-15 karma · joined May 9, 2020
Can I say, you're a bit rude. I think you may disagree with my 'political' comments, but then put words in my mouth. I like meaningful engagement, and - yes I have my (reasoned) views and put them out there to be challenged and discussed. But I don't "know I'm right" - I actually like to be set straight when I'm wrong.
Really, your comments shows that HN is all about a consensus of opinion. You're saying I should police my own opinion, and even delete comments if its not going along with the flow or something.
20 years later, you should watch that film again and see the manipulative fear mongering that is in play.
And let's not forget that Al is heavily invested in 'green' tech.
You have absolutely no idea about what transpired in the past, except what you have been taught. And you were taught within the system. Perhaps you should watch 'The Village' :)
Without any laws, you would probably have a very equitable situation, based on 'treating others as you would like to treat others'. Its very simple. It is possible to conceive of a (better) society existing. How we could get to that from where we are now, where most people are incapable of managing themselves, and instead demand to be managed by system, is a different question.
If, on the other hand, you want to enforce your advantage over others, to make them do things that they do not want to do, you need a system.
It seems clear to me that rural areas are far less populated nowadays - small rural farms the world over, are being run by parents (or now, grandparents!) in their 80's it seems - the younger generation are in cities. From my school class no one has more that 3 children, and most have none. That should bode for a crashing population, but instead we are told it is increasing drastically.
So, while cities may feel busy, I tend to think the population is in decline. And that if lots of rural areas are in decline, that animal populations are probably on the increase, only there's no one there to see it.
Triple jump is valuable in itself - you train your body, and that has consequent benefits. Learning strings of consecutive characters characters perhaps has a memory benefit. But then, why not train your memory to get that benefit AND get a consequent benefit at the same time. Eg card counting to make money at casinos? Or actually learn English, so this becomes a vocab extension exercise? But all that effort to win....? At scrabble?!? The mind boggles.
And anyway, if you were that good, no-one would want to play scrabble with you at Christmas...
I don't even know how people can downvote. I only get the upvote option.
Imagine, as an English speaker, waking up wanting to win the Hungarian scrabble tournament. No, you don't want to know how to speak Hungarian. You only want to win the Hungarian scrabble tournaments. And you're prepared to invest months of your life memorising sequences of letters to do it!
Its insane.
Some people have waaaaayyyy too much time on their hands!
I guess bankers and communists share the idea of looking at 'the people' as a group to be governed and managed. Both are wedded to the system. I think communistic thinking is the idea that seems to have won, and (technocratic) governance is going to proceed with that as its basis.
Quite. But who says it is for anyone to organise 'society'?
You're missing the point of anarchism, I think. The only person you need to 'organise' and take responsibility for, is yourself. Most people look to government (not themselves) to take responsibility. And that is the problem.
That's an incontinent position to hold and he must have high cognitive dissonance of schizophrenia. Except if he is duplicitously self-serving, ie happy to receive the payments but not the opprobrium that comes with a high paying system position.
That's where we are heading. And many on this site are building that future.
The reason is that it helps to present what is in fact a false dichotomy. The radical thought they support is that within the Overton window. Nothing that would really shake up the ruling elite is expressed there. Like CNN and Fox news.
Really, IMO, you want individual rule for each individual. No system, no groups - just individuals. Anyone free to do what they want as long as they don't harm another individual. Do unto others, and all that.
That would be a closer definition of anarchy for me.
He was in support of Corbyn etc - this is to say he was happy to work within the system. You might say that this is a pragmatic view - but really he represented a hard left view.
Anarchism is, by definition, no-leaders. Self-determination. Neither communism nor a libertarian position. So I think in practise he was in contradiction of the beliefs he purported to hold.
BS jobs was good though!
But should you embrace it? While Yale and LSE are no doubt great institutions, to my mind they are also up there as educators of those who go on to become the system's top managers.
My question would be: do anarchists really work as professors at the London School of Economics? And Yale? Aren't you a 'system man' at that point?
... but oh dear, history is not what we think, as per the oft quoted Churchill:
"For my part, I consider that it will be found much better by all parties to leave the past to history, especially as I propose to write that history myself."
... even that quote is not what we think! https://slate.com/culture/2019/11/history-is-written-by-the-...
This is probably closer to the truth:
"History is a set of lies agreed upon." Napoleon Bonaparte
And that's a good thing, right?