HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

feralimal

-15 karma · joined May 9, 2020

submissionscomments
feralimal··on Google speakers are listening to more than just voice commands
How surprised would you be if in 5 years there was a Snowden-type revelation, that yes, the speakers and Facebook/Insta apps, Amazon echo, etc, etc, were listening all the time?

Sorry.

And that there was a secret court ruling that meant all that data was live-streamed to NSA Utah.

Not surprised at all, is the answer.

feralimal··on Science and scientific expertise are more important than ever
Even evidence might not be showing you what you think.

Eg if you fund 10 studies in support of, er, say cats being dangerous to humans. 2 might find that to be true, 2 find that false, and 6 remain neutral. You can leave the 8 you that don't support what you want to show unpublished. You can then fund more studies that build on the 2 you like. Rinse and repeat.

Pretty soon, driven by funding alone, you will have lots of 'evidence' that caters to your viewpoint. Is that science? Unfortunately, funding determines scientific reality.

feralimal··on A Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Permanently Flipped Workplace
Why and when do you think it will end?

Did you see how quickly the networks were upgraded? Within weeks around my way... So, infrastructure was upgraded quickly.

You are probably aware of what's going on in Australia - where lockdowns are returning, with certain tower blocks in Melbourne locked in, and the army making house to house calls.

feralimal··on What Experts Know About Covid-19 That They Didn't Know Then
Well, it is not a surprise that scientists converge on a more singular idea. This is described in the Delphi method: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ap77w8FKYM where we see how people's minds are changed as they attempt to reach a consensus.

But, we should remember that consensus on an answer doesn't actually mean it is the right answer. It can be gamed - eg if you only choose scientists with a particular background to respond in the consensus seeking process. The selection of those inputting into the process needs to be free and open. If not, and you select opinions from one group only, eg mechanical engineers, or bacterial bioligists, you will get a very specific answer that reflects the bias of those partaking in the process.

feralimal··on Artificial brains may need sleep too
I actually think this kind of nonsense comes from the predisposition humans have to empathise and anthropomorphise things.

So, yeah, in a way a brain is like a computer, it works as a metaphor. But no, a brain not a computer in reality. So a poor use of metaphor.

Or in another way, this sort of stuff comes from confusion in conflating the map with the terrain - a map can be useful at one level, but it is not the terrain itself so useless at a different level of observation.

feralimal··on Artificial brains may need sleep too
I agree.

Machinery does not need to sleep. Networks do not need to sleep. Roads do not need to sleep.

Living creatures do.

Machines and Living creatures are not the same thing, they do 'learn' the same way.

feralimal··on Understanding Victimhood Culture (2018)
Just an observation on the authors names:

Bradley Campbell and Jason Manning

Bradley ... ... ... Manning

.. and the topic - victimhood culture.

feralimal··on Video Game Approved as Prescription Medicine
Quote from Matt Omernick, Akili cofounder: "As a child progresses in game play, the technology is continuously measuring their performance and using adaptive algorithms to adjust the difficulty and personalize the treatment experience for each individual." and from Web developer and designer Craig Ferguson: "“It’s a well-known fact that so many mobile games use all sorts of psychological tricks to get people to give them money,” he says. “So we wanted to use the same exact psychological tricks, but to trick [users] into doing something that’s good for them.”"

I understand that this is game is intended to help depression and anxiety. But am I alone in thinking that these states are feedback that is telling you that you are doing something wrong, that you need to make a change, rather than continuing to do something (that you may feel invested in) that isn't working for you? Or if you are bored, that you need to find something more meaningful than being distracted?

From that point of view, I feel uncomfortable with this sort of idea - that a game monitors and personalises the experience with psychological tricks in order for the child (child!) to progress as the game's developers would like. No doubt the developers have best intentions, but time outdoors, in nature, undertaking more wild experiences, allowing for boredom even - without monitoring or personalisation - are surely better options!

Basically, this line of investigation as a "solution" to depression and anxiety - ie more immersion and greater monitoring by technology - sounds worse than the disease to me!

feralimal··on Pictures Show What the 1918 Flu Pandemic Looked Like (2018)
from: https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/14/8/07-1313_article

"Many influenza experts, policy makers, and knowledgeable observers believe that a novel influenza A (H1N1) strain directly caused most deaths during the 1918–19 pandemic, often from a hemorrhagic pneumonitis that rapidly progressed to acute respiratory distress syndrome and death (1–3). Not surprisingly, plans and resources to respond to the next influenza pandemic focus almost exclusively on the virus, i.e., preventive vaccines and antiviral treatment of infections with a novel influenza strain (4). However, healthcare providers, medical experts, and published data from the 1918 period suggest that most deaths were caused by secondary bacterial pneumonias (5–12); hemorrhagic pneumonitis that rapidly progressed to death was considered an alarming but uncommon clinical manifestation (8,11–13)."

The way I'm reading that, it doesn't seem that it's that clear that it was the flu that was to blame.

And it seems a pretty fair guess that the reason it spread was as a result of the end of WWI.

feralimal··on You Must Not ‘Do Your Own Research’
Opening paragraph: "“Research both sides and make up your own mind.” It’s simple, straightforward, common sense advice. And when it comes to issues like vaccinations, climate change, and the novel coronavirus SARS-CoV-2, it can be dangerous, destructive, and even deadly. The techniques that most of us use to navigate most of our decisions in life — gathering information, evaluating it based on what we know, and choosing a course of action — can lead to spectacular failures when it comes to a scientific matter."

Its dangerous to trust your own judgement. Trust the experts. Thanks Forbes!

In reality, this is a ridiculous argument - its just 'appeal to authority'. It devalues the individual. If you don't value your own judgement you are beholden to companies, corporations, etc that may not be acting in your interests.

My favourite example for this is diabetes. If you don't eat carbs or sugar, you don't overload your body and don't need to enter the medical system. This is to say that I am claiming you can manage your condition with a careful diet only.

Which medical company would advise you to do that?! None. There is simply no profit in it. I hope I am conveying the principle, whether you accept my thesis or not - and if you are a diabetic you should test this for yourself. My main point is that you need to trust your individual judgement - corporations, governments, and their paid for experts are not 100% trustworthy.

feralimal··on Why Do People Stay Poor? [pdf]
Sorry - my mistake. I was going off memory.

2 times, including the principle.

Looking here: https://finance.icalculator.info/mortgage-calculator.html

I enter, Mortgage Amount: 100000 Annual Interest Rate: 5% Term of Mortgage: 30years

The interest paid is 93255.20

feralimal··on Why Do People Stay Poor? [pdf]
For the individual, the answer is Debt. And servicing repayments of debt. Eg, that on the typical mortgage you repay ~3 times what you borrowed.
feralimal··on Spies can eavesdrop by watching a light bulb's vibrations
I'm saying, if someone writes an article and it is published, should we believe it?

You're saying that I should use tools to replicate the experiment. Great - this is what we should do before we accept something as true. Otherwise, we are in the realms of 'belief'.

So, do you believe this story? And did you do due diligence, and confirm with the tools that it is true? Or did you skip that bit and believe it despite the fact that NO evidence is presented at all? Be honest when you answer please!

Stepping back a bit, I'm not saying anything so drastic. I certainly don't see why I'm being downvoted. I'm really talking about applying the scientific method personally. I'm saying don't accept articles, videos by default, without even critically reading what is being presented. I really think its pretty obvious stuff, tbh!

feralimal··on Fewer premature babies born since Covid-19 lockdown
Nevermind the 3 causes they are looking at.

I think that this is very likely due to removal/lessening of the impact of doctors on what is a natural process. If doctors are less involved, things take their natural course without problems.

Let's not forget, that the third largest cause of death (higher than covid) is iatrogenic death: https://www.globalresearch.ca/drug-induced-iatrogenic-disord...

There is, in fact, a strong case to be made for closing doctors, hospitals, etc down, in order to increase the populations health!

EDIT - I don't know why my comment is being downvoted. I think I'm making a rational, reasonable argument! If you disagree, no problem! But perhaps state why you think what I'm suggesting is wrong.

feralimal··on The Value of Human Life (In $)
Every life is infinitely valuable. End of.
feralimal··on Spies can eavesdrop by watching a light bulb's vibrations
Should we believe videos and articles?

I think we should demand more. We are being presented science right? We should be able to recognise that this article and the videos, etc are just presenting a claim. They are not providing any evidence. This is just a story.

feralimal··on Spies can eavesdrop by watching a light bulb's vibrations
Well, ok.

Firstly, note that it provides no evidence. It has a claim, and shows a fancy graphic. That's it. Its not evidence. Anyone can make that sort of thing up. How can one differentiate this from a story I just made up?

Digging in, it says: "LED bulbs also offer a signal-to-noise ratio that's about 6.3 times that of an incandescent bulb and 70 times a fluorescent one."

Why? Why are LEDs better for this noise reflection stuff, than incandescent or fluorescent ones? They're all in glass. The heat of the glass is stable. The LED itself surely can't help.

Why does Shazam feature in these tests, at all?!

It also says: "Researchers have known for years that a laser bounced off a target's window can allow spies to pick up the sounds inside. Another group of researchers showed in 2014 that the gyroscope of a compromised smartphone can pick up sounds even if the malware can't access its microphone."

Right. Are we meant to believe that this is what spies do? I mean, a spy just has to access whatever systems are already at his or her disposal and listen to your calls. They don't need to do any of that!

And: "Still, Nassi says the researchers are publishing their findings not to enable spies or law enforcement, but to make clear to those on both sides of surveillance what's possible. "We want to raise the awareness of this kind of attack vector," he says. "We’re not in the game of providing tools.""

So, they even say that this article is about raising awareness of this kind of attack vector. They are raising awareness. Thanks spies!

The article is a joke. At best this is a puff piece for a spy agency, or more likely just to increase paranoid awareness amongst those in tech. Be scared, danger everywhere! There are spy agencies listening to you everywhere - they're not using your phone, they use light bulbs and leaves!!

feralimal··on Spies can eavesdrop by watching a light bulb's vibrations
PS, at what point would alarm bells ring for you, re this story. If they had said that they could pick up voices from a lightbulb with a telescope that was 50m away? 100m? 1000m?!?

I suspect that alarm bells wouldn't ring at all....

feralimal··on Spies can eavesdrop by watching a light bulb's vibrations
I watched the video. I'm sorry, but its inane. This is the worst sort of science magic. In fact its just trickery.

Do you seriously think that you have been provided evidence in that video? All that happened is that I ended up looking at a leaf and packets of things that weren't moving at all. That's not evidence!

It says that they are picking up vibrations from a leaf or bag of crisps. But they don't show you those vibrations. They just give you a bunch of graphics and fuzzy sounds and tell you that they have done something.

You do see that this is could be very simple video trickery right? As with the initial article - there's a claim, but nothing to really be able to use to verify that claim. Just a graphic, and references to Shazam. Perhaps this is guerrilla marketing for Shazam? Its a more viable thesis anyway, given the evidence!

feralimal··on Spies can eavesdrop by watching a light bulb's vibrations
And why should some skepticism of an article relating to the purported tools of spycraft be downvoted? Its ok to expect more than a simple schematic, surely?
feralimal··on Spies can eavesdrop by watching a light bulb's vibrations
Do you really think a telescope can pick up the reflected vibrations from a lightbulb, using a telescope 25m away?
feralimal··on Spies can eavesdrop by watching a light bulb's vibrations
Sorry - but that sounds like BS. Think about it - a hanging light bulb vibrates when you speak... Really? I don't see any movement, and I'm right there.

But yet, that can be picked up 25m away by a telescope? With equipment that costs less than $1000? No way.

Sounds like some phony story to me, that's meant to make us think spies have superpowers, or even that we're all being spied on. (Which we are, but not like this.)

feralimal··on Ancient microbial arms race sharpened our immune system but left us vulnerable
Do you think the stylised imagery has any correlation to the electron microscope image? Which image do you think the stylised one is based on?
feralimal··on Government to urge us all to walk and cycle more
The government isn't a person. It can't 'urge', even if the BBC says it can.
← PreviousPage 14 of 14