interesting to see numbers anyway.

feralimal··on Fasting improves chemotherapy results and protects from side effects: study
Yes. But there are alternative healing ideas that fasting and juicing in themselves can cure cancer.
feralimal··on Kindred: Neanderthal Life, Love, Death and Art
"Can't we just assume the standard narrative is correct, and work with that? What harm can it do?"
feralimal··on Fasting improves chemotherapy results and protects from side effects: study
Or perhaps, fasting is the cure, and can even undo the harm from chemo!
feralimal··on Tracking users via CSS
I like this sort of question, albeit it is akin to preparing to re-tune your violin, in order to do some fiddling while Rome is burning, given just how far we have lost all privacy.

In an ideal world, it should be up to the user what they want to disclose. So, perhaps there should be no logging at all. And having loaded a page, the page should work 'offline' with no further interaction with the page or site by default. I mean, that's how simple sites appear to work. That they don't work like how you think they appear to, illustrates how technologists are selling illusions for profit.

feralimal··on Kindred: Neanderthal Life, Love, Death and Art
There's so much that jumps out at me in this article.

It asks - 'Do neanderthals have a spiritual life?'.

Some questions: Do we (in the here and now) have a 'spiritual life'? What does it mean to have a 'spiritual life'? How could we possible know whether Neanderthals had one? How do we even know what Neanderthals were even like? Did they really live for 350,000 years? So much speculation.

The reality is we cannot know anything much beyond our present experience. History cannot really teach us anything. It is a politicised story - his-story - the story written by the victors, whoever they are.

All history is an interpretative act. When we look back at the past, it is all speculation. We are NOT being presented with facts. We find whatever we want to find in ourselves in the present; we use some artefacts (genuine or false ones) as a basis for exploring our current situation.

So, IMO, truth has little to do with it, but it can make for an interesting investigation anyway!

feralimal··on Your Phone Is Your Castle
Yes, but when the Play store can install whatever it wants without your knowledge....
feralimal··on Your Phone Is Your Castle
Thanks.

But, reading the comments on the pine64 forum you posted, it doesn't sound that functional.

Just last month, they are talking about a non-working camera, and that its unreliable at making calls.

It still sounds like the best option to me, is to go for a dumb phone, and leave the more complex stuff for a desktop or laptop.

feralimal··on Your Phone Is Your Castle
I would be open to this. Are the phones any good?

I did buy the red hat tablet a few years ago, but found I didn't use it. Maybe I didn't like the form (a tablet).

feralimal··on A couple of negative points about commenting on HackersNews
Lol. Passive aggressive much?

> I didn't mean you are angry or upset etc, sorry I wasn't clearer.

Say what you think. You think I'm dumb cos I didn't take the point that you repeatedly made. That you think I'm the problem. Be honest! Stop couching.

> I didn't say that you "need to be right".

But, you did! You said: "Try to avoid the "I'm downvoted because I'm right" disease". I have a disease, in your opinion, and its that I'm right.

> You've repeated that you are happy to be corrected, "set straight". It just seems that you thought nothing I said was in the least bit helpful, so I never got to see that!

But I really don't find what you say helpful! Sorry.

If I have an argument or a discussion point, I'm free to state it. At least, I think I should be. I'm happy to engage with a rational argument, and present a case. And if my PoV is found wanting, I'll embrace truth and reality. But your 'answer' is that I internalise an external problem. Delete my comment say, to not make a fuss.

But no, I'm not going to give up on reason or rational thinking, because the majority thinks something other. I'm hear to learn and share knowledge. I'm confident in my line of thought, that its rational. I'm very far from internalising or quashing my rational thinking for the sake of offending the majority, who I happen to think are frequently in error.

And, by the way, the majority really can be in error. It may feel like a comfortable consensus is occurring here on HN. I'm saying that this could be on account of the management of the site - certain uncomfortable realities cannot be discussed. Living in a bubble is fine in a way, but absence of knowledge won't make reality go away. I'm hoping the scientific method may force you (and me) to accept reality, even if we may wish for something else.

feralimal··on Your Phone Is Your Castle
But you don't know what privacy you have or don't have.

And they can install an update to covertly 'track and trace' you. How do you even know that this is what is being done?

Frankly, I think this was already possible to do. If anything I'm slightly mystified as to why this was announced as if they didn't already have the capability.

feralimal··on Your Phone Is Your Castle
No! It's so damn convenient. I wish I'd never got one.

I'm not walking the walk. I've seriously considered the idea for a long time, and it seems bound to happen. The issue for me is the convenience of having a podcast player + camera.

But, sigh, I'm not there yet.

I'll tell you what, I'll try to extract myself again over the next week.

feralimal··on Your Phone Is Your Castle
Yes, the phone is your castle, and the castle is breached.

By design. Whether that's by your phone automatically backing up your data to the cloud, or whether that's because your OS decides to roll out a 'track and trace' update to be used by governmental agencies, or any number of other possibilities.

Privacy cannot be regained by petitioning Google, Apple or the government for the features you think you should have - ie total control, repairability, headphone sockets, etc. You are the product.

When it turns out our own phones are snitches, the answer is to get out. Why stay in a breached castle? And these snitches can't get stitches. The only answer I see it to ditch the phone.

feralimal··on Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destruction, scientists warn
I'm not going to get in to a link war. All I'd ask is: in your personal experience, what have you observed? Are the seas higher than when you were a child? Are you struggling to breathe for all the C02?!? Stripping away the news coverage, what real life effects have you experienced personally?

Unfortunately, I'm not prepared to trust what I think are politicised governance authorities. At least not if they go against or do not cohere with my personal experience.

feralimal··on Why do so many people want us back in the office?
People are social and don't like change.

We are being forced to change and take the 'physical' out of the social.

What's not to like?!?!

feralimal··on Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destruction, scientists warn
I'm saying it is a long running conspiracy. We lost freedoms with the global war on terror, we have lost freedoms since then, we are going to lose more freedoms in the very near future. I can see the direction we are heading. And no, I'm not cheering it on as you seem to be.

> If this was a true conspiracy so far they’ve done a very poor job with it for the past 20 years.

What's poor about their job? I think they have done an excellent job. Most people defer to experts over their own experience. Imagine, one's own experience not carrying any weight with one's own beliefs! So, they have done an excellent job.

feralimal··on A couple of negative points about commenting on HackersNews
I'm not writing in an emotional way - I'm not angry or upset, or need to cool down, or any of the things I think you are mis-ascribing to me.

I'm writing in a way that proposes or advances an argument or a position. It might not be the same position as the majority hold, but it is my considered and explainable one.

I'm absolutely not saying 'I need to be right' - which is criticism you are levelling. I'm having conversations that explore, or trying to. I learn from being wrong, and I'm happy - HAPPY - to be corrected.

All the best.

feralimal··on Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destruction, scientists warn
> we used to call it the greenhouse effect or global warming back then.

And before that we were going to have a mini ice age...

Also, can I say I find it odd when people talk using the pronoun 'we'. The Queen does that when she talks about her country. That's called the royal 'we'.

What global warming effect can you say you've witnessed? I don't think I can say I've noticed a single thing. Nothing. Some warm summers some cold winters - ie weather. As a cyclist it seems the quality of air has improved and I'm noticing more birds. So 20+ years of talk and fear, and there's nothing to see?

I'm at the point where I see that all that fear serves a purpose in its own right. I don't think the rhetoric matches the reality. But putting people in a state of fear that they are also powerless to address does serve a purpose. The purpose is that it supports government. It supports global governance too. Government plays up a problem that only it can solve, and it can only solve that problem by reducing the freedoms of the people it governs. So less freedom of travel, closer monitoring, etc. For me, it's one of the justifications given for what is shaping up to be a technocratic hell. And technologists are unwittingly building the infrastructure.

What I see with Al Gore is, on the one side - a self-serving politician, happy to talk up the importance of governance when he is a member of the governing class, and on the other - a salesman doing a sales job given he is invested in green energies.

feralimal··on A couple of negative points about commenting on HackersNews
thanks
feralimal··on A couple of negative points about commenting on HackersNews
Yes.

I just don't get why its accepted or somehow morally ok to silently manage information for others.

The key word is: 'silently'. A mod should be able to manage the conversation, kick people off, delete comments etc, fine - but there should be a note to indicate how whatever bit was impacted. Otherwise, moderators are able to act like gods over a conversation or a forum, accountable to no one.

Well, I suppose they will have to judge themselves, but I don't think they are really going to take themselves to task!

If people are acting in good faith, they may present information that may be true AND unpleasant to accept or not per consensus opinion. The scientific method should accept the various viewpoints and converge to a better picture of reality. But that can't happen if dissenting voices are closed down.

It always surprises me that scientific thinkers, such as there are on this site, are not strongly in support of lots of voices. I don't mean that HN should become a popularity contest or something, but that honest sharing of curiosity and personal experience should be encouraged, not silenced.

Seriously, apart from some crap sites (eg 4chan), where can the 'unthinkable' be raised and discussed sensibly nowadays? I don't think there is anywhere.

feralimal··on Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destruction, scientists warn
I'd have to watch the film again (no thanks!) to provide more detail, but it was a tirade of fear. Eg:

No snow on Kilimanjaro? but: https://glacierhub.org/2018/04/04/greatest-snowfall-on-kilim...

20-foot rise in sea levels caused by melting ice caps?

shutting down of the ocean conveyor?

Hurricanes are getting stronger?

Pacific Islands drowning?

feralimal··on A couple of negative points about commenting on HackersNews
PS

From what you say, it seems that mods are pretty powerful. They can turn a story around or bury it or whatever.. That is all invisible to us users, right?

This is to say, we can't say whether the story is authentically popular or unpopular, as we don't have that information.

Gah! What happened to free speech?

I know that this is a private site... I know.

But still, can't we even know that we're being manipulated? Is this our life now, where we cannot be trusted to make judgements for ourselves, but instead all information must be massaged and managed for us?!!?

feralimal··on A couple of negative points about commenting on HackersNews
Answers from the thread with thanks:

news guidelines here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

format doc here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/formatdoc

an unofficial guide here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16437973

In summary: You need 501 karma to downvote a comment.

Stories fall from the front page when they get many flags. You need only 31 karma to flag.

When a story gets much more comments than upvotes, it gets a penalty.

The mods can sink a story, or remove the penalty of the flags or the automatic penalty.

feralimal··on A couple of negative points about commenting on HackersNews
> Internet points don't add value to my life.

Absolutely. I don't want points. But I'm collecting negative points whilst giving honest and authentic contributions. I'm being judged and found wanting. Why?

I don't mind hearing or being deconstructed (or ignored for that matter). But why take one on what I have to say, when I'm being straightforward? I'm acting in good faith.

It feels like I have to be part of the 'hive mind' or f* off like you suggest. But I like this site and what's discussed.

feralimal··on A couple of negative points about commenting on HackersNews
Very useful - thanks!

I don't want to downvote. I want to know why my comments get downvoted! How does one get that superpower? Because it absolutely seems that I bump into some sort of consensus thinking.

I mean, I've been posting in the last months pretty regularly, I'm posting my genuine arguments and positions, that I have come to over years, and I can support. I think they are interesting ideas - or at least they are authentic. And yet 4 months in, I'm currently at 26 points, having scaled the heady heights of 35 points!

Jeez, this seems to be a tough audience for people who I think should be open to interesting, unusual and perhaps challenging ideas!

> Try to avoid political threads. Each one has his/her opinion and wants to downvote any alternative.

Believe it or not, I don't think I'm political. I think I have a philosophical position. I really don't care about left or right. My philosophical position is of a skeptical bent. But, yep, this is misinterpreted as being political.

Cheers.

feralimal··on A couple of negative points about commenting on HackersNews
Thank you for the info.

But, that's just it! I think I'm polite. I have an opinion. If I don't see others making the point I have, I go ahead and make it. I'm happy to be challenged, I'll reply, and take corrections on the chin.

But that's not what's happening. I'm being downvoted (I think) because of the filtered consensus disagrees with my line of thought, not that I'm not following guidelines. Albeit, how could I follow guidelines they aren't even published! I had to create this post to, to get a link to another post where this is discussed!

← PreviousPage 11 of 14Next →